Abby Smith Rumsey on Remembering, Forgetting, and When We Are No More
What this covers
Abby Smith Rumsey, a historian and author of When We Are No More, joins Russ Roberts to examine how societies should preserve cultural memory in the digital age. The conversation begins with the Library of Congress's 2010 acquisition of Twitter's entire archive—a seemingly paradoxical choice for an institution devoted to lasting value—and spirals outward to ask what we preserve, why, and who decides. Rumsey argues that memory serves not nostalgia but futurity: humans perform mental time travel across decades and centuries to anticipate what comes next, so losing access to the past cripples our ability to plan and conjecture. Without durable institutional stewardship, commercial incentives alone will erase vast swaths of our era, leaving future generations cursed by our negligence.
The discussion ranges across history's information revolutions, showing that each technology—manuscript, print, digital—produces a chaotic period of information inflation where societies cannot yet judge what is valuable. Rumsey illustrates this through silent film, eighty percent of which vanished because studios saw it as disposable entertainment, only later revealing irreplaceable data about how people dressed, moved, and built their world. She traces the deeper tension: commerce creates culture but lacks incentive to preserve it once profit ends, forcing cultural assets to migrate into museums, libraries, and archives—institutions with longer time horizons than markets. The conversation also addresses why mental time travel itself matters: the heavily marked-up rough draft of the Declaration of Independence teaches us more about democratic negotiation than a polished final text; confronting figures like Isaac Newton on their own terms reveals he was a religious mystic, humbling present certainties. Rumsey contends that the digital era demands reformed infrastructure, rethought copyright, and a moral commitment to giving the next generation at least as much access to the past as we inherited.
Rumsey argues that memory is fundamentally about the future, not the past, and that the digital age—like past information revolutions—requires long-term institutions, deliberate forgetting, and reformed infrastructure to preserve cultural memory that markets have no incentive to keep.
- Human memory's purpose is anticipating the future, so losing access to the past cripples our ability to plan and conjecture forward
- Past information inflations (print, manuscript) show societies are temporarily overwhelmed before learning what is valuable
- Commerce has little incentive to preserve cultural assets, so durable cross-generational institutions are essential
Materialism as philosophical idea, not technical innovation, drove the present information profusion.
- It was not a technical innovation but an idea—the radically transformative notion that the universe and all that exists is no more and no less than the material effect of material causes—that set us on the present course of information profusion.
“It was not a technical innovation that set us on the present course, but an idea. That was the radically transformative idea that the universe and all that exists is no more and no less than the material effect of material causes.”