What this covers
Marty Makary, a Johns Hopkins physician, joins Russ Roberts to examine why American health care has become unaffordable and why the public has lost trust in it. Rather than blame inadequate funding, Makary argues the system suffers from two structural pathologies: the prevalence of unnecessary medical care and the near-total opacity of hospital pricing. The conversation draws on data from physician surveys, hospital billing studies, and price comparisons across procedures to sketch a portrait of a market fundamentally unlike any other in American commerce. Makary proposes that price transparency and market entry—not policy overhauls like Medicare for All—offer the most direct route to restoring both affordability and confidence.
The episode ranges across the mechanics of waste and exploitation. Makary presents evidence that roughly 21 percent of all medical care is unnecessary, with a paradoxical pattern: the safer a procedure, the more it tends to be overused. He details the predatory side of hospital operations—secret pricing, wage garnishment of low-income patients, and the steering of vulnerable populations into unproven interventions like repeat arterial stenting. He contrasts this with markets that have operated under price transparency for decades: LASIK eye surgery, IVF treatments, and cosmetic procedures have all seen price declines over three decades, while general medical prices have outpaced inflation. The conversation also examines how fee-for-service billing drives both unnecessary procedures and physician burnout, and explores emerging alternatives—employer-sponsored clinics and capitation-based models—that align incentives toward value rather than volume.
Makary argues American health care is broken not from underfunding but from two ignored problems—rampant unnecessary care and opaque, irrational pricing—and that price transparency plus market disruption, not Medicare for All, is the path to restoring affordability and public trust.
- Roughly 21% of medical care is unnecessary, and the safer a procedure is, the more it is overused
- Hospital prices are secret, random, and uncorrelated with quality, enabling gouging and predatory billing including wage garnishment
- Markets with transparent pricing (LASIK, IVF, cosmetic surgery) have seen price declines, suggesting transparency would work broadly
Medicine systematically overuses safe procedures and medications beyond what evidence supports.
- The biggest under-discussed problem in U.S. health care is too much medical care—over-screening, over-testing, over-diagnosing, and the medicalization of ordinary life—and this problem of overuse dominates the problem of too little care or access.
“We've got the problem of too much medical care and too little care or access issues. But by far the problem of too much care dominates our problem in healthcare today.”
- Opioid prescriptions roughly doubled from 2.4 billion to about 5 billion over a decade even though disease did not double, illustrating a crisis of appropriateness in medication prescribing.
“Five years ago, we were prescribing 2.4 billion meds. Sorry, 10 years ago, we were prescribing 2.4 billion meds. Last year it hit 5 billion. Did disease really double in the last 5, 10 years? No.”
- No study has shown that heart stents increase survival outside of an acute coronary syndrome (active heart attack); stents replace the artery's natural lining with bare metal, creating in-stent restenosis risk and requiring blood thinners that cause GI bleeds and dangerous falls in seniors.
“do you know that no study has ever shown that heart stents increased survival outside of an acute coronary syndrome, which is basically an active heart attack?”
- The safer a medical procedure is, the more it tends to be overused and abused, because low risk reduces resistance to performing it—examples include meniscectomies, endoscopy biopsies, skin cancer surgery, and leg artery stenting.
“Our research shows, Russ that the safer a procedure is, the more it's vastly over overused and abused.”
- The dominant theme in the medical literature over the past five years is that medicine has been doing too much, and indications previously thought appropriate are being narrowed across many conditions—termed precision medicine, appropriateness, or sound clinical judgment.
“If there's one theme in the medical literature in the last five years, it's been that we have been doing too much.”
- A published survey of 2,100 U.S. doctors (70% response rate) found physicians estimate 21% of all medical care is unnecessary, including 25% of diagnostic testing, 22% of medications, and 11% of medical procedures.
“We did a survey of U.S. doctors asking them to estimate the magnitude of this problem and they say 21% of all medical care is unnecessary. That's the voice of frontline docs.”
- Doctors' use of framing language ('nudges') can be as powerful as IV sedation in steering patients toward procedures, and a fraction of doctors (7-15% depending on the area) use these nudge terms to steer patients toward unnecessary or unsupported procedures—sometimes for the doctor's benefit rather than the patient's.
“Nudges from doctors can be as powerful as IV sedation. Sometimes we steer patients towards what's best for them. Sometimes we steer patients toward what's best for us.”
Healthcare billing practices deliberately target vulnerable patients through surprise bills and wage garnishment.
- What distinguishes the healthcare market from others is price gouging that takes advantage of people at the moment they are most vulnerable, violating hospitals' founding mission as safe havens for the sick and injured rather than places to gouge them.
“you have price gouging, taking advantage of people at a time when they are vulnerable.”
- Contrary to the claim that no one pays sticker prices, the uninsured, Amish, and faith-based co-op members are billed full sticker prices, and about 20% of U.S. hospitals—including major names—sue these patients to garnish wages, place liens on homes, or deduct state income tax, most commonly suing employees of Walmart, postal workers, and food service workers.
“some hospitals will sue them in court to garnish their wages. The most common business whose employer gets sued is Walmart, followed by postal workers, food service workers.”
- Makary's team defends sued patients pro bono and wins 100% of cases on the legal theory that without a written agreement specifying the price, the hospital has no right to garnish wages, lien homes, or deduct state income tax—deliberately losing one case to take it to Appeals Court.
“We win 100% of these cases, Russ. We lost one case deliberately in order to take it to Appeals Court.”
- Surprise billing is a deliberate practice of taking services off the master hospital bill and billing around insurance so they're labeled not covered, allowing the healthcare business—ambulances, labs, doctor groups—to collect more by billing patients directly.
“Surprise bills are the game of taking your services off the master hospital bill, billing around insurance: 'Gotcha. It's not covered.' And you can collect more as a business”
- Half of America has less than $400 of cash in their savings account and lives paycheck-to-paycheck, making them especially vulnerable to hospital lawsuits and wage garnishment.
“Half of America has less than $400 of cash in their savings account. They live paycheck-to-paycheck”
Hospital prices are random, disconnected from quality, and vary wildly for identical services.
- A University of Iowa study where a surgeon called 100 hospitals for a heart bypass price found quotes ranging from $44,000 to half a million dollars, with no correlation whatsoever between price and quality (using the mature heart surgery registry) and no correlation between price and charity care—proving prices are random and haphazard.
“The price ranged from $44,000 to half a million dollars... No correlation whatsoever between price and quality. Some of the best hospitals where some of the cheapest.”
- Two Harvard hospitals charge wildly different prices for a baby delivery—$41,000 versus $7,000—despite both being good hospitals, illustrating that price differences do not track quality.
“Harvard, one of their hospitals charges $41,000. Another one of their hospitals charges $7,000. Both Harvard hospitals. Is one really that much better than the other? No”
- Hospitals inherited a game of inflating list prices for the purpose of offering secret insurance discounts selectively to different groups, with insurers and hospitals each maintaining thousands of different negotiated prices for the same service.
“this crazy game of inflating prices for the purpose of offering secret insurance discounts selectively to different groups.”
- Hospitals have never itemized the price of individual services—even a surgeon specializing in pancreatic surgery couldn't state the price—because they have operated by eyeballing global revenue and expenses, a workflow shaped by regulatory and care demands and never required by the market until high-deductible plans exposed the pricing game.
“I could tell you 5,000 things about the pancreas with authority, except for one: the price of it.”
Proxy shoppers and transparent pricing in competitive markets drive costs down without sacrificing care.
- Adam Russo, running a self-funded employer health plan that bypasses insurance via a Third Party Administrator, could see that both a $41,000 and a $7,000 hospital deliver babies equally well, so he offered free diapers and wipes for a year to employees who chose the $7,000 hospital—everyone went there and he saved over a million dollars.
“'If they go to the $7,000 hospitals, he will give them free diapers and wipes for a year.' And guess what? Everybody is going there. He's saved over a million dollars.”
- A minority of price-conscious 'penny shoppers' (like Makary's frugal mother) keep markets in check for everyone else, and in healthcare the proxy shoppers driving the market are not just out-of-pocket patients but health plans and self-funded employers who can compare prices.
“her and the 10% of shoppers like her that are penny shopping, keep markets in check for the rest of us.”
- The economist argument that transparency causes anti-competitive collusion rests on a single outlier—the CBO citing two cement companies in Denmark where one's public pricing led to shadow pricing—but with only two firms it was obvious collusion; in markets generally and in LASIK, IVF, and cosmetic surgery, transparency moves prices toward stable, lower levels.
“they cited the two cement companies in the Danish market... Well that was--there's only two companies that make cement in that entire country. Obviously, that was price collusion. Obviously, it was a one-off.”
- The three areas of medicine with transparent pricing for decades—LASIK eye surgery, IVF treatments, and cosmetic procedures—have seen a global reduction in pricing over three decades, while medical prices generally have outpaced inflation and grown faster than any other area in the economy, demonstrating that price transparency lowers costs.
“the three areas of medicine that have had transparent pricing for decades: LASIK eye surgery, IVF treatments, and cosmetic procedures. They have had a global reduction in pricing”
- Just as markets responded when enough consumers asked for organic or low-sugar food, healthcare markets are now responding to consumers asking about prices—new marketplaces like MDSave, Sesame Health, Fairhealth.org, and Kayak-like comparison sites are emerging regardless of government action, driven by an increasingly informed public.
“When enough people asked in restaurants if food was organic, guess what? The market responded... And people are now asking.”
- A Hopkins study of centers that switched from the price run-around to transparent pricing found their business surged and patient satisfaction rose sharply, because transparent billing serves as a surrogate for honest medical care—patients didn't feel financially violated, supporting that billing quality is medical quality.
“saw what happened for the centers that adopted price transparency. Their business surged. Patient satisfaction went way up.”
Current healthcare market structure exploits vulnerable patients and violates hospitals' founding mission.
- If airlines operated like hospitals—no upfront prices and billing after the flight with excuses about uncertainty—they would gouge customers with surprise bills, demonstrating why the current healthcare market structure is dysfunctional.
“If airlines had no prices for their flights... You'd be flying to Chicago and get a surprise bill for $8,000 and a flurry of bills would trickle in later”
- Doctors recruit elderly patients—often in African-American churches via health fairs—for ultrasound screening of benign leg artery plaques, then funnel them into angiograms and repeat stenting procedures funded by Medicare, despite no good science supporting the intervention.
“we've found doctors in the fellowship hall during a health fair... with an ultrasound probe telling patients, 'Let's take a look and see if we see a blockage.' And then before you know it, 'Come to our center because we want to do an angiogram'”
- U.S. polls show 68% of the public have avoided or delayed medical care for fear of the bill, and 29% with a very serious condition have done so; if half the public doesn't trust the system, even effective cures and operations are undermined, creating a public trust problem that must be rebuilt.
“68% of the public says that they have avoided or delayed medical care for fear of the bill.”
- Veterinary services exhibit price gouging—running batteries of tests without explaining costs and presenting large bills afterward—fed by the same lack of price transparency, even though pet care has no third-party payment.
“there is price gouging with veterinary services. They will run this battery of tests without explaining the cost and come back and... 'Here's the bill.'”
- Pure pay-out-of-pocket theory fails because people are not equal in health—those born with genetic abnormalities or who develop exposure-related cancers shouldn't bear more pain for inherited conditions—and society has bipartisanly agreed preexisting conditions shouldn't gauge coverage, but proxy shoppers can keep markets competitive without requiring sick patients to see prices.
“not everybody is created equal in terms of their health. Why should somebody with a genetic abnormality... feel more pain because of a condition that they've inherited? No.”
- The polarized pro/con healthcare debate is an artificial facade invented by media and politicians; in reality Americans are united in believing surprise billing violates public trust, suing patients has gone too far, and tax-exempt hospitals price-gouging the vulnerable betrays the profession's mission.
“let's agree to turn off cable news and shut down this artificial facade, polarized debate that was invented by the media and politicians that we're a divided country on healthcare. No, we're united.”
Market-based reform through transparency and waste reduction, not financing overhaul, fixes healthcare's core failures.
- Makary's team created five measures of billing quality (whether hospitals charge for complications, promptly address billing errors, provide prices for shoppable services, and whether they sue patients), to be published in JAMA and used by hospital rating groups and even Google search results to rebuild public trust through accountability.
“We've created five measures of billing quality that are about to come out in the Journal of the American Medical Association.”
- Makary's JAMA research found that all the money a hospital collects from garnishing the wages of paycheck-to-paycheck patients amounts to less than half the CEO's pay at that institution, proving hospitals don't need to sue patients to survive.
“we found it's less than the CEO pay at the hospital. All the money they collect from garnishing the wages... less than half the CEO pay at that institution. They don't have to do this.”
- An airline ticket from Washington DC to Miami cost $76 in 1978 and about $112 today off-peak, representing reasonable price inflation over decades because free, open markets keep prices in check—unlike medical prices.
“the price of an airline ticket from Washington, DC to Miami was $76 in 1978. Today, it's about $112 in a non-off-peak.”
- Rather than throwing good money after bad into a broken system, the path forward is to give free markets a chance through basic price transparency for shoppable services and cutting waste, which would produce significant improvement—the debate should move from how to finance the broken system to how to fix it via addressing inappropriate care and pricing failures.
“if we can cut the waste instead of throwing good money after bad into a broken system, I think you'll start to see magical things happening.”
Billing-throughput incentives fuel physician burnout and worsen care quality through productivity pressure.
- Employers opening their own clinics (like Walmart) and Direct Primary Care models can control referrals and steer patients to high-value specialists, paid by global capitation rather than the broken billing-throughput model, freeing doctors from coding to spend time on chronic illness—steering toward value is one of the great holy grails of healthcare.
“Steering is one of the great holy grails, I think, of healthcare. If we can have steering from primary care, from employers and even health plans to high-value centers”
- Physician burnout rates are at record highs partly because of the billing-throughput model—doctors see a patient for 10 minutes then spend 5 minutes billing and coding, and studies show doctors do their charting on nights and Saturdays, a problem capitation-based clinics eliminate.
“Our burnout rates as doctors are at record highs. Why are we doing it? It's so broken. To see a patient for 10 minutes and spend 5 minutes billing and coding”
Medicare for All is fiscally unworkable given current federal healthcare spending levels and system strains.
- A Johns Hopkins study found 48% of all federal spending goes to healthcare in its many hidden forms—including half of Social Security going to Medicare costs, the Defense Department's health system (8% of its budget), the VA (4.5% of federal spending), federal worker coverage (1.2%), and part of the interest on the debt.
“we just had a study come out at Johns Hopkins that 48% of all federal spending goes to healthcare in its many hidden forms.”
- Medicare for All is fiscally irresponsible because, with federal spending already at 48% for healthcare, funding it while keeping hospitals open would require an enormous increase in healthcare spending, the Medicare Trust Fund is already strained, and 15% of Medicare spending comes from premiums drawn from Social Security.
“If you want to fund a Medicare For All system and still have hospitals that are open, we are talking about tens of thousands of percent increase in our current healthcare spending as a government.”
Broker kickbacks and commission structures corrupt employer health plan purchasing like subprime mortgage markets.
- Most businesses are overpaying on health and pharmacy plans because the broker industry that sells them takes commissions for life (regulated at 4% in New York) plus back-end kickbacks from insurers to retain business, an industry as corrupted as the subprime mortgage broker industry, placing employers in plans they shouldn't be in.
“they take commissions for life many times... They take 4% of every dollar you as a business and your employees spend health insurance premiums. They take 4% for life.”
Government-run systems inevitably underfund healthcare through year-over-year budget cuts relative to inflation.
- Government healthcare systems invariably dial down their overall expenditure year-to-year through gradual belt-tightening, so that 10-20 years later you are left with a dilapidated or at minimum underfunded system—as seen in Medicare's year-over-year cuts relative to inflation—threatening America's world-leading hospitals.
“Governments invariably over time, 100% of the time in every example in the world, dialed down their overall healthcare expenditure year-to-year with a broad minor tightening of the belt.”