What this covers
Janet Golden and Russ Roberts discuss how infants became engines of modernization in early-twentieth-century America. Golden argues that babies were not passive subjects of parental care but active economic actors whose survival needs pulled families into commercial markets, medical systems, and new consumer habits. The conversation traces how infant mortality fell dramatically—not because parents suddenly understood child development, but because basic infrastructure like clean water, milk pasteurization, and sewage systems, combined with simpler practices like keeping milk cold, removed the most lethal hazards. At the same time, the uncertainty of infant survival created a vacuum that businesses and reformers rushed to fill, often with fads and products of dubious merit.
The discussion moves across several distinct territories. It covers the economics of infancy—from baby farmers who took in unwanted infants to incubator displays at world's fairs that charged admission to view premature babies kept alive, to the illegal baby market uncovered in the Kefauver hearings. It examines the oscillation of childcare advice between strict and permissive approaches, from John Watson's behaviorism to Benjamin Spock's gentler methods, with little scientific basis undergirding either. The speakers note how survivorship bias likely inflated the apparent success of incubator operators and how the Children's Bureau became a trusted source of guidance despite imperfect knowledge. Throughout, Golden emphasizes that despite modern surveillance of developmental milestones and mountains of data, fundamental uncertainty about how infants think and develop persists—leaving parenting advice perpetually caught between fads.
Golden argues that infants were active economic and cultural agents who pulled American families into modern commercial, medical, and psychological life, and that the dramatic 20th-century fall in infant mortality came less from sophisticated knowledge than from basic sanitation and germ-avoidance taught to parents amid persistently imperfect understanding of how to raise children.
- Infant care connected families to banking, insurance, advertising, and consumer markets
- Mortality dropped mainly via clean water, milk pasteurization, and sanitation infrastructure
- Parenting advice on psychology and feeding swung between fads with little durable scientific basis
Infant mortality in early twentieth-century America was catastrophically high, particularly among immigrant communities.
- In Buffalo, New York at the turn of the century, 60-89% of Italian-American women over 30 had lost at least one child, with Polish women experiencing at least as high a rate, reflecting how perilous infant survival was.
“60-89% of women over 30 had lost at least at one child. And among Polish women in the city, the rate was at least as high.”
- At the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition in San Francisco, the incubator display took in $72,000, equivalent to nearly $1.7 million in today's dollars, demonstrating how much the public paid to see premature infants kept alive.
“the incubator display took in $72,000 dollars." Which is nearly $1.7 million in today's dollars.”
Infant care decisions reflected social status and economic capability rather than health or developmental reasoning.
- Choosing not to breastfeed carried social prestige in the early 1900s, signaling that a family was wealthy enough to afford purchased milk or hired feeding help.
“there was a prestige, I guess, to not breast feeding to show you are wealthy enough that you could afford to buy the milk or hire someone to feed the baby”
- Many products people used for infant care, particularly for digestion, were either ineffective or counterproductive, including opiate-laced products that constipated infants and others meant to loosen them up.
“It is remarkable how many things people used that were either ineffective or counterproductive--perhaps in terms of general health.”
Environmental costs of infant care alternatives are more complex than advocates for any single approach acknowledge.
- Critics who consider disposable diapers environmentally unfriendly often overlook that cleaning and reusing cloth diapers also imposes non-zero environmental costs.
“those are people I think who haven't thought quite enough about what cleaning a diaper does in re-using it, to the environment, which is not zero”
- Behaviorist psychologist John Watson advised mothers never to hug, kiss, or let children sit on their laps—arguing not that affection conveyed germs but that it created unhappy children—though his manual had little influence on actual nursery practices and a personal scandal ended his academic career, after which he moved into advertising.
“He advised mothers to never hug and kiss their children or let them sit on their laps. The problem was not, as other experts argued, that kissing conveyed germs but rather it led to the creation of unhappy children.”
Infants are born exceptionally fragile and dependent due to biological constraints on human gestation and birth.
- Humans are born prematurely and helpless compared to other animals because the ideal gestation period would be roughly two years, but the size of the human head relative to the birthing mother's hips forces birth at around nine months, leaving infants remarkably fragile and dependent.
“Humans are born way too early, compared to other animals. And that's because, if the gestation period was as long as it should be, which is probably something like 2 years, the baby could not be born. The size of the human crown, the head, is too large for the hips of a delivering mother.”