Robert Solow on Growth and the State of Economics
What this covers
Robert Solow, the Nobel laureate economist from MIT, sits down with EconTalk host Russ Roberts to discuss his foundational work on economic growth and his reflections on the state of macroeconomics. The conversation centers on Solow's landmark finding that technological progress in the broadest sense—not capital accumulation—drove more than 80% of US output growth per person between 1909 and 1949. Solow explains why saving and investment determine whether an economy lands on a high or low growth path, but the long-term rate itself depends entirely on demography and technological change. He also addresses why macroeconomic controversy persists: the problems are intrinsically complex, stakes are high, powerful interests compete, and crucially, the right answer changes as institutions and behavior evolve.
The discussion ranges across several overlapping territories. Solow draws a critical distinction between innovation and technology—the former a half-mystical creative act akin to Schumpeterian entrepreneurship, the latter more narrowly technical. He revisits Keynes's fundamental insight about the gap between productive capacity and the ability to sell goods (later formalized as aggregate supply versus aggregate demand), and contrasts it with how Say's Law dominated pre-1936 economics. The pair examine why computer productivity gains arrived late and came partly from falling production costs rather than use, why endogenous growth theory promised more than it delivered, and whether the low-hanging fruit from information technology may already be harvested. Along the way, Solow offers sharp views on Milton Friedman's influence on the discipline and the difference between real technical disagreement and ideological posturing dressed in economic language.
Solow argues that long-run economic growth is driven not by capital accumulation but by demography and technological progress in the broadest sense, and that macroeconomics remains permanently contested because its problems are complex, high-stakes, and change over time.
- More than 80% of US growth in output per person (1909-1949) traced to technological progress, not saving and investment
- The volume of saving determines the level of the growth path, not its long-term rate
- Macroeconomic controversy persists because the right answer changes as institutions and behavior change
Keynes's innovation was proposing government borrowing and spending as the solution to economic gaps.
- Economists were obsessed with the business cycle for at least 50 years before Keynes and were well aware the economy sometimes failed to reach its potential, so Keynes's genuinely distinctive contribution was not recognizing the gap but the claim that you can get out of that problem by having the government borrow money and spend it—and whether that is true is the central contested question.
“the distinctive contribution of Keynes is you can get out of that problem by borrowing money and spending it through the government. And that to me is the central question, is whether that is true.”
Friedman distinguished himself through confident application of principles, not by having ideology.
- Just about every economist—including Krugman, Samuelson, Solow, and Roberts himself—has an ideology, so Friedman's possession of strong principles is not itself a distinguishing flaw; what distinguished Friedman was his confidence in applying those principles, which may have been partly a deliberate marketing posture for a lonely minority view.
“Paul Krugman, and Paul Samuelson, yourself, me--just about every economist--has an ideology.”