What this covers

Richard Jones, a physicist at the University of Sheffield, joins Russ Roberts to challenge the dominant transhumanist vision of technological futures. The conversation centers on three grand claims: that human brains can be uploaded into computers, that radical nanotechnology will allow atomically precise manufacturing of matter, and that radical life extension is imminent. Jones contends each rests on a fundamental misreading—of biology, of how innovation actually works, and of what counts as progress. The discussion ranges across the gap between designed vs evolved systems, the difference between Moore's Law as a natural law versus a coordinated social roadmap, and whether technological direction is inevitable or a choice made by people and institutions.

The specifics run deep. Jones argues that computation in biology happens at the molecular scale, not the neuronal one, making the connectome insufficient for brain uploading and placing the complexity orders of magnitude beyond current or near-future synthetic systems. On radical nanotechnology, he contends that mechanical engineering concepts shrunk down fundamentally misunderstand how optimized evolved systems already are for nanoscale physics. Beyond the biological claims, he challenges the notion that technological progress is autonomous: Moore's Law is a self-fulfilling prophecy now ending, productivity has declined since the 1970s, and the major innovations of the late 20th century—from the internet to the accelerometer in the iPhone—trace back to government-commissioned work during wartime and the Cold War. This leads to the political economy of innovation: believing progress is inevitable serves incumbents and discourages deliberate steering toward alternatives. The conversation also touches artificial intelligence as a genuine advancing threat, cryonics as physically implausible, and Eroom's Law—the exponential rise in drug development costs—as a counterexample to the assumption that innovation always accelerates.

Sharpest takeaway

Jones argues that the grandest transhumanist visions—brain uploading, radical nanotechnology, and imminent radical life extension—rest on a misunderstanding of how evolved biological systems work and on a mistaken belief that technological progress is autonomous and inevitable, when in fact it is a contingent, socially constructed, often government-driven process.

  • Biology computes at the molecular, not neuronal, level and is optimized for nanoscale physics, so brain uploading and mechanical nanotech vastly underestimate complexity.
  • Moore's Law is a coordinated social construct, not a natural law, and treating it as inevitable misleads transhumanists.
  • The direction of technology is a choice shaped by political economy and government, so believing progress is inevitable serves incumbents and discourages deliberate steering.

The argument · threads4 threads · 21 claims
0.71

Not all innovation justifies its costs, yet markets ignore externalities and governments measure them poorly in practice.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Just because a technology emerges does not mean it was worth the investment—so-called improvements are not necessarily worth their costs; the private sector worries about whether innovation is worth it but ignores external costs and benefits, while the public sector in theory accounts for both but in practice does so poorly for different reasons.

    “Just because technology emerges doesn't mean it was worth the investment, right? So-called improvements that are made are not necessarily worth it. It depends on the costs.”

  • EconTalk reached its 10th anniversary with this episode.

    “Yesterday was the 10th anniversary of the first EconTalk episode.”

0.70

Emergent systems like markets and biology cannot be engineered or centrally planned, no matter computational power.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • The transhumanist belief that designed nanomachines can outperform 'haphazard' biology parallels the socialist calculation debate's claim that a central planner with a big enough computer could outperform markets—both ignore that the magic of metabolism, like the market, emerges from local interactions without a central controller, and no amount of computing power has let planners match emergent market processes.

    “There is a very close parallel behind the kinds of emergent processes that happen in a cell, where many things happen really determined by local interactions”

0.56

Productivity metrics fail to capture value from digital and free goods as the economy becomes increasingly virtual.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Productivity and GDP measurement, always imperfect, has become less accurate as the world becomes more digital and people inhabit a virtual world; free goods like podcasts deliver value that isn't captured, suggesting measured stagnation may partly reflect a qualitative change in what we consume rather than a real slowdown.

    “it's hard to measure, I think, productivity in this world. We haven't figured that out.”

0.43

Patent and intellectual property systems are increasingly weaponized by incumbents to protect themselves rather than enable progress.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • The patent and intellectual property system, itself a social innovation, is increasingly used to protect incumbents, raising the worry that political influence shapes it so that not all technology should be shared regardless, because some of it is being steered by those who benefit from it.

    “the role of the patent system, intellectual property. Which I worry is increasingly used to protect incumbents.”