Daniel Hamermesh on Spending Time
What this covers
Economist Daniel Hamermesh discusses his book Spending Time with Russ Roberts on EconTalk, exploring a central paradox: real income has more than tripled over the past fifty to sixty years while life expectancy has risen only about fifteen percent. This mismatch means time has become the binding constraint—the scarce resource relative to money. The conversation traces how this shift reshapes behavior across work, leisure, and home production, and why Americans experience constant time pressure even as material abundance grows. Hamermesh argues that money is inherently time-consuming to spend: you cannot hire someone to sleep, eat, attend theater, or read for you, so greater wealth creates an ever-expanding menu of desired activities competing for fixed hours.
The discussion ranges across multiple domains. It covers gender and marriage, showing how education and economic independence have reshaped family formation, particularly among the less-educated. It examines time diary data on how hours are actually used, revealing that higher family income reshapes time allocation even for non-earners. A substantial portion addresses work patterns and policy: Americans work significantly more than their counterparts in peer nations, a gap that emerged over the last forty years and stems from political choices about mandatory vacation rather than tax rates or cultural permanence. The conversation also covers Gary Becker's Household Production Model—treating households as factories that combine goods and time to produce experiences—and its surprisingly limited influence on economic thinking despite its explanatory power. Throughout, Hamermesh distinguishes between income effects, opportunity costs, and transaction costs in explaining why the wealthy outsource some tasks but not others.
Hamermesh argues that as income has tripled while lifespans rose only modestly, time has become the scarce resource relative to money, which reshapes how rich and poor (and Americans vs. other nations) allocate work, leisure, and home production.
- Income has more than tripled while life expectancy rose only ~15%, making time scarce relative to money
- Higher family income changes time use even for non-earners (less sleep, less TV)
- The U.S. works more than peer countries primarily due to shorter mandated vacations, a political rather than tax-driven choice
People allocate time based on its opportunity cost relative to other valuable uses available to them.
- Books, movies, and baseball doubleheaders have gotten shorter because as income rose the marginal hours of long entertainments became relatively more expensive in opportunity cost, since people now have many other valuable uses for their time.
“I used to make this argument to explain why books are shorter, movies are shorter, double-headers are rarer... that 3rd, 4th, and 5th hour at the baseball game and at the movie theater isn't quite as appealing as it used to be... because we have other things we can use our money for.”
- Even people with very valuable time do small chores themselves (like taking out the garbage) because the transaction costs of arranging and timing the contracting exceed the value of the few minutes saved, so they self-perform tasks where outsourcing isn't worth it.
“I take my own garbage out every week. I don't pay someone for that 90 seconds... the simple answer in economics is transaction costs: that to do that contracting and time it would just be not worth it, so I just do it myself.”
Household production combines time and purchased goods; this framework remains underdeveloped in economics despite its explanatory power.
- Gary Becker's 1965 framework (echoed by Kelvin Lancaster) holds that people do not get direct utility from purchased goods but produce final experiences by combining time with goods (the household as a little factory), yet this fundamental idea has had almost no impact on the teaching or conception of economics, largely because until recent time-use data there was insufficient data to test it.
“Becker pointed out... that we combine time with purchases. We don't get direct utility, direct pleasure from a steak. We have to take the steak, combine time... and we produce the ultimate good... the creation of experiences.”
- Competition for spots at the best schools has intensified because the large baby boomer cohort produced numerous children and grandchildren competing for a fixed number of elite-school spots.
“the baby boomers--we're a large cohort passing through time, and so our children and grandchildren are now numerous. And there's only a fixed number of spots at the best schools. So, that competition is much fiercer.”
Causal attribution requires disentangling pre-existing trends from effects of the policy intervention itself.
- Charts showing improvement after a law like the Occupational Safety and Health Act often mislead because the same improving trend existed before the law passed; legislation may still matter at the margin, but underlying factors moving in the same direction must be disentangled before crediting the law.
“a lot of people would put up a chart that would show the passage of the Occupational Safety and Health Act and say, 'Look what happened after it passed.' And what they often fail to do is look at the trend before it passed. And it's the same trend.”
Changes in men's earning capacity and women's economic independence reshape marriage patterns across education levels.
- The U.S. marriage rate has fallen very little for the college-educated but has plummeted among those without college or who did not finish high school, plausibly because less-educated men have a harder time earning enough to attract a spouse, women have greater economic independence, and reduced time needed for home production lessens women's need for a supporting spouse.
“it's fallen very little, for people with college education or higher... But among people without a college education, and particularly people who don't finish high school, it's dropped off the cliff.”