What this covers
Ryan Holiday and Russ Roberts explore how stillness—understood as present-focused clarity and inner composure—functions as both an intrinsic good and a practical asset. Holiday draws on examples ranging from performance artist Marina Abramovic's endurance piece to JFK's restraint during the Cuban Missile Crisis, arguing that stillness emerges not from pursuing it directly but from the conditions we deliberately create: ritual, routine, journaling, and radical presence. The conversation moves between philosophy, psychology, and practical method, examining why distraction and the relentless pursuit of "more" corrode peace, and how anger—however seductive as fuel—ultimately defeats itself.
A central claim is that the ideal of stillness recurs across Stoicism, Buddhism, Christianity, and Confucianism, suggesting it captures something durable about human flourishing rather than a modern invention. Holiday distinguishes between Ensue vs Pursue—stillness cannot be chased directly but follows from conditions you construct. The pair discuss anger specifically: Holiday argues it is nearly always self-defeating, a modern rationalization without historical foundation, while Roberts notes that losing your temper has never actually improved things. They also examine how the mind tricks itself through The Power of Enough: conquest breeds only appetite for more conquest, a pattern Stefan Zweig observed across history. On the tactical side, Holiday explains his Active Reading / Commonplace Book system—hand-written notecards filed by theme—as superior to passive digital clipping because repeated engagement with material produces retention and pattern-finding. He also addresses why meditation prescriptions fail most readers, and how hand-written Spiritual Windshield Wipers at dawn and dusk align with ancient practice while remaining accessible to the skeptical.
Holiday argues that stillness--present-focused inner clarity cultivated through ritual, routine, and deliberate slowness rather than forced effort--is a universal, intrinsically valuable capacity that also produces better work, while distraction, anger, and the pursuit of 'more' actively undermine it.
- The same ideal of stillness recurs independently across Stoicism, Buddhism, Christianity, and Confucianism, suggesting it is a durable human truth.
- Stillness 'ensues' from conditions you create (routine, journaling, presence) rather than being directly pursued.
- Anger and the insatiable desire for 'more' are seductive but self-defeating fuels that destroy peace.
Stillness and presence require active discipline and ritual practice, not passive waiting or forced pursuit.
- Moments of stillness cannot be directly chased; they ensue from conditions we create--like leaving the phone behind, being outside, being fully present--so the goal is to take positive steps that make them more likely rather than actively hunting for them.
“these moments ensue more than that they can be pursued. But, we can take positive steps to encourage them, to make them more likely.”
- Marina Abramovic's 'The Artist Is Present'--sitting silently and present for roughly 79 days, all day, staring into strangers' eyes one by one--was, by her own account, harder than performances in which she stabbed and whipped herself, demonstrating that being present and doing close to nothing requires an iron grip on the mind and is one of the greatest feats of mental and physical endurance.
“the physical feat is only possible with sort of iron, an iron grip on your mind. And clearly that's what she has.”
- A brief daily journaling ritual (5-10 minutes by hand, before engaging technology, setting an intention in the morning and reflecting in the evening as the Stoics did) acts as 'spiritual windshield wipers'--spilling thoughts onto paper clears the mind and produces benefits that carry through the entire day.
“Julia Cameron has called writing sort of spiritual windshield wipers, which is an analogy I love. It's just a... clearing.”
- Presence will not simply show up on its own; like Abramovic preparing for her performance, it requires intense focus, concentration, and commitment, and should be treated as an active discipline rather than a passive state.
“she basically prepared for this like an athlete. And she saw it as an intensely active thing to be doing, even though it was close to nothing. And we have to realize that presence isn't going to be this thing that shows up.”
- Trying to force creative mastery, insight, or greatness through sheer willpower is self-defeating because, as the archery master Awa Kenzo taught, willful will is our biggest enemy--it leaves no room for insight to ensue naturally, which is why breakthroughs often come during relaxed play rather than effortful striving.
“He was saying that sort of willful will is actually our sort of biggest enemy: When we are trying to duel this stuff on purpose, we are actually not creating room for that mastery or greatness or insight... to come into ensue naturally.”
- Truly wise and admired people exhibit a deliberate slowness, savoring, and presence (refusing to speed up conversations, books, meals); youthfulness is marked by an overabundance of enthusiasm that causes trouble, while maturity is marked by a slowing down and ability to be appreciative and present--this is what Holiday calls stillness.
“there is a deliberate slowness, almost, to how they behave and the demeanor”
Repeated, effortful engagement with material through deliberate systems produces lasting knowledge and pattern recognition.
- Holiday's notecard system--reading and marking a book, letting it sit, then going back and transcribing the best passages by hand onto notecards filed by theme--works because the repeated, effortful, active interaction with material (sometimes 4-5 times across notes, journals, and tweets) improves recall and surfaces patterns, unlike passively clipping to a tool like Evernote, which gives no real retention.
“That's like thinking that because you cut an article out of the newspaper, you have it memorized... It's the process of reading it, kind of forgetting about it, going back through the book; noticing”
- Most books fail to impart lasting knowledge because most authors don't do the hard work of communicating ideas in absorbable ways, yet books overall clearly work--like the worst best technology, akin to democracy--evidenced by how many books have changed lives and the fact that virtually no one has accomplished anything major without being a reader.
“books work, but it's probably like democracy, where it's kind of like the worst best technology that we have.”
- Holiday's high output is possible because he does the bulk of his work--accumulating notecards, ideas, anecdotes, and reactions--long before he ever sits down to 'write something,' so that the writing draws on a stock of pre-made material rather than starting from a blank page.
“the reason I'm able to be as productive as I am and have written the things I've written is because I'm doing a lot of the pre-work long before it ever gets to the point where I sit down and say, 'I'm going to write something now.'”
- Marcus Aurelius's Meditations is less a record of original thoughts from the most powerful man in the world and more an unattributed quote book--him rewriting in his own words ideas he read elsewhere and was trying to internalize through journaling.
“you basically find out that Meditations is actually sort of like an unattributed quote book, more than it is the original thoughts of the most powerful man in the world.”
We flee distraction and instant gratification because vulnerability and effort required for presence are frightening and costly.
- Even though deeply meaningful present moments are far more rewarding than distractions--the way an addict's best sober moments beat any high--we still choose distraction because, like a drug, it is instantly available on demand, whereas the meaningful moment requires effort.
“if, you know, getting high on heroin is a 7 and having the beautiful moment with your child is a 10, the truth is you can shoot up heroin any time you want.”
- The same openness and vulnerability required to be moved by beauty or to be fully present is a frightening, weak place to be, so we flee to phones and busy-ness because instant validation or aggravation is easier than the work of opening ourselves to what's around us.
“this same openness and vulnerability and presence that it takes to be moved to tears by a flower or to experience the deliciousness of a sunrise... that's a vulnerable place to live.”
- Building a tight routine--limiting himself to no more than three scheduled things a day--is a healthy form of control as autonomy that protects time for the unique work only he can do; chaotic schedules and packed calendars often exist precisely so people never have to face 10 minutes of quiet by themselves.
“a lot of people have a schedule or have a chaotic life--these can be two sides of the same coin--precisely so they don't ever have to have 10 minutes by themselves.”
- Holiday's difficulty saying no comes less from 'what could this become' and more from the insecurity that 'this might be the last time I ever get offered something'; such insecurity is adaptive in making us accomplish things but deprives us of the happiness, peace, and contentment the accomplishment was supposed to bring.
“I think, 'This might be the last time I ever get offered something.'... that insecurity, again can be adaptive in the sense that it makes us accomplish things. But, it also deprives us of what the accomplishment is supposed to bring us”
- Athletes obsess over routine for the same reason: loving their craft and knowing how easily one can fall out of the mindset needed to perform, they build their lives around a process that habitually carries them to the peak state required for their critical seconds or minutes of performance.
“They know how easy it is to take yourself out of the mindset necessary to be great at it. And so they try to build their lives around a process of sort of, like, working themself towards that place they need to be”
The pursuit of more, anger, and willful striving are self-defeating drives that trap rather than liberate us.
- The pursuit of 'more' is insidious and self-defeating: as Stefan Zweig observed, 'history knows of no conqueror who has been surfeited by conquests'--Alexander, then Caesar measuring himself against Alexander, found conquest empty; achieving a goal only makes the mind crave two, deceiving us into believing more is the answer when it isn't.
“there's this Stefan Zweig quote... he said, 'History knows of no conqueror who has been surfeited by conquests.'”
- Anger is a dangerous, combustible fuel: even if it propels early success by proving people wrong, the mind cannot switch it off once the goal is reached; it instead invents and breeds new grievances, so the person never gets past it--as Michael Jordan's Hall of Fame speech revealed when he resented an innocent high-school teammate decades later.
“If anger is a good fuel early on in our careers--proving people wrong--the problem is, once we do that, the body and the mind and the soul are not good at going, 'Okay. You can stop that.'”
- Pursuing stillness as a tool to become more productive destroys it; like leisure or prayer, stillness is intrinsically valuable and only secondarily makes us better at our work--if you pursue it for the edge it gives, you miss the point.
“leisure can make us better at work, in the same way that praying can make you sleep better at night. But, if you are praying to improve your sleep, you are missing the point.”
- The belief that anger is a useful tool--for political change, righting social wrongs, or fueling athletic greatness--is a modern rationalization with essentially no support in the philosophical schools and is a complete misreading of history.
“there are almost no philosophical school that says, 'Hey, use anger. Anger is a really great tool.' This is a modern rationalization that we've come up with.”
Modern technology and media structures corrupt thought, polarize judgment, and demand constant adaptation from creators and minds.
- Because modern conditions--social media, 24-hour news, smartphones, instant information--bombard us far more than the ancients who took 15 days to receive news from a neighboring city, we need stillness, clarity, and patience even more desperately today than they did.
“if these things were important in their time, when they didn't have social media, when they didn't have 24-hour news, when they didn't have smart phones... how much more desperately do we need that stillness and clarity and patience today.”
- The Daily Stoic had to be redesigned for its second printing--adding the title to pages--because readers kept sharing photos of single pages on Instagram and commenters couldn't tell what book it was, illustrating that creators are constantly being shaped by the demands of social media whether they realize it or not.
“we actually had to redesign the second printing of the book around making it more favorable and useful to be shared on Instagram.”
- Twitter has had a massively corrupting, radicalizing effect on journalists by taking professionals whose craft was long-form, balanced, nuanced truth-seeking and turning them into reactionary, mean, biased actors, and the constraint of 140 then 280 characters is a key reason journalism and politics have become so polarized.
“it took people whose entire profession was about long-form communication... and it turned them into being reactionary and mean”
Strategic patience, thinking ahead, and deliberate use of time outperform rushing and immediate action.
- During the Cuban Missile Crisis Kennedy was uniquely effective because, unlike his advisers who only considered the first move, he insisted on thinking several steps ahead about how the Soviets would respond--'it's not the first step that worries me, it's the sixth step'--which let him slow down, preserve his opponent's options, and use time as a tool rather than rushing to escalation.
“he seemed to be the only person in the entire U.S. government at this time who was interested in thinking about what the Soviets would do in response to what the Americans would do.”
- We should use all sixty seconds of each present minute deliberately rather than whipping through one thing after another; doing this cumulatively yields more effective time than the people who rush, because time used as an active tool beats time used as a passive couch.
“his expression was, 'Let's use time as a tool, not as a couch.'”
- People who fail to plan their future are not actually living in the present; they are merely being pulled from one short-term stimulation to the next, whereas true presence means giving 100% of yourself to the current moment while still understanding how it fits with other moments.
“the person who is just playing video games all day, I'm not sure I would define them as a present person... they are being drawn along by stimulation and gratification.”
Stillness appears across independent ancient traditions, suggesting it reflects a genuine truth about human wisdom and maturity.
- Journaling should be done by hand on pen and paper because the analog nature is part of the ritual; doing it digitally loses something in the simulation, just as watching a video of Mass is not the same as attending Mass, and doing it before touching any technology delays and reduces dependence on addictive devices.
“I think the analog nature of it is important; I think it's part of the ritual. You know, you go to Mass; you don't watch a video of other people going to Mass.”
- Because roughly 90% of the population won't actually meditate, philosophical and self-help texts that begin by prescribing meditation do themselves and readers a disservice; like personal finance advice to keep a budget that almost nobody follows, such advice is both ineffective and a bit dishonest, so it is better to approach stillness from many Western, accessible angles rather than a single prescribed practice.
“the fact that every personal finance expert starts with telling people to go keep a budget is not only dishonest; it's incredibly ineffective.”
- The same core idea of stillness--inner peace, clarity, and self-mastery--appears with slightly different but fundamentally similar usage across essentially all ancient traditions (Buddhism, Stoicism, Christianity, Confucianism), and the fact that these independent schools converged on it suggests it is a genuine and important truth that only a fool would dismiss.
“you see these slightly different, but at the core very similar definitions and usage of the word in essentially all the ancient traditions, from Buddhism to Stoicism to Christianity to Confucianism. They are all speaking of this idea of stillness.”