David Owen on Parenting, Money, and the First National Bank of Dad
What this covers
David Owen, author of The First National Bank of Dad, joins Russ Roberts to examine how children actually learn about money and what methods make it stick. Owen's core argument runs against most parental instinct: rather than lecturing children about prudence or forcing them into conventional savings accounts, the most effective teaching comes from giving kids real money to control, paired with incentives they can actually feel. The conversation moves from the psychology of spending—why children are thoughtful with their own money but reckless with their parents'—through concrete household experiments Owen conducted, including an in-house savings bank paying 5% monthly interest and a scaled-down shadow stock market using pennies instead of full share prices.
The episode ranges across several linked territory. Owen describes how learning through low-cost mistakes works best when young, using his son's beanie-baby bubble experience as a case study: the boy bought high, refused to sell during the craze, and learned hard truths about markets for almost no real money. The discussion addresses why traditional bank accounts fail—the interest rate and time horizon offer no perceptible incentive—and why harness vs. thwart human nature matters more than most parents recognize. Roberts adds considerations around negotiation patterns, school stock-market contests that reward volatility, and the outsized value of reading aloud to children. Both speakers touch on sufficiency and true net worth as concepts that matter more than accumulation, and how supply and demand principles apply even to household money. The episode closes on literacy as foundational software underlying everything else a child learns.
Owen argues that the best way to teach children about money is to harness human nature rather than thwart it: by giving kids real control over their own money and incentives that operate on a timescale they can perceive (like a high in-house interest rate), they naturally learn saving, delayed gratification, and the value of money through low-cost mistakes.
- Conventional savings accounts fail children because the interest rate and time horizon offer no perceptible incentive
- Children spend their own money far more carefully than other people's money, including their parents'
- Costly real-world lessons (bubbles, bad purchases) teach durable financial humility cheaply when experienced young
Real financial incentives aligned with children's time perception drive saving and investment behavior better than traditional accounts.
- If you give children incentives that genuinely feel like incentives to them, they will do what human nature tells them to do; it is better to harness human nature than to try to change it, whereas most parental attempts to teach kids about money actually amount to thwarting human nature and bending children to the parents' will.
“if we give children incentives that seem like incentives to them, they will do what human nature tells them to do. I think the general lesson is that it's better to harness human nature than to change it”
- Traditional bank savings accounts fail to motivate children because the interest rate is remarkably low and the time horizon is unimaginably long for a child, so the account offers no incentive that feels like an incentive to them; a child's disinterest reflects an acute understanding that they are getting a raw deal, not ignorance.
“It was only later... that I realized that her disappointment was not about her ignorance about money but about her acute understanding of it. And that she was getting a raw deal; and it didn't make any sense.”
- By paying his children a 5% monthly interest rate (roughly a 70% annual percentage rate) on deposits in an in-house savings bank, Owen made their money grow at a rate they could actually notice on a timescale that felt reasonable to them, which immediately turned both children into savers who grasped compound interest intuitively.
“what I ultimately did was create a bank account in my house, a savings bank, in my house, in which I paid them an interest rate of 5% a month on their deposits. That works out to an annual percentage rate of something like 70%.”
- To let children participate in the stock market without worthless fantasy games or transaction costs that annihilate returns, Owen created a shadow market that converted real stock prices into pennies (a $40 share traded at $.40) with himself taking the other side of every transaction, seeding the kids with $250 of six familiar companies so the psychological barrier to entry was lower.
“what I did was create a kind of shadow market, where you used real stock prices but converted dollars into pennies. So, if a share of stock on the NY Stock Exchange was selling for $40, it sold for $.40 on my stock exchange.”
- As his children became successful savers and reached babysitting age, the 5% monthly rate became unrealistic, so Owen reduced it to 3%, explaining that the law of supply and demand applies to the supply of money as well; the children accepted it because they had no better alternative and had already accumulated significant balances.
“5% a month became unrealistic, and I had to explain to them that the law of supply and demand applied to the law of supply of money as well. And announced that I was reducing my monthly interest rate to 3%.”
Children become thoughtful decision-makers when spending their own money, not others', teaching frugality and asset awareness organically.
- When children spend their own money they become genuinely thoughtful purchasers without any lecturing, as illustrated by Owen's son who, unlike a friend who threw a tantrum for a rubber tomahawk, carefully negotiated to buy a single geode for $.33 because the money was his.
“he actually decided that he wanted to buy an unopened geode for $.33... he actually negotiated with the woman who ran the store; he wanted her to break up a set and sell him just one of them for $.33, because he thought the two extras were superfluous.”
- People are very careful when spending their own money and much less careful when spending other people's money, and this applies to children too: kids are reckless with their parents' money but thoughtful with their own, just as a CEO might skim shareholders' equity for a corporate jet or a government agency spends without restraint.
“We tend to be very careful when we spend our own money; we're much less careful when we spend other people's money. And that applies to kids too. My kids, when they were young, couldn't have been more reckless when they were spending my money, but when they were spending theirs, they were very thoughtful.”
- Letting children sell things on eBay teaches them that their possessions have value and are capital, transforming how they view their belongings; toys, games, and bicycles begin to look like assets rather than litter, which makes children more careful with their stuff and even leads them to save packaging.
“Suddenly their things began to look like assets to them rather than just sort of the litter in their room. And they were more careful with their stuff.”
- We learn about money the way we learn about anything, by making a series of gradually less catastrophic mistakes and through trial and error discovering what works, so children who lack their own money and must beg for every dollar have no incentive to consider the consequences of buying something foolish.
“I think we learn about money the way we learn about anything, which is by making a series of gradually less catastrophic mistakes, and eventually by trial and error seeing what works and what doesn't.”
Reading and literacy are the most valuable investments parents can make, underpinning intellectual development and life success.
- The best investment parents can make in their children is reading to them, because the easiest way to give kids a solid intellectual education is to help them become good readers from when they are very young and for as long as they can stand it, getting them addicted to books in a way that lasts their whole life.
“the easiest way to give kids a solid intellectual education in school is to help them become good readers, and the easiest way to help them become good readers from when they are very young and as long as they can stand it.”
- Children's literature, especially as children get older, beats almost anything on the adult shelf, providing huge benefits to parents who get to re-read beloved books and discover new ones.
“children's literature, especially as you get older, beats almost anything on the adult shelf. There are huge benefits to the parents, too.”
- Your language ability is your most important 'software' and underlies almost everything; even the math SAT is in part a verbal and vocabulary test because you must be able to read, so literary skills matter just as much in the sciences, and investing in a child's ability to learn and enjoy is more valuable than building an estate for them to squander.
“Your most important software is your language ability, what distinguishes us from who knows what.”
- Introductory economics is essentially a course in psychology and human behavior that explains much of what you need to know about human nature and geopolitics, making it the most valuable and transformative introductory course, even though economics beyond the introductory level becomes statistics and math that lose this explanatory poetry.
“Introductory Economics is really psychology. It's a course in psychology.”
Parents teach about money constantly through behavior and modeling; true wealth lies in understanding sufficiency and maximizing satisfaction.
- It is easiest to teach children about money in the middle-income range, hardest for both the poor and the rich: poverty is not much of a teacher because everything is necessity with nothing to learn, while at the rich end it is hard to create the artificial scarcity needed to make financial decisions feel meaningful.
“I think it's hardest for the poor and the rich to teach their kids about money. The first because poverty is not much of a teacher. There's not much to learn; it's all necessity. And at the rich end, it's hard to create the kind of artificial scarcity that you need to make decisions seem as though they mean anything.”
- Money is a necessary tool to finance a good life, but we should measure ourselves not by net worth but by something like 'true net worth' tied to satisfaction; on an hour-for-hour basis it is entirely possible to take as much or more satisfaction from life as Bill Gates does, while greed treated as an end in itself is like an addiction that can never be satisfied.
“the healthy attitude about money is that it's a tool, it's a necessary tool, that you use to make yourself happy.”
- When teaching children about saving, parents tend to stress only the deprivation side and fail to explain that there is a reward on the other end; saving is valuable because delaying gratification can actually increase net pleasure over the long run, just as adults save for retirement to maximize lifetime satisfaction rather than to make life hard now.
“when we tell kids about saving we tend to stress the deprivation side of it and not really explain that there's something on the other end, too”
- Having a clear understanding of sufficiency is often the key to maximizing happiness; rather than putting all your chips on a future square you may never reach, since people can be struck down at 64 just before retirement, it is better to allocate time and resources to maximize satisfaction as you go along.
“somehow making yourself have an understanding, a clear understanding, of sufficiency. And I think that sufficiency is often the key to maximizing happiness.”
- Parents teach their children about money constantly through how they talk and behave, not just through deliberate lessons; when parents sweat over credit card balances, fear collection-agency calls, or come home angry, they are teaching children about money, which makes it valuable to step outside and observe how you are handling it.
“We talk about teaching our kids about money constantly. And not necessarily the lessons we want them to learn. When you sweat over credit card balances; when you are afraid to answer the phone because you think it might be a collection card agency... all these things, we are teaching kids about money.”
- A study found that people made more intelligent decisions about their retirement savings when they were shown an artificially aged picture of themselves, because it made their future retirement tangible, suggesting that forcing yourself to confront mortality and the finiteness of time can improve life decisions about how to allocate time.
“people made more intelligent decisions about their retirement savings when they were looking at a picture of themselves, artificially aged--looked like they were retirement age. It became tangible to them.”
Children learn valuable market lessons through low-cost trial and error, not through school contests that reward the wrong behaviors.
- Owen's son learned the most valuable lesson about markets not from the stock market but from beanie babies: after selling two well-worn bears for $120.50 on eBay during the fad and then refusing to sell his collection because he believed markets only go up, he experienced both ends of a bubble at very low cost, learning the same lesson grownups learned in the late 1990s that markets do not always go up.
“the place where my son learned the most valuable lesson about the stock market didn't involve the stock market at all. It involved beanie babies.”
- School stock-market contests, where students make imaginary investments and are judged a month later on who is ahead, teach everything wrong about investing because they reward extreme volatility and all-or-nothing gambling on a one-month horizon, which is the opposite of how good long-term investors like Warren Buffett operate.
“that kind of contest teaches everything wrong about investing. It is not the way Warren Buffett does it. And it encourages a sort of all-or-nothing gamble, where you want extreme volatility; you are only worried about a month from now; it encourages you to roll the dice.”