Yoram Hazony on the Virtue of Nationalism
What this covers
Yoram Hazony and host Russ Roberts work through the argument of Hazony's book on nationalism, examining why independent national states might be morally and practically superior to unified global governance. The conversation turns on a distinction between two competing visions running through Western history: the Biblical model of nations living under their own governance within fixed borders, and the Roman model of universal imperial order. Hazony argues that the most destructive modern wars—the Thirty Years' War, Napoleonic and World Wars—were actually driven by universalist ideologies seeking world domination, not by nationalism defending borders. The core mechanism by which independent states preserve freedom is multipolarity: competing centers of power prevent any single elite from imposing its ideology globally, much as domestic checks and balances work domestically.
The conversation challenges the foundations of liberal and rationalist political thought, particularly Locke and his successors. Hazony contends that freedom is not self-evident or derived from universal reason, but rather an artificial inheritance grown from particular religious and national traditions—rooted in what he calls Old Testament Biblicism within a Christian framework, not Enlightenment rationalism. He argues that mutual loyalty, not consent, is the actual glue holding societies together; families and nations persist through inherited obligation and shared identity, not rational agreement. The discussion also addresses teaching as ideological: how presenting political theory as disputes among thinkers who share Lockean axioms—while hiding those shared premises—prevents students from questioning foundational assumptions. Roberts and Hazony consider concrete threats to this order: the post-Cold War "new world order" enforced by American military dominance, the European Union's centralization of power, and erosion of the Westphalian system of independent states. The conversation includes historical illustration from Henry VIII and John Fortescue, grounding abstract debate in texts and moments.
Hazony argues that a world order of independent national states—though it permits competition and even war—is morally and practically superior to imperial/global governance, because freedom is an artificial inheritance grown from particular national and religious traditions and sustained by mutual loyalty, not derivable from Lockean rationalist axioms.
- The deep historical conflict is between national independence (the Biblical/Israelite vision) and universal empire (the Roman vision), and the worst wars came from universalist ideologies of world domination, not from nation-states defending borders.
- Lockean rationalist axioms (universal reason, innate freedom/equality, consent as the source of obligation) describe markets but cannot describe families, tribes, or nations, which actually rest on mutual loyalty.
- Multiple competing centers of power (Vattel) are the only mechanism that preserves freedom by preventing any one elite from imposing its ideology on the world.
Material wellbeing is important but inadequate; human flourishing requires more than economic measures alone.
- Material wellbeing, though genuinely important, is only a small part of what makes humans flourish and gives ultimate satisfaction, so economics in its most sterile form—treating satisfaction as material wellbeing alone—is an inadequate account of human life.
“I think material wellbeing is really important; I'm a big fan of it. But, it's only a small part of what makes us flourish as human beings, gives us ultimate satisfaction.”
- America is in the middle of an unprecedented social experiment, undergoing dramatic social change in a very short period, in which the norms and traditions that created freedom are 'on the ropes' and no longer being discussed.
“we're in the middle of a great experiment right now, where the things that created, as you say, the norms of freedom and other things are on the ropes--not being discussed. So, we'll see how that plays out.”
- Raising children demonstrates that political obligation is not grounded in consent: the original decision to have a child cannot be revisited or renegotiated as hardships mount, the parents' consent or lack of it is irrelevant to their continuing responsibilities, and it is something other than consent that motivates them to persist in raising children to health and inheritance.
“The parents' consent or lack thereof is irrelevant to their continuing responsibilities, and it is nothing like consent that motivates them as they persist in their efforts to raise their children to health and inheritance.”
Centralized global governance concentrating power to enforce single solutions poses a genuine threat to freedom.
- The chief danger of a global system of governance is its potential to impose tyranny more widely; concentrating power in a central authority to enforce a single global solution (as some advocate for problems like climate change) removes the competing checks that protect freedom, making global solutions not merely inefficient but genuinely frightening.
“the part that really scares me is the potential for a global system of governance to impose tyranny more widely. I think that's the biggest fear I have, say, about climate change: if there were some global solution that had to be enforced.”
Decentralized competition among independent nations allows experimentation and learning from successes and failures.
- The post-Westphalian system of independent nation-states each trying different religious, cultural, and political traditions—learning from each other's successes and mistakes—has some of the characteristics of American federalism and of Hayekian trial-and-error, where good things can be copied and bad things set aside.
“some of the characteristics of federalism in the United States: each state has a certain level of autonomy to try different things; and good things can be copied and bad things can be set aside.”
Free markets and trade have dramatically improved living standards for the world's poorest over decades.
- Over the last 30 to 40 years there has been an enormous, extraordinary improvement in the standard of living for the poorest people in the world, achieved through free markets, the division of labor, and Smithian trade.
“we've seen an enormous improvement in standard of living for the poorest people in the world over the last 30 or 40 years; been extraordinary.”