What this covers
D. G. Myers, a literary critic and cancer patient, joins Russ Roberts on EconTalk to discuss what a terminal diagnosis has taught him about time, honesty, and what makes life worth living. The conversation moves between Myers's personal experience—six years into his diagnosis—and broader arguments about how culture, language, and choice shape the way we die and live. Myers contends that the prevalent "battle" metaphor for cancer is a cultural lie that obscures the actual experience of patients while protecting the healthy from discomfort; that facing finitude forces a reckoning with opportunity cost, turning time-use into a conscious economic choice; and that choosing life—focusing deliberately on what genuinely matters—remains available to anyone, terminal illness or not.
The discussion spans philosophy, medicine, and economics, but pivots repeatedly into literary and educational territory. Myers argues that great writers deserve study because they are wiser than we are, not as vehicles for exposing historical injustice; that Shakespeare is indispensable because he encompasses the full picture of human nature and exemplifies mastery of language itself; and that creative writing programs have devolved into self-serving bureaucracies disconnected from literary tradition. Roberts and Myers examine how mindfulness of mortality—the recognition that all life is "life-limiting"—could reshape how everyone allocates time, even those who resist the thought. A secondary thread addresses what cancer patients actually need: not false hope but honesty, so they can savor remaining time wisely. Myers also reflects on how his own diagnosis redirected him from writing an academic book on literary theory back to book reviewing, a choice that paradoxically made him more influential as a public literary voice. Throughout, the conversation treats dying and living not as opposites but as points on a continuum of conscious choice.
Myers argues that cancer should be faced with honesty rather than the false 'battle' metaphor, and that a terminal diagnosis clarifies opportunity cost — forcing a deliberate, economic reallocation of one's scarcest resource, time, toward what genuinely enhances life.
- The 'battle' metaphor is a cultural lie that erases the lived experience of patients and protects the healthy, not the sick
- Facing finitude turns time-use into a conscious economic choice (opportunity cost), letting one 'fill' rather than 'mark' time
- Choosing life — focusing on what matters (children, music, books) — is available to anyone, dying or not
Time is the scarcest resource we allocate, and awareness of mortality makes even idle moments feel meaningful rather than wasted.
- Economics is fundamentally a lens for thinking about life and choices, centered on opportunity cost — what we give up to do something — and the most precious and scarce resource we allocate is not money or oil but time, which is easily wasted.
“your essay reminded me of how easy it is to waste what I think of as our most precious resource. Which is--not oil--but time. Because it's very scarce.”
- When you become conscious of choosing how to spend your time and discover you enjoy your choices, even formerly 'wasted' activities take on new meaning; you no longer waste or mark time but fill it, because mortality lets you see the brim of your remaining time.
“You no longer waste or mark time. You fill it, because now you can see the brim from where you are lying.”
Most people fail to recognize the limits—lifespan and capacity—that constrain their choices, though mindfulness of these bounds would be valuable.
- Everyone, not just the terminally ill, lives with 'life-limiting' conditions — both in lifespan and in the activities they can do — but most people remain unaware of these limits; becoming mindful of them would be merciful, though it may be nearly impossible to teach.
“We all really have life-limiting conditions and we are just not aware of them.”
Becoming a better writer requires learning to critique others' work carefully, internalizing the reader's perspective to see and fix your own flaws.
- The way to teach people to write better is not to grade their writing but to grade how they critique each other, because becoming a better editor — internalizing the reader over your shoulder and responding to others' flaws — is what helps you see and fix your own writing.
“Don't grade people on how they write; grade them on how they critique each other.”
Somerset Maugham was discarded by critics for being a great storyteller, though plain storytelling craft is the highest literary virtue.
- Somerset Maugham has been critically discarded precisely because he is merely a great storyteller — a virtue Roberts considers possibly the single best one — since plain, unflashy storytelling craft is no longer valued highly in literary culture.
“he's been discarded because he's merely a great storyteller? Which is no longer valued very highly.”