What this covers

Elizabeth Pape, founder of Elizabeth Suzann, discusses her Nashville-based women's clothing company with EconTalk host Russ Roberts. The conversation moves from the specific economics of her business—a vertically integrated operation that manufactures and sells high-end garments made-to-order—to the broader transformation of the apparel industry over the past two decades. Pape argues that collapsing clothing prices have obscured the true costs of production, and that her company's response is to reject price competition entirely, instead building sustainable margins through durability, ethical sourcing, and a direct relationship with a small but devoted customer base. The interview traces both her entrepreneurial journey and the structural forces reshaping how clothing is made and sold globally.

The discussion opens with concrete economics: a detailed breakdown of a $185 tunic shows that labor and materials account for only $20-30, while fixed costs and overhead consume most of the remaining margin, leaving roughly 10% as net profit. This figure illustrates why offshoring labor alone cannot explain the price differences between premium and fast-fashion garments. The conversation then broadens to examine Economies of Scale—how retailers like H&M spread enormous fixed costs across vast volume—and the global forces that opened apparel production to low-cost regions, triggering a race to the bottom in pricing. Pape contends that Cost Per Wear, not sticker price, measures true value, while Mindful Consumption becomes her brand's advocacy. Along the way, Roberts and Pape debate whether deliberate full-garment construction breaks even against Division of Labor efficiency, whether Anchoring Against a Cheap Alternative harms premium sales, and whether the Internet truly enables profitable niche manufacturing at this scale.

Sharpest takeaway

Pape argues that the collapse in clothing prices has hidden the true costs of garment production, and that a made-to-order, in-house, ethically-sourced model can sustainably charge premium prices by selling durability, mindful consumption, and a community/brand experience rather than competing on price.

  • A detailed cost breakdown of a $185 garment shows labor and materials are a minority of price; overhead, small scale, and operating costs dominate.
  • Lower prices come from passing all savings to consumers, offshoring labor, and lower-quality materials—creating a 'race to the bottom.'
  • The right response for premium brands is to compete on durability (cost-per-wear), ethical sourcing, and brand community, not price.

The argument · threads5 threads · 28 claims
0.80

Consumers should evaluate true garment value by cost-per-wear and durability, not price, to escape destructive cheap-fashion cycles.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The brand's primary purpose is to advocate for intentionality and mindfulness in consumption—encouraging consumers to re-evaluate their needs (buy one $10 shirt every few months rather than ten), because the subculture of shopping 'like they eat,' wearing items once and discarding them, is both environmentally damaging and an unfulfilling, un-introspective way to live.

    “our primary objective is to encourage people to be consuming a little bit more mindfully. You may very well need to buy the $10 tee shirt ... But maybe you don't need 10 of them.”

  • Objects have a real power to transform lives—especially highly functional ones connected to a story of their origin—but consumers should evaluate an item's purpose and function and make conscious decisions rather than unconscious, compulsive purchases akin to mindlessly eating potato chips.

    “objects really do have the power to transform lives ... the objects that tend to add the most value are the ones that are highly, highly functional; and I can see and feel their application in my daily life. And the ones that I can connect with the story of where they came from.”

  • The true value of a garment is best measured by cost per wear—total price divided by number of wears—so a cheap shirt whose strap breaks after two wears costs $5/wear, while a durable higher-priced garment worn hundreds of times over years can drop to pennies per wear, and a rarely-worn ballgown can cost hundreds of dollars per wear.

    “If you buy a $10 shirt and the strap breaks after two wears, you've got a pretty expensive cost per wear: you wear it twice, so it was $5 per wear. If you have a higher-priced garment but you are able to wear it ... hundreds of times over many years, you could get down to $1 per wear.”

  • The mere existence of a $10 shirt makes the decision to buy a $250 shirt much harder, because the availability of a far more affordable option forces consumers to deeply justify the premium purchase even when they want it.

    “the sheer existence of a $10 shirt now makes a decision to buy the $250 shirt a much harder decision to make. Even if you really have interest in the $250 product, the simple existence of something that's so much more affordable, you really have to give that a lot of thought”

  • Since the 1990s, clothing prices have not merely failed to keep pace with rising consumer prices but have actually dropped, while the share of disposable income consumers are willing to spend on clothing has also fallen, producing a 'race to the bottom' in apparel pricing.

    “from the 1990s to today, clothing has not only failed to increase in price with other consumer products, but it has actually dropped. So, individual garment prices have dropped while other consumer prices have steadily inclined”

0.75

Made-to-order, full-garment production in-house with fair wages and worker pride yields a differentiated model competitors do not replicate.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The company uses an average wage of $16.50/hour to cost garments—well above Tennessee's $7.25 minimum wage and the roughly $11.09 average wage for garment manufacturing workers—with most employees ending up above $16.50 after annual raises, reflecting a deliberate ethical compensation choice.

    “We use an average wage of $16.50/hour ... Minimum wage in Tennessee is $7.25. Average wage for garment manufacturing workers is about $11.09. So, we're well above that, for our entry level”

  • Elizabeth Suzann produces basic women's wear from all-natural fibers entirely made-to-order in its own Nashville studio, which is an unconventional model compared to fashion brands that release seasonal collections and outsource production.

    “We produce basics that are made from all-natural fibers and we do everything made-to-order from our national studio. So, we're pretty unconventional in terms of how we make clothes”

  • The company deliberately rejects assembly-line specialization in favor of lean, full-garment construction where each seamstress sews a garment start-to-finish; despite lower efficiency and foregone gains from Smith's division of labor, it produces happier, prouder employees and may break even once reduced turnover and training costs are counted.

    “We don't sew garments in assembly-line fashion, we instead use a lean, full-garment construction method. That means each seamstress sews a garment from start-to-finish. Despite it requiring more time, this improves craftsmanship, ensures everybody is learning ... and is most importantly a more rewarding and fulfilling way to work.”

  • Because the company launders all garments to account for shrinkage before sale, it uses roughly 15% more fabric than competitors—most fabrics shrink 10-20% in length—so customers receive a garment that will fit the same forever even after washing and drying, unlike an unlaundered shirt that shrinks to an unwearable size.

    “We account for all shrinkage ahead of time, so that when our customers receive a garment, it is going to fit the way it's going to fit forever ... Most fabrics shrink 10-20% in length. So, we're using probably about 15% more fabric than the H&M tunic”

0.57

Transparent cost structure and operational honesty ground pricing decisions and reinvestment strategy in actual economics, not arbitrary margins.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Fast-fashion companies can offer rock-bottom prices because they pass every dollar of savings to the consumer rather than investing in marketing, community, or brand culture—so the consumer is buying only the physical product, not an experience or lifestyle.

    “those companies have been able to offer the prices that they can offer because they've essentially passed every dollar of savings on to the consumer rather than investing in marketing or in the building up of a community or kind of a culture, lifestyle around the brand. They are literally just producing product and selling it at the minimum price.”

  • The company has no direct competitors doing made-to-order, lean, in-house production for its market; brands customers also shop (Everlane, Eileen Fisher, Jesse Kamm, Apiece Apart) focus on transparency or partial domestic production but none use the same model, partly because ethical, source-conscious shopping is a young industry.

    “Everlane really focuses on transparency, but their things are still produced all overseas. Same thing for Eileen Fisher: some of them are domestically produced. But nobody's doing this made-to-order, lean, in-house method.”

  • About 65% of the company's business comes from repeat customers out of roughly 4500 active customers, with sales growing from about $320,000 to $1 million in 2015, over $2 million in 2016, and a $3 million projection for 2017.

    “most of our business, I think 65% of our business, is repeat customers who are just continuing to support the brand.”

  • Of the $185 tunic price, after roughly $63 in material, labor, and wastage, most of the remaining ~$122 gross profit margin goes to operating costs because the company runs two businesses—a factory with its own overhead plus a sales business—leaving only about $18.50 (about 10%) as net profit for reinvestment.

    “most of that $120 leftover, our gross profit margin, is going towards our operating costs. We have a kind of interesting operation because we are essentially running two businesses ... we are also running a factory. So, we have two different kinds of overhead”

  • Forever21 was one of the first players to introduce obscenely low-priced clothing (e.g., $20 jeans, $40 coats), after which H&M and department stores joined the trend, and even formerly moderate brands like Gap and JCrew saw prices depressed, with $100 Gap jeans falling to $30-40.

    “Forever21 was I think one of the big first players to come into this scene and make kind of obscenely low priced clothing. And then everybody struggled to catch up.”

  • The company's key mistake in its domestic wool sourcing project was taking customer orders for the product before the fabric was physically in the building, leading to a failure when the small supplier crumbled under demand; the lesson was to work only with operations at least as large as your own and never take a customer's dollar until the product is secured.

    “the real mistake on our part was that we took orders for the product before we had the fabric in the building.”

0.56

Grassroots word-of-mouth from repeat customers and invested community builds sustainable growth better than conventional marketing capture.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The company grew its customer base in a grassroots way—starting on Etsy and in-person vendor events—where customers met in person would continue shopping online and tell friends, demonstrating the power of word-of-mouth for a niche brand.

    “In the beginning it was pretty exclusively grass roots: I would meet people in person and then they would literally tell a friend. And I'm still blown away by how well that worked and how many people actually talked about, you know, this tiny, nonexistent company.”

  • Growing beyond a certain point could damage the brand's image because customers value the feeling of discovery—'I found this really special company'—and becoming too big would dissolve that magic, so the founder deliberately does not aim to become a huge brand.

    “I think people really like our brand because it feels like a discovery. It feels like 'I found this really special company.' I think the bigger we get, we'll lose a little bit of that magic.”

  • Rather than spending on retargeting, Google ads, or capturing new customers, the company invests in keeping its current customers extremely happy and providing educational, value-adding content so customers themselves spread the word, which yields a larger long-term payoff through self-propagating marketing.

    “We do not do a lot of re-targeting; we do not do Google ads; we don't--we are not trying to capture new customers. We're trying to keep our current customers really, really pleased and let them tell new customers about us.”

0.38

Deliberate design for natural-fiber durability and trendless style maximizes garment lifespan while preventing synthetic landfill persistence.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • If growth allows fixed operating costs to shrink as a percentage of revenue, the company hopes to lower prices by 10-15%, take a bit more net profit to build capital for a new facility, and ultimately pass some of the savings back down to customers.

    “if we were able to see our costs shrink as a percentage of our revenue with growth, we would ideally be able to pass some of this back down to the customers ... if possible I'd like to get our prices down 10-15%.”

  • The company deliberately designs garments from biodegradable natural fibers to last between 3 and 7 years rather than forever, because everlasting synthetic pieces would persist in landfills, and also designs for style durability with trendless, neutral, simple Signature pieces that won't date.

    “Ideally, we'd like our garments to last between 3 and 7 years. We do not want them to last forever, because that means they're going to last forever in a landfill. We use natural fibers, which are going to biodegrade”