What this covers

Eric Wakin, director of the library and archives at Stanford's Hoover Institution, discusses with Russ Roberts what archivists actually do and why physical objects matter for historical research. The conversation ranges across the practical and philosophical dimensions of collecting and preserving—from why a jar of Ronald Reagan's jelly beans belongs in an archive to how institutions decide what to acquire and keep. Wakin explains the difference between how archives operate compared to libraries: archives prioritize preserving material of future research importance over materials that circulate frequently, which means accepting that some items may sit unused for decades before they transform understanding of an era.

A central tension runs through the discussion: the gap between Market Value vs Research Value. Wakin describes how archivists follow norms against disaggregating collections or buying items that have been excised from books, because the market value of individual pieces often diverges sharply from their research power when kept together. The conversation also addresses the Digital Preservation Paradox—that despite the appearance of comprehensive digital storage, materials from the early digital age face unique collection challenges. Emails sit on servers without systematic preservation; authors' drafts vanish unless hard drives are actively retained. Wakin notes the irony that older simulacrum-based technologies like microfilm remain more durable and practical than unproven long-term digital storage. He also addresses Power of the Object: even when faithful digital copies exist, the original physical artifact retains irreplaceable meaning rooted in human nature. The discussion includes obstacles ranging from the expense of digitization and metadata work to legal liability that can prevent acquiring even invaluable material. Roberts introduces questions about how historical figures like Jefferson curated what they committed to writing, suggesting that the historical record has always been a partial self-presentation rather than a complete account.

Sharpest takeaway

Wakin argues that physical archival objects carry irreplaceable meaning and research value, and that the shift to digital communication paradoxically threatens to make the historical record of our era less accessible, not more.

  • Original one-of-a-kind objects retain a visceral, meaningful value even when digital copies exist
  • Archives operate by mission-driven preservation rather than market value or usage frequency
  • Digital and email-era materials are harder to collect, preserve, and access than paper

The argument · threads2 threads · 20 claims
0.71

Historical figures strategically curated their written communications, reserving sensitive matters for private conversation.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Historical figures like Jefferson and Adams corresponded strategically because they knew their letters would be read by future generations, which shaped what they wrote and led them to reserve some matters for face-to-face conversation—meaning the written record is always partly a curated self-presentation rather than a complete account.

    “I think they knew that their correspondence would be read down the ages. And I assume that changed what they wrote.”

0.71

Digital openness is changing what gets preserved as younger generations with different privacy attitudes commit more of their lives to recordable form.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • One cost of digital openness is that people increasingly commit less to the public record—saying sensitive things face-to-face rather than in writing—but cultural attitudes toward privacy are changing dramatically, so younger generations who grew up with digital sharing may put more of their lives into preservable form, changing what archives can collect.

    “one of the costs of that openness is that we, I think, commit less and less to the public record. We say things that are quiet and face to face.”