What this covers

Becky Liddicoat Yamarik, a hospice and palliative care physician, speaks with Russ Roberts about how modern medicine has restructured the experience of dying. The conversation centers on a paradox: medical innovation has made death itself a managed choice rather than a natural event. Because life support can sustain patients almost indefinitely, someone must now actively decide to stop treatment—a burden that American incentives and institutional practice push toward aggressive intervention. The two examine how ICU beds proliferated, how reimbursement structures reward volume over conversation, and why physicians often lack training in prognosis discussions, leaving terminally ill patients to chase diminishing treatments rather than prepare for death.

The discussion crosses several distinct territories. Yamarik contrasts the American default—intensive care unless explicitly refused—with European practice, where physicians retain discretion to avoid ICU admission for very elderly or chronically ill patients. She explains the mechanics of LTAC facilities and tracheostomy with PEG placement as economic by-products of diagnosis-based hospital reimbursement. A central tension emerges around perverse incentives: oncologists facing patient defection have little reason to discuss realistic prognosis, while surgeons' published mortality rates create the opposite pressure—showing how measurement drives behavior in contradictory ways across specialties. The pair also negotiate harder ground: whether denial can be psychologically protective, how surrogate decision making varies across cultures, and whether patients can reliably foresee their future preferences about quality of life. Roberts invokes Hayek and the limits of design knowledge to frame the system's dysfunction, while Yamarik argues that palliative care arose not from lost skills but from the explosion of treatment choices that modern medicine created.

Sharpest takeaway

Yamarik argues that modern medicine has turned the timing and manner of death into a choice, and that the American system's incentives, lack of physician communication training, and volume-based reimbursement push terminally ill patients toward aggressive, low-value treatment rather than honest conversations and quality-of-life-focused care.

  • Because of medical innovation, patients must now actively choose to stop treatment rather than simply dying naturally, making death a conscious decision.
  • Oncologists and the system face incentives (patient doctor-shopping, time pressure, volume-based reimbursement, untrained in prognosis conversations) that discourage realism.
  • The explosive growth of ICUs and LTACs reflects a system that spends enormous sums on patients with high mortality, often against what patients would have wanted.

The argument · threads2 threads · 32 claims
0.85

The U.S. medical system lacks genuine market mechanisms, producing strange outcomes that reveal the limits of designed economic systems.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • The U.S. medical compensation and pricing system, being unrelated to genuine market exchange, inevitably produces perverse and strange outcomes, illustrating Hayek's point that economics' curious task is to demonstrate how little people know about what they imagine they can design.

    “it always reminds me of F. A. Hayek: 'The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about they imagine they can design.'”

0.71

Publishing mortality statistics incentivizes doctors to withhold treatment from high-risk patients to protect their measured outcomes.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Tracking and publishing mortality statistics can perversely lead doctors to withhold treatment from high-risk patients to protect their stats, analogous to a basketball player declining a low-probability buzzer-beater shot to avoid hurting their shooting percentage.

    “At the end of the half in basketball, a guy has the ball, 60 feet from the basket... now people don't even take them because they don't want it in their denominator of their shots attempted”