What this covers
Gary Belsky and Russ Roberts explore why golf played alone transforms into something fundamentally different from the social version of the sport. Belsky argues that much of the stress in conventional golf stems from performance anxiety from observation—the presence of other players and spectators introduces self-consciousness that the amateur golfer, unlike the professional, cannot compartmentalize. Remove the watchers, and the game shifts into a meditative space where flow state becomes possible, yielding measurable physical and mental benefits. The conversation moves outward from this core claim to examine what golf reveals about character, how its structure as a sport differs from football or tennis, and what barriers prevent courses from accommodating solo players given that the golf industrial complex prioritizes moving groups through the course efficiently.
The discussion ranges across the sport's economics, psychology, and philosophy. Belsky describes yoga off the mat—the principle of non-judgmental acceptance—as directly transferable from solo golf to everyday life, and proposes that learning to perform "as if no one's watching" is a valuable skill that extends far beyond the fairway. Roberts raises the question of whether golf, with its emphasis on tacit knowledge and physical mastery, gains cultural appeal precisely because it resists the digital world. Belsky adds that golf's distinctive ability to bring together people of different social status as equals gives it a culturally unifying function few sports match. The speakers also consider whether shorter-format golf courses or an intentional positioning of physical golf as an analog vs digital experience could expand the sport's appeal, particularly among younger players drawn to its mental health benefits.
Belsky argues that playing golf alone is a fundamentally different and more meditative activity than social golf, because the absence of observers removes performance anxiety and enables a yoga-like flow state that yields physical, mental, and self-awareness benefits.
- The stress of normal golf comes largely from being watched, not from the physical task itself
- Solo golf removes self-consciousness, producing flow states and self-forgiveness
- The 'yoga off the mat' principle of non-judgmental acceptance transfers to life beyond golf
Solo golf enables deep flow and stress relief by removing self-consciousness and social constraints that hobble amateur performance.
- The principle of 'yoga off the mat'--non-judgmental acceptance and altering one's breath rather than forcing or criticizing oneself when things aren't working--transfers from yoga to golf and to life: in solo golf one observes bad shots with curiosity rather than self-criticism, and acceptance of one's strengths and weaknesses actually enables ambition and better resource allocation.
“if solo golf works well, you rarely get mad at yourself, because even when you're working on a good hole or a good round, you're just, like, 'Oh, that was interesting.'”
- A huge part of the golf experience is the stress and self-consciousness of being watched and performing in front of others; the difference between a professional and an amateur is that the pro thinks only about the current shot while the amateur thinks about every prior shot, the other players, and what onlookers think.
“When I'm over a shot, all I am thinking about is that shot. Period. He goes, 'When you're over the ball, all you are thinking about is every shot you took before in this game'”
- Removing constraints and self-consciousness in solo golf can induce a deep flow state that produces exceptional performance and measurable stress relief, as illustrated by Belsky's best-ever round (ten shots better than his second-best) and a five-hole solo round that lowered his blood pressure and helped him solve a difficult professional reporting assignment.
“I was in such a flow state because of the solo golf experience and because of the absence of constraints or self-consciousness that I didn't even want to count my score at the turn”
- Solo golf--playing alone on a course or hole with no one present--is an entirely different experience from social golf because it is meditative, introspective, and contemplative in a way that resembles a yoga practice and feeds the soul differently than playing with others.
“essentially, it's a meditative, introspective, contemplative experience that's unlike almost anything you generally encounter when you're playing golf with other people”
The golf industry is structurally optimized for group play, which discourages solo participation despite its psychological value.
- The 'golf industrial complex' is structured to push four golfers out every eight to twelve minutes as many days as possible, so nearly every course--even private clubs--discourages solo play because courses are designed to be shared.
“almost every golf club or golf course in the world wants four golfers to go out every eight to 12 minutes, as many days of the year as they possibly can”
- There is no lonelier or emptier place in the world than a golf course with nobody on it, and the second loneliest is a golf course with one person on it.
“there's no lonelier place in the world, or emptier place in the world, than a golf course with nobody on it. And, the second loneliest place in the world is a golf course with one person on it”
- Because the main barrier to golf is the five-to-seven hours it requires, a short-format physical golf experience--such as a six-hole course distinct from Topgolf or a driving range--could attract significant interest and become a viable business.
“if somebody could come up with a six-hole golf experience, they might get some attention. That could be a business, because part of the problem with golf is people don't have six hours to spend”
- Solo golf does not count toward a player's official handicap because establishing a handicap requires witnesses to verify the round.
“one of the issues with solo golf is it does not count for your handicap because you need witnesses for your handicap”
Golf's extraordinary fine margins and skill ceiling create vast performance gaps separating casual players from professionals.
- Unlike many sports, you can practice golf a great deal and fail to improve, because if you do not get the mechanics right for your own body it simply does not click.
“golf, you can practice a lot and not improve in a certain way because if you're not getting the mechanics right for you, it just doesn't click”
- Golf has extraordinarily fine margins of error: averaging just a few strokes better per round separates a popular club player (73) from a college scholarship (72), a living (71), a millionaire (70), a multimillionaire (69), and the most famous athlete in the world (68), because mis-hitting the clubface by a centimeter or two can send the ball 70-80 yards off target.
“if you average 73 in golf, you'll be the most popular player in your local course... And, if you average 68, you'll be the most famous person in the world.”
Golf's tradition claims obscure its modern departure from origins, and live versus broadcast spectatorship are fundamentally different experiences.
- Despite golf's pride in tradition, the modern pristine-course game is in many ways very far from the original sport played by shepherds in Scotland, China, and Holland using crooks and aiming at random holes in the ground, so the game's claimed adherence to tradition is partly illusory.
“the game we play now is, in some ways, very far from the game they played when the sport was invented”
- Golf is among the sports where watching live differs most starkly from watching on TV: in person a spectator is typically camped at a single hole or follows one group, seeing only a fraction of the action, whereas TV follows leaders and splices in highlights, making the two experiences fundamentally different.
“the difference between watching it on TV and the difference between watching it in person is as stark or as wide as for any sport”
- ESPN The Magazine's editorial rule was that if roughly 10% of the audience would find a story compelling, that was reason enough to run it, because readers who didn't care about a minor sport would forgive its inclusion as long as they got their quotient of major sports.
“as long as we thought 10% of our audience would find the story compelling, that was reason enough to do it”
- No-Score Golf is a recommended solo practice of ignoring scoring entirely and measuring success by how well certain shots are executed or how creatively one recovers from tough lies, which can be freeing and lets a player experiment (e.g., hitting multiple balls from one lie to test technique).
“Ignore scoring entirely and focus solely on execution. Measure success by how well you hit certain shots or how creatively you recover from tough lies.”
- Recent growth in sales of pocket watches and fountain pens reflects a hunger for analog experiences in a digital world, and golf has an opportunity to position its physical version as a complementary analog escape from the exploding simulated golf market.
“recent years have seen an explosions in the sales of pocket watches and fountain pens... it has to do with analog versus digital”
- Caddying in a professional golf tournament is extraordinarily difficult because a caddy must know not only the rules, the course, and the greens, but also the unwritten etiquette, since any mistake can anger the golfer's playing partners mid-round.
“if you're a caddy, you really have to know not just the rules, and not just the course, and not just the green. You have to understand the unwritten rules of golf, too”
Golf uniquely reveals character and enables social equality across status divides, distinguishing it among participatory sports.
- Playing comfortably with much better golfers is far more within the amateur's control than they realize; the problem with weak golfers in mixed groups is not their play but their failure to understand how to play with others--such as knowing when to pick up the ball and keep pace--and learning this is part of a broader life skill of being at ease being observed.
“the issue is not their play, it's their not-understanding of how to play with others when others are considerably better”
- Playing golf with someone reveals their character because over the course of a round you see how they handle mistakes, defeat, others doing better, their graciousness, and their respect for the game and for golfers who come after them.
“you walk with somebody, and you see how they handle mistakes, how they handle defeat, how they handle somebody else doing better than them, their graciousness, their respect for the game”
- Golf is unusual among participatory sports in allowing people of vastly different social status to play together as relative equals--a CEO and a maintenance worker, or strangers--in a way few other sports (bowling, etc.) actually do, giving it a distinctive culturally unifying function.
“there's not many sports where you can do that--sort of play with strangers... golf serves a lot of purposes culturally in a way that people, I don't think, who don't participate in it quite understand”