Paul Tough on How Children Succeed
What this covers
This is a conversation between economist Russ Roberts and journalist Paul Tough about the psychological traits that predict success in school and life. Tough argues that non-cognitive skills—chiefly conscientiousness, self-control, and what psychologist Angela Duckworth calls "grit"—matter as much or more than IQ for long-term outcomes. The discussion moves from research showing that self-control predicts middle-school grades better than IQ test performance, through the neuroscience of how these traits develop in relationships with demanding adults, to the practical question of whether schools and nonprofits can reliably build them at scale.
The conversation ranges across three domains: the psychology of achievement, specific interventions that appear to work, and the stubborn problem of policy. Tough explores how character might be reframed as habit rather than fixed trait, making self-improvement feel possible. He discusses how demanding teachers like Elizabeth Spiegel and high-performing charter networks like KIPP succeed by cultivating extreme conscientiousness through group motivation. He and Roberts examine Geoffrey Canada's Harlem Children's Zone, a wraparound intervention addressing all dimensions of poverty at once. The harder terrain concerns whether such successes can be replicated through government. President Obama's Promised Neighborhoods initiative receives scrutiny for its gap between ambition and funding. Roberts and Tough debate whether government can spend money wisely on poverty at scale, with Roberts skeptical and Tough identifying a real resource problem: concentrated poverty attracts philanthropic funding where billionaires live, but leaves other cities without similar support.
Tough argues that non-cognitive skills--conscientiousness, self-control, and especially 'grit'--are at least as predictive of children's long-term success as IQ, and that these skills can be developed, particularly through close relationships with demanding adults, with major implications for how we fight concentrated poverty.
- Self-control predicts middle-school GPA better than IQ, and conscientiousness predicts adult outcomes like income and marriage
- Character is closer to habit, which can be changed, usually within relationships with motivating adults
- Interventions like KIPP, the chess program at IS 318, and the Harlem Children's Zone build these skills, but scaling them via government spending is uncertain
Government spending on poverty and education fails because government cannot spend money well.
- The biggest mistake in anti-poverty and education policy is assuming that more money means more results, which we know is false, so success depends on how money is spent--and it is extremely hard for government to spend that money well, making the goal of forcing better government spending possibly too difficult to achieve.
“the biggest mistake we've made in anti-poverty and education is assuming that more money means more results. We know that's not true. So it has to be true that it's how the money is spent.”
- The book opens by saying we have been looking for results--childhood success, fighting poverty, helping kids escape poverty and get education--in the wrong places.
“You open your book by saying we've been looking for results in the wrong places.”
External motivation from admired figures builds durable habits despite criticism of unsustainability.
- Some great teachers are great because of a unique ability to make an individual want to please them--an external motivation that has become frowned upon as unsustainable by critics like Alfie Kohn, but which helps build the habits that lead to durable improvement.
“some great teachers are great because they have a unique ability to motivate an individual to want to please them. It's an external motivation that's become frowned on by Alfie Kohn”
- While people change habits all the time and society has shifted behaviors like seatbelt use and smoking, the small habits are easier to change than the big ones, and changing a habit for good--rather than for a while--is dramatically harder and poorly understood, as Mark Twain's quip about quitting smoking a dozen times illustrates.
“Changing habits for a while is relatively easy. It's changing them for good that is I think is dramatically harder and we don't know that much about it.”
Voluntary civil-society organizations funded by donation work better when government withdraws from poverty.
- The lesson of the book's success stories is that change comes from individuals voluntarily creating non-profit organizations in civil society funded by voluntary giving; the more government tries to solve poverty with taxpayer dollars, the less incentive people have to create those organizations and to donate, so government should get out of the poverty business and let the best organizations thrive and the worst fall away.
“What works is letting a bunch of individuals creatively create their own organizations in a civil society, voluntarily, collecting money from people voluntarily; and let those people blossom and bloom.”
Motivation determines real-world performance more than ability scores in contexts lacking external incentive.
- Although 97 is arguably a child's 'real' IQ when motivated, the lower unmotivated score of 79 may be the more useful measure because many real-life tasks are not incentivized--you either do them well or you don't--so the unmotivated score captures the consequential fact that a person won't try without external motivation.
“maybe the 79 is the right measure to use because that captures the fact that if they are not highly motivated, they just don't try.”