What this covers
Marina Krakovsky and Russ Roberts explore why intermediaries persist and thrive in the digital economy, contrary to predictions that the internet would eliminate them through cheap information. Krakovsky, author of The Middleman Economy, identifies six distinct roles middlemen play: bridge (connecting parties), certifier (vouching for quality), enforcer (eliciting effort through repeated interaction), risk-bearer (pooling uncertainty), concierge (matching complex preferences), and insulator (allowing clients to take positions they could not personally assert without damaging their image). The conversation centers on why transaction costs fell more sharply for professional intermediaries than for ordinary consumers, making it rational to hire a middleman even when information is abundant.
The discussion ranges across concrete examples: wedding planners who extract higher effort from vendors through repeat game dynamics; OpenTable solving restaurant no-shows through data aggregation and dispute resolution; appliance resellers providing liquidity by absorbing distressed inventory; publishers bearing portfolio risk that individual authors cannot; and travel agents surviving by solving the matching problem when choice overwhelms decision-makers. A recurring tension surfaces between Krakovsky's argument that genuine value justifies middleman fees and the broader cultural suspicion that intermediaries simply extract rents. The conversation also examines how competitive pressure from machines favors middlemen who create transparent, defensible value—moving experts forward while reducing routine order-takers to minimum wage work. Throughout, the focus stays on the economic mechanics that make intermediation rational rather than on technology hype.
Krakovsky argues that despite predictions the internet would eliminate middlemen, intermediaries are more valuable than ever because they perform distinct value-creating roles—bridge, certifier, enforcer, risk-bearer, concierge, and insulator—that cannot be replicated by direct access to information.
- Transaction costs fell more for professional middlemen than for consumers, so it still pays to use them
- Middlemen leverage long-run reputation and relationships to elicit higher quality (moral hazard) that one-time buyers cannot
- The internet created many new intermediary roles rather than destroying them
No-show costs are embedded in menu prices rather than charged as explicit reservation fees.
- Diners actually do pay for no-shows, but the cost is spread across everybody and hidden in menu prices, because restaurants cannot maximize capacity given some reservations won't show and must cover fixed costs; restaurants don't switch to lower menu prices plus reservation fees largely because most diners value the flexibility to change dining plans, which they exercise far more often than canceling a distant trip.
“we do pay for the no shows. They just get spread across everybody. It's part of the cost of doing business.”
Longer meal duration increases restaurant prices because slower turnover requires higher per-customer cost recovery.
- The longer it takes to eat a meal, the more expensive the restaurant tends to be, because slow table turnover means fewer customers per night, so fixed costs must be recovered from a smaller group, pushing prices higher.
“the longer it takes to eat something, the more expensive is the restaurant, because it takes a longer time for the table to turn over.”
OpenTable reduces transaction costs by consolidating restaurant availability into a single platform.
- OpenTable is a restaurant reservation service that lets diners see availability across many restaurants with a few taps instead of calling restaurants one by one.
“it's a reservation service. To make reservations at a restaurant.”