What this covers

Jesse Ausubel of the Rockefeller University speaks with host Russ Roberts about a counterintuitive trend: rising human population and incomes have not produced a larger environmental footprint, but a smaller one. The conversation traces how decoupling between human welfare and resource use is reshaping land, forests, and wildlife across the globe. Ausubel presents evidence that agricultural yields keep climbing while the acreage devoted to farming stabilizes or shrinks, that forests have been expanding since roughly 1990, and that efficiency gains in transport, water use, and material consumption are freeing natural resources even as billions more people consume more. The thread connecting these domains is technological progress: better seeds, precision agriculture, aquaculture breeding, plantation sylviculture, and the dematerialization of goods from smartphones to transport systems.

The discussion ranges widely across the mechanisms of this shift. Ausubel walks through animals as conversion machines—the efficiency differences that make fish, poultry, and herbivorous species more land-sparing than cattle—and how dietary shifts and waste reduction could free a third to half of global farmland over a century. He explains global greening as both a product of changed demand (wood and newsprint collapsing into digital substitutes, making Jeff Bezos and Steve Jobs accidental forest heroes) and of rising crop productivity. The oceans emerge as a lagging problem: marine governance is weaker than terrestrial, and demand has "democratized" faster than supply can sustain. On climate, Ausubel offers cautious optimism—distinguishing between whether warming acts as a dial (gradual, manageable) or a switch (abrupt, potentially catastrophic)—and predicts that emissions may plateau around 450–500 ppm rather than reach the higher catastrophic scenarios, if efficiency trends hold. The conversation also confronts harder questions: whether leapfrogging technologies like autonomous vehicles and automated farming will create enough new work to replace the jobs they displace.

Sharpest takeaway

Ausubel argues that technology is decoupling human welfare from environmental footprint—rising agricultural yields, dematerialization, and shifting demand are freeing land and allowing nature to rebound, making peak human disturbance of the terrestrial landscape plausibly behind us.

  • Crop yields keep rising while inputs (land, water, fertilizer) stabilize or fall, decoupling production from acreage
  • Demand-side collapse for wood products plus plantation forestry has produced global greening since ~1990
  • Efficiency gains in transport, water, and materials spare natural resources even as population and incomes rise

The argument · threads7 threads · 30 claims
0.85

Decoupling crop yields from land use through agricultural innovation frees land for nature while feeding larger populations.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Until about 1940 corn acreage advanced in tandem with production, but since then land used for corn has stabilized or shrunk while yields rose by a factor of 4 to 5, decoupling acreage from production and freeing land for nature.

    “around 1940, the land used for corn stabilized or even started to shrink a bit. But the corn yields, the corn production kept going up and up and up. And it's gone up by a factor of 4 or almost 5 times since 1940, with the same land”

  • Agricultural innovation (precision agriculture, better seeds, better weather forecasts) keeps pushing crop yields up even as inputs like fertilizer, pesticides, herbicides, water, and land are stabilized or reduced, meaning more protein and calories can be produced for a larger population using less land and water.

    “yields keep rising... we've stabilized or even reduced a bit some of the inputs, like fertilizers and pesticides and herbicides and water. But weather forecasts have gotten better, and we have better seeds”

  • The US wood products industry has shifted to the faster-growing Southeast and toward plantation forestry (about 20% of US forestry), where fast-growing varieties on 15-20 year rotations yield 2-4 times more wood per hectare than unmanaged forests maturing over 50-100 years, so the same wood is produced from less logged land.

    “you can introduce varieties that grow very quickly... they may be on a rotation of let's say 15 or 20 years, whereas trees in unmanaged forests may take 50 or 60 or 100 years to mature”

  • Over the last 20-25 years the continents have been getting greener, not browner—a phenomenon termed 'global greening'—driven by top-down factors (rising atmospheric CO2 acting as plant food, longer Northern Hemisphere growing seasons, more nitrogen, increased rainfall in places like the Sahel) and bottom-up factors (changing demand for wood, rising crop yields), with the biosphere growing by roughly 1-2 billion tons a year.

    “over the last 20, 25 years, a growing group of us are convinced and publishing papers about a phenomenon we're calling global greening--that on land, in fact... the continents are getting greener”

  • About a third of food produced in the world is wasted—in rich countries through purchase and disposal, in poor countries through field rot and poor storage—so that diet change, fuel substitution, and waste reduction together could release a third to half of the world's agricultural land back to nature over the next century.

    “about a third of the food produced in the world is wasted. It doesn't go onto our plates or into our stomachs”

  • In 2014 a Georgia farmer named Randy Dowdy grew over 500 bushels of corn per acre—enough to feed a couple hundred people for a year and 3-4 times the average Iowa yield and 6-8 times the world average—demonstrating enormous remaining headroom for yield improvement.

    “Last year a farmer in Georgia named Randy Dowdy grew over 500 bushels an acre... it's 3 or 4 times what the average Iowa grower does and 6 to 8 times what the average world grower does”

0.66

Dietary shifts toward more efficient protein sources like poultry and aquaculture spare land while maintaining nutrition and returning habitat.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Animals can be viewed as machines for converting feed into meat, and they differ greatly in efficiency: cattle yield roughly the equivalent of 12 miles per gallon, pigs 40, chickens 60, and fish around 80, so the dietary shift toward poultry and aquaculture is driven by producer economics and faster returns as much as by health, and freeing land for nature.

    “if you feed a steer some corn, you are getting, in automotive terms, say, 12 miles to the gallon. You're a pig, maybe 40 miles to the gallon. But a chicken is 60 miles to the gallon”

  • As land is freed from agriculture, vegetation returns first—bushes then trees—and wildlife follows, so that the United States now has rebounding populations of deer, wild turkeys, bobcats, mountain lions and bears, with New Jersey supporting roughly 2,500 bears and an annual hunt that culls 400-500.

    “the trees come first. Or, you know, maybe some bushes and then some trees. But animals follow. Wildlife... New Jersey has something like 2500 bears”

  • Aquaculture of filter feeders (clams, oysters) and herbivorous fish (catfish, tilapia) is efficient, but farming carnivorous species like tuna and salmon by grinding up wild anchovies, herring, or menhaden to feed them creates no net benefit; the solution is to train carnivorous fish to accept plant-based feed, which has already been done in some cases.

    “some of those popular ocean meats like tuna and salmon, those animals are carnivores. And so we catch anchovies or herring or menhaden and grind them up and feed those to the salmon... that doesn't create a net benefit. So we need to teach the salmon to eat tofu”

  • The shift to a carnivorous diet and certain kinds of cooking over thousands of years enabled humanity to develop a smaller, more compact digestive system and a larger brain, unlike ruminants that need long stomachs to digest grass, making meat an important and natural part of human evolutionary history.

    “it was the shift to a carnivorous diet and certain kinds of cooking that over thousands of years enabled humanity to sort of change its shape and have the smaller, compact digestive system that we do and the bigger brain”

  • Rather than requiring a radical shift to vegetarianism, high agricultural yields are the best friend of nature because they let humanity afford some meat while still sparing land, supporting a gradual evolution toward a 'Mediterranean diet' where calories come mainly from grains and meat or fish is used for flavor.

    “it's really high yields that are the best friend of nature. And if we have high yields, I'd say, humanity can afford to produce meat, some meat, for those who want it”

0.56

Efficiency gains in transportation and shifting to shared autonomous vehicles dramatically reduce resource inputs and material demand.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Improving vehicle efficiency (fuel cells, electric, compressed natural gas, and even improved internal combustion engines reaching 60-75 mpg) plus changing driving habits could make transport 2-3 times more efficient over decades, and petroleum demand in the US, Japan, Korea and many countries has already been flat for some time—only partly explained by recession.

    “petroleum demand in the United States and Japan and Korea and many, many countries has been flat for quite a long time now. Partly it may be economic recession. But partly I think it is also these changes starting to nibble away”

  • Because the average motor vehicle is used only about an hour a day, autonomous GPS-guided shared taxis used even 2-4 hours a day would let society need far fewer vehicles, reducing congestion, road wear, lost-driving miles, and the glass, rubber, and oil inputs of the car system—especially if developing nations like China and India leapfrog directly to such a system.

    “The average car... the average motor vehicle in America and around the world--is only used about an hour a day... Suppose they were just used 2 or 3 or 4 hours a day... We would need many, many fewer motor vehicles”

  • The same technological trends that spare natural resources—drones, autonomous taxis, farming without farmers—also spare human labor, raising the deep open question of whether there will be enough jobs in information handling to preserve people's social status and income.

    “the sparing of natural resources, the drones, all of this goes hand in hand with sparing of labor... the question of what people will do--will there be enough jobs in information handling to keep people's social status as well as their income--that's a very, very big question”

0.56

Global forests and vegetation are expanding while ocean fish stocks face depletion requiring both supply and demand solutions.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Solving ocean depletion requires addressing both supply and demand—educating consumers toward responsible choices while providing economical farmed substitutes—because reprimanding alone fails like 'Just Say No,' supported by technologies such as DNA identification and chain-of-custody tracking to combat seafood fraud.

    “we need to address both the supply and the demand. So we need to help educate people about what are more responsible things to eat. But we also have to provide economical substitutes”

  • Since about 1990, worldwide forests have been increasing rather than shrinking—both in area and in wood volume per existing forest—as a global average, even though some regions like Indonesia and central Africa still suffer tragic deforestation.

    “since about 1990, worldwide, forests are actually getting larger again, not getting smaller. There's more area of forest and more wood in the forests that exist”

  • The oceans are roughly a hundred years behind the land in conservation because natural ocean productivity has plateaued while demand has exploded ('the democratization of sushi'), and weak enforcement of marine governance even within exclusive economic zones allows continued depletion of wild sea life.

    “The oceans are a hundred years behind the land... the democratization of sushi is the greatest problem of the oceans. When only the Emperor of Japan ate sushi, it wasn't a bit problem. But now a billion people want to eat sushi”

0.39

Modern agriculture combines advanced science and technology with craft expertise, making it a dynamic sector contrary to backward perceptions.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Contrary to the common perception of agriculture as a backward sector, modern farming combines deep craft with advanced technology and science—the cab of a tractor resembling a Wall Street trading desk—making it an extremely dynamic sector.

    “Most people tend to think of it as somehow a backward sector--you know, brown collars; but if you spend a little time with growers today, you find that agriculture... there's a lot of technology and science as well. And it's an extremely dynamic sector”

  • The optimal wood products industry may not be entirely plantation-based but rather a mix of heavily managed forests and less-managed forests, because thinning and culling wild forests reduces forest fire risk, allows new growth, and maintains habitat for certain birds and animals.

    “the optimal wood products industry might not be completely concentrated in sylviculture. It might well be a mix of the two. There are reasons to thin and cull the less managed forests to reduce risks of forest fires”

  • Only about one in ten ears of corn grown in America is eaten directly by humans; almost half is now turned into ethanol to power cars, with much of the rest fed to animals—a policy Ausubel and Roberts consider an environmental and economic mistake that, if reversed, would free more land for nature.

    “Only about 1 out of 10 ears of corn that we grow in America is fed directly to an American as creamed corn or popcorn or corn on the cob. Almost half of it is now being turned into--liquor, I'll say, to power cars”

  • Just as technology improves semiconductors, human performance enhancement technologies will become stronger and stronger, raising a profound identity question—'Who is the real me?'—as exemplified by figures like Lance Armstrong who showed such enhancements work.

    “human performance enhancement. There are a whole set of technologies that--I don't think you can only get better at semiconductors and not get better at a bunch of other things. And we saw Lance Armstrong, and they work”

  • The key unknown about climate change is whether it behaves like a 'dial'—where cities gradually shift to slightly warmer climates that no one ultimately minds—or a 'switch'—where a place jumps to a radically different climate, with the latter being far more worrying and possibly unknowable rather than merely unknown.

    “that leaves wide open whether climate change is a dial or a switch. If it's a dial, so that New York ends up with the climate of Philadelphia... no one's really in the end going to care a lot. On the other hand, if... New York ends up with the climate of Galveston, then obviously that's a lot more to worry about”

0.38

Digital substitution and information technology replace material-intensive physical goods, reducing natural resource extraction.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The 21st century may be a period in which information and capital become the truly important resources while natural resources—water, energy, land, materials, and labor—are spared, exemplified by the smartphone replacing a boom box, alarm clock, camera and many other plastic-and-metal devices.

    “we may actually be entering into a period in which information, and I'll say capital, are extremely important. Those are the really important resources. And the natural resources--water, energy, land, materials, and as you said, labor--are spared”

  • The collapse of demand for traditional wood products—railroad ties, telephone poles, newsprint, and first-class mail (down a quarter in five years) due to digital substitution—means that even efficiently grown wood faces soft demand, making figures like Jeff Bezos and Steve Jobs effective 'heroes of the forests.'

    “with e-books and email, the demand for paper, for newsprint or for paper for first class letters and so forth, is collapsing. So the number of first class letters in the United States dropped by about a quarter in 5 years recently”

0.38

Climate emissions are moderating as efficiency gains spread, likely plateauing atmospheric CO2 well below catastrophic scenarios.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Climate emissions are moderating—US and European emissions have probably peaked and Chinese and Indian emissions will likely peak in 10-20 years—so rather than reaching the frightening 600-900 ppm scenarios, atmospheric CO2 will probably plateau around 450-500 ppm if efficiency continues to win across domains of life.

    “U.S. emissions have probably peaked; European emissions have probably peaked. And I think that the Chinese and Indian emissions will also peak in another 10, 20 years... I think will probably plateau there”

  • American water withdrawals have been falling and are now as low as they were in the 1960s, because farmers and power plants are using water more efficiently—contrary to the impression created by events like the California drought.

    “Water use in America actually now is lower--is as low as it was in the 1960s... American water withdrawals... they've been falling, because farmers are using water more efficiently, power plants are using water more efficiently”