What this covers

Rachel Laudan, a historian of food and author of Cuisine and Empire, sits down with Russ Roberts to trace how food systems, cuisines, and eating habits have shaped human history. The conversation ranges across millennia, examining the role of grain in civilization, the emergence of French cooking as a global standard, and the modern industrialized food system's place in human progress. Laudan's central argument is historical and economic: the modern food system, including processing, represents a genuine human achievement that freed ordinary people from the scarcity and drudgery that once governed their diets. She contests the Golden Age Myth embedded in the locavore movement, arguing it misrepresents the past and, if applied to development policy, would harm the poor today.

The conversation moves through several overlapping territories. It traces how Invented Tradition shapes our sense of food heritage—the French baguette, English fish and chips, Greek moussaka—most created within the past two centuries rather than descending from ancient custom. It examines how Culinary Hierarchy Theory once justified aristocratic diets by claiming elites had different digestive capacities than commoners, a physiological claim abolished only by modern middling cuisine, where everyone can eat the same food. The discussion covers grain's unique role in history, the mechanics of cooking as Outsourcing Digestion, and how potatoes and other crops required centuries of selective breeding to become palatable. A later section examines Food of Aspiration through McDonald's and instant ramen—how processed, affordable foods reach aspiring consumers worldwide—before concluding with Laudan's critique of Romantic Naturalism: that the movement's ideal of fresh, local, unprocessed food, while emotionally appealing, rests on ignoring both the historical labor involved and the economic logic of specialization and trade.

Sharpest takeaway

Laudan argues that the modern industrialized food system—including processing—is one of humanity's great triumphs, and that the Romantic 'fresh, local, natural, slow' food movement rests on a historically false golden-age myth that, if imposed on others, would re-condemn people to the scarcity and drudgery their ancestors escaped.

  • For most of history, food was governed by hierarchical cuisines that physiologically justified different diets for elites versus the masses, and choice was essentially nil.
  • Processing—not just farming—is central to making nutritious food accessible, yet the food movement dismisses it.
  • Many supposedly ancient 'traditional' national dishes were actually invented in the last 30-200 years.

The argument · threads3 threads · 29 claims
0.85

Self-sufficiency ideology rejects the economic gains from specialization and trade.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • The Romantic locavore ideal of self-sufficiency is internally inconsistent and economically impoverishing—analogous to building your own roof but still buying the hammer—because true self-sufficiency forgoes the gains from specialization and trade; self-sufficiency is the road to poverty.

    “It's the equivalent of saying, 'I want to be self-sufficient, so I'm going to do my own roof.' But are you going to make your own hammer? No. You are going to buy a hammer. You are going to cheat. So you are really not self-sufficient--because self-sufficiency is the road to poverty.”

0.71

Food abundance is a human achievement undermined by subsidies that distort agricultural markets.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • While the inexpensive availability of first-rate food is a triumph of human ingenuity to be celebrated, government subsidies in the U.S. and many other countries—favoring particular farmers and crops such as corn producers, and extending into processing—distort that achievement and leave plenty of room for improvement.

    “I do think that we have privileged some corporate players in ways that are really bad. The subsidies in the U.S. system... that privilege farmers and increase their profits, that favor, say, corn producers [?] all subsidies, etc.--that overlays the human creativity that I praised earlier.”

0.30

Historical food crops transformed radically through selective cultivation over centuries.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • The potato first introduced to Europe in the early 18th century was bitter and nothing like the modern Idaho baked potato.

    “was bitter, and nothing like the Idaho baked potato that we might envision at a potato bar.”