What this covers

Arthur Diamond of the University of Nebraska at Omaha speaks with Russ Roberts about his book on creative destruction, the economic mechanism by which new innovations displace obsolete ones. Diamond argues that economics has misread this process: the creative gains have been systematically underestimated while the destructive losses loom large in public perception and policy. His central claim is that Schumpeter's framework best explains the Great Fact—the roughly 250-year arc of dramatically rising human living standards—but that the discipline fails to teach innovation and entrepreneurship as central to how capitalism actually works. Instead, he contends, outsider entrepreneurs drive the breakthroughs that matter most, and regulatory barriers suppress them.

The conversation spans medicine, labor markets, regulatory design, and the structure of economic education. Diamond illustrates the Epistemology of Entrepreneurship through medical advances: mustard gas's accidental effect on blood cells, Sidney Farber's counterintuitive folic-acid antagonist, and Vince DeVita's iterative weekly adjustments that cured childhood leukemia. He argues that job creation flows not from small firms generally but from young, fast-growing gazelles, and that gazelle creation collapsed after 2008—explaining sluggish employment recovery. A recurring tension surfaces between claim and evidence: Diamond argues that perfect competition models misrepresent capitalism, that FDA protocols block nimble trial-and-error, that government misses innovations (fracking, personal computers), and that labor-market regulation should be loosened. Roberts pushes back on several fronts, particularly around whether displaced workers actually find equivalent work, whether cities' zoning restrictions are primarily regulatory, and whether government has truly failed at recognizing breakthroughs. The result is a sustained argument about who drives innovation and whether current institutions help or hinder it.

Sharpest takeaway

Diamond argues that the 'creative' side of creative destruction has been chronically underestimated while the 'destructive' side is overestimated, and that economics should teach innovation and entrepreneurship as central—because outsider entrepreneurs, not government or experts, drive the breakthroughs that lengthen and improve human lives, and over-regulation suppresses them.

  • The 'Great Fact'—the dramatic ~250-year rise in human living standards—is best explained by Schumpeterian creative destruction.
  • Job creation comes mainly from young, fast-growing 'gazelles' that are suppressed by labor-market and startup regulation.
  • Breakthrough innovation typically comes from outsiders using serendipity, slow hunches, and nimble trial-and-error, which both regulators and centralized funders cannot recognize or permit.

The argument · threads7 threads · 35 claims
0.85

Regulatory constraints on entrepreneurship—FDA, labor markets, zoning, professional licensing—suppress innovation by blocking the trial-and-error processes that historically produce breakthroughs.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Regulatory hurdles have suppressed concrete innovations—an entrepreneur's flying-car startup was slowed by regulatory obstacles, and drone innovation, though originated in the US, has migrated abroad because of US regulatory obstacles such as a rule requiring an operations manual aboard every drone.

    “I have a brief vignette of somebody who actually had an entrepreneurial startup to make a flying car, and he complains about all the regulatory hurdles that have slowed him down so much in developing that.”

  • The current regulatory setup strongly incentivizes developing drugs for late-stage cancer rather than early-stage, because late-stage patients readily enroll in trials and reach endpoints faster, making trials cheaper and quicker; the prevalence of incremental drugs reflects this incentive structure, not the exhaustion of 'low-hanging fruit' or the absence of potential magic bullets.

    “the current set-up strongly encourages development of new drugs for later stage. And, the reason is that it's a lot cheaper to do that, given how hard it is to do these double-blind clinical randomized trials. Because people will sign up. If they've tried everything else at the end, they'll sign up for a trial for the final stage new drug.”

  • Current FDA policy requiring a pre-specified protocol that researchers must stick to throughout a trial blocks the nimble trial-and-error process that historically cured childhood leukemia and Hodgkin's lymphoma; as Vince DeVita argues, this causes people to lose lives unnecessarily, and the FDA's delays also demoralize researchers like Steven Rosenberg and render time-sensitive cells unusable.

    “The current policies of the Food and Drug Administration [FDA] are blocking the kind of process that succeeded in curing cancer in the past. So, what you have to do now is you have to have a protocol, that's approved by the FDA... and you have to stick with it throughout the trial. Well, that's not what Freireich was doing when he cured childhood leukemia.”

  • The FDA's mandate that only randomized, double-blind clinical trials count as knowledge of drug effectiveness is so expensive that only big incumbents can pass the screen, and since incumbents are less likely to make breakthroughs, this skews innovation toward small, unimportant advances rather than transformative ones.

    “they mandate a very expensive kind of research... the randomized, double-blind research... And they also, they favor the incumbents. And the incumbents... are not as likely to do the breakthrough innovations... if the only people who can make it through the screen of the FDA's methodology are the big incumbents, that's going to result in a lot of small, unimportant-in-general, innovations.”

  • In many professions, especially health and education, doing what one should do requires being a 'canny outlaw'—working around institutional rules—which is itself an indictment of how those institutions are structured.

    “To do what you should do in many professions, especially health and education, you need to be a canny outlaw. Isn't that terrible? You have to be a canny outlaw to do what you should be doing?”

  • A freer health-care system would generate competition to provide less expensive ways of doing what is now done expensively—for example, letting nurse practitioners perform routine medicine they do repeatedly, which would be both better and cheaper—but credentialing rules currently block such innovation.

    “If you had a free system, there would be more competition to provide less expensive ways to do some of the things that we're now doing expensively... if you had... nurse practitioners doing the parts of medicine that have become routine, they would actually be better at those parts they do over and over again, and it would be less expensive”

  • Milton Friedman, while once enthusiastically favoring abolishing the FDA, later argued for the politically possible reform of limiting the FDA to evaluating safety but not efficacy, which would allow venturesome consumers to make more of their own choices.

    “what he thought was politically possible is that you have the FDA limit itself to evaluating safety, but not efficacy. And that would allow venturesome consumers to make more choices”

0.72

Creative destruction generates net job creation and welfare gains that far exceed the losses people fear.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • In the process of creative destruction, the creative part has been underestimated and the destructive part overestimated; fewer jobs are lost than people fear, the jobs that replace them are much better, so a more realistic picture would make people less afraid and more open to innovation.

    “the creative part of the process hasn't been emphasized enough. It's been underestimated. And the destructive part has been overestimated. What I found is people are afraid of losing jobs. And some jobs are lost. But not as much as people think. And the jobs that replace them are much better jobs.”

  • For tens of thousands of years humans lived lives that were poor, nasty, brutish, and short, but roughly 250 years ago—a blink of an eye in human history—living standards improved dramatically, first in Europe and then worldwide; this is the 'Great Fact' that creative destruction best explains.

    “for tens of thousands of years, people like us--homo sapiens--lived lives that were 'poor, nasty, brutish, and short'... And then something spectacular happened--the Great Fact--somewhere around 250 years ago. The lives of many people, at first in Europe mainly but then throughout the world, got substantially better.”

  • Creative destruction is wrongly perceived as a zero-sum game with winners and losers; in fact, as the Brunelleschi-Ghiberti example shows, those who 'lose' a competition often find other valuable contributions, so in the short run there are losers but more often than not everyone can be winners.

    “in the short run there are losers. But more often than not everyone can be winners in this process of creative destruction. And that's optimistic. But I think there's a lot of truth to it.”

  • Rather than arguing that displaced workers must sacrifice for their children's benefit, with a robustly redundant job market most people who lose jobs to creative destruction will themselves find jobs as good or better within their own lifetimes.

    “I think if we have what I call a robustly redundant job market--and there's things we can do to make that more likely--then, people who lose their jobs will themselves find jobs that are as good or better in their lifetimes.”

0.58

Entrepreneurs with skin in the game and specialized knowledge are far better positioned than experts or government to recognize and fund breakthrough innovations.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The more breakthrough an innovation is, the harder it is for any expert or outside funder to recognize it as plausible, so allowing entrepreneurs to accumulate funds and self-fund is crucial—they alone combine the knowledge to see the possibility with the skin in the game to pursue spectacularly beneficial ideas.

    “the more break-through the breakthrough is, the harder it's going to be for any entrepreneur to have any expert or a possible funder understand that it's a plausible, possible thing... It's a combination: knowledge and skin in the game, both, to pursue some of these things”

  • Government has a poor track record picking winners; its successes (like the Manhattan Project) come mainly when there is strong mission-orientation and the fundamental science is already worked out, but in general government funding imposes opportunity cost by taking resources away from outsider entrepreneurs who are the real sources of most innovation.

    “If you take tax money and you put it into the projects that the government anoints, that's money that's not left for the Wilbur Wrights or the Marconis... if it's these outsiders... who are the real sources of most innovation, then taking resources from them is exactly the opposite of what you should be doing.”

  • The claim that government was responsible for fracking is unsupported; while government did some useful preliminary research, the key figures were private entrepreneurs like George Mitchell, and as the source of the quote that Obama used acknowledged, George Mitchell would have developed fracking without the government, but the government would not have developed it without Mitchell.

    “'At the end of the day, George Mitchell would have developed fracking without the government. The government would not have developed fracking without George Mitchell.'”

  • The successes of prominent government-led innovation programs are exaggerated: Japan's MITI bet on high-definition TV and supercomputers while missing personal computers, and DARPA, credited with the Internet, only connected mainframes between universities—the key innovation of connecting local area networks came from privately funded Xerox PARC after Bob Taylor left DARPA in frustration.

    “In the case of MITI, the two big projects... one was a system of high-definition TV... inferior to the system that eventually was used. They also were putting a bunch of money into supercomputers... what they missed was personal computers.”

0.54

Innovative breakthroughs arise through serendipity, slow hunches, and nimble experimentation, processes that historical examples in medicine, aviation, and energy demonstrate.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Innovative entrepreneurs think and act through three characteristic processes: making use of serendipitous occurrences, developing 'slow hunches'—vague ideas mulled and sharpened over long periods—and running nimble trial-and-error experiments without knowing in advance where they will lead.

    “I focus on three aspects. One is, they often benefit from and make use of serendipitous occurrences. And they often have what Steven Johnson called... slow hunches... And they also do nimble trial-and-error experiments where they're not sure where it's going to go”

  • Major advances against cancer exemplify the epistemology of entrepreneurship: mustard gas's serendipitous effect on blood cells inspired chemotherapy, Sidney Farber's reversal from folic acid to a folic-acid antagonist produced the first leukemia remissions, and Freireich's and DeVita's weekly trial-and-error adjustment of chemical cocktails actually cured childhood leukemia and Hodgkin's lymphoma.

    “when people investigated the effects of mustard gas, they saw that... there were effects on red blood cells... maybe there's some way we can harness that when we actually do have... cancerous blood cells... that we want to get rid of. And that started, that was one of the jump starts or inspirations for chemotherapy.”

  • Many of history's great innovations come from outsiders without formal training who are skeptical of received wisdom—Orville Wright had no pilot's license, Lord Kelvin denied faith in aerial navigation, Marconi worked against the physics of the day—so regulating against ideas that seem crazy to experts would suppress exactly these transformative breakthroughs.

    “"Orville Wright didn't have a pilot's license." The idea that you can change the world without being an expert, without going the way everyone knows is the right way is just extraordinarily important.”

0.50

Young high-growth firms, not small firms generally, are the primary job creators; slowdowns in gazelle formation explain sluggish employment.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Contrary to the widely repeated belief that small firms are the main job creators, the vast majority of small firms stay small and short-lived; it is young, fast-growing firms—'gazelles'—that create the bulk of new jobs, per Haltiwanger's research, and a slowdown in gazelle creation (e.g., after 2008) plausibly explains slow job growth.

    “the vast majority of small firms are not job creators. They stay small. They don't last very long. It's the new firms that--the person who has done the most research... is a fellow named Haltiwanger... what he finds is, it's not small that matters: it's young and fast-growing; and hence the name 'gazelle.'”

  • The more the labor market is regulated, the stronger the incentive for firms to substitute automation—robots or algorithms—for expensive, inflexible human labor, so reducing both labor-market regulation and regulation on gazelles would move toward a robustly redundant job market.

    “the more you regulate the labor market, the more the incentive is, for what gazelles exist, to think about perhaps seeing, 'Can we automate this? Can we cut down on the expensive, inflexible labor, human labor, and have something that is not as regulated? Is not as expensive?'”

0.45

Economic theory and institutional practice wrongly omit entrepreneurship and undervalue innovation, variety, and venturesome behavior that capitalism actually relies on.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Even leading Chicago economists like George Stigler treated Schumpeter's creative destruction as heresy that was left out of price-theory textbooks, yet Stigler acknowledged it influenced his change of views on antitrust, and both Stigler and Becker found themselves needing creative destruction when addressing real-world policy—revealing a disconnect between what is taught and what economists actually need.

    “'But also some of us read Joseph Schumpeter's Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy. And although it was complete heresy, it had its effects on us.' So, this is heresy, right? And we don't put that in the textbooks... but it was something that mattered.”

  • Diamond teaches that the perfect-competition model is the paradigm the Communists put forward for how capitalism should work when working well, and while useful, students should not judge capitalism solely by it but should consider other characteristics—like innovation and variety—that the model fails to capture.

    “what I'm going to talk about here is the model that the Communists put of the paradigm of how capitalism should work when it's working well... if you are going to use this as your way to judge capitalism, you should think more broadly... about some of the other characteristics of capitalism that are not captured by this.”

  • The framing that socialism is where idealists go while capitalism is for practical number-crunchers sells capitalism short; inventors, entrepreneurs, and venturesome consumers are heroes who do great things despite their flaws, and economics has wrongly removed the entrepreneur from its accounts of how capitalism works.

    “these people who are responsible for innovative dynamism--the inventors, the entrepreneurs, and some of the venturesome consumers that I think especially get short shrift--that these people are heroes in many ways... we've taken the entrepreneur out of our accounts of capitalism.”

  • John McGee's paper on Standard Oil showed that Standard Oil had not engaged in predatory pricing, which was part of what changed George Stigler's views on antitrust.

    “John McGee showing that Standard Oil had not been predatory, and so on.”

0.27

Regulatory barriers to labor mobility and housing supply prevent displaced workers from relocating to opportunity, undermining the dynamic job markets that once absorbed disruption.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Policies in cities that could be natural magnets for displaced workers—such as regulated minimum apartment sizes, restrictions on tall buildings, and limits on geographic expansion—discourage mobility and prevent the poor and displaced from getting a foothold, undermining the boom-town dynamism that once absorbed workers.

    “there are policies in effect in some of the cities that might be natural magnets that discourage people from coming, to hire... the size of the apartments is regulated. So, people who are poor and displaced can't get a foothold. But there's other issues, like restrictions on vertical building, tall buildings, and the actual expansion of the city geographically over greater territory.”

  • In Amy Goldstein's study of the Janesville auto-plant closure, workers who were willing to move did better than those who stayed and followed the standard recommendation to enroll in local community-college retraining programs, where supply of certified graduates vastly exceeded available jobs.

    “those people who were willing to move seemed to do better than those who stayed and took, quote--"what was the usual recommendation" of the authorities. Which is: 'Go to the local community college and sign up for one of the training classes.'”

  • It is a mistake to over-generalize from Silicon Valley to entrepreneurship in general; its dramatic success may stem partly from relatively less regulation, and other domains like fracking show high-impact entrepreneurship by people who lack the coding skills and high education levels Silicon Valley demands.

    “this may be an example of something... which is to over-generalize from Silicon Valley of what might be true of entrepreneur in general... part of the reason why we've got the spectacular success in Silicon Valley but not so much elsewhere is because there had been... less regulation of what's going on in Silicon Valley compared to other areas.”