Chris Blattman on Sweatshops
What this covers
Economist Chris Blattman of the University of Chicago joins Russ Roberts to discuss experimental findings that challenge a widely held assumption about poverty and work. The conversation centers on a randomized controlled trial conducted across five Ethiopian firms, which tracked roughly one thousand workers—some offered factory jobs, others given a $300 cash grant plus business training, and a control group—over one year. Rather than confirming that factory employment represents a clear step up for the poor, the study revealed unexpected patterns in how workers themselves assess their options and what such jobs actually cost them.
The heart of the discussion is Blattman's finding that two-thirds of factory hires quit within a month or two and exited the industrial sector entirely, discovering that informal sector opportunities were more viable than they had appeared before the factory job was offered. Those who received the $300 cash transfer instead reported being happier and less financially anxious, invested in small businesses like charcoal and livestock, and raised their earnings modestly without the health toll. Factory work produced a striking finding: exposure to chemical and particulate hazards doubled the rate of serious health problems among workers, a physical consequence rather than a stress effect. The conversation weaves in broader questions about economies of scale, division of labor, and why industrialization transformed living standards in China and India yet may not follow the same path in Ethiopia. Blattman emphasizes that his field work overturned prior assumptions—including his own—about what poor workers actually prefer and which interventions genuinely improve their circumstances.
Blattman argues that factory ('sweatshop') jobs in early-industrializing Ethiopia are not the clear improvement over informal self-employment that economists assumed: a randomized experiment showed workers quit quickly, faced doubled health problems, and that a $300 cash grant produced happier, less anxious, modestly richer entrepreneurs than the factory job.
- A randomized trial across 5 firms (~1000 people) compared factory hires, $300 cash-grant recipients, and a control group over one year
- Two-thirds of factory hires quit within a month or two and left the industrial sector, finding informal-sector options better than expected
- Factory job offers doubled the rate of self-reported health problems, attributed to chemicals and particulate matter rather than stress
Factory work in expanded markets enables transformative living-standard improvements that isolated economies cannot achieve.
- Small village economies face an inherent ceiling on prosperity because division of labor is limited by the extent of the market; a hundred people on an isolated island cannot be wealthy regardless of resources, whereas the same people trading with a billion others can be, which is why economies of scale and industrialization in larger markets are what enable transformative growth.
“100 people can't be very wealthy. Now, 100 people trading with, you know, a billion people can be wealthy.”
- Hundreds of millions of people in China and India improved their living standards by leaving agriculture, moving to cities, and working in factories producing goods for global markets, demonstrating industrialization's transformative material potential, though whether it can be replicated in Ethiopia, Uganda, or Kenya is an open question.
“hundreds of millions of people--in China, in India, have improved their standard of living by leaving agriculture, coming to the cities, and working in factories, producing goods for people around the world.”
Low-wage industrial employment, though miserable, remains preferable to the worse alternatives available to the poor.
- As Joan Robinson remarked, the misery of being exploited by capitalists is nothing compared to the misery of not being exploited at all, capturing the difficult truth that low-wage factory work for the poor, while paying very little, is still better than their alternatives.
“The misery of being exploited by capitalists is nothing compared to the misery of not being exploited at all.”
Major life changes including relocation and marriage create stress that impairs health and immune function.
- Folk wisdom holds that changing jobs, getting married, getting divorced, or moving each make a person more likely to get sick, with the effect compounding if several occur at once, plausibly because such changes are stressful and compromise the immune system.
“if you change jobs, get married, get divorced, move--any of those three things, you are much more likely to get sick. If you do all 3...you are really much more likely to get sick.”