Katherine Levine Einstein on Neighborhood Defenders
What this covers
Political scientist Katherine Levine Einstein of Boston University speaks with Russ Roberts on EconTalk about why America cannot build enough housing. Einstein's argument is straightforward: the culprit is not scarcity of land or labor, but a permitting process dominated by what she calls "neighborhood defenders"—a narrow, unrepresentative slice of residents who use zoning hearings and lawsuits to block, shrink, and delay housing projects. The real mechanism is rarely outright rejection; instead, delays, repeated studies, and concessions that raise construction costs suppress supply across entire cities and regions. The implied fix diverges sharply from the conventional wisdom: rather than deepen local participation or mandate affordability through inclusionary zoning, the answer lies in shifting land-use authority upward to state and federal levels.
The conversation traverses the demographics of who shows up at hearings—whiter, older, disproportionately homeowners—and why they succeed despite representing a minority view. Einstein draws on Mançur Olson's Logic of Collective Action to explain how small, motivated groups outflank diffuse majorities, and she documents how opponents invoke environmental, traffic, and density concerns rather than property values or class-based objections, making their arguments more persuasive to planners. The discussion examines Externalities—how costs concentrate locally while benefits spread citywide—and explores how discretionary review, meant to be flexible, instead creates Rules versus Discretion problems that invite endless renegotiation and litigation. Einstein argues that inclusionary zoning produces mixed-to-negative results and that federal leverage through transit funding or state up-zoning mandates offer more direct routes to reform. A substantial thread addresses how exclusionary practices, rooted partly in explicitly racist single-family zoning ordinances, persist through coded language and class sorting rather than overt discrimination.
Einstein argues that America's housing shortage is driven largely by a hyper-local public-hearing and permitting process that empowers an unrepresentative, privileged subset of residents ('neighborhood defenders') to block, shrink, and delay housing—so the fix lies in moving land-use decisions to higher levels of government rather than improving local participation.
- Public hearing participants are demographically unrepresentative—whiter, older, more likely homeowners—and overwhelmingly oppose new housing.
- The real damage comes less from outright rejection than from delay, lawsuits, and project-shrinking concessions that raise costs and suppress supply.
- Inclusionary zoning and local participation are the wrong tools; federal/state funding and preemption of local zoning are more effective levers.
Local discretionary housing processes enable cronyism by creating hidden beneficiaries and favoring those who curry favor with long-term decision-makers.
- Small, intensely-motivated groups gain disproportionate political influence over diffuse majorities (per Mancur Olson's collective action logic), which can protect vulnerable minorities but also produces cronyism—and the housing hearing process is a detailed example of that cronyism running amok.
“Mancur Olson was I think the person most associated with this idea that small, intensely-motivated and intensely-interested groups get a lot more political influence than the people who might be harmed or benefited but it's relatively small amounts”
- The discretionary process creates hidden beneficiaries: the firms that perform repeated traffic and parking studies gain demand for their services, and the discretionary structure enables favoritism and cronyism toward those who curry favor with long-term decision-makers like mayors and legislators—making cronyism a feature, not a bug.
“one obvious group that benefits from this is the people who do the studies. Because this is good for them: creates a demand for their good, their service... that's the other advantage of the discretionary process. It allows for favoritism and cronyism”
The normative choice to preserve static museum-like cities prioritizes aesthetic preservation over access and opportunity for disadvantaged people.
- During the pandemic, rents have plummeted in many major cities and prices are presumably down too, making it a relatively good time to be a renter or buyer—though these are expected to return to former levels once the pandemic ends.
“we're recording this in the middle of the pandemic when rents have plummeted in a lot of the cities that we're talking about. They will, I think, return to their former levels once the pandemic ends”
- There is a normative tradeoff between a dynamic world that loses some cherished things but gains better, cheaper options and access for the disadvantaged, versus a static preserved one; we have gone too far toward turning cities into beautiful but static 'museums' that are detrimental to the people we should care about.
“we've gone so far in the other direction to turn our cities into what I think of as museums. These preserved, often-beautiful, but static and detrimental to people who we should be caring about”
Housing supply throttling has made it far more expensive and harder for economically struggling people to move into high-opportunity cities, representing a terrible national policy failure.
- Enabling economically struggling people to move into high-opportunity cities may be the single most important area of reform for improving the country, yet we have made it incredibly hard and far more expensive than it used to be by throttling housing supply—a terrible national decision ironically rooted in the doctrine of local control.
“I sometimes think this is the single most important area of change that could make our country better... we throttled the supply. And, I think we've made a terrible decision as a country. And, ironically, it's the idea that local jurisdiction should have more power”
Restrictive land-use regulations blocking density harm environmental goals despite being justified with environmental concerns.
- Dense urban living is environmentally beneficial, while spreading people out into single homes on large lots requiring car travel is environmentally harmful, so restrictive land-use regulations that block density work against environmental goals even as opponents invoke environmental concerns to block housing.
“Density is really good for the environment. And, having a lot of people spread out and driving to their single homes out in the middle of large lots, it's not particularly environmentally a good thing. And, so density in cities are actually quite green just by themselves”