Erik Brynjolfsson on the Second Machine Age
What this covers
Erik Brynjolfsson and host Russ Roberts discuss the thesis of Brynjolfsson's book The Second Machine Age, co-authored with Andrew McAfee. The conversation centers on how technological advance—now automating cognitive labor alongside physical work—will reshape economic life. Unlike earlier machine ages, which raised the value of human judgment and oversight, cognitive automation risks making humans economic substitutes rather than complements. Brynjolfsson argues that technology creates possibility, not destiny: the question is not whether the economy will transform, but whether people will share in its gains. This hinges on deliberate choices in education, entrepreneurship, and policy, not on technology's trajectory alone.
The discussion ranges across three economic forces driving widening inequality: skill-biased technical change that rewards the educated, capital-biased technical change shifting income from labor to capital, and superstar-biased technical change that concentrates rewards in winner-take-all markets. Brynjolfsson challenges economists for optimizing the wrong metrics—GDP rather than welfare—and disputes whether median household income truly stagnated once adjusted for household composition. He examines why MOOCs and digital learning offer genuine scalability, why Keynes miscalculated how we would spend freed time, and why declining entrepreneurship (not just automation) erodes job creation. He advocates for immigration reform favoring foreign PhDs, educational overhaul emphasizing statistics, and an expanded Earned Income Tax Credit over minimum wages—arguing that Technology Is Not Destiny means policy should enable adaptation rather than resist change.
Brynjolfsson argues we are entering a Second Machine Age in which technology advances exponentially and grows the economic pie, but there is no economic law guaranteeing those gains are shared, so deliberate adaptation—reinvented education, entrepreneurship, and work-supporting policy—is required to avoid a future of widening inequality.
- Technology now automates cognitive tasks, not just muscle, so historical reassurances about new jobs are less certain
- Skill-biased, capital-biased, and superstar-biased technical change together drive the divergence between median and average income
- Outcomes depend on choices (education, entrepreneurship, EITC), not on technology as destiny
Modern work affords substantial leisure time through low-engagement tasks and personal activities.
- Quality of life is mismeasured not only for the future but the present: a large portion of people—not 70% but well more than 5%—enjoy substantial leisure on the job, doing mindless tasks while listening to podcasts or shopping online during working hours, so modern work is far less painful than the drudgery of earlier eras.
“a large portion of people have an immense amount of leisure on the job. I recently asked people to contact me if they listen to EconTalk at work, and I got well over 100 emails”