Matthew Futterman on Players and the Business of Sports
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews Matthew Futterman, Wall Street Journal reporter and author of Players, on how sports transformed into a multi-billion-dollar industry over the past fifty years. Futterman traces this explosion not to television alone, but to a foundational shift: athletes winning the right to earn professional salaries. Once athletes could live off sport, they could train full-time and compete across years, producing a dramatically better on-field product that attracted viewers and sponsors in turn. Roberts and Futterman explore how this Virtuous Cycle of Sports unfolded across football, baseball, basketball, tennis, swimming, and the Olympics, and how it reshaped not just compensation but the entire texture of athletic competition and fandom.
The conversation ranges widely across how sports products became more compelling. Deliberate rule changes—the NFL opening up the forward pass in the late 1970s, baseball lowering the strike zone and pitcher's mound, basketball's adoption of the 3-point line—were designed to increase scoring because fans prefer it. Broadcasters like ABC humanized athletes into recurring characters, transforming games into dramas. Nike succeeded by Selling Stories Not Products—marketing legends and dreams rather than shoe features. The discussion also touches on harder edges: how Edwin Moses and others pushed Olympic professionalization against entrenched amateur rules that artificially suppressed athlete pay; how Bill Walsh capitalized on structural shifts; and how the hunt for competitive advantage through training and data evaluation became sport's hidden innovation. Futterman argues that Cost of Suppressing Competition proved real—once free agency arrived, everyone, including owners, grew richer. The speakers also consider present anxieties: baseball's slowing pace, whether Fantasy Football fragments attention, and which sports will dominate American culture in two decades amid European soccer's rise.
Futterman argues that modern sports became a multi-billion dollar industry not because of television alone but because athletes won the right to be paid as professionals, which set off a virtuous cycle: better pay enabled better training, which improved the on-field product, which attracted more money and emotional investment from fans.
- Paying the labor force what it was worth unlocked harder training and a dramatically better athletic product
- Deliberate rule changes (NFL passing rules, lowered pitcher's mound, 3-point line) made games higher-scoring and more watchable
- Marketing turned games into dramas and athletes into characters, e.g. Nike selling stories rather than shoes
Professionalization and rule changes that allowed athlete compensation and competition fundamentally restructured sports economics and performance.
- Like movie executives who feared videotape would lose them money while sitting on a profit monster, sports owners who suppressed player pay and blocked free agency were making a terrible mistake—when free agency arrived everybody got richer, including owners and especially fans; suppressing workers and discouraging competition is not the road to success.
“this idea that if you suppress and pay your workers as little as possible and discourage competition, that that's the road to success, I don't know where exactly we got that idea. But time and again it shows us, in industry to industry, it seems not to be true.”
- The supposedly pure amateur Olympic system was actually an ugly arrangement in which the organizers who set the rules barring athletes from pay were the same people artificially keeping down their labor costs while profiting from their side businesses.
“Was there purity in a system where the organizers of it are pushing a system that essentially artificially keeps down their labor costs and allows them to make money on their side businesses?”
- Athletes like Edwin Moses, tired of secret under-the-table payments while being barred from professional status, agitated to change the rules; allied with IOC head Juan Antonio Samaranch's recognition that the Olympics needed the best-of-the-best to survive, professionalization let athletes train and compete across many years, which made the Olympics a continuing TV show and exploded the value of broadcast rights.
“in order for the Olympics to survive, they were going to have to be in competition between the best of the best. It was no longer going to be able to survive as a sort of quirky amateur competition because people weren't going to be interested in that.”
- The transformation of sports into a multi-billion dollar industry started with athletes agitating to be paid as professionals; once they earned enough money, they could train harder and get better, which improved the product (the games as shows), which drew more fans and TV money, snowballing into the modern sports economy.
“what it really starts with, was, paying the labor force what it deserved to be paid and valuing it in the way it deserved to be valued. And that sort of seems to have been the thing that really unlocked the box of sports.”
Marketing and narrative storytelling became the real driver of modern sports value, prioritizing athlete legends and emotional appeal over technical product.
- The marketing revolution changed athletes' priorities so that what became important was not just championships or points but 'What's my story?'—and once the industry became addicted to legends, certain irresistible but false narratives (like Lance Armstrong beating cancer) became dangerous, because people dislike being lied to.
“what really became important to a lot of the athletes is not so much, you know, how many championships they've won or exactly how many points they scored... but 'What's my story?' here.”
- Nike's massive success comes not from being primarily an equipment company but a marketing company that sells stories—it understood before competitors that what mattered was the legend spun about the athlete wearing the swoosh, not the technical features of the shoe, exemplified by edgy Spike Lee commercials about big ideas like dreams and 'Just Do It' while rivals touted molded soles.
“their main product was selling stories... they realized that they were not so much an equipment company but a marketing company. That that's where their main strength was.”
Structural changes in equipment, rules, and fields transformed how sports are played, enabling increased speed, scoring, and strategic adaptation.
- Top European soccer leagues are unrecognizable from 25-30 years ago despite unchanged field and goal dimensions, because of subtle equipment and surface changes—a livelier synthetic ball that no longer absorbs water, manicured fast fields watered before games—that increased speed and scoring, plus heavy investment in England's stadiums after a dangerous era.
“maybe the size of the field is the same and the goals are the same size; but it's a completely different ball. The fields are much more manicured... The fields are watered down before to make them even faster. They have made tremendous changes to speed up those games as well.”
- The NFL deliberately changed its rules in the late 1970s—allowing linemen to extend their arms when blocking and prohibiting contact with receivers beyond 5 yards—to open up the passing game and increase scoring, transforming the sport from a coach's league (Lombardi) to a quarterback's league (Montana).
“they changed the rules to open up the field to make it easier, essentially, to move the ball down the field. And what's the easiest way to move the ball down the field? It's through the forward pass... that rule changed, where you couldn't have contact beyond 5 yards. And that really opened things up... So, it went from being a coach's league to a quarterback's league.”
- Coach Bill Walsh in San Francisco was first to exploit the NFL's passing rule changes, not only adapting Sunday play but also changing how the team practiced—eliminating contact to keep players fresh, fast, and healthy—demonstrating how forward-thinking actors capitalize on structural shifts.
“you had a coach like Bill Walsh, San Francisco, could really sort of see where this was going... He stopped having contact. He stopped wearing down his players. He wanted them fresh and he wanted them fast and he wanted them speedy and he wanted them healthy.”
Athletic performance improved dramatically through training, specialization, nutrition, and data-driven player evaluation rather than human evolution.
- The major innovation in modern sports is not just training but player evaluation—the hunt for the secret data and important numbers that reveal who is better than whom—which has also made fandom far more entertaining for statistically oriented fans.
“the real innovation that's happened is the hunt for the secret data... the hunt for those important numbers that will tell you who is better than whom.”
- The dramatic improvement in athletic performance over a generation is not due to human evolution but to training, practice, nutrition, weight training, and rest—activities athletes of the 1950s lacked time for because they held off-season jobs like Arnold Palmer (paint salesman) and Roger Staubach (real estate).
“the species hasn't changed. Evolution didn't suddenly change over the last 30 years. We know that didn't happen. What happened was training and practice and all these things that people didn't have time for. Because in the 1950s, Arnold Palmer was a paint salesman in addition to trying to become a professional golfer.”
- Nick Bollettieri foresaw that as sports professionalized and more money entered, more kids and parents would want those jobs, prompting him to flip the American ideal of the well-balanced child—advocating that a tennis-bound teenager practice 8-10 hours a day and attend school only 3 hours—a once-blasphemous idea that became normalized and fed down into the travel-team system.
“his insight: Once it got professionalized and more money was going into it, that more kids were going to want these jobs... if you are a teenager and your future was tennis, then you should practice tennis 8 or 10 hours a day and maybe go to school for 3 hours a day instead of the opposite ratio. And it was sort of blasphemy at the time.”
Sports inspire and reveal human potential and character in ways few other activities can, creating beauty, fairness, and meaningful competition.
- One of the great things about sports is that everyone can be an expert and discussions inevitably become debates.
“everybody should be an expert. That's one of the things that's great about sports”
- The long-held belief that swimmers peak in their early 20s (and women even younger) was wrong; swimmers peak in their mid-to-late 20s like other athletes. The myth persisted only because amateur rules made it impossible to earn money swimming past age 21-22, so no one continued competing.
“for a very long time there was this idea that swimmers peaked in their early 20s... And it's completely wrong. Swimmers peak when every other athlete peaks--which is their mid- to late 20s... the reason we thought this was because no one dared to swim after they were 21 or 22, so you couldn't make any money doing it.”
- Few sports today can afford to ask fans for three hours of attention; football works because there are only 16 games while baseball asks for three-plus hours 162 times a year, which is unsustainable in a world of distractions and fantasy sports.
“I think that very few sports have the luxury of asking fans to spend 3 hours with them these days. Football, you do, but there's only 16 games in a season... baseball is asking fans to pay attention for at least 3 hours... 162 times a year. In today's world, that's a big ask.”
- The real challenge for soccer leagues in the United States is not competing against other US sports but competing against high-quality European soccer, which media availability now makes accessible to all American viewers.
“the real challenge, actually for the soccer league in the United States is not so much competing against other U.S. sports--it's competing against the great soccer from Europe that's now, because of media, so available to all of us.”
- The odds against making a living as an elite athlete are severe—only about 10 top-10 tennis players exist at any time and only roughly 80 tennis players make money, yet many families devote their lives to the slim chance, despite most kids never even playing Division 1 college sports.
“There's under a thousand who think they have a shot at it--and maybe a couple of them do”
- Smart observers think that in 20 years the big sports in the United States will be the NFL, the NBA, and international soccer, with the richest European leagues continuing to attract the best players for the foreseeable future, though Brexit throws this somewhat into question.
“The smart people that I talk to, they sort of think that in 20 years the big sports in the United States will be the NFL, the NBA, and International Soccer.”
- Contrary to the common belief that television created the modern sports economy, sports had to become a compelling TV product before TV could amplify it; TV supplies the lifeblood but only after the underlying product improved.
“what's been said for a long time, was always said for a long time, was that TV made sports... But sports had to become good TV before TV could make sports.”
- Society holds a prejudice against athletic prodigies dedicating their lives to a single sport, viewing it as crass, while never judging a gifted child who attends a music conservatory or trains intensely as a ballet dancer—an inconsistency in how we treat specialization across domains.
“if that kid is a great ballet dancer or a great pianist, we never say that kid shouldn't go to a conservatory. No one ever judges the prodigies, I don't think, in the arts or in other pursuits. But there is something that I think people still see as kind of crass about doing that if the effort is sports.”
- When sports work, they inspire us and make us think about what's possible like nothing else; there is a larger idea behind them—beauty, fairness, or the Olympics as essentially a peace movement—and they can not just build character but also reveal it in ways other activities cannot.
“at their root is this really big idea--which is that the Olympics is essentially a peace movement... they can not just build character but also reveal character, in ways that other activities simply can't.”