John Ralston Saul on Reason, Elites, and Voltaire's Bastards
What this covers
John Ralston Saul, author and head of PEN International, joins Russ Roberts to argue that the Enlightenment's elevation of reason into a supreme governing ideology has produced a cascade of institutional failures. The conversation traces how reason, once a tool among many, became detached from ethics, intuition, and common sense—transforming into amoral methodology that corrupts public policy, hollows out education, and empowers technocratic elites. Saul contends that the solution lies not in rejecting reason but in restoring it to a humanist balance with other human qualities, enabling what he calls responsible individualism and empathy as the foundation of fair governance.
The discussion ranges across education, finance, economics, and business. Saul argues that 19th-century public schools aimed to produce engaged citizens, not job-trained workers, and that recent decades have corrupted this humanist purpose. He examines the 1990s African debt crisis as a case study in how rational elites applied ever-narrower technical fixes that destroyed economies and democracies, only to apply identical approaches to Western nations after 2008. The conversation touches on corporate reform—how bylaws were gradually rewritten to legalize practices once prosecutable as fraud—and critiques universities for growing compartmentalized rather than integrative. Roberts pushes back with observations on Adam Smith's actual humanism, the confusion between management and leadership, and why economics operates more like history than mathematics. The speakers also debate whether fascism's rise from populism poses an imminent danger, whether doubt belongs in governance, and whether the financial crisis might have been better solved by writing off mortgages rather than bailing out banks.
Saul argues that the Enlightenment's elevation of reason from one human faculty to a supreme governing ideology has corrupted public life — producing amoral technocrats, hero-worship, hollowed-out education, and managerial elites — and that the remedy is a humanist balance of reason with ethics, intuition, common sense, and empathetic citizenship.
- Reason detached from other human qualities (ethics, intuition, imagination, common sense) becomes amoral methodology that deforms judgment.
- Rational methodology applied to governance produces technocratic elites, corporatism, and hero-worship rather than responsible individualism.
- Healthy societies require constant, effortful balance between engaged citizenship and restraints on all sectors — public and private alike.
Isolated rational methodology without ethical and human grounding becomes amoral and corrupts institutions and leadership.
- When rational methodology is corrupted by isolation from other human qualities it becomes amoral rather than immoral, which is far worse because immorality is at least something you can work with, whereas amorality — a denial of ethics, human purpose, and responsibility — is impossible to engage and is the same methodology that built Auschwitz and that makes trains run on time.
“the rational methodology corrupted becomes amoral. Not immoral--amoral. And I've gradually come to believe that, you know, immorality is at least something you can work with. Amorality is impossible.”
- Robert McNamara is one of the most interesting figures of the 20th century because he considered himself a humanist yet acted in no humanist way — using clever rational argument to skate around the responsibility he held without ever actually taking it — embodying the failure of rationality, in contrast to a more predictable figure like Kissinger.
“he never actually apologized for his errors but tried to skate very cleverly in a rational argument around the fact that he held a responsibility. He never actually took responsibility, because he thought of himself as a humanist, but actually did not act in any way as a humanist.”
- The Enlightenment thinkers promoted reason as a counterweight to superstition and ignorance, but the problem arose when reason was ripped from its broader context and placed on a Platonic throne above other equally valuable human qualities like ethics, intuition, common sense, and imagination; Voltaire himself treated reason as merely one tool among several, not the single truth.
“I don't think that Voltaire or any of the others would have imagined reason being put in a Platonic way on the throne and that everything else would be demoted beneath it. And the problem lies there.”
- The tight rational methodology of efficiency and structured management we adopted in the 1960s-70s, believing it new and born of 1870s-1880s managerial schools, actually descends from Cardinal Richelieu, who invented the monolithic Westphalian nation-state and pioneered secret services and information-gathering as instruments of control — making figures like Robert McNamara essentially 20th-century versions of a 17th-century French creation.
“one of the key ones was Cardinal Richelieu, who really invents the modern nation-state, the Westphalian nation-state... he creates something like the first modern approaches toward secret services and secrecy as methods of power and control--very relevant today.”
- Being offered a Manichean choice between reason and irrationality is artificial; there are many non-rational counterweights (ethics, intuition, imagination) that are not the same as being irrational, and an obsession with rational methodology forces everything through a linear, utilitarian process that deforms the human ability to act sensibly in crises — for example our half-century inability to respond to the environmental crisis.
“if you become obsessed by rationalism or reason then you start to construct everything around it and you are dragging everything through what you think is a rational methodology. Well, of course, imagination is not rational. Ethics is not rational. Intuition is not rational. So you are now deforming human intelligence”
Populism and corporatism signal fascism's return; accepting complexity and understanding facts' selective nature can lead toward humanism or authoritarianism.
- Tenure was created to let professors be fearless public voices in debate since they could not be fired, but it has often produced the opposite — an excuse to become a hermit and merely pay one's mortgage; the deeper flaw is that designing an employment structure to remove all risk after a 7-year hurdle will not attract risk-takers.
“in my mind tenure was created largely to give professors the ability to be public voices, because they couldn't be fired... And it's ended up being often the exact opposite, that it becomes an excuse to be a hermit.”
- Technology has advanced tremendously but humans remain the same — we think at roughly the same speed we always have, perhaps slightly slower as a counterweight to technology's speed — so the belief that we have become new men and women incapable of repeating atrocities like Auschwitz is incredibly naive.
“Technology is dumb machinery, and we think at approximately the same speed we've always thought. I actually think we might be thinking a little slower, as a weight counteracting the speed of the technology.”
- The growth of government secrecy is staggering: when the book was written the United States was creating roughly 5-6 million new secrets a year, a number Saul mocked as impossibly large, but it has since risen to around 54 million new secrets a year.
“I think the United States was creating about 5 million new secrets a year. Or 6... Now you are up to something like 54 million new secrets a year.”
- The strong return of populism in all countries including the United States is a precursor of fascism, because historically fascism's rise begins with populism — government through fear and manipulation of the citizen by forces attempting to take power — placing us in a dangerous but also opportune period.
“The return of populism at such a strong level in all countries, including the United States--those are the precursors of Fascism. Just look at the history of the last time it starts, with the rise of populism.”
- People are beginning to understand that facts do not produce truth — there are billions of facts and you choose which ones to support an argument — and grasping that understanding rather than a couple of facts is required leads back toward humanism, empathy, and the public good, though it could equally slide back toward fascism.
“people are starting to understand that facts do not produce truth. That there are billions of facts, and that you choose which facts you want in order to come up with an argument.”
- From the 1970s onward, changes in corporate bylaws and then laws gradually made legal things that had previously been illegal — for example employees running joint-stock companies paying themselves enormous benefits regardless of performance — practices that would have been prosecutable as fraud thirty years earlier, reflecting a utilitarian rationality that normalized 'that's just what you do.'
“things that were illegal were made legal inside corporations through changes in bylaws and then changes in laws. So that for example employees running joint stock companies could pretend they were capitalists and could pay themselves enormous benefits, whether they were doing well or not.”
- Rational elites mishandled the African debt crisis of the 1990s by treating debt as a moral rather than a technical issue and applying ever-narrower technical methodology, destroying what democracy existed, encouraging civil wars, and breaking economies in the name of repaying debts — until they wrote off much of the debt around 2003 and Africa began to recover; the same elites have learned nothing and are now applying the identical approach to Western nations in the recent crisis.
“they basically crucified Africa on the basis of rational methodology... they destroyed what democracy there was; they encouraged civil wars, they broke the economies down--all in the name of the need to repay the African debts.”
- Management schools are probably the single most dangerous organization in the Western world today because they create confusion and merely pretend to lead us somewhere when they have no idea where they are going, having replaced lawyers, priests, and soldiers as the big force of organized mediocrity.
“Probably the single most dangerous organization in the world today, in the western world today, is the management schools. Because they are just creating confusing.”
True leadership means embracing uncertainty and public good over heroic decisiveness, rejecting confusion between management and genuine leadership.
- Thomas Jefferson belonged to the humanist tradition because he took a non-solution-oriented, doubt-based approach to power — taking pride in keeping the United States out of war and understanding that the most important responsibility of holding power is not to do damage to what you are in charge of, recognizing that much of leadership is avoiding and getting out of things.
“There's this thing of when you have power, your most important responsibility is not to do damage to the thing you are in charge of. I think he understood that profoundly. So that is a non-solution-oriented approach.”
- The demand for heroic leaders partly stems from pushing hundreds of thousands of graduates out of management schools who confuse management with leadership, when the two are almost opposite — a confusion that is a central problem in business and in the management of national and international banks.
“we are shoving hundreds of thousands of kids out of management schools who have confused concepts of management with concepts of leadership, when they are, in a way, almost the opposite.”
- Complexity is a good thing because accepting it lets you look at complicated things and arrive at clear answers, whereas a hero-driven society hates complexity and has increasingly demeaned it as a failure of leadership over the past half-century.
“Complexity is a good thing. One of the problems with a hero-driven society is that it hates complexity.”
- A true leader is someone who knows how to talk about direction and uncertainty and the public good rather than interest — saying things like 'we're going to try this, it may not work, and if it doesn't, throw me out' — embracing a kind of public-good risk distinct from private-sector risk, because we are capable of more than self-interest.
“a leader is somebody who knows how to talk about direction and knows how to talk about uncertainty, and knows how to talk about the public good, as opposed to interest, always interest-based. We are capable of more than self-interest.”
Humanities have been corrupted by reduction to pseudo-sciences, stripping universities of cross-disciplinary thinking and integration.
- The humanities have been singled out as the enemy of reason and co-opted by being transformed into pseudo-sciences — architecture into quantitative technology, art history into technical evolution, and the social sciences into mathematical visions wrapped in obscure, hermetically sealed vocabularies — a reduction that future generations may regard as one of the greatest follies of our civilization.
“The reduction of politics, economics, social problems and the arts to mathematical visions and obscure, hermetically sealed vocabularies may well be looked upon by those who come after us as one of the greatest follies of our civilization.”
- Universities are becoming a bigger part of the problem not because students or professors lack intelligence, but because their structures have grown ever narrower and more compartmentalized, obstructing cross-collateral thinking; even interdisciplinary efforts mostly fail because they just juxtapose two bits of math or facts without genuine integration.
“It's because the structures which we've accepted, which again are extracted and are becoming narrower and narrower pieces of things, are getting in the way of our talking about what's going on and being able to think in an interesting cross-collateral way.”
- We are at the dangerous end of a written-obsessed society — having become victims of textual detail like 18th-century monks scribbling in margins — and the new technology is moving us in waves back toward an aural culture, which carries risks (populism thrives on it) but also great strengths because it can free up imagination, intuition, and empathy.
“we've come in a curious way to the dangerous end of a written-obsessed society. And this new technology is leading us back to towards the aural... there are also enormous advantages, because it can free up the imagination. It can free up intuition. It can free up empathy.”
Humanism rests on empathy and responsible individualism rather than self-interest or corporatism dominated by interest groups.
- In a sense Mussolini won the 20th century because his fascism rested on arguments by many Italian philosophers who rejected democracy based on responsible individualism in favor of corporatism — the view that people primarily belong to interest groups (unions, companies, even football teams) and that society's direction is set by negotiations between these groups — and the dominance of lobbying and interest groups in modern Western democracies shows that corporatism prevailed over the concept of the responsible individual citizen.
“the corporatist view that people primarily belong to groups, and groups are interest groups... when you look at the power of lobbying and the power of interest groups today in Western democracies, you realize the extent to which Mussolini's fascism won, and the concept of the responsible individual lost.”
- Because all humans are flawed, a healthy democracy needs restraints in every direction — on the private sector, the public sector, and ourselves — which is why the concept is 'responsible' individualism rather than wildcard individualism; this makes democracy exhausting daily work, far harder than living comfortably as the middle class under a semi-benign dictatorship.
“we need restraints on everything. We need restraints on the private sector. We need restraints on the public sector. We need restraints in every single direction on ourselves.”
- A healthy society depends not on loving fellow citizens — a meaningless notion since you do not even know them and may actively dislike them — but on empathy: the ability to imagine and feel what it is like to be the other, on the basis of which fair public programs and protections are built, with empathy dominant and selfishness subordinate.
“It isn't about love. It's about empathy. It's about the public good. It's about being able to imagine or feel... what it's like to be the other. And then, on that basis, you put in place both public programs and public protections which make for a fair society.”
Public goods require public structures with restraints and arm's-length governance, not privatization driven by profit motives.
- Delivering the public good requires public structures because handing it to the private sector makes corruption immediate and deep — the profit sector is rightly based on profit, not the public good — illustrated by privately held water being one of the world's most corrupt areas, where incoming money buys people off; remedies include arm's-length public institutions and rotating leadership.
“if you don't have them then basically you are handing it over to the private sector, and the private sector, when asked to look after the public good, is immediately and deeply corrupt.”
- In the financial crisis, rather than saving banks directly, the government could have taken an Athenian approach and written off all mortgages up to a threshold (say $300,000), stabilizing the home-owning working and middle classes, removing panic and unpayable debt, pushing that debt into banks to save the ones that could be saved, and relaunching the economy by enabling citizens to borrow again — saving citizens first rather than banks.
“the government is going to write off all mortgages in the United States up to $300,000... You've stabilized your home-owning class--so you've removed the essence of panic and despair... You've saved the banks that can be saved--by saving the citizens first.”
- The free market worked very well with high taxes in the 1950s, and lowering taxes over the last 30 years has not reliably produced growth, so simple ideas like 'just release people to do what they want' should be treated with suspicion because the real problem lies elsewhere.
“we know that the free market can work very, very well with high taxes, in the 1950s, right? We know that lowering taxes may or may not produce growth; as we've seen in the last 30 years, it really hasn't produced growth.”
Education's original humanist purpose was producing engaged citizens, not job training; reframing it utilitarian deforms that vision.
- Voltaire's Bastards is written backwards relative to a PhD — starting with a theory and using stories as illustrations rather than proofs — belonging to a pre-19th-century approach where there is no sharp divide between fact and fiction, because fiction is really about what truth should be, whereas facts are abundant and selectively chosen to prove a point.
“Fiction is really about truth, right? Fiction is about finding out what is truth should be. Whereas facts, there are lots of facts out there and you can choose a few to prove your point.”
- Economists largely misrepresent Adam Smith, who was a humanist who believed in the public good, citizenship, and how to use the market — yet in halls full of economists only about ten have read Wealth of Nations through and perhaps two have read The Theory of Moral Sentiments, most having read only assigned extracts.
“I go into halls where there are all these economists, and I say, How many of you have actually read Wealth of Nations all the way through? And you get like 10... How many of you have read The Theory of Moral Sentiments? You get two.”
- The original purpose of 19th-century public education in the US and Canada was to produce engaged citizens, not to train workers for jobs; poverty-stricken illiterate farmers wanted their children educated so they could be citizens, assuming financial benefit would follow but knowing it was not the purpose — and the last 30-40 years' utilitarian reinterpretation of education as job training is a deformation of that humanist idea.
“the principle concept of the public education system is: We need citizens... there's a misreading that's been going on in the last 30, 40 years, that the purpose of education is to train people to do jobs. A utilitarian interpretation.”