What this covers

Robert Pondiscio spent a year embedded in a Success Academy charter school in New York City and discusses what he learned about teaching, education policy, and student achievement with EconTalk host Russ Roberts. Pondiscio's central claim cuts against the common view of Success Academy as a model driven by instructional brilliance or heroic teaching talent. Instead, he argues the network's commanding test results rest on three pillars: a parent population fundamentally self-selected for commitment and bandwidth through nominally random but functionally demanding admissions practices; a relentlessly uniform culture maintained across schools; and a coherent, real curriculum. The conversation weaves between concrete classroom dynamics—how teachers should position themselves during questioning, the adversarial effects of constant grading, the power of the coach-like stance—and systemic claims about what makes schools work at scale.

The substance ranges widely across teaching craft, reading comprehension, and the politics of school choice. Pondiscio argues that background knowledge and vocabulary drive reading success far more than generic decoding strategies, and that schools must prioritize reading volume. He contends that teaching must be systematized to succeed with people of average ability rather than superstars, since classrooms will never be staffed by geniuses. He contrasts The Window and the Mirror—using curriculum to direct students outward to new domains versus catering only to their existing experience. The conversation acknowledges Success Academy's genuine achievement while holding firm that its results cannot be straightforwardly replicated elsewhere, because its conditions—committed parents, consistent culture—cannot be imposed on the unwilling. Pondiscio also identifies real tensions: standardized tests are necessary to prevent neglect of poor and minority students, yet they narrow curricula; removing high-performing students to charter schools genuinely harms neighborhood public schools, yet children belong to families, not systems; charter networks outperform under better conditions, yet comparing them fairly requires asking Compared to What.

Sharpest takeaway

Pondiscio argues that Success Academy's extraordinary test results stem less from a replicable instructional 'magic bullet' than from a self-selecting committed parent population plus a relentlessly consistent culture and a real curriculum, which makes the model powerful but not straightforwardly scalable.

  • Success Academy's demanding admissions process functionally selects for high-bandwidth, motivated parents who become culture keepers
  • What distinguishes the network is uniform culture and a real curriculum, not heroic individual teachers
  • Teaching at scale must be doable by people of average talent, so reformers should build craft and curriculum rather than rely on superstars

The argument · threads9 threads · 38 claims
0.73

Teaching must be configured as a learnable craft routine, not an art requiring genius, so ordinary competent people can do it well.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • A Rand study found roughly 98% of American teachers use materials they created or found themselves, which is a prodigious waste of time—every hour spent building lessons from scratch is an hour not spent studying student work, building relationships, giving feedback, or deepening pedagogical skill; Success Academy avoids this by providing a curriculum.

    “There was a Rand Study done some years ago that showed that teachers, virtually all teachers, like 98% of teachers in America are using materials they either created or found themselves, in their lessons.”

  • Success Academy achieves strong test results with relatively inexperienced staff—not hired off the street, but trained through an intake process and assistant-teacher model—by routinizing teaching in ways most other schools have not.

    “they seem to have cracked the code on getting really good results, test results, with relatively inexperienced staff... But they've routinized it in a way that a lot of other folks have not.”

  • At scale, teaching must be a job that can be done well by people of average ability, because that is who staffs classrooms and all we are ever likely to have—there are not 3.7 million 'classroom saints and superstars,' so systems should make teaching a craft a competent person can succeed at quickly, like McDonald's reliably produces a good hamburger without requiring genius managers.

    “At scale, teaching must be a job that can be done well and competently by people of average sentience and talent. That is who we have in our classrooms and all we are likely ever to have.”

  • The way teaching is configured—requiring teachers to design their own lessons and differentiate for every skill and need in the classroom—has made the job literally beyond the ability of ordinary people to do competently; reform has made teaching too hard for mere mortals.

    “we were making teaching too hard for mere mortals... not only are you going to design your lessons on your own, you're going to differentiate for every skill and need in your classroom, etc. It is literally beyond the ability of ordinary people to do this job competently.”

  • Great teachers are not simply born; given a baseline desire to do the job and affection for children, teaching is best understood as a noble craft—a learnable suite of skills and moves—rather than an innate disposition, and there is no evidence for the 'born teacher.'

    “we would be better off if we thought of teaching, frankly, as more of a craft than a profession... a series of moves, and as opposed to a disposition, and this idea that you're a born teacher. I don't see any evidence for that.”

  • Success Academy distinguishes between planning the lesson and planning to teach the lesson ('intellectual preparation'): because the curriculum already exists, teachers invest their preparation time in rehearsing delivery, developing questioning strategies, and preparing feedback rather than inventing content.

    “they make a great virtue of what they call intellectual preparation: planning to teach the lesson as opposed to planning the lesson.”

0.64

Success Academy is excellent for its population but not scalable because its conditions require willing participants and rare cultural consistency.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Success Academy is excellent for the population it serves but not scalable, because its conditions cannot be imposed on the unwilling and because replicating Moskowitz's consistent culture across many schools is extraordinarily difficult—no other charter network of comparable size achieves the same consistency without weak outliers.

    “I don't think Success Academy is scalable... Does that mean that every school should be a Success Academy? No, because you couldn't impose these conditions on the unwilling.”

  • Whether Success Academy is the right choice depends entirely on a family's alternatives: Pondiscio wouldn't choose it over an elite private school, but would choose it in a heartbeat over the failing public school where he taught; the real goal is giving low-income parents the same 'good, better, best' range of choices the affluent enjoy, rather than a binary of one horrible option and a lifeboat.

    “Would I send my kid to Success Academy Bronx 1 instead of PS 277, where I taught for five years? Of course, I would.”

  • A charter school is a public school in that it charges no tuition and has open admissions, but it is government-funded and privately managed (not privately owned); most American charters, and all of New York's and Success Academy's, are not-for-profit.

    “A charter school is a public school in so far as it does not charge tuition and has open admissions; but basically it's government funded and privately run.”

0.53

Success Academy achieves remarkable consistency across all its schools, reflecting an unusually coherent and strong organizational culture.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The single most striking feature of Success Academy is the profound level of investment and caring the adults have in the children (the 'Care a Lot factor'); whatever form it takes, anyone spending significant time there who fails to see this level of caring simply doesn't want to see it.

    “It's just impossible to spend a significant amount of time at one of these schools and not be struck by the, just the profound, level of investment that the adults in Bronx 1 had in their children.”

  • What makes Success Academy uniquely worthy of study is the consistency of its results across all schools, which Pondiscio attributes to an unusually consistent and coherent organizational culture—more consistent than any corporate culture he had seen.

    “In my mind, it has to do with that consistency of culture.”

  • If Success Academy were a standalone school district in New York State, it would by a considerable distance be the highest-performing district in the state based on test scores.

    “if they were a standalone school district in the State of New York, Russ, they would be by far the best performing school district--based on test scores.”

  • Across roughly 36-37 of Success Academy's testing-grade schools, even the poorest performer had about 85% of kids at or above grade level in reading and 92% in math, with about 90% of students being low-income kids of color—meaning there is, uniquely, no weak school in the network.

    “the poorest performing school had, again from memory, 85% of their kids at/or above grade level in reading. All the other ones were better. In math, 92%--that was the worst one.”

0.50

Reading comprehension depends overwhelmingly on background knowledge and vocabulary built through high-volume reading, not transferable decoding strategies.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Contrary to the misconception—driven partly by standardized tests—that reading is a decoding-plus-strategies skill that transfers to any text, reading comprehension depends overwhelmingly on shared background knowledge and vocabulary; the Recht and Leslie baseball study showed low-ability readers with high baseball knowledge outperformed high-ability readers lacking it, proving what you read about matters prodigiously.

    “language proficiency and reading comprehension has much more to do with shared background knowledge, and vocabulary. That it's not enough to know the words and the 26 letters, but you have to have context.”

  • The way to grow background knowledge and vocabulary is through sheer volume of reading; even children's books contain more rare and unique words than the conversational language of college graduates, which is why Success Academy valorizes 'tonnage'—requiring kids to read every night and log everything.

    “the number of rare and unique words that you see in even children's books is more sophisticated than the language of college graduates conversationally... So, the way that you grow background knowledge and vocabulary is through volumes of reading.”

  • Conventional teaching uses the 'mirror'—letting kids read only what reflects their own experience to engage them—but this forces mediocrity by never leading children to what they don't know; good schools like Success Academy instead use the 'window,' directing kids' attention outward to science, history, art, and music, restoring teachers to their role as guides to the universe.

    “If that school of thought is the mirror, well, what you see at Success Academy and other good schools is the window. You're forever directing kids' attention not in the mirror, but out the window.”

0.47

Success Academy's admissions process, though nominally a lottery, functionally selects for committed families with time and resources.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Success Academy's admissions, while nominally a lottery with roughly six applicants per seat, layers compulsory welcome meetings, paperwork, uniform fittings, and dress rehearsals on top, raising effective odds to about one-in-two while functionally selecting for parents with the time and commitment to persist—producing a population disproportionately married, employed, religious or spiritual, and ambitious for their kids who become the culture's keepers.

    “Because Success makes such prodigious demands on parent time, showing up for meetings... it just seems pointless to deny that some number of parents--this is simply too much.”

  • The parental engagement advantage that powers Success Academy is identical to what affluent suburban families provide by choosing neighborhoods, buying homes (whose property taxes act as de facto tuition), and assuming their kids will go to college—an advantage so normalized it goes unnoticed as 'the water we swim in.'

    “they have unquestioned access to educational excellence, either by purchasing it or by purchasing a home where your real estate taxes are your de facto tuition to a public private, as it were, school in a Bethesda or a Scarsdale”

0.44

Education reform and debate harmfully oversimplify causes, underestimate poverty's concentrated effects, and require more honest nuanced framings.

10 pointscentrality 2/5
  • When a motivated parent moves a child from a neighborhood public school to a charter, the loss to the public school is real—removing such students measurably changes the classroom—but treating the child as a 'public resource' that must stay is illegitimate, because the child belongs to the family, not the system.

    “We don't have the right to keep that kid there because the kid is not a public resource. But this is the tension that exists in all of this work”

  • While standardized tests are necessary—the pre-testing era was 'a permission slip to disregard' poor and minority kids' outcomes—they have a real downstream effect of narrowing the curriculum, reducing many children's education to reading, math, and test prep while stripping out the subjects that give kids a reason to come to school.

    “I refuse to pretend that it isn't having a downstream effect, in terms of narrowing the curriculum, in terms of, you know, reducing a child's education too often to just a whole lot of reading, math, and test prep and not much else; and that's not okay either.”

  • It is an open and currently unanswerable question whether high third-through-eighth-grade test scores translate into longer-term attainment, since the first Success Academy cohort are only college sophomores; KIPP, a 20-25-year-old network, provides the leading edge of data and currently graduates about 50% of students from college against a 75% goal.

    “the first cohort of Success Academy kids are only, as we speak, sophomores in college. So, it's not like we've got a large n-size, here”

  • The dominant logic of education reform assumes we don't need to understand what happens inside the classroom 'black box'—we only need to measure outputs—because it presumes schools and teachers already know what to do; this assumption is false, as evidenced by how little practical guidance teachers actually receive.

    “The logic of education reform, broadly speaking, is what? We don't need to know what happens inside that black box. We just need to measure what comes out of it. That's predicated on the assumption that schools and teachers know what to do.”

  • Most schools of education don't see it as their job to teach the practical nuts and bolts of teaching—how to stand when asking questions, how to hand out papers, how to cold-call students—which is precisely what new teachers need most, leaving them unprepared.

    “he's giving teachers what they really need, which is stand still when asking questions, practice handing out papers, cold-call students. Just nuts and bolts of teaching that most schools of education don't think is their job.”

  • Success Academy can't expand to its desired 100 schools because New York's charter school cap leaves no more charters to issue, and charters have become politically unpopular—particularly on the Left—despite serving low-income kids of color best.

    “we're hard up against the charter school cap in the State of New York. So, there are no more charters to be given out, politically, at the moment.”

  • The education debate is harmfully reduced to two narratives—that the only difference between good and bad outcomes is which door a child walks through, versus the opposite—when the reality is far more complicated; both narratives have served education poorly, and progress requires more honest, nuanced framings.

    “we tend to want to reduce this to one of two narratives... 'the only difference is the door that the kid walks in, in the morning.' ... Well, it's a lot more complicated than that, obviously.”

  • It will not do for reformers to ask why neighborhood public schools can't match charter results, because those schools deal with the concentrated effects of poverty and dysfunction; their job is genuinely harder, and the ed-reform world has been insufficiently mindful of that reality.

    “when folks in neighborhood schools say, 'Look, we're dealing with all the concentrated effects of poverty and dysfunction. Our job is harder,' they're not wrong. They're right about that.”

  • Nonprofits doing important work should pay competitively to attract great talent, so criticism of Moskowitz's high salary is misplaced given the performance she delivers and the far greater sum she could command in the private sector.

    “Do you have any idea what money this woman would make in the private sector with her ability to just put her stamp on a school culture?”

  • There is no evidence that requiring teachers to hold a master's degree or teaching certificate, or graduate schools of education generally, pays any educational dividends; an academy teaching the practical craft of classroom management and instruction would be more valuable than teaching the latest, often-rejected education theories.

    “There's no evidence that it pays any dividends.”

0.36

Strict regimentation and small-rule enforcement create conditions for learning and signal high expectations without being arbitrary.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The strict regimentation—straight lines, uniforms, tracking the teacher with one's eyes—is not imposed for its own sake but creates the conditions for learning, joy, and participation, since students' attention is a prerequisite for learning.

    “we don't do this because we enjoy imposing our will upon students. This creates the conditions for learning, for joy, for participation. And she's absolutely right.”

  • Success Academy's enforcement of small rules like uniform sock color is a culture-keeping mechanism modeled on broken windows theory: by sweating the small stuff, the big stuff takes care of itself, signaling that expectations are high and preventing the chaos that impedes learning in typical inner-city schools.

    “It's a culture-keeping mechanism. Right? Another thing that we're not supposed to talk about in social policy anymore is broken windows theory. But, I mean, this is what that looks like, right? In other words, if you sweat the small stuff, then the big stuff takes care of itself.”

  • A teacher becomes more effective the moment they stop trying to make students like them; the belief that being liked makes students work harder is unreliable—some will, some won't—and pursuing students' affection is a misunderstanding of the tough-love role of teaching, which is about what you can do for them, not what they can do for you.

    “I became a lot more effective the moment I stopped trying to make kids like me.”

0.36

Elementary years are where educational trajectories are determined, making Success Academy's early focus the critical battleground.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • How a child is doing at the end of third grade almost certainly predicts how that child will do for the rest of his or her educational trajectory, which is why the elementary years are where the educational battle is won or lost.

    “you tell me how a kid is doing at the end of third grade, and I'll tell you how that kid is going to do almost certainly for the rest of his or her educational trajectory.”

  • Even bracketing whether test scores are the right measure, having large numbers of low-income kids of color succeed in school—where they, their friends, teachers, and parents are all 'in on it'—transforms a community's typically adversarial relationship with the civic institution of school into a productive one, with powerful downstream effects.

    “there's something powerful about large numbers of low-income kids of color in a neighborhood like the South Bronx, all doing well.”

  • Pondiscio predicts that within a couple of years the data on the first KIPP cohorts will show a real effect—not just on test scores but on broader life outcomes like employment, marital stability, substance abuse, and incarceration—driven by the schools' culture and students' productive relationship with school.

    “I would bet you a prodigious sum of money that you're going to see a real effect from, not just the test scores, but the culture of those schools and that productive relationship with the school.”

0.34

Treating parents as capable partners rather than subjects of low expectations produces genuine engagement and transforms community relation to school.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Success Academy elementary schools have no formal parent-teacher conferences because the absence of busing means parents do daily pickup and drop-off, giving constant face time; teachers can summon parents at dismissal or hold an 'upstairs dismissal' requiring parents to come to the classroom.

    “because they have face time all the time... every day at pick up and drop off... there's no transportation.”

  • The dominant mindset in education, even at good charter schools, that 'we can't make demands on parents'—whether framed as humane or as quiet disregard—is a continuation of the soft bigotry of low expectations, now applied to parents; Moskowitz instead treats parents as capable partners, and it shows.

    “I fear that the soft bigotry of low expectations hasn't gone away: we just apply it to parents now.”