Kelly Weinersmith and Zach Weinersmith on Soonish
What this covers
Ecologist Kelly Weinersmith and cartoonist Zach Weinersmith join Russ Roberts to discuss their book Soonish, which surveys emerging and near-term technologies through an economic lens. Rather than asking what's possible, they ask what's worth doing—and at what cost. The conversation ranges from asteroid mining to construction robots to biological modification, but the Weinersmiths consistently return to a single frame: radical technologies should be evaluated by hard tradeoffs, especially opportunity cost and the unpredictability of adoption, not by their technical feasibility or the promise they carry.
The substance breaks into distinct territories. On how progress actually happens, they argue that breakthroughs rarely advance within a single field in isolation. Instead, technological spillover—carbon nanotubes developed for unrelated electronics, lithium-ion batteries created for gadgets—suddenly unlock applications like space elevators and electric vehicles. On space economics, they make the skeptical case that going beyond Earth orbit lacks obvious market value since the Periodic Table is identical everywhere; the comparison is not astral romance but whether mining asteroids beats digging holes at home. On adoption, they demonstrate how cultural forces dominate technical merit: augmented reality works brilliantly in construction training but Google Glass failed because people disliked being watched. They also explore moral hazard in organ replacement, novel property law questions raised by augmented reality, and why construction has resisted automation for a century while other industries have transformed. Throughout, the emphasis falls on tradeoffs and unintended consequences—what actually gets built versus what merely becomes technically possible.
The Weinersmiths argue that radical future technologies should be judged not by the wonders they promise but by hard economic tradeoffs—especially opportunity cost and the unpredictability of adoption—where breakthroughs in one field often unlock progress in unrelated ones.
- Asteroid mining and space travel face the question of whether going to space beats just digging a hole on earth, since the rest of the universe shares our Periodic Table
- Technologies advance through cross-domain spillovers (carbon nanotubes for space elevators, lithium-ion batteries for EVs) rather than steady incremental gains within a field
- Adoption is shaped culturally and unpredictably (Google Glass failed socially despite working technically)
Adoption hinges on social and cultural fit, not technical excellence or appearance alone.
- Google Glass, which overlaid virtual elements on what you see, was technically functional but failed in the market because people reacted with anger to wearers—disliking the look and feeling surveilled—illustrating that the adoption of a working technology is unpredictable and culturally driven, prompting a pivot toward less obtrusive contact lenses.
“it turned out that if you were walking down the street with Google Glass, people would just kind of get angry seeing you... it's hard to know how people are going to respond.”
- Some technologies like Room Bots may look ugly but become adopted anyway when their functionality—such as a table that adjusts height or moves to a person who can't get up easily—so improves quality of life that people overlook the lack of homey aesthetics, illustrating that adoption is governed by tradeoffs rather than beauty alone.
“even though they don't look homey, you want them anyway because their functionality just really improves the quality of your life”
- Successive generations already hold markedly different views of acceptable privacy—older people avoid Facebook, the speaker shares about herself but not her kids, and the youngest may share every detail—suggesting that as facial-recognition AR makes information instantly visible, what counts as acceptable disclosure will continue to shift rather than be governed by today's fears.
“each generation already seems to have a very different feel for what's acceptable. So, you know, my parents don't want to be on Facebook... presumably, my daughter... will put every single detail about her life on there”
Technological progress emerges unpredictably when breakthroughs in unrelated fields enable new applications.
- New technology is not simply the slow accumulation of better things; stalled fields can be revived when an unrelated field produces a breakthrough—carbon nanotubes (needed for a space elevator cable) and lithium-ion batteries (which enabled Tesla's EVs but were developed for gadgets) advanced for reasons unrelated to those applications.
“a totally different field discovered carbon nanotubes... if you can make a long-enough carbon nanotube... then that might be what you need to make a space elevator work.”
- Current rockets cost about $10,000 per pound to put material into space (including fuel), but estimates suggest a working space elevator could lower that to about $250 per pound—a huge if—since it solves the fuel problem and reuses the launch infrastructure rather than discarding it each trip.
“for rockets right now, it costs about $10,000 per pound of stuff that's going up there... the estimates for a space elevator is that you could get stuff up there for about $250/pound if you could get this crazy idea to work”
- Humans have genetically altered biology for at least 10,000 years through artificial selection, and a striking example is that brussels sprouts, cauliflower, broccoli, cabbage, kale, kohlrabi, and collard greens are all the single species Brassica oleracea, slowly modified over generations into distinct forms.
“we took a single species called Brassica oleracea and turned it into every vegetable you hated as a kid--brussels sprouts, cauliflower, broccoli, cabbage, kale, kohlrabi, collard greens... All one species, slowly modified over generations”
- The authors wrote each chapter by having one person read the primary literature and write a rough draft so the less-knowledgeable second person could check clarity, then alternated drafts, conducted interviews, added jokes and comics, and sent it back to experts to catch errors.
“one of us did the initial look at the primary literature... so we could make sure that at least our first pass... was clear enough that someone who didn't know much about the technology would be able to follow it.”
Emerging technologies create novel legal and ethical questions requiring new frameworks to resolve.
- Augmented reality that overlays the physical world creates novel legal and property questions—such as whether you can forcibly remove an offensive image like a swastika that someone places on your company's door in a popular AR channel—that current frameworks do not resolve and may require new laws.
“What right do you have to forcibly remove something from this augmented world? And the answer to that is not clear.”
- If you could harvest a person's cells and 3D-print a replacement organ such as a liver on demand, this creates a moral hazard because people might drink heavily knowing they could get a perfect liver anytime—though the horror of organ-replacement surgery itself acts as a countervailing cost, analogous to imposing real personal costs on bankers to deter risky behavior.
“people could decide: 'Okay, I could just get a perfect liver at any time, so I'm just going to drink like crazy and not worry about that.' So, we were talking about that moral hazard.”
Practical co-bots and configurable systems demonstrate how technology improves efficiency and quality of life.
- The Semi-Automated Mason (SAM) applies mortar and places bricks while a human cleans up the lines, making it a co-bot rather than a robot, and working together they lay bricks three times faster than a conventional construction worker—potentially reducing the cost of brick houses.
“working together, they are 3 times faster than a conventional construction worker. And so, that's already out.”
- Programmable matter envisions a room containing a robot that changes its configuration to meet changing needs—opening into a meeting space with a table, then folding into private workspaces—so a single room can serve many more purposes than it originally had simply by reconfiguring over the course of a day.
“you could have a room that essentially has a robot in it, and the robot is able to change its configuration to meet the needs of the room at the time”
- Augmented reality used in worker helmets (e.g., DAQRI with Boeing) makes trainees far less error-prone on delicate assembly tasks, and in at least one study they actually picked up the underlying skill—performable without AR—more quickly, because it functions like a tutor controlling your field of view.
“people who are putting together a delicate part of an airplane made far fewer mistakes when they used this augmented reality setup”