Simeon Djankov and Matt Warner on the Doing Business Report and Development Aid
What this covers
Simeon Djankov, creator of the World Bank's Doing Business Report, and Matt Warner of Atlas Network discuss with Russ Roberts how external ranking systems can drive regulatory reform in developing economies. The conversation centers on a counterintuitive mechanism: by publishing objective, internationally comparable measures of business registration burden, the Doing Business Report creates competitive pressure that allows reformist politicians to overcome entrenched interests. Djankov and Warner argue that countries treat the rankings like a competition—Russia initially resisted but eventually reformed to climb the standings; India's dramatic improvement coincided with nearly 8 percentage points of new business registration growth. The hosts examine the report's methodology, its limitations as a measurement tool, and the empirical evidence linking regulatory reduction to poverty alleviation.
The discussion ranges across concrete reform examples: Bulgaria's elimination of costly notary requirements, France's rigid hiring laws that pushed workers into part-time positions, and Argentina's successful campaign to remove a 35 percent laptop tariff. A key tension emerges around locally-led development. Warner argues that outsiders cannot provide effective reform design because they lack the tacit knowledge of local interests and culture—citing South Africa's conversion of informal housing to formal title as valuable precisely because local civil society understood what property ownership meant to residents beyond economic metrics. Alongside this, the speakers weigh whether regulatory quality causes prosperity or whether wealthier countries develop better institutions as a consequence of wealth (reverse causation). Roberts also raises a deeper question: whether emphasizing measurable outcomes crowds out genuinely important but unmeasurable achievements. The conversation balances enthusiasm for objective metrics as tools for political leverage against skepticism about what numbers actually capture.
Djankov and Warner argue that measurable, externally-gathered indicators of regulatory burden (the Doing Business Report) create competitive pressure that drives real deregulation, and that the most effective development reforms come from locally-led organizations rather than paternalistic outsiders.
- An external, objective ranking lets reformist politicians bind themselves to the mast and overcome entrenched interests
- Reductions in red tape correlate with lower poverty and more business registration
- Local civil-society groups, not foreign technocrats, possess the tacit knowledge to design winning reforms
Local organizations achieve measurable poverty reduction through focused, time-bound reform campaigns with public commitments and transparent accountability.
- A local Argentine organization identified a 35% tariff on laptops and tablets that meant Argentines paid double what Chileans and triple what Americans paid for the same products, harming consumers who need technology; within a year they prevailed upon the Macri administration to eliminate the tariff, demonstrating that locally-designed reform strategies can produce change in short time windows.
“here in Argentina we're paying double what they are paying in Chile for that same computer product. We are paying three times what Americans are paying”
- In a cohort of investments across 29 countries tied to Doing Business or Economic Freedom of the World reforms, Atlas Network had wins in 10, which based on Djankov's research equates to 405,000 people lifting themselves out of poverty at a cost of about $4.88 per person—demonstrating accountability to clear outcomes without a profit motive.
“we invested in 29 countries, with reforms tied to either Doing Business or Economic Freedom of the World. We've had wins in 10 of them.”
- India's policy requiring entrepreneurs to prove they held 111.2% of GDP per capita in their bank account before starting a business was an arbitrary rule that disproportionately burdened low-income people; its elimination, achieved by the Centre for Civil Society's campaign, translates to roughly 126,000 people lifting themselves out of poverty in Year 1, because the decision of whether someone is prepared to start a business properly rests with the risk-bearing individual.
“you had to go show a bureaucrat and prove to him, or her, that you had 111.2% GDP per capita in your bank account, as some sort of a proxy indicator”
Effective development requires locals to lead with their tacit knowledge of culture and vested interests, while outsiders limit themselves to funding support.
- Atlas Network promotes a 'call-your-shots' model (like Babe Ruth pointing to the outfield) where organizations publicly commit to a specific achievable reform in a 12-24 month window, build a sophisticated research and marketing strategy, and cannot hide or explain away failure—building a track record that warrants donor support and strengthens the causal credibility of the reform.
“a call-your-shots method. Like, in billiards... when you say, 'Hey, I see something on the horizon that I think we can achieve'”
- Effective development requires putting a premium on locally-grown solutions led by people who have their own vision and understanding of the culture, rather than paternalistic outsiders telling them what to do; outsiders should be limited to philanthropic support because locals possess the tacit knowledge of vested interests and dynamics needed to build winning reform strategies.
“one of the key things that is missing is putting a premium on locally grown solutions, led not by outsiders but by the people there who have their own division, their own understanding of the culture”
Reform delivers both instrumental and non-monetary value including dignity and intergenerational legacy that only beneficiaries can fully know.
- Converting tenant housing to formal land title in South Africa, as a civil society institute achieved for apartheid-era residents, gives owners options to sell or use the land as collateral for credit, but also delivers non-monetary value of dignity and intergenerational legacy that no technocrat could assess because the owner holds tacit knowledge of what the property means to her.
“when you achieve land title that gives you a lot more options economically in terms of, you could sell the land... They can use the land as collateral to access credit”