What this covers

Kevin McKenna, a Russian literature professor, joins Russ Roberts to examine how Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn constructed In the First Circle around two interlocking moral claims. The conversation treats the novel not as an exposé of Soviet brutality—though it depicts that plainly—but as a work of artistic philosophy centered on living by conscience as the measure of humanity, and on the paradox that prisoners can possess greater freedom in captivity than their jailers and oppressors. McKenna and Roberts move through the major characters and incidents: Volodin's treasonous warning call, Nerzhin's refusal of a sexual opportunity, the blind sweeper Spiridon and his embodiment of peasant wisdom, and even the controversial Stalin chapters that show the dictator imprisoned within his own paranoia and fear.

The discussion dwells on Solzhenitsyn's method: [artistic understatement](concept:Artistic Understatement) rather than indictment. He avoids screaming the pain; readers must do that themselves. The conversation also traces the novel's satire—a trial of a medieval prince under Soviet law, a farcical visit by Mrs. Roosevelt's delegation coached to see nothing—and examines how incentives entangle everyone, from zeks seeking release through their labor to Stalin himself seeking security through fear. McKenna details Solzhenitsyn's choice to restore a factual incident over a fictional one in the rewritten opening, discusses the role of Sergei Yesinin's poetry and Russian proverbs as anchors for the narrative, and reflects on the deep question the novel poses: whether conscience or personal advancement motivates human action.

Sharpest takeaway

McKenna and Roberts argue that the genius of Solzhenitsyn's 'In the First Circle' lies not in exposing Stalinist crimes but in its artistic understatement and its twin themes—that living in accord with one's conscience is the measure of being human, and that prisoners can be freer than those who comply with the system.

  • The conscience theme (Volodin's treasonous call, Nerzhin forgoing the sexual opportunity) defines the moral core of the novel
  • The freedom theme holds that zeks in the 'First Circle' are freer than the powerful (Stalin, ministers) who imprison themselves
  • Solzhenitsyn's artistry is the understatement—he never screams the pain, leaving readers to do so

The argument · threads5 threads · 27 claims
0.85

Prisoners stripped of everything become freer than the powerful who have much to lose and must serve the system.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The central theme of the novel is that a human being must be able to live consistently with the dictates of his conscience; Volodin's treasonous call is an act he has to undertake to remain human, because to continue his sybaritic life of compliance would mean giving in to the system and ceasing to be fully human.

    “we human beings have to be able to live consistently with the terms of conscience in our own lives”

  • A prisoner from whom everything has been taken is freer and beyond the jailer's power, while the colonels and generals who still have much to lose remain controllable—captured in the quote 'You need me, and I don't need you,' which inverts the usual power relationship.

    “'You need me, and I don't need you.' He goes on to say, 'Shout at your colonels and generals. They've got a lot to lose. But the man from whom you've taken everything is no longer in your power. He is free again.'”

  • Solzhenitsyn's recurring insight, across all his fiction, is that prisoners in the camps can be freer than most people living outside them; the occupants of the First Circle of Hell tend to be far freer than those who occupy the First Circle of Power, whether Abakumov or Stalin himself.

    “those occupants of the First Circle of Hell tend to be far freer than those who occupy the First Circle of Power”

  • McKenna recounts meeting Sasha, a zek arrested in 1976 and sentenced to an Arctic Gulag for mooning the U.S. President, who, watching ant-like women on a Leningrad street at 5 a.m., declared that for six years in the camp he was far freer than those people outside—an empirical anecdote supporting the freedom theme.

    “'I, for 6 years, living in the camp, was far freer than these people that we're looking at down on the ground.'”

0.64

The novel's genius lies in understated artistry that lets readers feel the horror rather than the author shouting it.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The genius of Solzhenitsyn's fiction is not that it reveals Stalin's crimes or camp life but the artistry of how it does so: he never screams out his pain or the prisoners' pain; understatement is his main device, leaving readers to scream their heads off—as in One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, where a single horrific day astounds without the author ever raising his voice.

    “It's the under-statement that is the main artistic device, I would say, that Solzhenitsyn employs in his writing. He leaves it up to us, his readers, to essentially scream our heads off”

  • 'The Trial of Prince Igor' is a comic chapter in which a 13th-century Russian prince is put on a 20th-century court trial under Article 58—the criminal code provision under which essentially all Gulag prisoners were convicted—brilliantly satirizing the Soviet system of law while ostensibly discussing the distant past to safely critique the present.

    “the 20th century court trial is to try the 13th century Prince Igor for his failure to live up to the dictates of the Soviet system. So, it is a huge, comical chapter in which Solzhenitsyn brilliantly satirizes the Soviet system of law”

  • Solzhenitsyn rewrote the novel's opening because he was dissatisfied with the censored version's fictional event (Volodin calling a family doctor); the uncensored edition restores the factually-based Kovalev incident of 1949, in which a Russian diplomat warns the American Embassy of a Soviet plot to obtain atomic bomb plans, and Solzhenitsyn's treatment of the factual event is far superior to the fictional one.

    “it is entirely factually-based on the Kovalev[sp?] incident that takes place, indeed, in 1949 in New York City”

0.64

Russian peasant wisdom and classical literature, especially proverbs and Yesinin, embody the moral truth Nerzhin ultimately embraces.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Russian proverbs are unbelievably important to Solzhenitsyn's fiction; among the three books Solzhenitsyn took into the Gulag were a volume of Yesinin's poems (his favorite poet because the poetry gelled with peasant and rural Russian life), a Bible, and a collection of Russian proverbs—mirrored in the scene where Nerzhin gives his precious Yesinin volume to the blind Spiridon.

    “Proverbs are unbelievably important to Solzhenitsyn's fiction, at least. This is something I'm arguing in the book that I'm currently writing”

  • Spiridon, the half-blind snow sweeper sent to the institute by mistake who never finished high school, embodies homespun peasant wisdom; after Nerzhin finds neither Rubin's Communism nor Sologdin's will-of-the-intellect satisfying, he turns to Spiridon, who answers the question of truth with the proverb 'The wolfhound is right, the man who hunts men is wrong'—meaning the wolf hunts by its nature, but for a man to hunt the lives and souls of fellow men is wrong.

    “Spiridon responds with a very, very famous and yet age-old wisdom, Russian wisdom, Russian proverb... 'The wolfhound is right. The man who hunts men is wrong.'”

  • After zeks were freed around 1955 into 'eternal exile' and then allowed home around 1957-58, Solzhenitsyn chose not to return to his native Rostov but to Matryona's home, seeking 'the real Russia'—the Russia of Yesinin and Turgenev—a quest mirrored later when he settled in rural Vermont for some 17-18 years after exile.

    “'I wanted to go to the real Russia.' And by the real Russia, he means the Russia of Yesinin, the Russia of Turgenev”

0.57

Most people choose personal interest over conscience, a fundamental question Solzhenitsyn poses but few Russians or Americans truly resolve.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The deep question Solzhenitsyn poses—and which most Russians and Americans alike have not resolved—is whether we are motivated primarily by our duty to conscience, as Solzhenitsyn and Nerzhin are, or by personal interests such as career advancement and getting ahead, which motivates the overwhelming majority.

    “Are we motivated primarily, as is Solzhenitsyn, and of course, Gleb Nerzhin--are we motivated primarily by our conscience, our duty to our conscience? Or, like the overwhelming, vast majority of Russians and Americans, are we motivated more so by personal interests?”

  • Rubin, on learning Volodin will be sentenced, first feels guilt, then consoles himself that the four other accused will go free—an ironic demonstration of how people shift guilt or blame to suit and quiet their consciences.

    “it's an ironic kind of notion on Solzhenitsyn's part of how it is that we or one can kind of shift gain, guilt or blame to suit our consciences”

  • Sologdin, having discovered the secret to the difficult phonologic research, makes a bargain to cooperate with the system in exchange for freedom and wealth—a choice that embodies the novel's central dilemma of advancing technology that will help the regime oppress people.

    “Sologdin is going to make a bargain with the system whereby he, as one of the engineers, the prison-engineer zeks in the camp--he is going to go ahead and to cooperate”

  • Contrary to the assumption that many Soviet citizens rooted for the Americans, Russians both in the Soviet period and in 2018 are fiercely patriotic, and only those few who have found a comfort place in their conscience would agree with Volodin's act.

    “during the Soviet period, and today by the way, the Russians in 2018 are fiercely patriotic”

0.57

Even Stalin, at the pinnacle of power, dwells in his own hell of self-deception and fear, demonstrating that tyranny imprisons the tyrant.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Though many critics deem the Stalin chapters (19-23) unsuccessful and deletable, they are essential because they reveal that Stalin himself resides in his own circle of hell—a hell of self-deception, ego, fear, doubt, and suspicion, fearing and resenting the decades-dead Lenin—demonstrating that even at the pinnacle of power Stalin is a prisoner.

    “Stalin himself finds, by the last two chapters, 19 to 23, realizes that he himself resides in his own circle of hell--a hell of self-deception or a hell of ego or a fear or a doubt of suspicion”

  • The chapter 'Buddha's Smile' dramatizes Solzhenitsyn's grievance that the United States was unable to see the evil of the Soviet Union as it really was: a staged camp visit by Mrs. Roosevelt's delegation, deceived by fresh clothing, elaborate meals, and religious books, with prisoners coached to complain about American slavery and racism rather than their own conditions.

    “Solzhenitsyn was never comfortable with what he saw to be the United States's inability to see evil of the Soviet Union as it really was”

  • Following Nabokov's dictum that 'there is no such thing as reading a novel—novels can only be re-read,' deep understanding of a work like In the First Circle requires multiple readings.

    “Nabokov[?] responded by saying, 'Reading a novel? There is no such thing as reading a novel. Novels can only be re-read, re-read, and re-read.'”

  • The novel centers on three main characters—Gleb Nerzhin (who most identifies with Solzhenitsyn himself and searches for the meaning of life), Lev Rubin (a devoted Communist based on one of Solzhenitsyn's closest Gulag friends), and Sologdin (who rejects all imposed philosophy and believes the talented individual should control his own fate)—with Spiridon the peasant serving as a fourth figure embodying homespun wisdom.

    “the first so-called main character, I think the one that most identifies with Solzhenitsyn himself, would be Gleb Nerzhin”