Becky Pettit on the Prison Population, Survey Data and African-American Progress
What this covers
Becky Pettit, author of Invisible Men, speaks with Russ Roberts about how the massive expansion of US incarceration has distorted the picture of African-American progress. The conversation centers on a methodological problem: major government surveys used to track social and economic trends—including the Current Population Survey that produces monthly unemployment figures—systematically exclude the incarcerated. Because those excluded from surveys are disproportionately the most disadvantaged people, their removal biases statistics toward looking better than reality. The US prison and jail population quintupled over 35 years to about 2.3 million on any given day, concentrated among young men with low education, particularly African Americans. Among young black male high school dropouts, an estimated two-thirds can expect to spend time in prison, compared to far lower rates for white dropouts.
Pettit traces how this exclusion corrupts major narratives of progress. Claims that the high school dropout rate among young black men has declined disappear once incarcerated men—who are disproportionately dropouts—are counted. Similarly, while absolute numbers of black voters in 2008 may have set records, the fraction of low-education black men voting remained flat from the 1980s, masked by Sample Selection Bias in standard measures. The conversation covers the causes of this expansion: not rising crime (which has fallen since the late 1960s) but shifts in policing, prosecution, mandatory minimum sentences, and parole revocation policy. Pettit and Roberts discuss how incarceration functions as the tail end of the education system, why censoring the most disadvantaged distorts understanding of inequality, and whether prevention through early education or drug treatment could reduce nonviolent incarceration more effectively than continued expansion.
Pettit argues that the massive, demographically concentrated growth in US incarceration systematically removes the most disadvantaged people (especially low-education young black men) from standard household surveys, so that widely cited measures of African-American progress are distorted and overstate gains.
- Incarceration quintupled over 35 years and is concentrated among young, low-education black men, with two-thirds of young black male dropouts expected to spend time in prison.
- Major surveys like the CPS exclude the incarcerated, who are disproportionately disadvantaged, biasing dropout, employment, and voter turnout statistics.
- Correcting for the excluded prison population shows no improvement in the black high school dropout rate and flat turnout among low-education black men.
Minimum wage policy prices low-skilled workers into informal and illegal markets, harming disadvantaged communities.
- Raising the minimum wage can price low-skilled labor out of the legal market and push workers into the 'uncovered sector' not subject to minimum wage—including crime—so in poor inner-city areas with weak education systems the minimum wage is among the ugly forces working against disadvantaged people.
“If it prices low-skilled labor out of the labor market, it encourages people to find what we economists call the 'uncovered sector.' The places you can work that aren't subject to the minimum wage. And crime is one of those.”
Incarceration depletes human capital and labor-force attachment, lowering wages and economic opportunity upon release.
- Spending years incarcerated depreciates a person's skills and labor-force attachment, so that even setting aside stigma, their wage rate and economic opportunities are lower upon release, which further worsens measured high school dropout earnings ratios because dropouts who went to prison are excluded from the data.
“if you get arrested and you are spending a few years in jail, it's not so good for your wage rate when you come out... if you were in the labor market obviously has decreased and your skill set is going to deteriorate a little bit.”