What this covers

Wences Casares, founder and CEO of Xapo and a longtime bitcoin proponent, discusses with Russ Roberts what makes bitcoin revolutionary and how his company addresses its most pressing practical problem. The conversation centers on three properties Casares argues make bitcoin superior to existing stores of value: it is controlled by no single entity, it has Absolute Scarcity fixed at 21 million units, and it can be transferred instantly and free across the globe. Casares contends that Emergent Value as Social Consensus sustains bitcoin's worth much as it does gold's, and that despite present volatility, bitcoin's absolute scarcity makes it orders of magnitude better than gold as a long-term store of value. Roberts and Casares explore the mechanics of mining, the lottery-like process by which new bitcoins enter circulation, and why Satoshi Nakamoto's decision to remain anonymous strengthens the system's Fatherless System Robustness.

The interview then pivots to the practical. A private key—a 64-character piece of code—is itself digital money, not a pointer to it elsewhere, which creates acute security risks and makes Custody vs Ownership a central problem. Xapo functions as a custodian rather than a bank, safekeeping deposited bitcoin in offline vaults distributed across five continents, including a military bunker in the Swiss Alps, with internal controls preventing even rogue employees from stealing keys. Casares argues the system's Trustless System design eliminates counterparty risk that traditional institutions carry, while noting that self-custody is irresponsible for most users. The discussion also covers divisibility, irreversibility of transactions, and the contrast between Store of Value vs Medium of Exchange—Casares forecasts bitcoin will first establish itself as a store of value among the unbanked before becoming a widely used payment mechanism.

Sharpest takeaway

Casares argues bitcoin's revolutionary power lies in three properties—no one controls it, absolute scarcity (21 million cap), and free real-time transfer—which together make it the best store of value ever created, especially for the unbanked, even if it remains highly volatile and could still fail.

  • Bitcoin's value is a social/'magical' emergent consensus, not intrinsic, just like gold's
  • Its absolute scarcity makes it superior to gold as a long-run store of value
  • Custody of private keys is the central practical problem, which Xapo solves via extreme physical security

The argument · threads7 threads · 31 claims
0.68

Bitcoin's three combined properties—distributed control, mathematical scarcity, and trustless transfer—make it fundamentally superior to all prior forms of money.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Bitcoin is revolutionary because of three combined properties: nobody controls it (it is fully distributed and unalterable), it is absolutely scarce (there will never be more than 21 million bitcoins, verifiable by mathematics rather than trust), and it can be sent to anybody anywhere in real time for free without a trusted third party—together making it the best form of money ever seen.

    “There are only 3 things that matter with Bitcoin and that make it revolutionary. Those three things are, number one: Nobody controls Bitcoin... Number two is that there will never be more than 21 million bitcoins... And the third and last point that makes Bitcoin unique is that if I own some bitcoin, I am free to send those bitcoins to anybody, anywhere in the world, in real time and for free.”

  • The fear that 21 million bitcoins are too few is mistaken, because each bitcoin is divisible into 100 million Satoshis (and 1 million bits), so the unit can be subdivided as far as needed without ever changing the value—divisibility, not unit count, accommodates any transaction size.

    “You don't, because there's actually 21 million bitcoins, there's actually 21--zillion--Satoshis.”

  • Because the supply of bitcoin is fixed at 21 million while gold is still mined (~2% per year) and dollars/pesos are continually printed, whatever percentage of total bitcoin you hold today you will still hold 300 years from now—making bitcoin, in theory, an orders-of-magnitude superior store of value to gold, despite its current high volatility.

    “With bitcoin, whatever percentage of 21 million you have today will be the same percentage 300 years from now. We cannot say that of anything else that I know.”

  • Any currency performs two distinct functions—storing value (saving) and paying (transactions)—and gold has been by far the best store of value ever (orders of magnitude better than any currency), with land a distant second, purely because gold is the most scarce.

    “Any form of currency performs two functions--two very different functions. Currencies are used for saving and currencies are used for paying.”

0.51

Mining's lottery mechanism elegantly solved currency launch and ensures trustless security by distributing power and reward widely across the network.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Mining brilliantly solved the chicken-and-egg problem of launching a new currency: rather than arbitrarily deciding who owns the initial supply (which nobody trusts), the mining process allocates new coins gradually and widely over time to people who provide something useful to the network, producing legitimate, distributed ownership.

    “this mining process was a brilliant process to allocate it over time. But-- ... [?] something that was very useful to a network and very widely distributed. So, that was very, very powerful.”

  • Who adds the next block (every ~10 minutes) and earns the reward (then 25 bitcoin) is decided by a lottery in which tickets are issued in proportion to processing power (hashes per second); this design brilliantly guarantees abundant processing power will serve the network and makes the system trustless because no single person or company can amass enough power to take it over.

    “who gets to add the next block and therefore who gets the 25 bitcoins, is decided by a lottery. So, you want to buy tickets to the lottery. And the only way to buy--the tickets to the lottery are issued against processing power.”

  • If you combined all the laptops, desktops, and computers in the world and set them to mine bitcoin, they would not have as much processing power as the current bitcoin mining network.

    “If you get all the Mac Airs in the world and all of the laptops in the world and all of the desktops in the world, all of the computers in the world, and you put them to mine bitcoins, they will not mine as much--they won't have as much processing power--as the current bitcoin mine.”

0.51

Bitcoin will succeed as a store of value first, then as a payment mechanism once adoption exceeds 200 million users, driven by emerging markets and organic growth.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Unlike Americans and Europeans who focus on bitcoin as a payment mechanism (because they already have good ones), bitcoin is actually developing in the reverse order—first as a store of value—and once more than ~200 million people own it (more than have bank accounts), it will be impossible to prevent its use as a payment mechanism.

    “Bitcoin is developing the other way around. It's first a good [?] creator store of value. Eventually it will be a great [?].”

  • Bitcoin will change the world more than the Internet did, eventually bringing 4 to 5 billion people better access to money, though it may take 10 or 20 years to become established.

    “I think that Bitcoin is going to change the world more than the Internet.”

  • Bitcoin will be successful when more than 200 million people own it, and the most likely path there is a 'boring' organic one with no killer app—just as it grew from 0 to 13 million owners in six years without one—supplemented by emerging-market demand and uses like online gaming among young people.

    “I think it would be successful when we see more than 200 million people owning bitcoin.”

0.48

Bitcoin gives the world's poor and citizens of failing currencies an escape from government financial exploitation and cash's inherent costs and risks.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • In Argentina, the government effectively exploited the poor through currency debasement because they had no alternative to holding pesos; if anyone with a cellphone has a bitcoin alternative, it forces governments to be more responsible with their currency to retain holders.

    “basically the government was taking advantage of the poor, who didn't have an alternative... If now anyone with a cell phone has an alternative, it will force those countries to be more responsible with their currency.”

  • Living on cash is expensive and risky for the world's poor—cash is costly to keep, transport, and pay with, requires slow physical transport that raises theft risk, and when currencies fail the poor suffer most because, unlike the rich, they cannot move their assets; bitcoin gives anyone with a cellphone an alternative store of value and entry to the digital economy.

    “It's ridiculous[?] but it's very expensive to be poor. And it's very expensive to live on cash. And then, when there are problems with a currency like I saw growing up in Argentina, that poor get the worst end of that trade whereas the rich can move their assets somewhere but the poor can't.”

0.44

Xapo's vault infrastructure and credentialed investors demonstrate institutional-grade custody without traditional banking's balance-sheet risks.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Xapo's credibility is signaled by large clients holding over $50 million in bitcoin who conduct rigorous financial, legal, and security due diligence; by top Silicon Valley investors (Benchmark, Reid Hoffman, Index Ventures, Fortress); and by an advisory board including VISA founder Dee Hock, former Citibank chairman John Reed, and former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers.

    “Our Board of Advisers is composed of Dee Hock, who was the founder of VISA, John Reed, who was the Chairman of Citibank, and Larry Summers, who was the Secretary of the Treasury.”

  • Xapo functions like a bitcoin bank but differs crucially from a regular bank: deposited bitcoin is not on Xapo's balance sheet and Xapo does not own or use it—Xapo merely safekeeps it, like a parking garage where the structure is theirs but the car remains yours and cannot be used, leased, or sold by them.

    “When you give us $100 bitcoin, it's very, very different in that that is not in our balance sheet. We do not own it. We just safekeep those bitcoin for you.”

  • Xapo secures private keys on offline servers that have never been and will never be online (preventing fingerprinting), housed in deep-underground vaults—the main one in a military bunker in the Swiss Alps—with keys distributed across five continents, so stealing a key would require physically breaking into bunkers and vaults on three different continents simultaneously, plus internal controls preventing even colluding rogue employees from absconding.

    “we keep the private keys of the bitcoin that we do custody for in outlying servers. These outlying servers have never been online and will never be online.”

  • Although Xapo's physical security infrastructure is very expensive to build, it is cheap to run because the cost is the same whether processing one transaction or a hundred million per day—the marginal cost per transaction is close to zero, so per-transaction costs fall over time.

    “Whether we process one transaction a day or a hundred million transactions a day, the cost is the same--meaning the marginal transactions cost is close to zero.”

  • Xapo provides bitcoin storage and transfers for free and always will, earning money instead by charging 1% when customers ask it to buy or sell bitcoin and by issuing a debit card—free to the user—that earns Xapo a margin each time it is used.

    “We make money when people ask us to buy bitcoin for them. We charge them 1%. When people ask us to sell bitcoin for them, we charge 1%. And we issue a debit card that can be used anywhere credit cards are accepted.”

0.44

Satoshi's disappearance was deliberate design ensuring the protocol remains robust and trustworthy independent of any founder's reputation or ideology.

9 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Satoshi disappeared because a system without a known creator is far more robust than one with a 'father'—when a single person is associated with a technology (like Julian Assange with Wikileaks), people's trust gets entangled with their feelings about that person, whereas a fatherless protocol like TCP/IP commands trust impersonally; Satoshi consistently chose robustness over efficiency, even to a ridiculous degree.

    “a system with a father is, I think, Wikileaks, it's a lot less robust than a system without a father. I think TCP/IP.”

  • The Mt. Gox collapse, in which nearly a million customer bitcoins were lost forever, was a failure of the company (through theft or fraud) in protecting private keys—not a flaw in bitcoin itself—and it created immense awareness of how important private-key security is.

    “In the Mt. Gox story, there was nothing wrong with bitcoin itself. It was things that went wrong because Mt. Gox did them wrong.”

  • Because spending bitcoin requires its private key and a forgotten or lost key permanently locks those coins, bitcoin lost through forgotten keys or owners' deaths is gone forever, meaning the effective circulating supply will end up below 21 million.

    “Because some will be dissipated through--God forbid, I'm run over by a car or--then there's no estate to be--it's gone. Totally gone.”

  • Casares felt his first bitcoin transaction was like witnessing the beginning of the Internet—a sense that it would change the world forever.

    “I felt like I was witnessing the beginning of the Internet, that kind of fascination.”

  • Because there is a nontrivial chance (maybe more than 20%) bitcoin fails and goes to zero, no one should own more than they can afford to lose; but because Casares believes there is more than a 50% chance it succeeds and that one bitcoin will exceed $1 million within 10 years, it is also silly not to own a little—placing about 1% of savings in bitcoin is an asymmetric bet where the downside is capped at 1% but the upside could be many times one's entire savings.

    “I think there's a nontrivial chance, maybe more than 20% that Bitcoin fails: in which case it's value will go to zero. So, nobody should own any amount of bitcoin they cannot afford to lose.”

  • Bitcoin payments are irreversible like cash—once sent, there is no chargeback recourse against an anonymous seller as there would be with PayPal or Visa—so buyers protect themselves by transacting with trusted, reputable merchants or by relying on reputational/review mechanisms in marketplaces.

    “In this case, you cannot do that with bitcoin. It's like paying with cash.”

  • Bitcoin was designed as private money for individuals, not as a country's national currency; a rational individual prefers a currency that appreciates, but a country adopting bitcoin would be 'suicide' because it surrenders all ability to control its currency and its appreciation would make domestic wages uncompetitive—instead bitcoin is positioned to become the native currency of the Internet and a global meta-currency for cross-border trade.

    “Bitcoin was not designed to be the currency of a country. It was designed to be private money, of private individuals, by individuals for individuals.”

  • Safekeeping private keys requires significant know-how and expertise, so for most people self-custody is irresponsible—like keeping all your savings under the mattress—because keys can be lost, stolen, or broken into; hence most people are better served letting a specialized third party handle security.

    “I do not trust my mom to keep her private key safe. That requires quite a lot of know-how and expertise.”

  • Bitcoin is not truly anonymous but 'selvonymous'/pseudonymous: anyone can read the blockchain and see that one address sent coins to another, but the blockchain does not record which real person owns each address, so identities are hidden only insofar as you don't reveal your address.

    “someone will go to a blockchain and will see that one address that belongs to me... they will see that one address gave another address 100 bitcoin. That's all they'll see. They don't know that one address is... Russ. Anonymous would be that they can't see any of this.”

0.38

Bitcoin's value emerged from pure social consensus around late 2011, a magical transition that cannot be technically recreated and distinguishes it from failed alternatives.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Bitcoin has zero intrinsic value—its value (~$292 at the time) is purely a social consensus that something is worth something; this 'magical' transition from no value to value happened around late 2011 and is, like the emergence of life on Earth, something we cannot deliberately recreate technically or financially, which is why most competing currencies never acquire real value.

    “The value of Bitcoin is not technology, not financial, not regulatory. It's magical. Just people deciding that something has value.”

  • A bitcoin private key is the first time in computing history that a digital piece of information (64 characters) is itself money rather than merely pointing to cash held elsewhere—it is real digital cash, which creates strong incentives for theft and makes securing keys critically important.

    “this is the first time ever in the history of computers that you have a digital piece of information, 64 characters, that are worth money. ... It is money.”

  • Gold, like diamonds, has essentially no intrinsic value—all gold above ground is worth about $8 trillion despite almost nobody accepting it as payment, making it a purely sterile store of value sustained entirely by social convention, which parallels bitcoin's nature.

    “all the gold above ground is worth about $8 trillion dollars, and nobody accepts gold for anything. It's purely a sterile value.”