What this covers

Doug Lemov, an educator with Uncommon Schools and author of Teach Like a Champion, joins economist Russ Roberts to examine teaching as a learnable craft. Drawing on experience in charter schools serving low-income students, Lemov argues that teaching shares the structure of performance professions like surgery and tennis: it requires deliberate practice before entering the live event, not merely on-the-job trial and error. The conversation moves from what makes an individual teacher excellent—the mastery of replicable techniques, subject expertise, and content-specific pedagogy—to how schools as organizations can systematically elevate their entire teaching force through culture, feedback, and trust.

The episode covers several distinct domains. At the classroom level, Lemov identifies specific techniques—cold calling, check for understanding, no opt out—that can be observed in outlier teachers and trained into others. The discussion explores the psychology of error: why emotional constancy matters when a student answers wrongly, how Error Analysis deepens learning, and why Depth Over Breadth in vocabulary knowledge predicts achievement far better than breadth alone. At the organizational level, Lemov argues that great schools exceed their talented teachers because management, coaching, and evaluation practices either compound or waste teacher quality. A notably contentious thread runs through the conversation: the claim that teacher quality, not school resources or demographics, determines both individual student learning and long-term national economic viability, citing Eric Hanushek's analysis of GDP growth. The episode concludes with practical advice on hiring—favoring Hire for Coachability and observation over interview performance—and a brief exchange on how the podcast itself might be made more rigorous.

Sharpest takeaway

Lemov argues that great teaching is a learnable craft built on deliberate practice and replicable techniques, and that great schools are organizations that systematically make their teachers better through trust, feedback, and accountability.

  • Teaching is a 'performance profession' that, like sports or surgery, requires practice before the live event, not just on-the-job experience
  • Specific techniques (cold call, at-bats, check for understanding, no opt out) can be identified by watching outlier teachers and trained into others
  • A great school exceeds the sum of its teachers because its culture and management make every teacher better

The argument · threads7 threads · 34 claims
0.85

Teaching effectiveness depends on mastering observable techniques that can be trained, practiced, and improved through feedback.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Teachers can be trained to be effective and many of them to be really good, just as we train economists, accountants, and surgeons; the assumption that teaching cannot be taught is deeply ironic and should be rejected, and if good training cannot make a willing, open-minded person at least an effective teacher, then the training itself is broken.

    “I think we can teach people to be economists. I think we can teach people to be accountants. We think we can teach people to be surgeons. We don't think we can teach people to be teachers? There's a deep and disturbing irony to the assumption that teaching is something that cannot be taught.”

  • The fundamental attribute of a great teacher is the willingness to seek and see the difference between what was taught and what was learned (per John Wooden, 'It's not whether you taught it; it's whether they learned it'), making 'check for understanding' the single most important technique—important enough that Lemov would make it the first chapter of a rewritten book.

    “The great basketball coach, John Wooden, said, It's not whether you taught it; it's whether they learned it.”

  • Becoming a great teacher requires mastering three domains: general teaching techniques (like cold call, checking for understanding, and classroom management), subject-specific content knowledge (which is very hard to train and must largely be acquired beforehand), and content-specific pedagogical approaches (how to teach reading vs math vs science differently).

    “there are really three domains of knowledge that you need to master to be a great teacher. One of them is general teaching techniques... And then there's subject-specific content... But some of the middle group of skills which are sort of content-specific approaches--how do you teach reading? How do you teach math?”

  • Cold calling—calling on students regardless of whether they raised their hands—instantly boosts academic rigor because every student does the cognitive work in anticipation of being called, speeds up class pacing by eliminating time wasted pleading for participation, and lets the teacher check for understanding with a reliable sample rather than the biased sample of only those who volunteer.

    “cold calling makes it so that everyone answers the question. And then you decide who shares the answer.”

  • Teaching is a performance profession done live in front of an audience that cannot be paused, and like tennis players, surgeons, or musicians who practice thousands of repetitions before performing, teachers must practice their techniques before entering the classroom—yet typical educators almost never practice their craft before 'playing the game'.

    “teaching is a performance profession, and that you do it live in front of 30--an audience of 30 or so, four times a day, and sometimes it's a very skeptical audience of 30.”

  • Practicing the things you don't want to consciously think about during teaching—such as how to respond to an unexpected wrong answer—automates them, so they happen intuitively and free up cognitive processing capacity to focus on the content; this transformed a teacher named Maggie who, after practicing reactions to wrong answers with a colleague, could keep her mind on the book rather than on how to react.

    “once you automate something, it frees your mind to think about something else.”

  • Hiring teachers should rely on watching them teach a sample lesson rather than talking about teaching, because the ability to articulate the nuances, paradoxes, and ambiguities of teaching is very different from—and may even inversely correlate with—the ability to actually get up and do it in front of a class.

    “an ability to articulate all the paradoxes and ambiguities in some ways probably inversely correlates to your ability in knowing how to get up in front of the class and do it.”

0.72

Teachers must create psychological safety around error by analyzing why wrong answers are attractive and normalizing mistakes as learning.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • If a teacher gets angry at a student for being wrong, the student learns to hide errors (making it harder to check for understanding) and the teacher destroys the sense that getting things wrong is the normal state of learning; therefore teachers must maintain emotional constancy to normalize error and make it safe to be wrong.

    “as soon as I get mad at a student for struggling and being wrong, I do two things. One is to teach that student that they shouldn't try to hide their errors from me, because I'll get mad at them.”

  • After making error visible, the most powerful teaching move is to analyze it—asking why a wrong answer was attractive, what was 'right' about the wrong choice that fooled students—because understanding errors, including deliberately designing distractor answers, helps students see what they don't understand rather than prematurely moving on.

    “after you've made error visible and learned from it, then you want to invest in sort of analyzing error--that error is actually one of the most powerful teaching tools.”

  • The 'no opt out' technique handles a student who says 'I don't know' by getting the correct answer from another student and then returning to the original student to repeat it, so that over time students learn that saying 'I don't know' saves them no work and stay engaged.

    “over time you learn that you are not going to save any work for yourself by saying, 'I don't know.' Because you are going to ask the question anyway in the end.”

  • Learning does not end when a student can get something right once; to drive a skill into muscle memory and free the mind for the next, more complex concept, a student needs to do it many times (20, 100) in different permutations—for example, getting one fractions problem right does not mean you've mastered adding fractions with unlike denominators.

    “being able to do one problem where you add fractions with unlike denominators right does not mean you've mastered adding fractions with unlike denominators. You really need to be able to do 20 of them or 100 of them and do them in different permutations.”

0.67

Schools succeed only when they develop great teachers, differentiate top performers, and build cultures of trust and improvement.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Schools fail worse at the conversation that rewards and develops great teachers than at the conversation that dismisses poor ones, and this matters more—because the saddest loss is the great teachers who leave the profession since they will never be differentiated from their least competent peer under dysfunctional labor dynamics.

    “We fail in that conversation worse than we fail in the dismissal conversation and it's more important.”

  • An open-minded teacher who scores lower in raw skill (a 6) but is hungry for feedback and can apply it in a re-teach should be hired over a more skilled candidate (an 8) who is defensive about feedback, because over five to ten years the coachable teacher will surpass the skilled one and will lift others around them.

    “someone who is open to feedback, who scores a 6 in skill but is thirsty for feedback and hungry and wants it, I'm going to hire that person over someone who comes in an 8 or an 8.5 but who is a little bit defensive”

  • Per the McKinsey study, the quality of a school or school system can never exceed the quality of its teachers, so a school will only succeed if its teachers love working there, feel trusted and safe, and believe the evaluation system will never do them an injustice—evaluation must be grounded in trust and the goal of making them better.

    “The quality of the school or school system can never exceed the quality of its teachers.”

  • Every teacher should be observed at least every three weeks—even briefly—because a single announced 'dog-and-pony show' observation gives a biased snapshot, whereas frequent observation across many data points reveals what is typical in a classroom, with the primary goal being to help the teacher improve rather than to catch them.

    “every teacher should be observed at least every 3 weeks. If it's for 10 minutes that's fine.”

  • A great school is greater than the sum of its teachers because it is an organization that makes people better—merely recruiting a great teacher is a Pyrrhic victory affecting only her 30 students, whereas a school that improves her and lets her rub off on colleagues multiplies impact, which boils down to a culture of team spirit, candor, training, and building each other up.

    “A school is greater than the sum of its teachers. And a great school is an organization that makes people better.”

  • Per Lemov's colleague Paul Bamberg, buy-in is an outcome rather than a precondition: people walk into training with arms metaphorically folded because they've been disappointed before, but if the training is genuinely good they come to believe in it and open up, which has held consistently across schools outside the charter sector.

    “My colleague Paul Bamberg says that 'Buy-in is an outcome, not a precondition.'”

0.58

Teacher quality determines national economic and democratic outcomes; observation of exceptional outlier schools reveals what is possible.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Although school performance is negatively correlated with student poverty levels, for any level of poverty—even 100% of students living in poverty—there are always schools and teachers that defy expectations and achieve credible outcomes, and these outliers can be studied to learn what makes them successful.

    “for any level of poverty, even 100% of the kids in the school living in poverty, there are always schools that defy expectations. There are always teachers who defy expectations.”

  • Economist Eric Hanushek's 40-year analysis of education test scores and GDP growth rates in Latin American countries found that test scores explained 80% of GDP growth rates over 40 years, meaning teachers who determine how fast students learn determine a nation's economic and democratic viability.

    “he ran a 40-year analysis of test scores, education test scores in Latin American countries, and their GDP (Gross Domestic Product) growth rates. And the test scores explained 80% of the GDP growth rates over 40 years.”

  • In any sector other than education—such as a Silicon Valley chip fabrication plant achieving remarkable results—competitors would engage in industrial espionage to learn the secret, but education's culture has not historically included studying and replicating what makes its best performers exceptional.

    “if this were any other sector other than education--Silicon Valley in which it figured out how to put immense amounts of additional memory on the chip for the same amount of size--people would be engaged in industrial espionage, trying to sneak into chip fabrication plants to figure out what it was that made one plant's results so incredible. But in education that wasn't part of the culture”

  • While data often shows the average principal is a poor judge of teacher effectiveness against value-added measures, this does not mean excellent principals are poor judges—in fact strong principals are great judges of teacher quality, which is the very definition of a great principal, so educational data is most powerful as an organizational management tool in good managers' hands rather than published publicly.

    “excellent principals, strong principals, are great judges of teacher quality. And this is proven in the data. In fact this is the definition of a great principal--someone who understands what good teaching is and then can identify it and support it.”

0.40

Vocabulary depth and precise word knowledge correlate strongly with student achievement and require careful, nuanced instruction.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • When words overlap in meaning by 80-90% (like 'mimic' and 'imitate') teachers tend to teach them as synonyms, but for reading comprehension the differences matter more than the similarities—'mimic' carries a pejorative sense of mockery—so teaching them as synonyms causes students to miss the implication of a text.

    “if words overlap in meaning by 80% or 90%, 'mimic' and 'imitate', say, we tend to teach them as synonyms. But what's important for reading perspective is the difference in the words.”

  • The strength and especially the depth of a student's vocabulary correlates very strongly with achievement—better than almost anything—and depth of word knowledge (knowing how to use words across many scenarios and their nuances) correlates better than breadth of word knowledge (knowing a little about many words).

    “Vocabulary--the strength of your vocabulary, and interestingly the depth of your vocabulary--correlates very strongly to achievement. Better than almost anything. And interestingly, depth of word knowledge correlates better than breadth of word knowledge.”

  • You do not truly understand something until you have disciplined it into words; a notion is only half an idea, but when you put it into specific words, syntax, and say what it is and is not in writing, it becomes an idea—so having learners write one carefully-crafted sentence capturing a complex idea would make education much more rigorous.

    “a notion was half an idea; but when you put it into specific words and into syntax and are disciplined about saying what it is and what it isn't, when you've written it down on paper, then it becomes an idea.”

0.22

Suburban schools mask mediocre teaching through selection effects and resist improvement, while under-resourced schools feel urgent pressure to excel.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • A dirty secret of American education is that middle- and upper-middle-class suburban schools mask mediocrity through selection effects—their high scores come from advantaged students (and SAT tutoring) rather than great teaching—so they are insulated from urgency and risk being outcompeted internationally while believing they are excellent.

    “one of the dirty little secrets of American education is that what they have at schools is have tremendous selection effects.”

  • Although an achievement gap exists everywhere—rich/poor, actual vs potential, U.S. vs the best in the world—inner-city schools have one benefit: people generally feel the urgency to improve, whereas suburban schools are often insulated from urgency and resist efforts to become excellent.

    “The benefit that we have in inner city schools is that generally people get the urgency. I think in suburban schools people are often pretty insulated from the urgency.”

0.09

Reading teachers are harder to identify than math teachers because reading requires insightful interpretation of individual texts.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Among teaching specialties, reading teachers are the hardest to identify in the selection process because each book requires a different active, insightful interpretation demanding a high level of intellect, whereas math teachers can be found relatively reliably through selection criteria.

    “the one that we see the most difference in how we hire for is reading teachers: that each book requires a different active insightful interpretation and it's just a level of intellect and interpretation that reading teachers tend to be harder.”

  • Per David Epstein's work, while practice strongly drives skill, reaching the elite world-class level (e.g., a world-class sprinter) requires the right physiology because so many people compete for so few spots—but this is a special case of elite performance and does not undermine the value of practice for getting the vast majority of people into high quartiles of skill.

    “When you get to the world of elite performance now, it's not enough to practice; that you have to have the right physiology, because there's so many people clamoring for those few spots”