What this covers

Lisa Turner, an organic farmer, joins Russ Roberts to discuss the economics and realities of running Laughing Stock Farm. The conversation moves across her daily work, the regulatory and financial landscape she navigates, and what the term "organic" actually means—both as a legal category and as a farming practice. Turner grounds her argument in a central claim: small-scale organic farming is a business first, and it survives only through profitability, not through romantic notions of sustainability or consumer goodwill.

The discussion covers several layers of economic distortion and misunderstanding. Turner explains how the USDA's National Organic Program functions as a marketing system rather than a quality guarantee, and how Unintended Consequences emerge from government intervention—she details how renewable energy credits intended to help renewables actually harmed small-scale users by driving up the price of waste cooking oil. The conversation also touches on how subsidies, land-trust favoritism, and crop insurance reshape farmer incentives in ways that pick winners and losers. Beyond policy, Turner addresses common misconceptions: what CSA models actually offer, why locally-grown produce costs what it does, how Revealed Preference shapes what people eat versus what they claim to value, and what restaurant buyers want versus ordinary customers. Roberts raises questions about education, noting how Advanced Placement economics teaching prioritizes test answers over economic reasoning. The pair also work through the practical side—how nitrogen fixation and green manure build soil fertility, why early-morning harvest preserves quality, and why young job applicants often misunderstand that employment is an exchange benefiting both parties, not a subsidy for their education.

Sharpest takeaway

Turner argues that small-scale organic farming is fundamentally a capitalist business requiring profitability to survive, and that both consumers and would-be workers misunderstand this by romanticizing 'organic' and 'sustainable' while government programs distort the market by picking winners and losers.

  • Organic certification is a USDA marketing program, not a guarantee of superior food, and scale erodes quality
  • Government subsidies, credits, and land-trust favoritism distort competition and pick winners and losers
  • Sustainability fundamentally means earning enough money each year to farm again next year

The argument · threads4 threads · 18 claims
0.70

Farming sustainability depends fundamentally on the farmer earning enough profit this year to operate next year.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The first rule of sustainable agriculture is that the farmer must make enough money this year to do it again next year, or the operation ends; people prefer to associate 'sustainable' with natural products, direct sales, and windmills, but are uncomfortable confronting the financial profitability that actually makes farming sustainable.

    “the first rule of sustainability is I've got to make enough money this year to do it again next year, or game over. And nobody wants to hear that part of 'sustainable.'”

  • Working all seven days of the week is counterproductive because fatigue means it effectively yields the output of only twelve productive days, so she deliberately tries to take at least one weekend day off.

    “I try really hard not to work at least one weekend day. Because you work 7 days, it means you are going to work 12 days.”

  • Profit is simply the additional return owners deserve for risking their capital on uncertain investments—like greenhouses and equipment that might not pay off—rather than placing money safely in a bank; profit is not bad, but greed is bad, and greed exists in nonprofits, individuals, and corporations alike.

    “we've done this, and we're risking that--it may not work out... Don't we deserve a little more than what we could get in a bank by doing something safe?... Well, that's profit. And that's all that profit is.”

0.56

Small farms selling directly to restaurants and CSA customers operate on tacit agreements accepting mutual uncertainty and different buyer demands.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The relationship between the farm and restaurants runs on a tacit agreement in which the farmer tries to grow what restaurants want but neither side guarantees anything—the restaurant doesn't guarantee purchase and the farmer doesn't guarantee availability—because weather and demand variability mean supply cannot be assured.

    “It's part of the tacit agreement, is that I will try and grow what you want; you're not going to guarantee that you are going to buy it from me and I'm not going to guarantee that I have it.”

  • Restaurant buyers and individual CSA members have systematically different demand: restaurants buy far more salad greens (since restaurant meals include salads while home meals do not), prefer novel and visually distinctive products like broccoli rabe, colored carrots, and heirloom tomatoes for their cachet, whereas ordinary CSA customers tend to want familiar produce.

    “if you go to a restaurant you are probably going to have a salad... Whereas people don't necessarily have salad at home every night. So there's a whole lot more salad-type greens that are sold to the restaurants”

  • A Community Supported Agriculture model has customers prepay for a share and receive whatever is ready each week; customers give up individual choice but receive more total volume of product than they would pay for at a farm stand, while the farmer benefits from upfront capital for what is a startup business every year.

    “if you are going to give me money ahead of time, you are getting more in your share than what I charge at the farm stand”

0.56

Organic production uses naturally-derived inputs and labor-intensive timing to grow nutritionally dense vegetables with superior flavor.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Organic farming does not mean avoiding fertilizer or spraying; rather it means using naturally-derived (non-synthetic) inputs—building soil fertility through green manure crops, legumes that fix nitrogen, and rock-derived minerals, and spraying biological pesticides—so that healthy, fully-nourished plants resist diseases that arise from nutrient deficiencies.

    “The goal of organic is that you are growing healthy crops that then don't get these diseases. There's a lot of plant diseases that are based on nutrient deficiencies. So, you want to get the full nutrient picture in there, then you'll have healthy plants that don't get the disease problem.”

  • Vegetables must be harvested early in the morning because overnight they take up water in cooler conditions, producing greater turgor pressure and rigidity in leaves like lettuce; the same leaf cut at 1pm in the heat will look wilted immediately, so early harvest plus prompt cooling preserves quality.

    “the vegetables suck up water overnight; it's cooler; they get more--it's called 'turgor pressure'--it's more rigidity to like a lettuce leaf first thing in the morning than there would be if it's hot out.”

  • Locally-grown, small-batch mixed vegetables taste better than organic produce from large distant farms because the broad spectrum of soil nutrients develops flavor compounds (including sweetness with a scientific basis), and a small farm of mixed crops cannot be managed as effectively at the scale of thousands of acres of a single crop.

    “I don't think you can manage 10,000 acres of carrots... or a 1000 acres of carrots as effectively as I can manage my 10 acres of mixed vegetables. The taste certainly would say that they don't.”

0.44

Government programs that pick winners distort farm competition; affordability is choice-based and organic certification is purely a marketing label.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • From the USDA's perspective, organic certification is fundamentally a marketing program: certified farms may legally market produce as 'organic' while uncertified farms cannot, regardless of practices, so the label confers a marketing right rather than verifying a way of life.

    “So, from USDA's point of view, it's a marketing program.”

  • Locally-grown organic produce can be priced reasonably—a head of lettuce for the same price as conventional supermarket lettuce—and for many people affording it is a matter of choice rather than income, since giving up something like cable TV would free up more than enough money, but people allocate resources according to what they value.

    “if everybody gave up cable TV they could easily afford to buy my vegetables for the summer. They would have money to spare. They are not going to give up cable TV.”

  • Government agricultural assistance programs distort competition by picking winners and losers—for example awarding one free greenhouse per county, or directing NRCS conservation money toward land-trust farms and new young farmers—creating unfairness to those who don't receive aid and competition against subsidized operations that pay far-below-market rents.

    “Picking winners and losers. I've heard you talk about that a lot, and these things absolutely do that. One of the programs, like, one person in each county gets a free greenhouse. Like how do you pick that?”

  • Federal renewable energy credits, which apply to large-scale transportation biofuels but not to small stationary heating users like her farm, created a market in which brokers sell renewable energy credits to oil companies; this drove up the price of used cooking oil from free (with restaurants paying to dispose of it) to about $1.50 a gallon, illustrating how government 'help' for renewables hurt a genuine small renewable user.

    “So that's driven the price of used cooking oil up. When we started, which was like 2002, 2003, all the restaurants paid... to get rid of the used cooking oil... Well, at this point the rendering companies are paying $1.50 a gallon for used cooking oil from restaurants.”

  • Insurance policies' fine print is never what policyholders expect, people rarely read their policies, and even if they did they likely would not understand them—so when their barn burned down in 2003 they rebuilt without relying on the insurance company.

    “Not with the insurance company--because the fine print is never what you expect. Nobody ever reads their insurance policy. And even if you did, I don't think you'd understand it.”

  • Employing workers must be a mutually beneficial arrangement: the employer hires workers because their presence is expected to generate more money than they cost, and young first-time workers must learn that work is not for their benefit like camp or school but an exchange of labor for pay that profits both parties.

    “This is: You are going to work, and at the end of the week I'm going to give you money; and I expect that because you are here, I will make more money... Why would I have you here if I wasn't going to end up with more money?”