David Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility
What this covers
Russ Roberts and David Deppner explore whether leaders can be privately humble while publicly confident, the animating question raised in an email Deppner sent Roberts. The conversation centers on whether these stances are inherently opposed or whether a leader can resolve the tension by holding conviction while acknowledging, at least internally, that they may be wrong. The two argue that what followers need to hear depends on context and on understanding that listeners differ from the speaker—that one's own need for reassurance is not universal. They work toward a practical answer: leaders need not voice every uncertainty to remain honest, and choosing not to reveal irrelevant doubts is not dishonest. The principle Strong Opinions Weakly Held becomes central—the idea of arguing as though you are right while listening as though you are wrong.
The episode moves through several distinct terrain. It examines how people in authority face a social demand for certainty that pure intellectual humility cannot satisfy, and how an enormous part of daily life depends on operating with unexamined certainty about countless things without paralysis. The conversation turns to institutional design, with Deppner contending that what matters most is the institutions and checks and balances surrounding a role rather than the individual leader. Roberts introduces the tension between individual justice and broad incentive effects through examples like rigid rule of thumb policies—a ship captain loses his commission regardless of circumstance, unfairly punishing good people but maintaining high standards. The pair also engage Via Negativa, the notion that progress often means understanding more ways one used to be wrong rather than reaching certainty, and they confront the Illusion of Control and the Stoic Dichotomy of Control, exploring how the desire to feel in control misleads leaders about what they actually govern.
Roberts and Deppner argue that intellectual humility and leadership confidence are not opposites: leaders can resolve the tension by holding conviction while privately knowing they may be wrong, acting decisively under uncertainty without lying, because what followers need to hear depends on context and is rarely the leader's full set of doubts.
- People in authority face social demand for certainty that pure intellectual humility cannot satisfy.
- There is a difference between dishonesty and nuance: leaders need not voice every uncertainty to remain honest.
- The resolution is 'argue as though you are right, but listen as though you are wrong' - conviction plus openness to being wrong.
Humility and acknowledging uncertainty need not paralyze action; leaders can proceed confidently in process while knowing outcomes remain uncertain.
- Being aware of your failings and confronting your imperfection does not mean you should give up, stay quiet, or conclude you have nothing to contribute; humility means you should grow and get better from mistakes without foolishly assuming they will never recur or letting them paralyze you—though sometimes the right lesson is that you should stop doing something.
“I don't think humility means that you give up. It doesn't mean you have nothing to contribute. It doesn't mean you're flawed and therefore you should stay quiet. You should grow. You should understand what you needed to learn from a situation, and ideally you should get better at it.”
- You can square the humility-leadership circle by being confident that you've made the right decision—following best practices with imperfect information—while knowing it might turn out to be the wrong decision; you do the best you can under inevitable uncertainty, are allowed confidence that the process was sound, and can even be confident it will turn out well while knowing it might not.
“Is it possible to be confident that you've made the right decision knowing that you've made the wrong decision? And I think that's the way to square this circle, is that: You do the best you can, knowing that there is never enough information to make a perfect decision... But you are allowed to have confidence that the process is the best it could be.”
- Being aware of your failings and imperfections should not paralyze you or make you give up; humility does not mean you are flawed and should stay quiet - you should confront your imperfection, learn what a situation taught you, grow, and get better, while not foolishly believing mistakes will never recur.
“I don't think humility means that you give up. It doesn't mean you have nothing to contribute. It doesn't mean you're flawed and therefore you should stay quiet. You should grow. You should understand what you needed to learn from a situation, and ideally you should get better at it.”
- You can square the certainty-humility circle by being confident that you have made the right decision through the best possible process - imperfect information, best practices, grappling fully - while simultaneously knowing the outcome might turn out wrong, because life never offers enough information for a perfect or just decision.
“Is it possible to be confident that you've made the right decision knowing that you've made the wrong decision? And I think that's the way to square this circle, is that: You do the best you can, knowing that there is never enough information to make a perfect decision... But you are allowed to have confidence that the process is the best it could be.”
- Groups making decisions are often in error but never in doubt—leaving a meeting feeling high that they did the right thing—so being reminded of the possibility that you are wrong is valuable.
Leaders must exude confidence and certainty; employees need to believe their leader is in control, making vulnerability a failed strategy.
- While Brené Brown advocates the power of vulnerability, employees and direct reports do not want their leader to express deepest fears, weaknesses, or emotional challenges—those belong to spouses and intimates—and a CEO who tries vulnerability finds it a horrible strategy that leaves people bewildered rather than inspired.
“your reports--your employees--are not your intimates, though they sometimes feel like they are. And they don't want to hear your fears. They don't want to hear your weaknesses; they don't want to hear your emotional challenges.”
- Employees and direct reports do not want to hear a leader's fears, weaknesses, or emotional challenges; unlike spouses and intimates, reports are bewildered rather than moved by leadership vulnerability, making vulnerability a poor CEO strategy despite its appeal in popular talks.
“your reports--your employees--are not your intimates, though they sometimes feel like they are. And they don't want to hear your fears. They don't want to hear your weaknesses; they don't want to hear your emotional challenges.”
- It is relatively cost-free for a podcast host, professor, or scholar to say 'I don't know,' but for someone in a leadership position—CEO, head of mission control, president, surgeon—admitting uncertainty is not only a deal-killer for attaining the role but is inconsistent with doing the job well, because the job requires exuding confidence, certainty, and a path to a vision.
“it's relatively cost-free for a podcast host, or a professor, or an academic, or a scholar, or a thinker to be--umm, thinking: 'I don't know.'”
- It is relatively cost-free for a podcast host, professor, or scholar to be humble and say 'I don't know,' whereas for someone in a leadership position humility is not only a deal-killer for attaining the role but is inconsistent with doing the job well, where the job demands exuding confidence, certainty, vision, and a path to that vision.
“it's relatively cost-free for a podcast host, or a professor, or an academic, or a scholar, or a thinker to be--umm, thinking: 'I don't know.'”
In crises, extreme overconfidence is necessary; in most contexts, confidence in sound process with willingness to learn suffices.
- Gene Kranz / Churchill 'failure is not an option' overconfidence is crucial in a life-threatening crisis where a leader cannot show insecurity or uncertainty, but that level of exuded certainty is not appropriate for most of life, where honest confidence in process suffices.
“the Gene Kranz level... that level of overconfidence, that failure is not an option--and that's the Churchill level of confidence--that's crucial in a life-threatening situation. You've got to have and exude that level of confidence... But that's not most of life.”
- The Gene Kranz / Churchill level of overconfidence ('failure is not an option') is crucial and appropriate in a life-threatening crisis where a leader cannot show insecurity, but that is not most of life, where the better stance is confidence in process plus willingness to learn from mistakes.
“the Gene Kranz level... that level of overconfidence, that failure is not an option--and that's the Churchill level of confidence--that's crucial in a life-threatening situation. You've got to have and exude that level of confidence... But that's not most of life.”
- The desire to be confident and in charge is partly a form of misleading yourself; followers want to believe the leader is in charge, but if you are not careful you delude yourself into thinking you are in charge when you are not—a delusion that may drive maximum effort but will repeatedly confront you with reality.
“the desire for control. And the desire to be confident--it's a form of misleading yourself. That, you're in charge... if you are not careful you actually delude yourself into thinking you are in charge... The drawback is that: You are not in charge. And you are going to be confronted with that over and over and over again.”
- Rising to the level of a Churchill or a Fortune 500 CEO may require a level of arrogance, overconfidence, and self-assurance that is not psychologically healthy, such that a thoughtful, honest person worried about their emotional wellbeing arguably should not aspire to those roles—some argue successful politicians are effectively psychopaths craving adulation and power.
- Rising to the level of a Churchill or a Fortune 500 CEO may require a level of arrogance, overconfidence, and self-assurance that is not psychologically healthy, such that a thoughtful, honest person worried about their emotional wellbeing arguably should not aspire to those tasks.
“to rise to that level, to be a Churchill, to be a CEO of a Fortune 50- or 500-company, requires a level of arrogance that really isn't maybe not so healthy.”
- The desire to be confident and in control is a form of misleading yourself, because you are not actually in charge; while believing you are in control may have benefits like driving maximum effort, the drawback is that reality will repeatedly confront you with your lack of control, and coping with the need for control is central personal growth.
“the desire for control. And the desire to be confident--it's a form of misleading yourself. That, you're in charge... if you are not careful you actually delude yourself into thinking you are in charge... The drawback is that: You are not in charge. And you are going to be confronted with that over and over and over again.”
Harsh categorical rules, though individually unjust, produce better organizational outcomes than case-by-case discretion through superior incentive effects.
- A rule of thumb such as 'the captain loses the ship, the captain loses his commission' is individually unjust—it punishes good people for mere mistakes—but because dispensing true case-by-case justice is prohibitively expensive in information and effort, the harsh rule produces amazingly good broad effects by maintaining a very high standard and making everyone try harder.
“that also means that there's a very high standard, and people are going to try a whole lot harder than if you didn't have that level of punishment... even when it truly was some freak of nature, just because that maintains that standard, that really high standard, on the value of human life.”
- Roberts refused to regrade homework even when he agreed a grade was too low, because if he changed unfairly low grades, only the under-graded students would ever come in while over-graded students stay silent, biasing the process; a no-regrade rule of thumb is fairer in aggregate than selective correction.
- A blunt rule of thumb (the ship goes down, the captain loses his commission; the homework is never regraded) can be unjust to the individual in the hot seat yet be the right rule overall, because the effort and information required to dispense true case-by-case justice is effectively infinite, and the broader incentive effects on the organization are beneficial.
“Sometimes justice is too expensive... The amount of effort it would take to dispense that level of justice is infinite. It's a level of information that almost never will be acquired. And so, a rule of thumb--your ship goes down, you lose your commission, you are out--is unfair. It's unjust... it might be better to be unjust.”
Humans have a deep need for certainty that drives overconfidence and shapes decisions; constant humility would paralyze ordinary life.
- Beyond confirmation bias, human beings have a deep need to know something—to put things in a box labeled 'now I don't have to think about that anymore because I know it's true'—and this drive shapes how we make decisions and underlies our tendency toward overconfidence.
“our need to know something. Our desire to put things in the box called, 'Now I don't have to think about that any more, because I know it's true.'”
- An enormous part of daily life depends on total, unexamined certainty about countless things—that the person beside you is your spouse, that the water taps weren't switched—and if we did not have this autopilot certainty we would be debilitated and paralyzed, so the trade-off between humility and certainty is inevitable and unavoidable.
“An enormous part of our life is total certainty about a huge amount of stuff, that if we didn't have, we'd be debilitated.”
- An enormous part of life depends on total certainty about mundane facts that we never question (who is sleeping next to us, that the water taps weren't swapped overnight), and this certainty operating on autopilot is necessary because constant humility about everything would be paralyzing.
“An enormous part of our life is total certainty about a huge amount of stuff, that if we didn't have, we'd be debilitated.”
- Human beings have a deep need to know things - to put things in a box labeled 'now I don't have to think about that anymore because I know it's true' - which goes beyond confirmation bias and contributes to a natural tendency toward overconfidence and cherry-picking facts that confirm our views.
“our need to know something. Our desire to put things in the box called, 'Now I don't have to think about that any more, because I know it's true.'”
Strong opinions weakly held—arguing as though right while listening as though wrong—reconciles conviction with genuine openness to being mistaken.
- Influential figures who force you to listen are not merely confident but have conviction—they have deeply thought about and believe what they assert, yet can simultaneously know at a deep level that they don't have the full answer; this is captured by 'strong opinions, weakly held,' where you argue as though you are right but listen as though you are wrong.
“his phrase is: Argue as though you are right, but listen as though you are wrong. And that, to some extent... you are arguing as though you are right, because like the strong opinions. But you listen as though you are wrong. And that's because you know they are weakly held and there's still much to learn.”
- Effective truth-tellers and troublemakers are not merely confident but have conviction: they state something they have deeply thought about and truly believe, while at a deep level knowing or even acknowledging they might be wrong and have much to learn - so one can hold strong opinions weakly held and be both convinced and humble at once.
“It's not so much that they are confident as they are, they have conviction... they are stating something that they really have--they've thought about and really believe. But that doesn't mean that they also don't, at a very deep level, know--or in fact are sure that they don't have the full answer.”
- Karl Weick's principle - argue as though you are right but listen as though you are wrong - captures how to hold both stances at once: you advance strong opinions while remaining genuinely open because those opinions are weakly held and there is still much to learn.
“his phrase is: Argue as though you are right, but listen as though you are wrong. And that, to some extent... you are arguing as though you are right, because like the strong opinions. But you listen as though you are wrong. And that's because you know they are weakly held and there's still much to learn.”
What a leader must voice differs from what they privately feel; omitting irrelevant uncertainties is nuanced discretion, not dishonesty.
- How much humility you feel inside and how much you voice are two different things; there is a difference between being dishonest and being nuanced, and choosing not to reveal every uncertainty is not dishonest when it is irrelevant or unwanted by the listener.
“There's a difference between dishonest and nuanced. There's a difference between dishonest and--I don't have to reveal every single uncertainty I have about this process--because people are sick of hearing about that, and my family sometimes; and also because it's just not relevant. It's not what that person wants to hear. It's not dishonest to ignore it.”
- How much humility you have inside and how much you voice are two different things; there is a difference between being dishonest and being nuanced - a leader need not reveal every single uncertainty, and omitting irrelevant doubts that the listener does not want or need to hear is not dishonest.
“There's a difference between dishonest and nuanced. There's a difference between dishonest and--I don't have to reveal every single uncertainty I have about this process--because people are sick of hearing about that, and my family sometimes; and also because it's just not relevant. It's not what that person wants to hear. It's not dishonest to ignore it.”
- Being humble and saying 'I don't know' keeps a podcast's ratings down, because the show would likely attract more listeners if the host were angrier, louder, and more certain.
When mistakes occur, honesty and accountability matter more than strategic self-protection, even in high-stakes professional settings.
- When a surgeon makes a fatal mistake, the right response as a human being is to tell the truth, express deep regret, and be vulnerable—regardless of whether it raises or lowers the odds of a lawsuit—and much of modern medicine is messed up because of these strategic legal considerations.
“I believe that the right response in that setting is to tell the truth--that you made a mistake. That you deeply regret it. And to be vulnerable... and I don't care whether it raises or lowers the choice, the odds, of a lawsuit. And I think a lot of medicine is messed up today because of those kinds of strategic issues.”
- Monsanto CEO Dick Mahoney summoned any plant manager whose worker died and demanded 'Why did you kill that person?'—not to dispense cosmic justice but to bend the organization's culture toward safety rather than recklessness, accepting that the optimal number of deaths isn't zero yet using shared responsibility to keep a high standard.
“Dick wasn't dispensing cosmic justice. He was trying to create a safer organization... you want your culture to bend toward safety rather than toward recklessness.”
- When a surgeon makes a fatal mistake, the right human response is to tell the family the truth, express deep regret, and be vulnerable, regardless of whether doing so raises or lowers the odds of a lawsuit; much of medicine is messed up today because honesty is distorted by strategic litigation considerations.
“I believe that the right response in that setting is to tell the truth--that you made a mistake. That you deeply regret it. And to be vulnerable... and I don't care whether it raises or lowers the choice, the odds, of a lawsuit. And I think a lot of medicine is messed up today because of those kinds of strategic issues.”
- The Monsanto CEO who summoned any plant manager whose worker died and asked 'Why did you kill that person?' was not dispensing cosmic justice but trying to make organizational culture bend toward safety rather than recklessness, by keeping accountability front and center even though there is an inevitably imperfect chain of command.
“Dick wasn't dispensing cosmic justice. He was trying to create a safer organization... you want your culture to bend toward safety rather than toward recklessness.”
Listeners vary in what they need to hear; most people wrongly assume others need the comfort they would want themselves.
- It is critically important in any relationship to remember that the people you interact with are not the same as you—what you would need to hear from a leader is not what others in the room need, yet most people unnaturally default to giving the answers that would comfort themselves rather than the listener.
“What would be good for you--what you need to hear from a leader is not necessarily what other people in the room need to hear. I think that's so unnatural for most of us to remember that.”
- In any relationship, not just leadership, it is crucial to recognize that the people you interact with are not the same as you - what you would need to hear from a leader is not necessarily what others need - yet most people unnaturally default to giving the answers that would comfort themselves rather than what the other person actually needs.
“What would be good for you--what you need to hear from a leader is not necessarily what other people in the room need to hear. I think that's so unnatural for most of us to remember that.”
- Today's episode is going to be a little bit different.
- It is remarkable how EconTalk listeners remember the content of past episodes better than the host does.
“it's remarkable how listeners remember more than I do; and the transcripts are even more memorable, of course.”
Troublemakers who articulate conviction force cultural resistance to groupthink; they must be competent and coherent to be heard.
- Troublemakers who stand against groupthink and intellectual trends—people overconfident enough to keep arguing, like Churchill warning of Germany—are extremely important; to be heard they must be competent, articulate, or eloquent, and when someone calmly asserts certainty they force you to listen, which is part of why people crave that quality in leaders.
- Living in an era of intense self-righteous certainty and outrage, Roberts's instinct toward humility and saying 'I don't know' may itself be the wrong response, because there could be dangerous self-righteous actors who must be opposed with equal conviction rather than passive uncertainty.
“Part of it is living in a time when there's so much certainty on the part of people yelling and the outrage is so self-righteous that my natural impulse is to be less self-righteous. And that that comes with a cost, though... this academic, former professor sitting around saying, 'I don't know. I don't know,' is possibly the wrong response at this moment in history.”
Medical and parental honesty norms shift over time based on evolving understanding of what serves human wellbeing and autonomy.
- For much of recent history doctors lied to terminally ill patients to give them hope and a placebo-like comfort, but medical norms have reversed toward honesty so patients can prepare, enter hospice, and face death honestly while doing what they would want with their remaining time.
“for a long time, once we got to that point, the answer was: You don't tell them. You lie to them... And yet, today, I think we've gone much in the other direction, which is: You should be honest. Let me them prepare.”
- Parents inevitably lie to children—not by outright deception but by providing a structure of certainty and simplified explanations appropriate to the child's age—and at certain stages this is the right thing to do because it is crucial for them to thrive and develop comfort with how complicated the world is.
- For much of medical history once death could be predicted, doctors lied to dying patients (justified by placebo effect and compassion), but today the norm has shifted strongly toward honesty so patients can prepare, face death, and use hospice to do what they want before dying.
“for a long time, once we got to that point, the answer was: You don't tell them. You lie to them... And yet, today, I think we've gone much in the other direction, which is: You should be honest. Let me them prepare.”
- All parents lie to their children, and most of the time it is for the best - not literally misleading them but giving them a structure of certainty that is crucial for going forward in life and developing comfort with how complicated the world is, which at certain ages is the right thing to do.
“if you are listening out there as a parent as well, you don't think, 'I don't lie to my kids!' and the answer is 'Yes, you do.' And most of the time, it's for the best... It's giving them a structure of certainty that we are talking about today, that is crucial to go forward in life.”