What this covers

Lisa Cook, an economist at Michigan State University, speaks with Russ Roberts about the measurable economic cost of racial violence, segregation laws, and discrimination on Black invention and entrepreneurship in the United States. The conversation centers on Cook's research tracking patents by African American inventors from 1870 onward, which reveals a sharp collapse in patenting around 1899—a peak year that was never again reached—precisely as waves of racial violence intensified. Cook argues that this suppression was not incidental but structural: violence, legal segregation, and consumer racism each operated through distinct mechanisms to disrupt the conditions inventors need to work and innovate.

The discussion moves through the specific mechanisms of this suppression. After Plessy v. Ferguson enabled segregation of public accommodations, Black inventors lost access to public libraries and patent attorneys (none were African American until the 1970s), while those trying to sell to the general public encountered such severe consumer discrimination that they were forced into wholesale work or other arrangements that kept them away from direct customer contact. Cook illustrates these dynamics with historical examples—including Garrett Morgan's need to hire white salesmen to demonstrate his gas mask—and argues that the loss of patents due to racial violence would have equaled the output of a medium-sized European country over the same period. She contends that restoring the free flow of ideas by removing barriers to underrepresented groups could raise GDP per capita by 0.6 to 4.4 percent, meaning the entire economy, not merely affected groups, has suffered from this exclusion. The conversation also touches on ongoing workplace discrimination in technology and the barriers facing Black women in particular.

Sharpest takeaway

Lisa Cook argues that racial violence, segregation, and discrimination directly suppressed Black invention and entrepreneurship in the US, imposing measurable losses on innovation and the broader economy, and that confronting this history is necessary to remove barriers to the free flow of ideas.

  • Patenting by African American inventors dropped sharply after waves of violence around 1899 while white patenting continued rising
  • Violence, segregation laws, and consumer racism each had distinct mechanisms that disrupted invention and forced entrepreneurs to adapt
  • Lack of diversity and the suppression of ideas costs the entire economy, not just affected groups

The argument · threads6 threads · 28 claims
0.72

Racial violence and segregation directly suppressed African American invention through personal insecurity and blocked access to resources.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • When racial violence (lynchings, riots, segregation) increased in the US, African American inventors stopped inventing, and when it subsided they resumed, demonstrating that personal insecurity and lack of rule of law directly inhibit innovation.

    “when this violence kicks up in the US, African Americans stop inventing: African American inventors stop inventing. And, when it subsides, they start inventing again.”

  • After Plessy v. Ferguson enabled segregation of public accommodations, Black inventors lost the ability to meet freely at public libraries and could not reach their patent attorneys, since there were no African American patent attorneys until the 1970s and white business districts were inaccessible.

    “Inventors are not able to get to their patent attorneys. There aren't African American patent attorneys until the 1970s. So, they were heavily dependent on white patent attorneys and they weren't able to get to them, because central commercial districts--business districts--would have been all white.”

  • Based on lynching data Cook constructed from 1683 to 1984, Confederate monument-building took the place of and substituted for lynching, since monuments were erected roughly 50 years after the Civil War around the time of the Voting Rights Act, and were meant to intimidate rather than commemorate.

    “I have updated the lynching data, and I've constructed this dataset from 1683 to 1984. And what we see is that Confederate monument-building took the place of lynching: that it was a substitute for lynching. So, it was meant to intimidate. It was not done at the time of the Civil War; it was done, 50 years afterwards”

  • Garrett Morgan circumvented racial barriers by hiring white salesmen and a Native American to pretend to be him while demonstrating his gas mask, and was only outed as Black when his photo appeared in newspapers after the Lake Erie rescue, after which Southern fire departments canceled their orders.

    “He sold his gas mask in different ways by hiring white salesmen who pretended to be Garrett Morgan... He also hired a Native American to pretend to be him... Southern fire departments who had ordered the gas mask, canceled their orders.”

0.72

The historical loss of African American patents from racial violence represents economic harm equivalent to a medium-sized European country's output.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The number of patents lost due to racial violence would have equaled the patenting output of a medium-sized European country over the same period, making the aggregate loss substantial despite small per capita magnitudes.

    “the number of patents that would be missing would have constituted the patents that we would have seen in that same period from a medium-sized European country. Which would have been substantial.”

  • 1899 remains the peak year for invention per capita for African Americans, showing that the suppression of Black innovation had a long-term, persistent effect.

    “it remains the case that 1899 is still the peak year for invention per capita for African Americans. So, this can have a long term persistent effect.”

  • Segregation laws, lynchings, and riots had distinct effects on different types of invention: segregation laws had a greater impact on electrical patents because those require many steps involving multiple people, while lynchings had greater impact on mechanical inventions tied to mobility-dependent work like railroads.

    “segregation laws, for example, have a greater impact on electrical patents... Lynchings would have a greater impact on, let's say, mechanical ones, where you might need to go to work--to work on a railroad”

  • Climate survey data show black women report having to do more than any other group to avoid sexist and racist behavior, such as moving institutions and skipping seminars, and report being the most discriminated against in promotion and pay.

    “black women report having to do more than any other group to avoid sexist and racist behavior. Moving institutions, not going to seminars, doing other things like that. They also report being the most discriminated against and discriminated against with respect to promotion and pay.”

0.72

Diversity in innovation teams and economics improves outcomes for everyone, not just excluded groups, raising aggregate GDP per capita substantially.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Patenting by women is an order of magnitude lower than by men, yet integrated co-ed teams are more productive at patenting than single-sex teams of either kind, with single-sex female teams less productive than single-sex male but both less productive than integrated teams.

    “Patenting by women is one order of magnitude lower than it is for men in the patent dataset... co-ed teams, that diverse teams, are more productive at patenting than those who are not. Single-sex female teams are less productive than single-sex male, but they're both less productive than those that are integrated.”

  • Reducing barriers to the free flow of ideas by including underrepresented groups in economics and innovation would raise GDP per capita by an estimated 0.6% to 4.4%, meaning the entire society and economy, not just excluded groups, loses out from a lack of diversity.

    “GDP could be between 0.6% and 4.4% higher per capita if more African Americans and women--those were the two groups I looked at... everybody is losing out. It's not just African Americans and women who are losing out. It's the entire society, entire economy that is losing out.”

  • Citing Janet Yellen, the lack of diversity and lived experience among economists analyzing the data caused groupthink that contributed to the Financial Crisis, since African Americans can serve as canaries in the coal mine and leading indicators for problems like unemployment.

    “she has said that the lack of diversity of the economists who were analyzing the data related to the Financial Crisis was a cause of the Financial Crisis. That it led to groupthink. There was little diversity and lived experience.”

  • Chetty et al.'s research shows that exposure to inventors changes a child's life outcomes, and minorities and poorer children who lack access to inventors have worse outcomes, supporting investment in K-12 education and inventor exposure.

    “the work of Chetty et al. shows us this--that exposure to inventors actually changes one's life outcomes... what we see is that minorities and poorer children who don't have access to inventors have worse life outcomes.”

0.71

Systemic barriers forced Black inventors into constrained roles and prevented them from accessing the institutional and legal infrastructure of innovation.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • As consumer racial discrimination increased after 1896-1899, Black inventors and businesses stopped selling directly to the public, becoming wholesalers or otherwise avoiding consumer interface, which limited them to poorer clienteles, producing a so-called Golden Age of African American business born of having no other options.

    “they stopped selling to the public because the racial discrimination coming from consumers was increasing. So, they decided to stop interacting with consumers, and they became wholesalers, or they found some way not to interface with the public.”

  • The cotton gin may be the most contested patent in US history, having been invented by an enslaved African American on a Georgia plantation, with Eli Whitney being the first to reach the patent office; the lawsuits against Whitney came from other planters angry at not patenting first, illustrating how rural agricultural innovators typically went unpatented.

    “The most contested patents in U.S. history, and may still be, is the cotton gin, an invention of an African American slave that was being used on a Georgia plantation; and Eli Whitney just happened to be the first person to get to the patent office.”

  • Great inventors share common characteristics regardless of race, notably being highly mobile and moving to where opportunities are, so the failure of Black inventors to respond to invention incentives during wartime signaled that something was structurally blocking them.

    “great inventors have some of the same characteristics, whether they're white or black. They are mobile. They're highly mobile. They go to where the opportunities are.”

  • Race did not appear on patents and there had never been a systematic review of black names in the historical period before the Civil Rights era, so Cook had to create the first systematic list of black names from 1870-1940, though many inventors did not have typical period-specific Black names, requiring exhaustive searches of directories, obituaries, and the census.

    “I wound up creating the first list, the first systematic investigation, identification, of black names in the historical period... Many of these did not have typical African American names for the period I was covering from 1870 to 1940.”

  • Because patents recorded only a name and place with no way to verify race in a pre-Internet era, some Black inventors with non-Black-sounding names could remain anonymous, though this conflicted with the prevailing practice of inventors like Edison personally identifying with and advertising their inventions.

    “patents helped some inventors stay anonymous. So, all you see recorded is the name and the place where the person lived. So, there was no Internet at the time; there was no way to fact-check who was who.”

  • The dramatic drop in African American patenting cannot be explained by inventors passing as white or changing their names, because such an explanation would require an implausibly large amount of passing, and a patent held under someone else's name provides little benefit to the actual inventor.

    “for a number of inventors to fall out like this. so dramatically, there would have to be a lot of passing. There would have to be a lot of people changing their names. And, I just don't see that.”

  • Soviet inventors, largely scientific teams at institutes, were motivated by being able to obtain patents outside the Soviet Union, namely in the United States, because the US was the only place able to validate whether an idea was original.

    “the thing that worked was allowing Soviet inventors to obtain patents outside of the Soviet Union, namely in the United States. So, we were the only ones who were able to validate whether this was the original idea.”

0.36

Segregation created economically separate worlds reducing productivity, paralleling the integration and re-segregation of organized baseball.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Segregation created separate parallel economic and social worlds that reduced productivity, paralleling organized baseball which was integrated until the late 1890s, then segregated, and only rejoined in the 1940s-1950s.

    “this had the same effect in baseball. You had organized baseball that was integrated until the late 1890s, and then it was segregated. And we have the same kind of phenomena happening: You see a decline in productivity, but you see the alternate universes that arise, and then they come back together in the 1940s, 1950s.”

  • Everyone in the economy at the time of slavery benefited from it, not just slaveholders, including universities, banks, and insurance companies that underwrote slave ships, and this complicity cannot be excused as a 21st-century lens because people at the time made the same moral judgments.

    “Everybody benefited from slavery, everybody... It's not just universities who bought and sold enslaved people. It is institutions, it's banks, insurance companies that underwrote the ships. There is so much complicity. And, we can't say that we're looking at it from a 21st century lens... because there were people at the time saying that.”

0.31

Policy reforms in policing, workplace practices, and education investment can leverage existing talent and reduce barriers to innovation.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Police are being asked to perform roles far outside their training, such as mental health and drug treatment functions, partly due to de-institutionalization, and they often have fewer hours of training than hairstylists and nail technicians, so reform should refocus police on public safety and provide proper training.

    “In most states... it seems as though police have fewer hours of training than hairstylists. So, and nail techs. This is one of the most important jobs in the community... we need to have them focused on public safety, and get them trained properly”

  • Workplace discrimination in tech and Silicon Valley, including African Americans being let go, not funded, and harassed, and companies scaling back minority-attraction efforts under backlash before George Floyd, prevents the education people already have from being used, so reform must leverage existing education rather than only producing more.

    “just before the George Floyd incident... tech companies were scaling back anything that had to do with attracting more minorities to their firms, because they were coming under such pressure, such backlash from their white counterparts in these firms.”

  • Adopting codes of conduct and ending long-standing practices like interviewing job candidates in hotel rooms, prompted by fresh perspectives from graduate students, sets expectations for how people interact and improves professional climate.

    “interviewing in hotel rooms. Now, that it did go to zero, but I think it's a long-standing practice that some of us just got used to, we thought was weird... it just took a fresh pair of eyes from graduate students, to get us to do better”

  • Experiments promising college to high-achieving students from low socio-economic backgrounds make a large difference because the families did not believe college was affordable, and the promise can change the ultimate outcomes of the entire family rather than just the individual.

    “promising college to high-achieving students who are of lower socio-economic backgrounds. And it's just that promise--just that promise--that makes a big difference, because they don't even think that this is something that they can afford... it can have an effect on the entire family”