What this covers
Gary Belsky, Editor-in-Chief of ESPN The Magazine, sits down with Russ Roberts to reflect on his path through journalism and the practical work of running a major American magazine. The conversation weaves together Belsky's early training as a business journalist with his current editorial leadership, tracing how lessons from financial reporting—exactness, mathematical literacy, and the ability to tell complex stories clearly—apply across the whole field. The core argument centers on what a modern magazine actually sells: not the commodity data now free online, but a distinctive collective sensibility and a curated reading experience that print, in particular, provides.
The discussion spans several territories. Belsky applies concepts from behavioral economics to explain reader behavior, particularly how choice overload on the web creates anxiety that a bounded print product dissolves. He contrasts this with the paradox facing any publication that wants to stay in business: telling readers to hold steady—the financially sound advice from return chasing research—makes for unmarketable magazine copy. Elsewhere, Belsky describes the unglamorous reality of magazine management (mostly budget and staff work, rarely creative ecstasy), explains ESPN's strategy of mixing sports natives with non-sports enthusiasts to avoid insularity, and develops his theory of trivia—the idea that the best trivia questions either delight you with new knowledge or make you feel you should have known it already. Along the way, he surfaces a distinction between surface-level online meanness and the social filters that normally restrain people's behavior.
Belsky argues that a successful magazine like ESPN The Magazine sells a distinctive editorial point of view and a curated, delightful 'magazine experience' rather than commodity data, and that lessons from business journalism and behavioral economics explain both editorial strategy and reader behavior.
- Commodity sports data is now free online, so a magazine must differentiate via a unique collective editorial sensibility
- Readers value the print product partly because limiting choice reduces the anxiety the web creates
- Business journalism trains exactness and storytelling that transfer across all journalism
Quality journalism and distinctive editorial voice make a publication indispensable to readers and advertisers alike.
- If you make the product well, even the advertisers you offend with negative stories will eventually have to come back, because the quality of the journalism makes the publication indispensable.
“If you guys keep doing this kind of journalism, they're going to have to come back. Taught me an important lesson: if you make the product well, even the people you are offending will have to be back eventually.”
- ESPN The Magazine is distinctive because it is not really a sports magazine in the traditional sense; it takes sports seriously but treats sports as part of an entertainment continuum, aiming to replicate the joking, conversational way people experience sports in bars, living rooms, and dorms.
“ESPN distinctive because it's not really a sports magazine. Different things to different people. We take sports seriously because most of our subscribers do; but take sports as part of an entertainment continuum.”
- ESPN The Magazine has thrived in print by remaining committed to the magazine experience—elevating the print version to meet or exceed the level that entices advertisers and making it more luxurious by focusing on images, stories, and design—even as the television side of the company earns orders of magnitude more.
“We have remained committed to magazines as a magazine experience... We are making the magazine more luxurious, focusing more on the images, stories, design--magazine-ness.”
- A good magazine should be a mixture of art and science—not depending entirely on what surveys, focus groups, and research tell you people want—aiming to meet readers' expectations, rarely fail them insultingly, and periodically surprise them in delightful ways, like giving presents to people who trust you.
“Want to do a magazine in which people sometimes like it for meeting their expectations and hardly ever failing it in a way that's insulting and periodically surprising them in a way that's delightful.”
- What ESPN The Magazine sells, distinct from freely available statistics, is the collective ideation of roughly 120 staff who share a specific, unique, differentiated way of looking at sports; the editor's job is to judge whether at least 10% of readers will love a piece while the other 90% are not offended.
“I know exactly what I'm selling: collective ideation of about 120 people who work for me, who have a very specific idea and way of looking at sports that I think is unique and differentiated on multiple levels from anybody else in the sports world.”
- The standalone World Cup preview sells unbelievably well despite the average American disliking soccer because there are 40-50 million soccer fans in the country who follow good European soccer, and ESPN's broadcasting of the World Cup pulls fans who want to be in the conversation into paying attention.
“Average American doesn't like soccer. But 40-50 million soccer fans in this country--paying attention to good soccer, in Europe, just not American soccer.”
Information abundance and decision pressure harm personal finance choices; people benefit from constraint and trust rather than endless options.
- The spotlight effect is the tendency for people to think others are paying far more attention to them than they actually are.
“co-author, Thomas Gilovich, wrote a paper about something he calls the spotlight effect--we all think people are paying way more attention to us than they are.”
- People can have too much information: the more information you have, the more likely you are to want to make decisions—or to think you should make decisions—with that information, which is not good for personal finance.
“people can have too much information, and the more information you have, the more likely you are to want to make decisions or think you should make decisions with that information. Not very good for people's personal finance”
- Staying in a mediocre mutual fund for 20 years almost always leaves you better off than switching every year into last year's best-performing fund, because chasing returns is a fool's game; yet a magazine cannot profitably tell readers to simply stay the course, since people won't pay for advice to do nothing.
“If you put yourself in a mediocre mutual fund and stay there without moving for 20 years, you are almost always better off than if every year you put yourself in last year's best mutual fund, because chasing returns ends up being a fool's game.”
- If you don't respond to emails until the end of the day, everything turns out fine, because people who genuinely need you will call or come to your office instead.
“It turns out that if I don't respond to emails till the end of the day, everything turns out fine. If people really need you they actually call you or come into your office.”
- A manager should avoid emailing staff at night without indicating no response is needed, because otherwise people feel compelled to respond immediately even when the message is just the manager clearing their head.
“Have learned not to email staff at night unless I indicate that they don't need to respond till the next day, or people feel compelled to respond.”
- The best trivia questions do one or both of two things: they make you happy that you now know the answer, or they make you think you should have known it; a meaningful trivia question contains a contradiction or iconic hook (e.g., the Professor's real name on Gilligan's Island), which makes it worth knowing.
“the best trivia questions do one of two things and in some ways both. Makes you happy that you now know it or makes you think, Darn, I should have known it.”
- Speech functions as a beneficial editor or filter on thought, so you never want to read people's minds; Belsky learned this when he accidentally read an honest but unflattering letter someone wrote about him at age 22.
“You don't want to read people's minds. Speech is a good way to edit--filter.”
- Online nastiness is not evidence that people are meaner than we thought; rather, the web allows people's inner mean thoughts—which everyone has—to come out without the social filters of in-person interaction, and norms, manners, or religion normally keep us from being our worst selves.
“any number of people with whom you could have perfectly nice conversations with in person, when they are allowed to send emails or comment on the Internet, they allow their id to come out and get extraordinarily nasty.”
Print magazines thrive by limiting choice and curating experience in ways digital platforms cannot, reducing reader anxiety.
- Car Talk is analogous to ESPN The Magazine's strategy: the car advice is just an excuse for entertainment, and the charm of the show is the humor rather than the advice—the subject matter is a vehicle for entertainment.
“They do give car advice, but the charm of the show is the humor, not the car advice. The car advice is an excuse to be entertaining, funny. Sports as a vehicle.”
- People like the physical magazine partly because it limits choice, whereas the web causes anxiety by making people wonder if they are missing something; a print story on a topic like Peyton Manning is all you need to know and doesn't leave you wondering which link to follow next—an effect rooted in behavioral economics.
“People like having the physical product; like the limiting of choice. The web causes anxiety because people wonder if they are missing something.”
Magazine editing work is predominantly personnel management and budget decisions rather than the glamorous creative task it appears.
- Most of the un-fun parts of an editing job are not work problems but 'them' problems—staff issues arising from chemistry, personal lives, or home situations—and these are a function of the nature of jobs in general rather than anything specific to ESPN or sports.
“Dealing with the problems of staff, the kind of ongoing recognition that most of the problems you are dealing with are not work problems but "them" problems. Chemistry doesn't always work out. Function of their life or something going on in their home.”
- Just as running a restaurant is fantasized to be all about food but is really about inventory control and keeping the chef happy, editing a glamorous magazine is mostly high-pressure management work—making decisions affecting many people and big budgets—punctuated only periodically by ecstatic moments.
“Fantasy, like being a restaurateur, that it's all about food--but it's also about inventory control, keeping your chef happy, etc.”
Editorial success requires mixing intentional diversity of perspective with rigorous judgment rather than relying solely on research.
- Half of the magazine's staff comes from a traditional sports background and half are people who understand fandom in non-sports domains, deliberately to help the magazine think outside the box and avoid fetishizing sports expertise.
“Populated half by people who come up from a traditional sports background and half by people who are or understand fans--other than sports--because it helps you think outside of the box. Mean to be different--do not fetishize sports experience.”
Business journalism training teaches foundational skills—exactness, math, economics—applicable across all journalism and society.
- Business journalism is excellent training for young journalists because it forces exactness, requires understanding of math, economics, and corporate strategy, and these elements are present throughout all of society and all journalism.
“Business writing is very good training for young journalists: makes you be exact, makes you understand a little bit of math and a little bit of economics, corporate strategy--present in all of society and all journalism.”
- Local newspapers do a poor job covering local business because they lack staff who understand business, are intimidated by approaching local firms, and tend to cover businesses that ride the coattails of national businesses; meanwhile the real local business happens in real estate development, small business creation, retail trends, healthcare, government, and the ease of getting things done at city hall.
“The average newspaper doesn't have many people who know a lot about business; intimidated by going to talk to the local business, even if it's thriving. The businesses they cover are often on the coattails of national businesses”
- Belsky started writing professionally at age 16 after a 17-year-old friend who wrote for a local St. Louis paper recommended him to the editor, and this freelance writing paid for his college.
“Started writing professionally at age 16; friend who was 17 was writing for a local paper in St. Louis; saw his byline. He recommended me to the editor of the paper. That's how I paid for college”