What this covers

Margaret Heffernan and Russ Roberts explore how organizations and individuals can prepare for a fundamentally unpredictable future without relying on forecasts or certainty. Heffernan, a professor, former CEO, and entrepreneur, argues that since the future cannot be known, the practical response is not to seek prophecy but to build capacity for thoughtful response. The conversation ranges across neuroscience, business strategy, and personal development, anchored by the observation that forecasting as a profession has repeatedly failed—from the founding fathers of economic prediction like Irving Fisher through the 1929 crash and beyond. Rather than despairing at this reality, Heffernan proposes three concrete approaches: scenario planning to surface options and choices, active experimentation to test assumptions, and attentive sense-making to gather the raw materials needed for navigating uncertainty.

The discussion moves fluidly between scales. On neuroscience: Eleanor Maguire's work on memory as future-construction shows how the brain builds scenarios by recombining present experience, not retrieving fixed knowledge. On organizations: a Dutch care facility found that distinguishing complex vs complicated work—letting nurses use judgment on unpredictable patients rather than applying rigid protocols—cut costs while halving recovery time. On careers and learning: people rarely plan successful paths; instead they experiment until something clicks, suggesting education should cultivate curiosity over fixed knowledge. Heffernan draws parallels to living like an artist—paying intense attention, tolerating uncertainty, and asking what things mean—as a model for both organizations and individuals. She contrasts this with the Instagram effect, where algorithmic visibility homogenizes choices, and with retail giants who failed by foreclosing experimentation rather than adapting.

Sharpest takeaway

Heffernan argues that the future is fundamentally unpredictable, so rather than seeking forecasts or certainty, individuals and organizations should prepare through scenario planning, experimentation, and attentive 'artist-like' sense-making to retain agency.

  • Forecasting as a profession has repeatedly failed because the future cannot be known
  • Scenario planning surfaces options and choices rather than predicting one outcome
  • Experimentation and paying attention to the present build the raw material for navigating an uncharted future

The argument · threads8 threads · 29 claims
0.85

The future is inherently unpredictable; no expert or pundit can actually know it despite sounding confident.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Accepting that you cannot know the future and that no special people hold a key to it is liberating, because it lets you ask better questions—running scenarios about what you would do under different outcomes—which gives you a sense of agency and choice rather than placing your fate in pundits' hands.

    “not knowing and knowing that I don't know--knowing that I can't know, and knowing that there aren't any of these special people out there--is incredibly liberating, because it makes me ask better questions.”

  • The human passion for certainty and control leaves us wildly susceptible to pundits, prophets, and snake oil salesmen who sound confident, creating a huge demand for punditry even though nobody can actually know the future.

    “we do have a passion for certainty. And I think the difficulty of this is that it leaves us wildly susceptible to pundits and profits and snake oil salesmen who sound so confident that we think, 'Well, they must know something that we don't know.'”

  • The founding fathers of economic forecasting (Babson, Fisher, Persons) all ultimately failed in their predictions despite their intellectual brilliance and confidence, because the future is fundamentally unpredictable—the Great Depression made nearly all of them look foolish.

    “And they really all fail.”

  • Babson appeared to predict the 1929 crash correctly only because he had been forecasting a crash for three years running; he then got it wrong by predicting an imminent boom that was actually years away, yet he was the only one of the three who died wealthy.

    “it makes everyone except Babson look stupid because--but Babson gets it right for no other reason that they'd been forecasting a crash for three years running”

  • The early forecasters thought of forecasting not merely as gleaning what's out there but, like a potter casting a pot, as shaping the future through the advice they gave people—they had a deep need not just to see the future but to make it.

    “they're thinking of forecasting not just as gleaning what's out there, but if you think of the word and you think about a potter casting a pot, really trying to shape the future, too”

  • People hold a magical-thinking idea that the future lies behind a locked door to which a few special people have the key, and that finding and consulting those people would give one a special edge—a belief Heffernan rejects as illusory.

    “we have this kind of idea that what these questions embodied was the idea that the future lies behind a locked door, and a few special people have the key, and every now and then they're allowed a sneak peek.”

0.65

Scenario planning works by constructing multiple futures and asking what you would do under each, surfacing real choices.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Scenario planning is widely misunderstood as coming up with different views of the future and then choosing one; in reality it is about constructing multiple scenarios and interrogating each by asking 'if this came true, what would I wish I had been doing now?'—its value is surfacing choices, options, and alternatives rather than predicting an outcome.

    “It's really about coming up with a number of different scenarios of the future and then interrogating each one and saying, 'Okay, if Scenario One were to come true, what would I wish I had been doing right now in order to put myself in a stronger position for that eventuality?'”

  • Rather than arguing about when the next banking crash would occur (which neither could know), Heffernan and her husband asked 'if there is another banking crash, what will we wish we had been doing now?'—reorganizing investments and resources—which left them feeling robustly prepared without claiming to know the future.

    “'Okay, let's ask a different question. Let's ask the question: If there is another banking crash, or when there is another banking crash, what will we wish we had been doing right now?'”

0.61

The brain simulates futures by retrieving and reconfiguring memories from present attention and experience.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Eleanor Maguire found that London cab drivers who memorized 25,000 streets started with normal brains but developed significantly more gray matter in the hippocampus after qualifying, demonstrating the neuroplasticity of the brain.

    “the people who qualified to be London cab drivers had a significantly, and large amount of gray matter in their hippocampus--which is responsible for memory. So, this was regarded as a great breakthrough, demonstrating the neuroplasticity of the brain.”

  • A signal feature of the human brain is that it constantly creates scenarios of what the next minute, hour, day, month, or year might look like; we cannot simply 'live in the moment' because the brain is built to simulate the future.

    “it's actually one of the signal features of our brain--which is it's constantly creating scenarios of what the next minute, the next hour, the next day, the next month, the next year might look like.”

  • Faulkner's line 'Being knows before knowing remembers' captures how we absorb sensations unconsciously before we consciously notice them and they become memories, perfectly encapsulating Maguire's neuroscience of how the mind sweeps up experience that later becomes the material of memory.

    “'Being knows before knowing remembers.'... we absorb these sensations and they're unconscious before we then notice them. And then there are memories.”

  • Maguire discovered that amnesiacs who cannot remember the past also cannot imagine the future; the brain imagines the future by retrieving memories and reconfiguring them in the present, meaning we are not retrieving a file but reassembling and reenacting memories to construct future scenarios.

    “people who are amnesiacs--so they can't remember the past--also could not imagine the future... the way we think about the future is we're retrieving memories and reconfiguring them.”

0.61

Genuine experimentation and discovery emerge from trying things without knowing outcomes, not from advance planning or copying.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Outstanding artists often create work that ends up being exactly what people want years later, not through prediction but by being fantastic sense-makers—wandering, paying intense attention, and constantly asking 'what does this mean?'—which lets them create work that lasts for decades while tolerating great uncertainty.

    “it wasn't about prediction. It was: They were fantastic sense-makers, and they generally wandered around... they really paid attention to where they were and what people were thinking... constantly mulling over this and thinking, 'What does it mean?'”

  • Much of what passes for innovation in corporations is mere incrementalism—like changing Oreo filling colors for holidays—because nobody wants to make a genuine gamble or risk failure; true experimentation requires doing something where you genuinely do not know the outcome.

    “we've also seen, what I think of as the rise of incrementalism. Which is: I'm going to call it experiment, but it's not, really.”

  • People with tremendous careers almost never planned them; their paths emerged from trying things, disliking them, and trying something else—experimentation is hugely undervalued in personal and career life because at 18 or 19 you don't yet know who you'll become or what the options are.

    “the answer is absolutely not, 'This is how I planned it.' It's the exact opposite. It's like, 'Well, I tried this and I didn't like it, so I tried that.'”

  • Travelers who research and book every hotel, restaurant, site, and walk in advance experience only a generic, pre-seen version of a place; by foreclosing uncertainty in the name of efficiency, they leave out the chance to discover their own version of the city—a metaphor for foreclosing discovery in life itself.

    “what they're going to do is they're going to see a generic Barcelona. They've already seen it in their heads... in foreclosing uncertainty, they've really left out finding their Barcelona.”

0.51

Close attention to present experience and people generates better raw material for imagining futures than passive consumption.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The more you genuinely live in the present and pay attention to your surroundings and people, the better the raw ingredients you have to craft future scenarios; conversely, being absorbed in your phone and the virtual world leaves you with a depleted 'stock cupboard' for generating new ideas.

    “to the degree that you really live in the present--so, you really notice what's around you... you have better ingredients with which to craft these ongoing scenarios of the future.”

  • What Heffernan calls the 'Instagram effect'—everyone seeing what's popular and copying it—homogenizes people, so that subway passengers all share the same style, hairdo, and eyebrows; being most alert to your phone makes everyone rather the same, whereas attention to your own experience makes you distinctly yourself.

    “this is what I think of as the Instagram effect, which is 'Everybody can see what's what and they're all copying it.'”

0.43

Organizations and individuals succeed by separating predictable tasks from complex ones and letting judgment operate where outcomes vary.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Bricks-and-mortar retailers blamed Amazon for their failures while themselves showing a dearth of experimentation, sitting petrified and doing nothing except competing on cost, which is why they failed.

    “everybody has been very happy to use Amazon as the scapegoat for their own failure, but actually you've seen an absolute dearth of experimentation in bricks and mortar retail.”

  • The Bank of England's Chief Data Officer, facing exponentially rising work with flat resources, openly solicited productivity ideas from the entire team rather than retreating to executive offsites; the experiment produced a 10X data-tagging improvement from junior engineers and revealed that great strategic ideas are no respecter of hierarchy and that he had more institutional freedom than he realized.

    “Some very young engineers, kind of almost at the bottom of the hierarchy, come up with a different way of tagging the data; it's a 10X improvement.”

  • A Dutch home-care experiment separated the 'complicated' (predictable, repeatable tasks like contracts and invoicing, best handled by technology) from the 'complex' (unpredictable patients who recover at different rates, best handled by nurse judgment); letting nurses use their own judgment cut costs 30% and patients recovered in half the time.

    “this looks like one piece of work, but it's actually really two... The thing that's complex is the patient... The patients are complex, not complicated... the cost of this style of home care nursing fell by 30%, because the patients got better in half the time”

0.19

Education and long lives require cultivating curiosity and love of learning, not hoarding knowledge that will shift.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Because lifespans are lengthening and people may have several careers, the prime thing education should instill in children is not knowledge per se (which keeps shifting) but a love of learning and curiosity, so they can reinvent themselves across a long life.

    “the prime thing we want to instill in children is not knowledge per se--which will keep shifting--but a love of learning; and being really, really good at learning”

0.15

Living memories and genuine freedom matter more than literal immortality or controlling the future beyond death.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Death has positive value because after children stop grieving their parents, they gain a large sense of freedom—shedding the subtle absorbed parental judgments and deciding for themselves who they are; the best gift one can leave is living memories that the next generation can freely reshape, which is how we 'live forever' without burdening them with an accumulation of losses.

    “when their parents were no longer there, then it was just them deciding who they were... The subtle ways in which we all absorb our parents' judgment, it was gone. And it was wonderful.”

  • The Silicon Valley desire to live forever (the 'Methuselararity') is fundamentally fatuous and a misuse of brainpower; we would not want figures like Hitler or Pol Pot to live forever, and that great talent should instead be directed at real crises like declining longevity, healthcare, and climate change.

    “the whole Silicon Valley desire to live forever was just useless. You want to use all this great brain power, do something useful... we don't want people to live forever. We wouldn't have wanted PoL Pot to live forever. We wouldn't have wanted Hitler to live forever.”

  • Hannah Arendt defines thinking as having a conversation with yourself—repeatedly asking whether something is right and whether it honors what you are trying to do—which is the kind of internal interrogation artists engage in.

    “This is what Hannah Arendt calls having a conversation with yourself--which is how she defines thinking.”