What this covers
Rachel Laudan, a food historian, joins Russ Roberts to examine food waste not as a simple moral imperative but as one value that competes with time, health, safety, and food security. The conversation traces how waste became moralized, beginning with religious taboos and intensifying through World War I and II propaganda claiming that discarded food could feed the hungry—a claim rarely borne out in practice. Laudan argues that understanding waste requires weighing tradeoffs: reducing waste always involves some cost, whether in preparation time, food safety risk, or the abandonment of inventory buffers that keep shelves stocked. The discussion extends into why food choices have become so charged with moral weight in American culture, and how the burden of constant dietary decision-making—a historical novelty—has generated anxiety rather than freedom.
The exchange covers several specific tensions. An optimal surplus in the food system is essential to prevent hunger, yet the impulse to eliminate waste can undermine that surplus. Widely cited food-waste statistics are difficult to verify, warranting skepticism about their precision. Conservative sell-by dates cause unnecessary disposal of edible food. The modern preference for fresh over processed food pushes the burden of waste prevention onto consumers who lack the skills to manage perishables, whereas canned and frozen foods naturally resist spoilage. Laudan further argues that the moralization of food—including movements around eating local, organic, or following Paleo or keto regimens—reflects broader dissatisfaction with how others freely choose to eat, recruiting consumers to political agendas while generating a perpetual sense of failure. Throughout, Laudan defends individual choice and expresses skepticism toward top-down intervention, favoring decentralized experimentation over government mandates.
Laudan argues that food waste is not a moral absolute but one value among many that must be weighed against tradeoffs like time, health, safety, and food security; and that the modern moralization of food choices reflects broader cultural anxieties rather than a genuinely broken food system.
- Reducing food waste imposes real costs (time, skills, health) that must be balanced against the benefit of waste reduction
- A surplus in the food system is desirable because it is the only route to food security
- The framing of food choices as moral issues recruits consumers to broader political concerns and produces neurotic anxiety
Food waste statistics are unreliable and the moralization of waste obscures real economic questions about optimal surplus.
- Food systems exist in three states—not enough food (disaster), just enough (extremely difficult to achieve and dangerously fragile to shocks like disease, climate, or war), or surplus—and a surplus is highly desirable because it is the only way to achieve food security; the real question is therefore not the morality of waste but the economic one of what optimal surplus is needed and how to keep it moving to minimize loss.
“a surplus in the system is I think tremendously much to be desired, because it is the only way you can have food security.”
- Conservative sell-by and best-by dates—likely set conservatively by producers protecting themselves and government regulators—cause unnecessary food waste because consumers and grocers discard food that remains perfectly edible after the date; reducing these dates, as Britain has begun doing, also reduces the broader neurotic fear of food.
“Britain has recently begun changing those sell-by dates in order to reduce the kind of unnecessary waste that goes along with those.”
- The moralization of food waste is not new but draws on traditional religious taboos and was strongly reinforced by WWI and WWII campaigns framing waste as a moral absolute, justified by the claim that wasted food could feed others—troops, starving Belgians, Africans, and now the food-insecure in the United States—even when in practice the food cannot actually be transferred to those people.
“if you go back to World War I, there was an enormous campaign against food waste that was conducted in just these terms--that it was a moral absolute.”
- Many widely cited food-waste statistics—such as one third of all food produced never being eaten, 40% going to waste, or an annual cost of a trillion dollars—are dramatic but hard to verify because waste is incredibly difficult to measure, warranting less-than-total confidence in the numbers commonly circulated.
“many of which are hard to verify, but which sound horrible: one third of all food produced is never eaten; 40% of the food that is produced goes to waste”
- Upscale restaurants generate little waste because they serve small, aesthetically pleasing portions at high prices that patrons finish, but most restaurants must serve generous helpings or risk losing customers, which makes restaurant portions far larger than home portions and thereby makes the doggie-bag and leftover phenomenon a large source of waste.
“for most restaurants not to give a generous helping is to turn away customers. And that does mean that the doggie-bad phenomenon, or the restaurant left-over food phenomenon, is one that is a large one.”
Modern food freedom is historically unprecedented but people lack the decision-making skills to handle daily food choices without anxiety.
- Increased individual food choice has made social interaction more difficult because shared eating historically functioned as social bonding—accepting the group's food was a way of joining it—whereas now, from a young age, individuals expect to choose their own food, so society must find new ways of expressing communality.
“whereas before the assumption was that short of some real serious health or religious issue, when you are invited to join a group you would share food with that group, that was a bonding in many ways; now it is quite the reverse.”
- The freedom to choose what one eats is a relatively recent historical development; for most of history most people had no choice—either through scarcity or through institutions like monasteries and armies that used communal feeding to control diet—so the modern abundance of choice is an enormous increase in both pleasure and responsibility that humanity has not yet learned to handle, marking a shift from subject to citizen.
“For most of history, most people did not have a choice of what they ate.”
- The current intense attention to food is a transition period that cannot be sustained indefinitely; because of the practical pressure of feeding oneself three times a day, people will eventually settle into a more routinized way of eating—possibly via more eating away from home or home delivery—though the exact form is unpredictable.
“I see this as a transition period. Just because of the practicalities of, you know, the pressure of feeding three times a day. It's hard to do well.”
- People increasingly believe that subscribing to extreme diets like Paleo or keto will let them express themselves and prolong their lives in ways Laudan doubts they actually can; this obsessive attention to food, combined with impossibly high standards for being simultaneously healthy and delicious, gives many people a constant sense of failure and unhappiness about food.
“People are coming to believe that if they subscribe to the Paleo diet, or the keto-diet... they can not only express themselves but probably prolong their lives in ways that I very much doubt they'll be able to.”
- Although the freedom to choose what to eat is valuable, it is a decision that must be made two or three times a day every day, and for the first or second generation to have this choice it has produced a learning curve and a great deal of anxiety as people struggle to handle the responsibility of constant food decisions.
“it's a decision that has to be made 3 times a day, or twice a day, 7 days a week. And I think it's led, for many people, to a lot of anxiety.”
Food discourse is ideologically laden, serving wider political concerns and contradicting itself rather than pursuing coherent goals.
- Even if wasting food is bad, it is only one among many competing goods and harms adults must weigh—food safety, health, time to prepare, enjoyment, and respect for others—so reducing waste always involves balancing it against other potential harms rather than treating it as an absolute.
“even if you think it's wrong, it is simply one among many wrongs and rights that as adults we have to weigh. There are other issues about food. Is our food safe? Is our food healthy? Is our food taking an inordinate amount of time to acquire and prepare?”
- Successive food scares and imperatives—eat organic, local, natural; avoid fast food—are less fads than a generally well-intentioned way of articulating a vision in which food and society could be arranged differently, expressing a belief that the food system is a symptom of wider problems of capitalism, big agriculture, big food processing, and global chains.
“these successive scares of 'fast food is bad for you,' and 'non-organic food is bad for you,' and 'you must eat local,' are, in fact, by and large well-intentioned... they are less fads than a way of trying to articulate and make clear to Americans a vision of a world where food and indeed society could be arranged differently.”
- The extraordinary moralization of food in the United States—absent in countries like Mexico—is not accidental but serves to persuade consumers that their food choices are moral issues, thereby recruiting them to wider political concerns and treating things like body weight as a sign of self-control and maturity, so food becomes a carrier for broad ideological concern.
“if you can persuade the consumer that choices are moral issues, you can include them in, or recruit them to, or demonstrate to them the importance of wider political concerns about everything”
- The contemporary food discourse is full of ironies because the worry about obesity and the worry about food waste pull in opposite directions: not finishing the food on your plate can be good if you are overweight, so the underlying value systems are far more complex and contradictory than simple imperatives like 'Don't waste' or 'Eat local.'
“one of the concerns... with abundance is obesity. There's a lot of worry about people being obese. And yet, at the same time, we are worried about people wasting food. There is something to be said for not finishing the food on your plate.”
Widespread advice to reduce waste through cooking skills or fresh food actually increases burden on ordinary people unprepared for it.
- When chefs promote reducing waste through nose-to-tail or low-waste cooking, they tend to overestimate the skills and the available time of the average home food preparer, since what a chef like Dan Barber can do in a professional kitchen is far beyond what ordinary people can do at home.
“when I see chefs arguing or promoting a lack of waste, there, as in many other areas, they are apt to over-estimate the skills of--and the time--of the average home-preparer of food.”
- The movement urging consumers to eat more fresh, natural food and less canned or frozen food is ironic in the waste debate, because canned and frozen foods last well regardless of shape, whereas fresh produce is the most difficult food to use up before it spoils—pushing the burden of preventing waste onto consumers who must acquire new skills they often lack.
“if you go to fresh, natural food, what you are doing is pushing along to the consumer, or the consumer is buying some of the most difficult food to use up, in time, before it goes bad.”
- Backyard composting in suburban neighborhoods often fails because households don't generate enough food waste to compost effectively, the compost heap becomes either ineffective or a neighborhood nuisance, and major waste streams like fats and oils don't compost well—and municipal composting programs incur real costs, such as cities having to provide compostable plastic bags after overestimating compostable waste volumes.
“In the suburban neighborhood, unless you know what you are doing, your compost heap is either ineffective, or it is a neighborhood nuisance--because you obviously can't just put all your household waste into the compost--and fats and oils in particular, which are one of the biggest sources of household waste, food waste, don't do well in composts.”
Government intervention in food is unnecessary; market solutions and diverse private efforts will address problems better.
- Laudan does not want the government to intervene more in food production and distribution; she favors a laissez-faire approach because numerous non-governmental organizations with competing agendas are already working on these issues, and she believes the problems of coping with choice and obesity will find solutions through many people trying different things rather than a top-down roadmap.
“Do I want the government to intervene more in food production and distribution? No, I don't think so... I tend to be rather laissez faire about this moment.”