Anne Applebaum on the Twilight of Democracy
What this covers
Anne Applebaum, a journalist and author, speaks with EconTalk host Russ Roberts about her book Twilight of Democracy, examining the fracture of post-Cold War conservatism and the worldwide drift toward anti-democratic politics. The conversation traces how the international conservative coalition—a coalition of Realpolitik strategists, human-rights advocates, free-marketeers, and Christians—held together primarily by opposition to Communism rather than shared values. Once that common enemy vanished, its members discovered they had little in common and drifted apart. Applebaum argues that a subset of every population carries an Authoritarian Predisposition that political entrepreneurs now deliberately activate through media, and that major shifts in how people process information have historically triggered upheaval exploited by anti-democratic forces.
The discussion moves across several distinct territories. Applebaum traces how control of broadcasting—from Hitler and Stalin to Franklin Delano Roosevelt—shaped political transformation, and draws parallels to today's internet. She draws on Value Pluralism) to explain why people hold contradictory desires that no political system can fully satisfy, then contrasts a surviving Burkean center-right devoted to democratic institutions with a more radical right rejecting those commitments. The conversation examines disappointment and rapid change—economic, demographic, religious—as drivers of the shift toward authoritarianism, and considers how weakened membership organizations left a gap filled by online communities. Other points of emphasis include the role of dark money in distorting politics, the structural similarities between propaganda in Russia and Belarus and messaging in the American right, the risk of winner-take-all politics as executive power accumulates, and the need for democratic regulation of social media platforms. Applebaum addresses whether the authoritarian left poses an equivalent threat, arguing the authoritarian right is far more dangerous in the current moment.
Applebaum argues that the post-Cold War conservative coalition fragmented because its members held incompatible underlying motives, and that a recurring 'authoritarian predisposition'—amplified by new media—now drives a worldwide drift toward anti-democratic politics that threatens established democracies.
- The anti-Communist conservative coalition was held together by a common enemy, not shared values, so it broke apart once Communism fell
- A subset of every population has an authoritarian predisposition that political entrepreneurs deliberately activate via media
- Every major change in how people process information (printing press, radio, internet) has triggered political upheaval exploited by anti-democratic forces
Concentrated executive power and social media amplify winner-take-all politics, destroying cross-partisan respect and deliberation.
- Power has increasingly accrued to the US President, and partisans cheer executive overreach when it is their side in office while forgetting the other side will inherit those powers; this trend, amplified by social media, is pushing politics toward a winner-take-all dynamic where, if people believe the country hangs in the balance, anything goes and respect for the other side collapses.
“in our lifetime, we've seen increasing power accrued to the President. And, when it's your guy in office... people will say, 'Yeah, go! Fix all this stuff. Don't pay attention to these democratic institutions. Use executive orders.'”
- Human beings carry an unresolved tension between the childhood desire to be protected and the adult desire to make their own choices; politicians always exploit the fear arising from life's uncertainty by offering protection, and people will trade away freedoms to a surrogate parent or authority figure that promises to take care of them and to discipline others.
“fear, that comes from the nature of life and the uncertainty of life, is always exploited by politicians to take power.”
- As religion and religious community have receded in the West, people have turned to politics as a source of meaning and identity, increasingly treating political affiliation as a matter of faith and tribal identity rather than empirical testing, which makes it harder to form community across political divides.
“as religion has receded somewhat in the West, people have turned to politics as a source of meaning, source of identity.”
Information democratization paradoxically enables authoritarians and new elites to capture entrepreneurial political opportunities rather than universal good.
- The internet's democratization of information is an enormous threat to existing elites, and as elites and institutions fall apart it creates entrepreneurial opportunities in the political space—ironically for authoritarians and for new elites who simply replace the old ones, rather than producing the universally good democratization that idealists expect.
“the Internet has democratized information, and is an enormous threat to the elites. And as the elites fall apart... it creates opportunities, entrepreneurial opportunities in the political space for, ironically, authoritarians.”
- Anne Applebaum is a staff writer for The Atlantic and author of the Pulitzer Prize winning Gulag: A History and Twilight of Democracy.
“Among her many books is the Pulitzer Prize winning Gulag: A History”
Decentralized decision-making preserves democratic function by keeping information burdens local and preventing voter manipulation.
- Democracy works best when incentives are local because local decisions mobilize information; as decision-making moves further from the voter and the information burden grows, voters are more likely to be taken advantage of—so the key question is not whether some decisions belong at higher levels but which issues and how broadly, with decentralization valued for fostering competition.
“as decisions get further and further away from the voter, and as the amount of information that a voter is supposed to have to make a wise and thoughtful decision, the more likely they are to be taken advantage of.”
Present crises, however severe, have historically been survived, suggesting contemporary fears need not justify institutional breakdown.
- As James Buchanan observed, one can be a pessimist looking to the future yet an optimist looking to the past: 1933 looked terrifying with 25% unemployment, rising fascism, and an impending world war, yet things ultimately got better—suggesting present fears, however severe, may likewise be survived.
“'When I look to the future, I'm a pessimist. When I look to the past, I'm an optimist.'”