Moises Velasquez-Manoff on Autoimmune Disease, Parasites, and Complexity
What this covers
Moises Velasquez-Manoff discusses his book An Epidemic of Absence with Russ Roberts on why allergies and autoimmune diseases have surged in developed countries over the past fifty years. The central claim rests on a paradox: not that we are diagnosing disease better, but that we have removed parasites and microbial diversity that historically calibrated immune tolerance. Through natural experiments—Sardinia's malaria eradication, Argentina's economic collapse leading to accidental parasite reacquisition, and the "farm effect" protecting children born to mothers with chronic microbial exposure—Velasquez-Manoff builds a case that public-health victories have masked a deeper cost. The conversation extends beyond epidemiology into gene-environment mismatch, epigenetics, and how the immune system requires not firepower alone but calibrated tolerance to avoid self-destruction.
The discussion ranges across several interlocking mechanisms. Epigenetics figures prominently: the Dutch famine cohort demonstrates how maternal conditions during pregnancy shape disease risk decades later. The immune system's job is not merely to fight but to know when to stop; uncontrolled response causes collateral damage. Genes associated with autoimmune disease have actually become more prevalent over fifteen thousand years—a puzzle only solved if those genes were protective in parasite-rich ancestral environments. Roberts and Velasquez-Manoff examine whether reintroducing parasites holds therapeutic promise, the timing sensitivity of microbial exposure (early life matters; adult travel does not), and why conventional autoimmune treatments carry serious cost-benefit tradeoffs. Throughout, Roberts emphasizes the hazard of confirmation bias when facing compelling narratives, invoking the principle that suppressing all small threats can produce catastrophic outcomes—a theme of unintended consequences in a complex world.
Velasquez-Manoff argues that the modern rise of allergies and autoimmune diseases is not merely better diagnosis but a real consequence of removing parasites and microbial diversity that co-evolved to calibrate our immune systems, illustrating how public-health triumphs carry hidden costs in a complex causal world.
- Side-by-side genetically similar populations show divergent allergy rates by objective measures, ruling out pure measurement artifact
- Parasites and a diverse microbiome strengthen immune tolerance; their removal unmasks autoimmune/allergic tendencies
- Natural experiments (Sardinia malaria eradication, Buenos Aires deworming) link removal of immune-suppressing organisms to autoimmune disease
The immune system requires evolutionarily expected microbial and parasitic stimuli early in life to develop properly and avoid atrophy.
- Hormesis, central to Taleb's Antifragile, is the idea that certain stresses in the right amount and at the right developmental time make a system stronger rather than weaker; just as regular exercise stresses the body to improve circulation, bones, muscles, and neurogenesis, the immune system requires evolutionarily expected microbial and parasitic stimuli—especially early in life—to develop properly, and their absence leads to atrophy expressed as autoimmune and allergic disease.
“our immune system needs certain influx, certain stimuli that are evolutionarily determined. Because they've just simply always been there... And that we need them especially early in life.”
- The protective effect of microbial and parasitic exposure is critically dependent on timing—it must occur early in life; an adult traveling to a place with poor sanitation will not see improvement in their allergies.
“If you are an adult and you go to a place where there is not very good sanitary amenities, it's not going to help your allergies.”
- Microbes in our body outnumber our cells by roughly 10 to 1, and a more diverse internal microbiome calibrates and strengthens the immune system; diversity has declined over the 20th century due to improved sanitation and smaller, less crowded families, which reduces inherited microbial exposure.
“microbes in our body right now actually outnumber our cells by a factor of 10 to 1”
- The hygiene hypothesis originated with David Strachan's 1989 study of tens of thousands of birth records, which found that of 17 variables, the single variable correlating with protection from hay fever was the number of other children in the house when the subject was an infant—the more siblings, the lower the later hay fever risk.
“the single variable that correlates with protection is how many other kids are in the house when these kids are infants or very young. So, the more other kids there are, the lower their risk of hay fever when they are in their early 20s”
Chronic parasites suppress immune reactivity by inducing tolerance, preventing allergic and autoimmune disease emergence.
- The harder a person's immune system pushes back against parasites, the fewer worms they retain but the more it hurts them, indicating that the harm is largely caused by one's own immune response rather than the parasite directly.
“it seems like the harder your immune system pushes back, the fewer worms you end up with but also the more it kind of hurts you. So really what's hurting you is your own immune response.”
- Parasites such as hookworms survive inside hosts by tweaking the immune system to induce tolerance—convincing the immune system they belong, like a tolerated food—and by strengthening the tolerance-inducing part of the immune system they may prevent allergic and autoimmune disease from emerging.
“what the parasites do is they convince you to tolerate them and treat it like some food that's supposed to be there. That's how they live for years inside of their hosts. And by strengthening that part of your immune system, the thinking goes, they then prevent allergic disease and possibly the autoimmune disease from ever emerging.”
- Unlike acute pathogens like plague or smallpox that multiply exponentially to jump to a new host, leaving the host a 'used-up husk,' chronic parasites have a survival strategy of keeping the host alive for years, which is why over-killing the host is bad for the parasite itself.
“This is not like, let's say, the plague, or let's say like smallpox, where it multiplies exponentially in a very short period of time with the idea of jumping to another host, leaving you as a sort of used-up husk. What the strategy of these parasites is, is to live for a year.”
- Beyond firepower, the immune system must shut down aggression to avoid self-harm; uncontrolled immune response causes collateral damage, as in septic infections where overwhelming immune response—not the bacteria—shuts down organs, so tolerance and controlling inflammation is itself necessary for survival.
“It's that your immune response has become so overwhelming that your whole body just collapses... there is this whole rethinking now going on about tolerance as a survival strategy, recognizing that you can destroy yourself with your own firepower.”
Maternal immune activation and prenatal microbial exposure shape fetal immune programming through epigenetics across decades.
- The Mediterranean diet's benefit may stem from soluble fiber that humans cannot digest but that feeds healthy gut microbes; eating this way selects for better microbes that tweak the immune system into a more tolerant state, and that tolerance profile is read by the developing fetus, potentially lowering the child's risk of asthma and allergic diseases.
“a diet that's high in fiber, and this is soluble fiber... is that it feeds your healthy microbes. So you are actually selecting for better microbes by eating this kind of diet that contains stuff that you can't actually digest.”
- Prenatal infections that activate the mother's immune system are a shared risk factor for diverse offspring diseases that manifest at different life stages—schizophrenia, autism, and asthma—because the maternal immune activation trains the developing fetus's immune system in ways that can be pushed out of the adaptive realm.
“Infections, prenatal infections are a risk factor for many, many different problems, from schizophrenia decades later in the offspring... for autism increasingly seems. And also for asthma”
- Through epigenetics, the signals from a mother during the 9 months of pregnancy shape fetal development and set predispositions to diseases decades later; the Dutch WWII famine cohort showed children born to starved mothers had increased risk of Western diseases (heart disease, cancers, diabetes) decades later, demonstrating causation rather than mere correlation.
“the mothers who were pregnant then... decades later they had increased risk to basically the suite of Western diseases--which are heart disease, some cancers, diabetes. Decades later. They were able to correlate this with this event.”
- The 'farm effect' is the observation that children of mothers who work on farms during pregnancy are strongly protected from allergy, possibly because exposure to up to 10,000 times more innocuous microbes than in a suburban house acts like immunotherapy, constantly training the developing fetus's immune system to prevent allergic disease.
“mothers who work on farms while they are pregnant, their kids seem to be very, very protected from allergy... you encounter up to 10,000 times more microbes in a barn with cows and chickens than you do in a house like mine in suburbia”
- Future treatment for these diseases will likely begin during or even before pregnancy and involve both parents, because there is evidence that fathers also pass on their experiences epigenetically through genes being turned on and off in the sperm, though the mother remains most important.
“there is a bunch of evidence suggesting that fathers pass on some of their experiences as well, epigenetically. That genes are turned on and off in the sperm.”
- Genes are fixed but their translation into proteins and hormones is tunable; the Dutch famine cohort was epigenetically prepared in utero for starvation, so when they instead encountered an affluent post-war environment they were epigenetically maladapted, over-processing food and becoming more prone to obesity and metabolic syndrome.
“they are essentially prepared in utero, in the womb, for a starvation situation. And what they come into... is not a starvation situation. So the thinking is it's a kind of mismatch of what they are prepared for, epigenetically, and what they encounter”
Autoimmune and allergic disease prevalence has increased dramatically in the developed world over the past century.
- Autoimmune and allergic diseases have increased very precipitously in the developed world, especially in the late 20th century, with allergies rising 2-3 fold or more and some autoimmune diseases like celiac rising 4-5 fold.
“allergies between 2- and 3-fold in the developed world, maybe more. And autoimmune disease, depending on which one, up to celiac is between 4- and 5-fold”
- While some measured increase in allergic disease is due to improved diagnosis, the rise is genuinely real because genetically similar populations living side by side show very different prevalence of allergic antibodies (IgE) and positive skin prick tests by objective measures.
“you can go to populations living side by side, usually exposed to different environments, and see that the prevalence of these antibodies and the prevalence of positive skin prick tests, the wheals or the swellings, are very different”
- Autoimmune and allergic diseases are not trivial—they cause immense suffering and cost, and each generation seems more prone, with conditions like inflammatory bowel disease and nut allergies now appearing in children rather than only young adults.
“Each generation seems to be more and more prone to these diseases. Inflammatory bowel disease seemed to be something you get it as a young adult; and now kids--there's pediatric inflammatory bowel disease.”
Removing parasites and microbes through sanitation unmasks autoimmune disease, as shown by malaria eradication and deworming studies.
- After malaria was eradicated in Sardinia in the 1940s using DDT, multiple sclerosis and Type 1 diabetes increased dramatically over 2-3 generations, with Sardinia becoming number 2 in the world for Type 1 diabetes prevalence; the chronic malaria infection may have suppressed the immune system the way worms do, and removing it unmasked autoimmune disease.
“Two autoimmune diseases started increasing dramatically: multiple sclerosis and Type 1 diabetes. It's now number 2 in the world for Type 1 diabetes, for the prevalence.”
- During Argentina's early-2000s economic collapse, sanitary backsliding led some multiple sclerosis patients to acquire parasites; neurologist Jorge Correale let patients choose to keep their worms, and those who did saw their MS nearly halt by objective MRI and blood measures over five years, while those later dewormed at their request saw anti-inflammatory immune molecules decline and disease resume.
“what he sees is that the whole balance of the immune system shifts from pre-deworming to post-deworming, where those molecules that indicate strong anti-inflammatory capacity decline dramatically, immediately after you deworm. And then the disease started right back up again for those patients he dewormed.”
- An old observation dating to the 1960s found that people who grew up using an outhouse rather than a toilet had a lower risk of multiple sclerosis, and counterintuitively it may literally be the sanitary amenities themselves—not merely correlated income—that matter.
“if you grew up without a toilet but used an outhouse that your risk of multiple sclerosis was lower”
- Studies in Africa where children are de-wormed show an immediate rebound in allergic reactivity and a measurable decline in the immune molecules associated with holding back, demonstrating that parasite removal rapidly shifts the whole balance of the immune system toward reactivity.
“they will de-worm them and basically measure how their immune function changes before and after. And you see an immediate rebound in allergic reactivity. And immediate decline.”
Genes for autoimmune disease were adaptive in parasite-rich ancestral environments but cause disease in modern sanitized conditions.
- Genes associated with autoimmune disease are widespread and have actually become more prevalent in the human population over the past ~15,000 years, which is paradoxical because autoimmune disease is so costly to fitness it should be selected against—implying these genes were useful and likely did not cause the same disease in the ancestral parasite-rich environment.
“it seems like they have actually become more prevalent in the past 15,000 years or so. Which suggests that they have some use.”
- Thalassemia, a congenital anemia, illustrates malaria's selective pressure on the Sardinian genome: two copies cause anemia, but one copy protects against the lethal cerebral malaria, and these protective genes become less prevalent at higher mountain altitudes where malaria intensity was lower.
“if you get just one copy then you are protected from cerebral malaria, which is the kind of malaria that kills you. So those genes do become less prevalent as you go up the mountain”
Parasite therapy for autoimmune disease is promising but carries real costs and unproven efficacy that patients often underestimate.
- Gastroenterologist Joel Weinstock developed a medicalized pig-native whipworm chosen because it cannot reproduce sexually in humans, so it cannot spread to others; early Crohn's Disease trials in about three dozen people showed a remarkable 75% remission rate, though later results have been lackluster, so efficacy is still unproven.
“It was like 3 dozen people and a 75% remission rate for Crohn's Disease. It was unbelievable. And now it's in testing. And some of the results have been very lackluster, so far.”
- Velasquez-Manoff's self-experiment with hookworm in Tijuana produced partial effects: his hay fever disappeared for about half the season and his eczema went away, but his hair did not grow back and his food allergies did not resolve, supporting both that parasites manipulate the immune system and that they carry real costs.
“my hay fever went away entirely for about half of hay fever season. My eczema went away. My hair did not grow back. My food allergies did not go away.”
- For people with chronic autoimmune disease where conventional therapies have failed or carry feared side effects like increased cancer risk from TNF inhibitors, choosing to try parasite therapy can be a rational decision because parasites can be removed with a short deworming course, though desperation leads people to ignore caveats and unfavorable cases.
“I think actually at some point it's a rational--it's a very rational choice. Where everything else failed”
- The ideal future direction is for scientists either to isolate the molecules parasites use to subvert the immune system and turn them into drugs, or to breed a benign parasite with all the benefit and none of the cost—analogous to how the cuddly Chihuahua descends from the ferocious gray wolf.
“they will isolate the molecules these parasites use to subvert your immune system and just create drugs out of those, or 2. They will breed a kind of benign parasite that has no cost and all benefit.”
Vaccines remain beneficial because protective microbes differ from disease pathogens, enabling both vaccination and microbial therapy.
- Vaccines remain beneficial because the organisms that protect against allergic and autoimmune disease are not the same ones we vaccinate against; infections like polio and measles have not shown up as protective, so it is possible to keep vaccines while addressing the absence problem.
“we vaccinate against polio and measles--none of those infections have shown up to be protective”
- Unlike parasites which carry clear costs, the promise of microbiota research is that there are beneficial organisms that tweak the immune system with no costs and can be leveraged therapeutically; organisms like Helicobacter pylori have both good and bad sides, being associated with stomach cancer yet apparently preventing some allergic and autoimmune diseases.
“the promise of the research on the microbiota is that there are organisms that are all beneficial. And that have no costs. And that those can be leveraged to fix some of these problems.”
- Conventional autoimmune treatments are difficult and risky: TNF-alpha inhibitors block an aspect of the immune system and increase the risk of certain infections and cancers, and while these absolute risks are very small they loom large in patients' imaginations, making the cost-benefit calculus of alternatives genuinely complex.
“they basically block some aspect of your ability to be inflamed... But then that increases the risk of some infections, because you have basically hobbled an aspect of your immune system.”
- Parasites are highly host-specific; a hookworm native to humans can navigate the body safely, but when animals acquire parasites not native to them the parasites can migrate to the wrong place—brain, central nervous system, liver—causing horrific or fatal disease, which is a key critique of using pig whipworms in humans.
“oftentimes when animals end up with parasites that are not native to them, it can kill them. Because then they can end up migrating to the wrong place. To the brain, to the central nervous system, to the liver--and they cause horrific disease.”
- Going to a farm only once or twice during pregnancy produces the opposite of protection, because without chronic exposure the immune system does not recalibrate and instead treats the microbial encounter as an attack—an infection-like response that is harmful during pregnancy and may make children more prone to allergy.
“if you just go once or twice to a farm, the opposite happens... because it's not chronic, because your immune system doesn't recalibrate... you treat it almost as an attack. And that's exactly what you don't want.”