Pete Geddes on the American Prairie Reserve
What this covers
Pete Geddes and Russ Roberts discuss the American Prairie Reserve, a 3.3 million-acre project in northeastern Montana aimed at restoring the prairie ecosystem that existed when Lewis and Clark crossed the region. The conversation centers on how large-scale wildlife conservation can succeed through a private, nonprofit model rather than federal management. Geddes, the reserve's Managing Director, explains the project's structure and its use of Wild Sky Beef, a for-profit company that pays ranchers premiums for adopting wildlife-friendly practices. The core argument is that [social carrying capacity](jargon:social carrying capacity) for wildlife—not biological limits—is the binding constraint, and that shifting ranchers' incentives from viewing wildlife as a cost to viewing it as an economic benefit is the key to restoring historic abundance.
The discussion ranges across ecological mechanics, economic incentives, and institutional comparison. Roberts and Geddes explore how prairie ecosystems depend on emergent order rather than assembly: the sequence in which species are introduced matters, fire is essential for rejuvenation, and the system cannot simply be constructed from scratch. They contrast the private Private property model with federal park management, criticizing how Political allocation of resources in places like Yellowstone has produced ecological damage—wolves were eliminated to maintain popular elk herds, and maintenance infrastructure deteriorated because upkeep is politically unfavorable. Geddes details practical solutions: Wildlife-friendly fencing designed for pronghorn antelope, which crawl under rather than jump over barriers; a tiered payment system through Wild Sky Beef rewarding increasing wildlife tolerance; and a Soft boundary vs hard boundary approach allowing animals to spill beyond reserve edges rather than being shot. The reserve also navigates regulatory complexity, since bison are classified as domestic cattle but grizzlies and wolves remain state-managed wildlife.
Geddes argues that large-scale wildlife conservation can be achieved through a private, for-profit-supported nonprofit model that realigns local ranchers' incentives--making wildlife an economic benefit rather than a cost--rather than relying on the federal government or traditional national parks.
- Wildlife abundance in the area is limited by social tolerance (sociology), not biology, so changing rancher incentives is the key lever
- A for-profit beef company (Wild Sky Beef) pays ranchers premiums to adopt wildlife-friendly practices, flipping wildlife from cost to benefit
- A private nonprofit model avoids the perverse incentive structures and political allocation problems of federally-run national parks
Restoring prairie heterogeneity and ecological function requires reintroducing bison, fire, and natural animal movement across large seamless landscapes.
- Reintroducing bison creates the heterogeneity that aids emergent order in the prairie because bison move across the landscape and graze completely differently from cattle--with different preferences for individual prairie plants--whereas cattle graze uniformly and create a homogeneous landscape.
“cattle graze things fairly uniformly, and what we're trying to reintroduce is the heterogeneity that comes from having a grazer like a bison which moves across landscape completely different from cattle”
- Fire was a frequent, critically important dynamic force responsible for grass rejuvenation and patchy prairie landscapes; after a controlled burn the bison herd concentrates on the burned area eating new shoots and trampling in their manure, producing a synergistic rejuvenating effect, though it can only be done on a limited scale given neighbors and property rights.
“Two weeks after the burn were on this burned area eating the shoots and sprouts and going poop on the ground and all that and trampling in their feces and manure, so you get this synergistic effect.”
- Pronghorn antelope have the largest land migration in North America, traveling some 400 miles from the Canadian prairie provinces in fall down through the area to southern Montana and northern Wyoming, which is why the project requires such a large land area to accommodate natural movement.
“Pronghorn antelope, just for your listeners, have the largest land migration in North America... a migration of some 400 miles that comes squarely through the land that we have managed.”
- Because 95% of the native prairie in their area still exists and most of the prairie's biomass sits 6 or 7 feet underground (only intensely grazed at the surface), the reserve starts from a far more advantageous position than ecologists trying to grow a prairie from cleared land--the original stock of biomass is still present and just needs heterogeneous grazing restored.
“One very interesting thing about the prairie ecosystem is most of the biomass is 6 or 7 feet underground. So indeed all the stock of the original biomass in our area is still there.”
- By taking down fences across private, leased, and federal lands, the reserve aims to create one seamless 'blended' landscape where animals and people move freely without regard to property boundaries, recreating the great animal migrations that occurred 200 years ago.
“fences go down and animals and people move across it without regard to what property they are on... And it becomes one seamless landscape where you can get some semblance of the great animal migrations that happened about 200 years ago.”
Converting wildlife from a cost into an economic benefit for ranchers is the critical lever for restoring historic wildlife abundance.
- Ranchers in the program receive compensation up front in the form of a beef price premium rather than after-the-fact compensation for predator-killed cattle, which is designed to change the psychology of landowners so they value wildlife on their property rather than fearing it.
“If that mountain lion went and killed one of his cows, we wouldn't pay him compensation for that. They are already getting compensation up front in terms of a premium for their beef that we buy”
- Wild Sky Beef, a for-profit company owned by the reserve, pays neighboring ranchers a premium for cattle raised in wildlife-friendly ways, structured like a frequent-flier tier program where higher tolerance (up to allowing grizzly bears) earns more money, thereby converting wildlife from a cost into an economic benefit for ranchers.
“it's kind of like a frequent flier program at Delta or United. You can be silver, gold, diamond, platinum, medallion, whatever it is. And as you move up that frequent-flier status, that means you are more tolerant of wildlife.”
- The tolerance for increasing wildlife numbers in their area is a sociological phenomenon rather than a biological or ecological one; because ranchers currently view wildlife as a cost (elk damaging fences and alfalfa), the key lever for restoring historic wildlife abundance is flipping rancher incentives so they receive an economic benefit from wildlife.
“The tolerance for increasing wildlife numbers is completely a sociological phenomenon; it has very little to do in our area with biology or ecology. It has everything to do with tolerance, from ranchers, to have wildlife on their land.”
- To flip the cost/benefit dynamic, the reserve negotiates with conflicted landowners by offering to buy their winter hay in exchange for letting elk eat their alfalfa, and uses its growing landowner influence in Fish, Wildlife and Parks meetings to advocate for higher wildlife population targets.
“So, we say, 'So, how about you let those elk eat your alfalfa hay; and we'll buy you hay all winter long?'”
Private nonprofit ownership with willing-seller land acquisition enables faster, more creative conservation action than federal parks or public management.
- A nonprofit entity managed by a board that collaborates with federal agencies but remains a private outfit is a superior alternative to federally-run national parks, because the federal government is unlikely in an era of fiscal constraint and debt to create a 3.5-million-acre reserve, whereas the private model is already proving the concept and the project plans to raise ~$500 million for land plus a ~$125 million endowment to run sustainably.
“having a nonprofit entity which is managed by a board, which has to work very collaboratively with these Federal public agencies, but really is a private outfit strikes me as a fantastic alternative to the national parks.”
- The willing-seller, willing-buyer private property model gives the reserve a high degree of control that allows it to act quickly and creatively--for example reintroducing fire on deeded land to generate landscape heterogeneity--in ways that would be slower or impossible under purely public ownership.
“the private property aspect just allows us to move very quickly and very creatively across a whole host of issues.”
- The seemingly fragmented patchwork of owned and leased land will, over time, invert into a much more blended, contiguous landscape, partly because the reserve will buy disparate outlying properties and later sell them to acquire parcels closer to the core.
“that matrix that you see that looks fragmented, over time is going to invert and you will see it as a much more blended, contiguous landscape.”
- The project aims to be a model showing that meaningful, large-scale conservation can be achieved without waiting for the federal government or lobbying Congress--by combining private entrepreneurship, a business perspective, the right people, and the right landscape--demonstrating that not just postage-stamp parks but vast reserves can be created in the present day.
“you don't need to wait for the Federal government to do things. You don't need to lobby Congress to be able to get these meaningful, not little postage-sized parks, but together with private entrepreneurship and the right people who have a business perspective and can get things done.”
Site selection for large-scale conservation requires affordable land in demographically declining areas with intact native habitat.
- Successful large-scale conservation requires picking sites that meet three conditions: the right habitat conditions, the right demographics (a place losing rather than gaining people), and land that is actually affordable to buy, which is why Northeastern Montana--with under one person per square mile and a decade-by-decade population decline--was chosen over expensive, growing areas like Bozeman.
“you've got to pick places for conservation where: a). you have the right habitat conditions; b). you have the right sociology, the right demographics, I guess, so that it's not a place that is getting an influx of people but rather an outflux of people; and c). where you can actually afford to buy the land.”
- The project's goal is to assemble a complex of land about one and a half times larger than Yellowstone National Park--roughly 3.5 million acres, the size of Connecticut--by buying 500,000 private acres that knit together leased federal and state lands into a single seamless landscape.
“our charge is to try to put together a complex of land that's 3 and a half million acres in size. That will be a mix of private lands that we own outright, of lands that we lease from the Federal Government”
- Much of the land in Northeastern Montana is already in federal public ownership because homesteaders who tried to settle this remote and rugged land in the late 19th and mid-20th century failed, causing the land to revert back to federal and state ownership.
“This is the result of the failure of homesteaders early in mid-20th century. Late 19th, early, mid-20th century they tried to settle this land, which is very remote and rugged. And couldn't. So the land reverted back into the Federal, state.”
- The critical limiting factor for the project is not the availability of land to buy--of which there is no shortage--but the availability of money to buy it with, so the pace of land acquisition is expected to continue without dropping off.
“There's no shortage of land to buy. There's a shortage of money to buy it with. So that's really the critical factor.”
Wildlife-friendly infrastructure and soft boundaries allow animals to move across property lines while accommodating rancher concerns.
- Wildlife-friendly fencing uses smooth wire low to the ground (18 inches) because pronghorn antelope go under fences rather than jumping over them, and a low barbed wire rips up their backs causing infection and can trap them so they starve in winter storms; the top wire is smooth and low (42 inches) so elk and deer can go over.
“on the bottom it has another smooth wire that's 18 inches off the ground, because pronghorn antelope don't jump over fences. They go underneath them. And if you have a low wire that's barbed, it rips up their back, and they are prone to infection.”
- Unlike Yellowstone, which has a hard rectilinear boundary where straying bison and wolves are either hazed back in or shot, the reserve aims for a 'soft boundary' where animals spilling over are met with tolerance from surrounding ranchers, which is what allows wildlife numbers to grow.
“We want a soft boundary. Exactly the opposite of what you get in Yellowstone. So that when those animals do spill over the boundaries, again, they are met with some level of tolerance.”
- The reserve does not own or control the wildlife (other than its bison, which the state classifies as domestic cattle); grizzly bears, wolves, and other animals are the property of the State of Montana and managed by Fish, Wildlife and Parks, so the reserve can only influence numbers indirectly by providing big enough habitat and reducing conflicts with neighbors.
“What's important for your listeners to understand is we do not control those animals. They are the property of the State. And we can't go down to Yellowstone, for example, and load a bunch of wolves, and back the pickup truck and drive them up to our area.”
Hunting and harvest are appropriate conservation tools aligned with Montana culture and state wildlife management.
- Visitor access will be designed in concentric circles of increasing wildness--from a developed central area with amenities, through zones with varying use rules (RV access in some, walk-in only near sensitive nesting birds), to dispersed backcountry recreation--so that, like Yosemite where being 25 miles from the convenience store puts you beyond other people, visitors can find their preferred level of wildness across the vast landscape.
“the way we're thinking about this right now is sort of in concentric circles... And then you go out from these concentric circles and you get into ever more layers of wildness.”
- The reserve's bison herd of 600 is classified by the State of Montana as domestic cattle (not wildlife), which allows the reserve to grow the herd as large as it wants subject to having enough grass, unlike grizzly bears and wolves which are classified and managed by the state as wildlife.
“They are classified by the State of Montana as domestic cattle. So, we can continue to grow that herd as large as we want”
- Hunting is a very important part of Montana culture and is the primary way the state manages wildlife numbers; grizzly bears and wolves on the federal lands the reserve leases will be available for public hunting, which the reserve cannot prevent, and the reserve considers it appropriate to harvest some bison annually as the herd grows.
“in Montana, hunting is a very important part of the culture. It's one way to manage the wildlife numbers: in fact, it's the way the state manages wildlife numbers.”
- Conservation is largely an American phenomenon in which the United States leads the world and provides inspiration, exemplified by Yellowstone becoming the world's first national park in 1872, an idea Ken Burns called one of America's best ideas.
“it's an American thing; conservation is largely an American phenomenon where we lead the world and provide inspiration.”
- The adjacent Fort Belknap Indian Reservation offers a critically important opportunity to engage American Indians, providing economic opportunity to an impoverished area and helping them achieve cultural goals particularly around bison restoration.
“the Fort Belknap Indian Reservation, which butts right up against some of our lands right now. This is another fantastic opportunity to engage the American Indians... particularly vis-a-vis bison restoration.”
Federal land management creates perverse incentives that produce deferred maintenance and political allocation rather than resource responsiveness.
- National parks like Yellowstone face a lack of feedback from their incentive structure because, until recently, most gate fees went back into the Federal Treasury rather than the park, giving little incentive to respond to visitors; resources are allocated politically, producing pathologies like unfixed bathrooms, sewage overflows, and run-down infrastructure since maintenance is not politically favored.
“most user fees or gate fees at Yellowstone went back into the Federal Treasury, so there's very little incentive for Yellowstone to respond to its customers”
- Operating on Federal public lands acts like ballast that works both for and against the project, because an administration hostile to the reserve could not single it out without applying the same treatment across the Bureau of Land Management's ~280 million acres in the lower 48, which makes targeted political attack difficult.
“what you do if, let's say, there were an Administration that were out to get us, per se. Then they'd have to do something similar across the rest of these lands. These Federal public lands like [?] ballast that works for you and against you.”