Sarah Carr on Charter Schools, Educational Reform, and Hope Against Hope
What this covers
Sarah Carr discusses her book about three New Orleans schools in the decade after Hurricane Katrina with Russ Roberts on EconTalk. The conversation traces the post-Katrina charter school reforms through their initial promise—standardized tests scores roughly doubled—to their long-term shortcomings. Carr argues that the reform movement collapsed into a False Dichotomy: either schools can overcome all obstacles or they cannot overcome any. This framing pushed reformers toward impossible demands on institutions and students, while obscuring the real constraints that made meaningful change harder than advocates believed.
The discussion ranges across several overlapping failures. Institutional Learning proved impossible when schools experienced chronic staff turnover every four years, particularly as Teach for America recruits and other young white educators cycled through while more experienced Black educators with community roots were sidelined. KIPP Renaissance's rigid discipline succeeded at test prep but eroded family buy-in when parents saw the approach in practice. The reliance on Limits of Quantification—McKinsey-style PowerPoint metrics—left schools disconnected from the trust and affection students needed to persist. Out-of-school realities proved immovable: violence, housing insecurity, and food instability, which schools alone cannot address. Yet Carr also pushes back against passivity—the claim that nothing schools do matters. The tension lies in recognizing both what schools can accomplish and what they cannot, and in building the stable, racially conscious relationships and institutions that the reform movement's instability destroyed.
Carr argues that the New Orleans charter school reforms failed by embracing a false dichotomy—either schools can fix everything or they can fix nothing—when the real path requires both accountability and the stable, trusting, racially-conscious relationships and institutions that the reform movement's instability undermined.
- Test score gains are real but insufficient; long-term college and life outcomes have been disappointing
- Out-of-school factors (poverty, violence, housing/food insecurity) cannot be overcome by schools acting alone
- Chronic personnel instability and reliance on young white outsiders eroded trust and prevented institutional learning
School reform success requires trust between students and educators as a necessary foundation for any intervention.
- The best intentions in the world cannot substitute for fundamental trust between students and educators; building trust and buy-in is the necessary first step before any educational intervention can succeed, as shown by a student who left college after a semester believing her school cared only about numbers and never about her as an individual.
“you can't underestimate the importance of trust and of buy-in. And all sort of the best intentions in the world can't substitute if you don't have that fundamental trust between students and their educators.”
- At KIPP Renaissance the rigid disciplinary approach went awry because many families supported it in theory but, seeing how it played out in practice, grew much more skeptical, leading to an erosion of trust.
“KIPP Renaissance was definitely one of these places where you saw that very rigid approach go awry, because you had a lot of families who supported it in theory, but when they saw how it played out, grew much more skeptical and there was the erosion of that trust.”
- People doing school reform work must fundamentally believe it is not a choice between quality and diversity—that staff can be competent, robust, and talented while also diverse—and the fact that many do not believe this is itself a problem; relatedly, white people in particular need to get more comfortable talking about race and racism rather than taking a deliberately color-blind approach.
“it's not a choice between quality[?] and diversity: That we can have really competent, robust, talented staff and have diversity. And I really think there's a lot of people who don't fundamentally believe that, and that that's a problem.”
- Many young educators were pumped up with a savior mentality—that no problem existed that they and the schools couldn't solve—which was unhealthy for the educators themselves and ultimately harmful for the students.
“there were a lot of young educators who I met who had been kind of pumped up with this savior mentality: that there was no problem that they and the schools couldn't solve. I think that that was unhealthy for them and ultimately harmful for the students, as well.”
Schools alone cannot overcome poverty, violence, housing insecurity, and trauma without complementary systemic support and community partnership.
- Because poor New Orleans families faced high gun violence, economic instability, and housing and food insecurity that did not change after Katrina, you cannot expect—except in rare cases—that schools acting alone can inoculate kids from this broader society; reformers and policymakers must attack the problem along multiple dimensions, and in non-paternalistic ways that earn community trust.
“You just can't expect that, except in really rare cases that the schools are going to be able to inoculate kids from this broader society.”
- Particularly the early charter school educators underestimated the complexity of getting poor first-generation students onto and through a college path and what they would need to have in place to do so successfully.
“a lot of the, particularly the early charter school educators underestimated the complexity and what they would need to have in place to successfully get kids on that path”
- The education reform movement asked schools like KIPP Renaissance to accomplish the impossible—to educate teenagers traumatized by Katrina and by life in a city with decrepit infrastructure, bare-bones welfare, inadequate health care, oversubscribed mental health programs, high violent crime, and corrupt, sometimes racist law enforcement—because the most die-hard advocates believed schools acting in isolation could compensate for all and educate poor children into middle-class lives.
“In some respects, the education reform movement had asked KIPP Renaissance to accomplish the impossible: to educate teenagers traumatized both by Katrina and the daily realities of life in a city with decrepit physical infrastructure, bare-bones welfare services, inadequate health care, grossly oversubscribed mental health and drug treatment programs, one of the nation's highest violent crime rates and corrupt--at times, racist--law enforcement.”
- Even with record-low unemployment before the coronavirus crisis, low pay meant people were not getting living wages, and the often-overlooked strain of constant economic, housing, and food insecurity on families burdens the very students these schools serve.
“We had such low--record low--unemployment rates in places, but that doesn't mean people are getting living wages...the strain of constant economic and housing and food insecurity on the families that are attending the types of schools that we're talking about.”
Chronic staff turnover and rapid principal burnout from demanding, unsupported roles destabilize schools and prevent institutional learning.
- The combination of New Orleans reform practices—recruiting young idealistic non-local educators, closing schools that don't succeed, rigid accountability to test-score benchmarks, and parental choice—produced chronic instability, evidenced by how few of the people leading school buildings during Carr's time there still are, which is a problem because families cannot exercise meaningful choice unless they understand what these institutions are.
“the upshot of all of these policies and practices in New Orleans seem to be...just be chronic instability. You just don't--I can count on one hand the number of people I know who were leading school buildings when I lived there who still are.”
- A major takeaway, whether in charter or non-charter schools, is the power of principals—an incredibly hard job requiring a unique, diverse skill set—and the fact that there are not enough such people and those who exist are burning out far too quickly stood out as one of the big unsolved problems of urban school reform.
“the power of principals, and just that it's an incredibly hard job, and it takes a really unique, diverse skill set, and that we don't have enough of those people and the people that we do are often burning out far too quickly”
- You cannot build a successful school with mass turnover of personnel every four years even with a pipeline of energetic talented newcomers, because an institution cannot learn from and adapt to the lessons of the near or far past without some stability of people.
“To learn, though, you need some stability of people. There are folks that I've interviewed who are pro-reform and pro-charter school who say that you can build the really successful school where there's major teacher turnover every four years...I don't believe that.”
New Orleans reforms created a false choice between test-focused outsiders and locally-rooted educators when schools needed both strengths integrated.
- Post-Katrina New Orleans developed two divergent school profiles—schools staffed by young white newcomers tied to Teach for America who were strategic at test prep, and schools staffed by black veteran educators with organic connection to students' home lives and cultures—and the failure to merge the strengths of both meant schools like PSI Academy lacked the locally-connected staff who could have counseled students toward sustainable, better-fit college choices.
“There were schools that employed mostly young, white newcomers to the city, a lot of whom had ties to Teach for America, and schools that employed mostly black veteran educators who had worked in the schools before Katrina. And I don't think you saw enough merging of those two school profiles to draw on the strengths of both.”
- Before Katrina the New Orleans public school system had horrible results, with the rate of students going on to graduate college in the single digits, failing to set most kids up for long-term educational or life success; there was even a perverse notion that it had been kept that way for economic reasons to supply low-paid service workers.
“If you looked at the rate of students from that system who were going on to graduate college, it was in the single digits.”
- The school reform debate is dominated by a false dichotomy between 'schools can do it all and just need to remove kids from distracting environments to prepare them for college and tests' versus 'outside-of-school factors mean schools can never make a dent'—both views are simplistic and, where they shaped policy, had harmful effects; the truth lies in the middle.
“there was just this false dichotomy between, sort of, 'schools can do it all and we just need to take kids out of these troubled, distracting environments, and focus 100% on preparing them for college and helping them pass standardized tests' versus the 'there's all of these outside-of-school factors; schools are never going to be able to make much of a dent' mentality”
- It is a false dichotomy to oppose a static old system against a dynamic always-changing new system; New Orleans could have nurtured local or Southern charter leaders and networks, refused to green-light schools where 100% of teachers were under 25 and white, and taken other steps that would have produced more accountability, change, and dynamism without creating chronic instability.
“I think it's another false dichotomy between that static old system and this dynamic, always-changing new system.”
Discipline policies imposed by predominantly white-led charter schools on predominantly black students risk racist character regardless of parental support.
- In many cases Carr witnessed, the schools were undeniably too heavy-handed on discipline, though many were genuinely close calls—because when individual kids are disrupting the learning of many classmates, it is very hard to figure out the best approach.
“the schools were, I felt, pretty undeniably too heavy handed. But, there were a lot that were really close calls. And when you had kids that were really disrupting the learning of a lot of their classmates, it's very hard to figure out the best approach.”
- KIPP-style discipline (walking on straight lines, sitting up straight, making eye contact) is not white culture but a phenomenon of predominantly black and brown schools—you do not see it in schools that are 95% white—so when predominantly white-led schools impose strict bodily comportment standards on predominantly black children it takes on a potentially racist character, even though many New Orleans families wanted more structure than pre-Katrina schools had offered.
“the KIPP-style discipline is not white culture. You don't see schools with 95% white kids where they're being asked to walk on straight lines down the hall and sit up straight and make eye contact. That's a phenomenon of predominantly black and brown schools.”
Schools should be held accountable to ambitious college-completion goals over decades, and early evidence shows most fall far short of that standard.
- Post-Katrina reforms produced encouraging short-term gains in standardized test scores, but because many schools explicitly stated their mission as producing first-generation college graduates, they should be held to that standard and assessed over 10, 20, 25, even 50 years; early data (e.g., PSI Academy's first graduating class with only a handful completing college six years out) suggests schools are finding this far harder than they hoped.
“many of these schools stated as their mission that they're going to get first generation college graduates. And I think they should be held to that, and we should be looking 10, 20, 25, 50 years out at whether that's really happening.”
- Rather than transcribing recordings, Carr relied on taking fast written notes during interviews and in schools and typing them up the same evening while memory was fresh, which prevented the project from being prolonged and produced a searchable document plus ideas for follow-up questions.
“the most important thing for me was just typing up my notes at the end of each day, whenever I could.”