What this covers

James Tooley, Professor of Education at Newcastle University, sits down with Russ Roberts to present a sustained argument about education in poor countries that challenges conventional development wisdom. Tooley's central claim rests on empirical findings: census work across slums and rural areas in India, sub-Saharan Africa, and rural China reveals that a majority of poor children (65–75% in urban areas, around 30% in rural ones) already attend low-cost private schools charging roughly one dollar per month. Testing approximately 35,000 children and controlling for background variables like family wealth and parental education shows these private pupils outperforming their government-school peers—a gap that persists even after accounting for observable differences in family circumstances. The conversation builds from this empirical base toward a political argument: that poor parents, through their own choices, have orchestrated what Tooley calls a grassroots "privatization by the people," a phenomenon that policymakers, aid organizations, and education experts have systematically overlooked or dismissed.

The discussion moves through the mechanisms sustaining this pattern. Tooley argues that profit and parental fees create accountability absent in unionized public systems: teachers get fired for chronic absence or poor performance because parents withdraw their children when standards slip, and schools lose revenue. By contrast, in government schools with social distance between teachers and poor pupils, and protected tenured employment, absenteeism runs rampant and principals report powerlessness to remove underperforming staff. Roberts raises the countervailing concern of selection bias—that unmeasurable traits like parental drive confound the comparison—while Tooley contends that poor, often illiterate parents judge school quality through practical proxies: whether children speak English confidently, whether teachers mark homework, classroom discipline. The conversation closes on whether public schooling should remain the ideal in poor countries, with Tooley sketching how competition as a discovery process allows private schools to adopt methods (like phonics instruction) that gain pupils and profits, while the government system stagnates. Roberts and Tooley also consider whether aid strategies—grants versus loans—might preserve the skin in the game feedback that keeps schools accountable.

Sharpest takeaway

Tooley argues that low-cost for-profit private schools have emerged organically across the world's poorest slums and rural areas, outperform free government schools because market feedback loops enforce accountability, and represent a grassroots 'privatization by the people' that aid experts wrongly dismiss or refuse to see.

  • Field censuses found the majority of poor children (65-75% urban) already attend private schools they pay for
  • Controlled testing of 35,000 children shows private-school pupils outperform government-school pupils after adjusting for background
  • Profit and parental fees create feedback loops (teachers get fired for not showing up) absent in unionized public systems

The argument · threads7 threads · 31 claims
0.85

Empirical evidence shows low-cost private schools are widespread, affordable, and produce better learning outcomes than government schools.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Despite experts insisting they could not exist because poor people cannot afford them, low-cost private schools charging around $1/month are widespread across slums and rural areas of poor countries, found everywhere from India and sub-Saharan Africa to rural China.

    “I wandered down into the slums of the Old City; and sure enough--I had a hunch about what I might find, and I found a private school. A school, charging in those days what would be the equivalent of $1 U.S. dollar per month, serving a hundred children.”

  • Census surveys repeatedly found the majority of school children in poor urban areas attend low-cost private schools—typically 65% to 75%—and around 30% in rural areas, demonstrating this is not a minority novelty but a dominant pattern.

    “the majority of school children were in these local, private schools. And that majority could be anywhere from 65% to 75%. So, very significant numbers. This was in the urban areas. In the rural areas we looked at it was typically around 30%.”

  • Testing roughly 35,000 children in math, English and another subject, and controlling scientifically for background variables like family socioeconomic status, maternal education and wealth proxies (TV or radio ownership), shows children in private schools categorically outperform government-school children—so the gap is not merely brighter or wealthier pupils self-selecting.

    “we've tested about 35,000 children, now, in these different communities around the world... we've controlled for all the relevant background variables... And we've been able to show quite categorically that the children in the private schools outperform those in the government schools, after controlling for all those effects.”

  • Low-cost private schools are affordable for families on or below the poverty line, demonstrated by showing that even sending all their children costs no more than 10% of family income, and schools further offer scholarships and discounts for large or very poor families.

    “take a family on the poverty line or even below the poverty line and show that many of these low-cost private schools are affordable to them, even if they are sending all their children to them, as long as they are not spending more than 10% of their family income”

  • In the poorest slums of Liberia such as West Point in Monrovia, 71% of children attend private schools, only 8% attend government schools, and 21% are out of school—evidence that poor parents overwhelmingly vote with their feet for private education.

    “In those slums, 71% of the children go to private schools. Seventy-one percent. Only 8% of them are going to government schools, and 21% are out of school.”

0.79

Market accountability through parent payment enforces teacher quality and student learning better than government employment.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Profit in low-cost private schools is not a dirty word but a mechanism of accountability: the entrepreneur monitors whether teachers turn up and whether children learn because parents will withdraw children and reduce profit if standards slip, so profit-seeking enforces high standards.

    “all these things--profit, what does it mean? Well, it's not a dirty word. It means accountability. It means checking up on teachers, making sure they turn up. It means accountability to parents, making sure the children are learning.”

  • The feedback loop works because parents pay and thus have skin in the game; giving money or schooling away free—as in the American school system or in voucher programs that pay schools directly without giving parents the vouchers—breaks the link and will cause schools to deteriorate.

    “there's some projects... where outside agencies with lots of money create voucher programs. But they don't even give the parents the vouchers. They bring in the money straight; they count the children and give the money straight to the school. That link is broken. My guess is very quickly... those schools will deteriorate.”

  • In private schools bad teachers who are consistently absent or don't show up are fired and everyone understands this, while heavily unionized public-school teachers are almost impossible to fire—at best a principal can move a problem teacher elsewhere—removing any incentive to perform.

    “in the public schools the teachers are so heavily unionized, they don't--it is almost impossible to fire a teacher there. At best you might be able to move a teacher somewhere else, and make it, him or her, someone else's problem.”

  • Throwing money, trainers and consultants at the public system fails because there is no incentive for improvement to reach the school level, whereas in the private sector competition propagates good methods—if one school teaches reading better (e.g. using phonics) it gains pupils and profit, and rivals copy the method—so the private system can improve in ways the government system cannot and will not.

    “there is no incentive to improve in the public system... In the private sector, however, the incentives are all at least pointing in the right direction. There is competition... If one of them is doing better than others, because it's found a good way of teaching reading... parents will soon cotton on to that. That school will get more kids.”

0.65

Poor parents rationally prefer private schools because government schools systematically fail through teacher absenteeism and lack of commitment.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Poor parents pay for private schooling even when free government schools provide free lunch and uniforms, because in the public schools 'children are abandoned'—teachers don't turn up, or if they do, they don't teach with commitment, leaving children to their own devices.

    “A typical phrase could be, 'In the public schools our children are abandoned. The teachers don't turn up, or if they do turn up, they don't teach; or they don't particularly teach very enthusiastically and with much commitment.'”

  • Private school teachers come from the local community and recognize the children as their own, working hard to ensure learning, whereas government school teachers have 'social distance'—they may despise poor children as dirty and smelly—which undermines their commitment to teaching them.

    “Study after study by the World Bank and other international agencies points to one of the problems in the public schools, the government schools, that teachers have 'social distance', they call it, from the children.”

  • The failure of public schooling is a systemic failure, not a failure of individual teachers; sympathetic principals report only 3 of 9 or 10 teachers attend regularly yet they had no role in selecting them and cannot remove them, leaving good people disheartened and acquiescent.

    “I'm not condemning them, individually. I'm condemning the system. You met some really good souls in these public schools, who say, 'Only 3 of my teachers come to school regularly, out of 9 or 10. I can't do anything about it.'”

  • Poor, often illiterate parents understand the virtues of competition, incentives and markets better than the bureaucrats and economists trying to help them, demonstrated by their reasoning that they choose private schools precisely because teachers will be fired if they don't show up.

    “I learnt a lot of my understanding about the virtues of markets, competition, incentives--I learnt a lot of this stuff not through reading Hayek or Friedman, but from talking to parents and entrepreneurs about what they were doing.”

0.65

The grassroots bottom-up privatization of education by poor families themselves is happening everywhere despite expert bias and policy neglect.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Even granting that better governance might one day make public schools so good private schools couldn't compete, in the meantime over the next 5 to 20 years the pragmatic course is to go where parents are going—they are choosing private schools because they think they are better, and they are right.

    “meanwhile, in the next 5 years, 10 years, 15 years, 20 years, I'm going where parents are going. Parents are choosing these private schools. They think they are better. They're right. That's where I want to follow.”

  • Billions or trillions of dollars in aid thrown at public education in poor countries have failed and if anything made things worse, with the burgeoning size of the private education market serving as one indicator of that failure.

    “Billions, trillions of dollars have been thrown at education, public education, in the countries we are talking about it. In aid. And if anything it's got worse. One indicator is the growing size, the burgeoning size of the private education market.”

  • Experts, policymakers and education ministries may be biased against the private-school finding not from malevolence but because if parents are right these officials are out of a job, reflecting a natural bias some economists have toward top-down solutions they get to run and change.

    “If what I'm saying--but more importantly, what the parents are saying... is right, then they are out of a job. And that's bound to affect the way you think about the world, isn't it? But I don't think we have to bring bad motives here.”

  • What is happening in poor countries is a grassroots, de facto 'privatization by the people, for the people'—no top-down policymaker decided to privatize education; the people themselves, unhappy with government schools, did it bottom-up, a phenomenon absent from policy textbooks yet happening everywhere.

    “what I call it, 'privatization by the people for the people.'... It's a grassroots privatization. No top-down policy maker has said, Okay, let's privatize education... The people themselves have said, 'We will privatize education ourselves.'”

0.46

Parents are competent judges of school quality using observable proxies and collective community knowledge, contrary to expert claims.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Even if private schools are not good enough by an absolute standard, a poor parent must choose among available options, and these schools are the best available—affordable and producing more literate, numerate children more likely to get a job or further education—so the relevant comparison is to government schools, not an ideal.

    “if you are a poor parent, you've got to look at your available options: what are we striving for?... if you are a poor parent, you've got to think about what's available now. And these are definitely the best options.”

  • What matters in poor areas is what is possible there; incremental improvements—a school slightly better than the surrounding shacks—can be better than any alternative and are something to be valued, rather than dismissed for failing to meet outside standards of beauty or adequacy.

    “you've got to look at what's possible in these areas, and increments can be better than any alternative. And that's good. That's something to be valued.”

  • Poor illiterate parents can judge school quality through proxy measures—hearing whether children converse confidently in English, checking whether teachers mark exercises and set homework, observing behavior and discipline—and the community pools this knowledge across families, so the expert claim that only experts can judge is both false and insulting.

    “poor illiterate parents who can't speak English can judge whether a school is teaching English by listening to the children talk... You can make sure if the teacher is checking the exercises in the book. You can make sure the teacher is setting homework”

0.46

Private schooling enables innovation and improvement through competitive propagation of effective methods that bureaucratic systems cannot achieve.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Forming associations and creating chains of private schools lets operators afford investments in teacher training, curriculum development and assessment that an individual standalone school cannot, providing a way to raise quality while preserving market incentives.

    “co-creating, a couple of chains of these private schools, where the idea there is if we bring schools together, we can afford to invest in teacher training, curriculum development, assessment, in a way that an individual, standalone school cannot.”

  • Just as England's nationalized telephone system was 'fine' for what a nationalized system could achieve but privatization unleashed remarkable new possibilities no one would now abandon, a privatized education system could do something genuinely remarkable that a solid-but-boring public system like Finland's never could.

    “you could have said the same thing about the telephone system in England... as soon as you privatized telephones, well, you bring in all these new possibilities... could a privatized system do something really remarkable with education”

  • It is not obvious private schools should teach what public schools teach, but national curricula and end-of-school testing constrain them—because parents want the national certificate as the only show in town—so schools only innovate around the edges, such as concentrating on math and language in the early years.

    “in all the countries that I'm working in, there is a national curriculum, and national end-of-school testing... the parents want you to get that national certificate. So, schools are constrained by that. Now, because they are private schools, you find them being innovative around the edges.”

0.38

Loans rather than grants and school associations preserve market incentives while enabling quality improvements that aid-dependent systems cannot achieve.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Giving loans rather than grants is the purest way to help these schools because capital lets them improve facilities to attract market share and repay the loan, without breaking the parent-payment feedback link—exemplified by the Indian School Finance Company and Africa's Edify.

    “loans, giving loans, is the absolute easiest way of doing that... that actually is the purest way of helping these schools, because it doesn't break any of those links we've been talking about.”

  • Unlike wealthier contexts, there is no welfare dependency in these poor areas—if you don't get off your butt and do something you are dead—which partly explains the energy of grassroots self-provision of schooling.

    “there's no welfare dependency in these poor areas. If you don't get off your butt and do something, then, you know, you are dead.”

  • Privatizing education lowers the possibility of corruption because it removes a large part of the budget and power from government, and reducing the size of government in any domain reduces the opportunities for corruption.

    “If you can lessen the size of the government in any way, then you lower the opportunities for corruption. And so if you are privatizing education then you are removing a large part of the budget, as it were, and power from government--already you are doing something to lower the possibility of corruption.”

  • Longitudinal studies of outcomes are difficult, but private schools are markedly better than hopeless government schools at keeping track of where their children go after school, because government schools don't see graduate tracking as their responsibility.

    “The private schools are better at keeping track of where their children go, after school. The government schools are hopeless; they don't see it as their responsibility.”