What this covers

Bob Frank and Russ Roberts debate whether the federal government should finance a large infrastructure program through a bipartisan commission during a period of economic slack and cheap borrowing. The conversation, conducted by Alex Blumberg of NPR's Planet Money in 2012, presents a clash over Investment vs Consumption Debt, the trustworthiness of government, and whether Keynesian Stimulus works in practice. Frank argues that deferring repairs costs more later—citing a Nevada stretch of I-80 that would cost $6 million now but $30 million in two years—making immediate spending a form of savings rather than waste. Roberts pushes back on virtually every piece: government already spends heavily at all levels, the political process cannot be trusted to pick only worthwhile projects, and there is no solid evidence of trillions in high-return projects waiting to be built.

The pair diverge sharply on evidence and diagnosis. Frank points to top-ranked governance countries that spend more on public goods per capita than the United States, arguing American skepticism of government creates a Self-Fulfilling Prophecy that drives competent people away from public service—offering the Ithaca DMV's transformation under Aurora Valenti as proof of concept. Roberts counters with Japan's $6 trillion in infrastructure spending between 1991 and 2006, which left the country unhappy and deeply indebted. He also questions whether the 2009 stimulus and European fiscal austerity settle anything, noting the Congressional Budget Office has admitted measuring the counterfactual is too difficult. The conversation touches on Coercion vs Voluntary Exchange, the weight of Conflict of Interest / Vested Interest in expert claims, and whether Model vs Empirical Evidence favors either position—ending without resolution but with both sides' core disagreements laid bare.

Sharpest takeaway

Frank argues a large, debt-financed infrastructure program chosen by a bipartisan commission would put idle workers and capital back to work and repair a failing system while borrowing and materials are cheapest; Roberts counters that government already spends ample money, the political process won't faithfully target only worthwhile projects, and there is no reliable evidence of trillions in unfunded high-return projects.

  • Frank claims deferring repairs raises future costs dramatically (e.g. $6M now vs $30M in two years), so spending now is net savings, not waste.
  • Roberts claims spending at all government levels has steadily risen, so binding budget constraints, not anti-government ideology, are not what blocks urgent repairs.
  • Both disagree on whether the 2009 stimulus and European 'austerity' provide evidence for or against Keynesian infrastructure spending.

The argument · threads6 threads · 44 claims
0.72

Infrastructure investment now costs least and yields fastest returns due to unemployed workers, cheap materials, and record-low financing rates.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Now is the cheapest time to do infrastructure projects because unemployed skilled workers and idle machines are available, materials are cheaper than they'll ever be in world markets, and financing is the cheapest in history with 10-year Treasury rates at record lows.

    “Right now there are people unemployed who know how to do that work. There are machines sitting idle in the yards... The materials we would need to do the job are cheaper than they'll ever be in world markets... interest rates on 10-year Treasury Bills are lower than they've been in history.”

  • Eliminating a couple of bottlenecks on the I-95 Northeast rail corridor—where low-clearance bridges block double-decker train cars and force truck traffic onto I-95—would cost about $6 billion but cut costs by $12 billion, making the country net wealthier by spending the money.

    “You can't get double decker train cars underneath low clearance bridges on the rail line going up the Northeast corridor. It would cost something like $6 billion to eliminate those bottlenecks; but the moment you did that, you'd cut costs by $12 billion. That's a savings on net. We are wealthier if we spend that money.”

  • Fixing a road for $6 million now instead of $30 million in two years produces no losers and only winners—everyone ends up richer—so the proposal should be uncontroversial.

    “There are no losers here. There are only winners. If we fix a road for $6 million now instead of spending $30 million in two years, there are no losers from that process. Everybody ends up richer.”

  • When infrastructure repairs are postponed beyond a certain point their cost rises very rapidly; for example a 10-mile stretch of I-80 in Nevada costs $6 million to repair now but is estimated to cost $30 million if repair waits two years, so doing it now is net savings rather than wasted money.

    “if we were to repair that stretch today, we could do it for $6 million... If we wait two years--just 2 years--they estimate that the cost of bringing that road up to code will rise from $6 million... to $30 million”

  • A rail expert's report (publicized by Matt Yglesias on Slate) identified a low-cost alternative to Amtrak's proposed $150 billion Northeast Corridor investment that would cut Boston-New York-Washington travel times almost as much for less than 10% of the cost, yielding huge short-run returns while putting people back to work.

    “read Matt Yglesias's report from a rail expert that identified a very low-cost alternative to Amtrak's proposal to spend $150 billion on the Northeast Rail Corridor... investments that would get travel times between Boston, New York, and Washington down, almost as far as the next bigger investment for less than 10% of the money.”

0.65

The economy suffers severe demand shortfall requiring spending stimulus, not austerity, to restore employment and output during recession.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • You do not engage in fiscal austerity when the economy suffers a severe demand downturn; austerity has a negative effect on the economy in the short run during a recession, and you instead bring revenues and spending into balance in the long run.

    “You did not engage in fiscal austerity when the economy is suffering from a severe demand downturn... Austerity is a negative effect on the economy in the short run, when you are in a recession.”

  • We are in the fourth year of a demand-shortfall recession in which millions are out of work because not enough is being spent to generate demand for as many people as want jobs.

    “we're here in the fourth year of a demand shortfall recession. There are millions of people out of work. For the simple reason that not enough is being spent to generate demand for as many people as want jobs.”

  • At the financial crisis output and employment were falling faster than at the onset of the Great Depression, with a forecast demand shortfall of $2 trillion per year, yet the stimulus was only $787 billion spread over three years—far too small to remedy the shortfall it targeted.

    “The forecast at the time was that we faced a demand shortfall of $2 trillion a year. The stimulus package... was for a total of $787 billion spread out over three years. Economists were warning at the time that it was nowhere up to the size necessary”

0.57

The 2009 stimulus failed not because infrastructure investment doesn't work but because the bill was too small and relied on ineffective tax cuts.

9 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The infrastructure component of the 2009 stimulus bill was quite small due to political wrangling, with much of the bill taking the form of ineffective tax cuts, so the claim that we tried infrastructure stimulus and it failed is a fiction.

    “No, the infrastructure component of the bill was quite small because of the political wrangling that led to the bill. Much of it was in the form of ineffective tax cuts.”

  • If you worry that debt means we can't afford these projects, you should be more worried that not undertaking them bequeaths a much bigger debt to our grandchildren, because economizing by skipping projects that need doing is false economy.

    “you really ought to be worried that if we don't take on projects like these we're going to have a much, much bigger debt to bequeath to our grandchildren. The whole idea of trying to economize by not doing projects that need to be done is false economy.”

  • The mantra that no government, business, or family can spend more than it takes in is false in the short run and when spending on investment; like a family borrowing $4,000-$5,000 to insulate an attic that saves $100/month, going into debt for an investment that yields larger savings leaves you better off month by month, so investment debt does not impoverish your grandchildren.

    “It's a very common mantra to say that neither the government nor business nor a family can spend more than it takes in... No! Not in the short run, and not when we are talking about investment. Here's a family thinking about whether to put insulation in its attic... if their utility bills will go down by $100 a month if they do the project, then what's the argument against doing it?”

  • Government spending is high not because of sustainable program growth but because the recession triggered automatic transfers—Medicaid increases as people lose insurance, long-term unemployment insurance, and other safety-net spending—which are dollars that go off the books once the economy recovers.

    “government is now spending an enormous amount on Medicaid increases because people are out of work and don't have medical insurance; they are spending on long-term unemployment insurance. There are all sorts of transfers that are triggered in the social safety net... Those are dollars that will go off the books once the economy recovers.”

  • Unlike infrastructure, one couldn't find credible experts to claim $2 trillion in education spending would save trillions later, because most studies show the amount spent per pupil has a very difficult-to-detect relationship with educational outcomes.

    “most of the studies on education suggest that the amount of money you spend per pupil has a very difficult-to-detect relationship with educational outcomes. I think that's the kind of claim that wouldn't withstand scrutiny.”

  • A bipartisan committee, given the engineers' report and locked in a room, should identify which projects should NOT be undertaken immediately, with all remaining projects greenlit and opened to bids by private firms, states, or municipalities; this depoliticizes which projects are legitimate.

    “Put a bipartisan committee in a locked room; have them take the American Society of Civil Engineers' Report with them, and let them identify the projects they don't think should be undertaken right away. All the rest get the green light.”

  • The current logjam is driven by the filibuster: since the Senate Minority Leader stated his caucus's main priority was preventing Obama's reelection, a 60-vote infrastructure bill that would put people back to work and boost reelection chances would predictably be filibustered, so eliminating the filibuster should be the Senate's first order of business.

    “Recall months ago the Senate Minority Leader, Mitch McConnell, said: The main priority of his caucus was to see that President Obama was not reelected... Might it occur to Mitch McConnell to instruct his caucus members to filibuster against that bill so that it needs 60 votes to pass?”

  • By international standards the US has a very small public sector that has grown mainly because the retiring baby-boomer Medicare generation and Social Security consume a larger GDP share for demographic reasons; factoring that out and comparing to other nations, the US is on a downward trajectory relative to the norm.

    “By international standards, we have a very small public sector. It has grown over time because the Medicare generation has gotten much, much bigger with the baby boomers retiring... if you factor all of that out and look at us versus other nations, we have seen a downward trajectory relative to the norm, and that's a fact.”

  • Government cuts what it can rather than what it should, because politicians first ask how loudly a program's supporters will scream; thus the Bush era cut low-profile but vital programs—securing poorly guarded Soviet nuclear materials and National Science Foundation research—precisely because no constituency complained, eroding America's competitive advantage.

    “when a program is are under consideration for being cut, the first thing that politicians ask is: How loud are the supporters of this program going to scream?... what we cut during the Bush era was, number 1, the Energy Department's program for rounding up poorly guarded nuclear materials in the former Soviet Union... We cut the budget for the research funding for the National Science Foundation.”

0.55

Government skepticism is self-defeating: good people flee public service, but effective management and proper incentives prove government can deliver quality.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • It is a mistake to assume the private sector is immune from imperfection; transferring planes on US Airways in the Philadelphia Airport will destroy any faith that the private sector is more efficient than the public sector, as workplace dysfunction satirized in Dilbert is founded on real episodes.

    “I think it's a mistake to just assume that the private sector is just immune from imperfection. Have you ever transferred in the Philadelphia Airport from one plane to another on U.S. Airways? You will abandon any faith that the private sector is more efficient than the public sector once you do that.”

  • Transparency International surveys consistently rank about 10 high-income countries (Scandinavian nations, Australia, New Zealand, Canada) at the top for quality of public goods and low corruption, while the US ranks around 25th despite being richer per capita than any of them—because American skepticism of government makes it hard to recruit good people into public service.

    “There's a group called Transparency International (TI) in Berlin... There are about 10 countries that consistently score at the top... We rank about 25th on that list. All the other countries at the top are high income countries. We are richer than any of them in per capita terms. And we're very skeptical of government; and we have built an environment in which it's very difficult to recruit good people to work in government.”

  • Bashing government as inevitably corrupt is a self-fulfilling prophecy that steers good people away; the Ithaca DMV transformed from a rude, slow nightmare into a pleasure to deal with after County Clerk Aurora Valenti let clerks both take money and process forms and gave them sales and personality training, demonstrating that government can be made effective rather than merely starved.

    “about 20 years ago, Aurora Valenti was elected Republican County Clerk... She made special arrangements with Albany that the clerks who took your money could also process your forms... She gave them sales and personality training... And lo and behold now, this DMV that we have is a pleasure to deal with.”

  • The ten countries at the top of the governance list all spend more per capita in the public sphere than the US, have well-maintained roads and bridges that don't collapse, universal health insurance access, and a well-ordered public sector where the rich don't feel oppressed and people seem happy—suggesting it's time to rethink how big a problem government is.

    “The 10 countries at the top of the list all spend more in the public sphere on a per capita basis than we do. Their roads are well-maintained for the most part; their bridges don't collapse. Everyone has access to health insurance. They've got a well-ordered public sector... So, it's time to rethink how big a problem government is.”

0.45

Federal government must lead because states cannot run deficits constitutionally and have no access to cheap capital markets.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Telling states to do these projects misses the point of public finance: states must run balanced budgets under their constitutions and cannot run deficits, whereas the federal government currently has access to the cheapest capital ever available in the world.

    “States are not allowed to run deficits. They must run balanced budgets under their constitutions. It's the Federal Government that right now has access to the cheapest capital that's ever been available in the world.”

0.45

Infrastructure neglect poses real safety risks with thousands of deteriorating projects awaiting authorization and funding.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Many bridges are in roughly the same condition the I-35 bridge over the Mississippi near Minneapolis was in when it collapsed, with thousands of projects awaiting only authorization, so infrastructure neglect poses real safety risks.

    “Has anyone read any of the independent reports about the number of bridges that are, roughly speaking, in the same condition that the bridge that collapsed over I-35 on the way into Minneapolis was in when it collapsed? There are just thousands of projects waiting to be done that need only the authorization to be done.”