Yuval Levin on A Time to Build
What this covers
Yuval Levin and Russ Roberts examine why Americans trust their institutions less than they once did, and what internal change might restore that trust. Levin argues the problem is not that institutions fail to perform their functions, but that they have stopped forming trustworthy people altogether. Where institutions once worked as molds—shaping participants through norms and shared purpose—they now function as platforms for individual visibility and self-promotion. This shift has inverted the incentives: politicians seek power to gain media attention rather than seeking attention as a means to power; journalists build personal brands on social media at the expense of professional authority; members of Congress understand their role as a way to be seen. The conversation traces this breakdown across media, politics, academia, and religion, and considers what it would take for individuals to reclaim a role-based ethic that asks not "how can I advance myself here?" but "given my role in this institution, how should I behave?"
The discussion distinguishes between two institutional failures. Insiderism—the familiar corruption of using power to abuse it—has given way to the more corrosive outsiderism, where participants reject the institution's formative purpose entirely. Levin traces this partly to prosperity and media fragmentation, which let people inhabit small worlds where they can feel famous without institutional mediation, and partly to a deep American cultural strand rooted in Protestant distrust of institutions themselves. He argues that disagreeing sustainably requires the very institutional structures now weakening—the places where compromise and accommodation happen. The military emerges as an exception: it retains public trust because people believe it forms better people. The path forward, Levin suggests, requires not external mandates but internal shifts in how individuals see their institutional roles, combined with changed incentives that make such formation possible again.
Levin argues that America's crisis of trust stems from institutions ceasing to function as molds that form trustworthy people and instead becoming platforms for individual self-promotion, and that restoring trust requires people to ask 'given my role here, how should I behave?'
- Trust in an institution depends on believing it forms trustworthy people via an internal ethic, not merely that it performs a function
- The shift from 'insiderism' (corruption) to 'outsiderism' (using institutions as platforms) is the novel modern failure
- Reform requires people inside institutions to want to be formed, supported by changed incentives, not external mandates
Institutions stopped molding norms and enforcing accountability, becoming performative rather than formative.
- What has changed is that the people in charge of institutions have become increasingly uncomfortable imposing norms and social expectations on participants—across journalism, hospitals, universities, religion, and even families—so that the molding function has fallen away over the last 50 years.
“the people in charge of individual parts of organizations that make up the larger institution have become increasingly uncomfortable with imposing those norms and social expectations on their participants.”
- Across the board, American institutions have become performative rather than formative—the ground has shifted beneath the people inside them—so that journalists who once strove to be objective now publicly abandon that aspiration, and universities do something fundamentally different from the truth-seeking they once embodied.
“these institutions as you put it, have become per-formative rather than formative.”
- Trust breaks down not just when insiders behave deviously, but when participants act in ways that don't conform to the perceived mission of the institution—such as a journalist self-promoting on Twitter to the degradation of truth-seeking, or a doctor prescribing a drug from a pharma company that gave them a conference vacation—which strikes observers as a breakdown of the institution's purpose.
“if you see a journalist promoting himself or herself on Twitter to the degradation of their role as truth seeker, I find that weird... for me, it's a breakdown of something.”
- From an economist's view, a participant looking out for themselves rather than their institution—a journalist or a professor enhancing their personal brand at the institution's expense—is a free rider problem; societies historically punish free riders through shame, jail, or fines, and what has changed is the willingness and ability of those with power to impose such costs, partly because punished people can now simply leave for somewhere less constraining.
“the way an economist would usually look at this is it's a free rider problem... I have an incentive to pursue my own self-interest at the expense of the group's.”
Self-interested information consumption and echo chambers prevent exposure to counterarguments and correction.
- A strategy of reading only books that have stood the test of time (or distrusting everything on Twitter) yields more trustworthy material in theory, but at the cost of missing valuable new work.
“The upside of that is that you will have more trustworthy--in theory at least because things have stood the test of time. The problem is you won't read A Time to Build”
- When we consume only the stream of information that makes us feel good—as is natural and pleasant—we fool ourselves and lose the contrarian voice, the counterpoint, and the possibility of being told we are wrong, and the unease we feel when confronted with our own biases is a real component of the broader loss of confidence.
“when I only consume the stream of information that makes me feel good, which I think is what a lot of us do, I am fooling myself. I've lost something. I've lost the voice of--the contrarian voice. I've lost the voice of counterpoint. I've lost the voice of 'Maybe you're wrong.'”
Seeing oneself as ensemble participant rather than hero enables productive, kind life and flourishing society.
- Roberts predicts, half-jokingly, that 2020 will be called the most important election of our lifetime—a claim we will hear repeatedly and which could turn out to be true.
“I have a feeling that 2020 will be the most important election of our lifetime.”
- Rather than seeing ourselves as the hero of a great narrative—which sometimes saves us but often makes us unkind—it is better to see ourselves as part of an ensemble, playing a cooperative role that ties people together and listens rather than waiting to speak; combined with asking what your role requires and recognizing it isn't all about you, this is a useful way to live a productive, kind life and a flourishing society.
“it might be better to think of ourselves as being part of an ensemble--a role that's not the starring role; a role that's maybe a cooperative; a role that ties people together; a role that listens to what the other person has to say rather than trying to think of what you want to say next.”
- Economics focuses relentlessly on individual satisfaction, maximization, and optimization—teaching that we act alone—even though in real life we have friends, clubs, and religious communities; the discipline's analytical mechanism runs almost entirely through the individual, with few exceptions like Gary Becker.
“you could argue that economists focus relentlessly on individual satisfaction, individual maximization, individual optimization. It's all about the individual.”
Political system is losing trust in checks and balances, drifting toward winner-take-all competition.
- American political life is drifting toward a European-style winner-take-all system—growing use of executive orders, increasingly extreme nominees, and the rationale on both sides that 'we must win everything now because the other side will ruin everything'—reflecting a deep loss of trust in the system's pendulum, counterbalance, and required compromise.
“it seems like we're moving toward that European system. The use of executive orders by the President, which just keeps growing, which I find repellent.”