What this covers

Sam Quinones, the journalist known for reporting on the opioid crisis, pivots here to an unlikely subject: the tuba and high school marching band. In conversation with Russ Roberts, Quinones traces how these institutions work as a structural counterweight to addiction. The conversation moves between personal stories of tuba players and band programs, the instrument's recent history, and a larger argument about what humans actually need. Where addiction isolates and delivers purchased gratification, band builds agency—the capacity to initiate, decide, and shape one's environment—through disciplined work alongside others. Quinones distinguishes Immediate Gratification vs Earned Fulfillment, arguing that the latter, forged through hard work rather than consumption, is what band uniquely offers young people, especially those without innate musical talent.

The conversation spans the tuba's instruments themselves—the sousaphone invented by John Philip Sousa, the euphonium, and others—and dips into the instrument's liberation struggle. A 1973 Indiana University gathering sparked what became the Tuba Civil Rights movement, asserting the instrument beyond its lowly orchestral role. Teachers like Jim Self and iconic players like Bill Bell reshaped what the tuba could be heard to do. The discussion then shifts to how band programs work: how non-auditioned, ordinary kids reach state finals against wealthy suburban ensembles, how Al Cortinas reformed a Texas program through sustained instruction, and how the Rio Grande Valley pushed teenagers into band as deliberate protection against drug recruitment. Throughout, Quinones resists talent-worship, arguing that Agency Over Intelligence determines real mastery, and that the values band cultivates—community, persistence, self-worth earned through effort—prove far more protective than any lecture about drugs.

Sharpest takeaway

Quinones argues that the tuba and marching band are the mirror opposite of drug addiction: where addiction is isolating, purchased, and immediately gratifying, mastery of the tuba builds agency, self-worth, and community through hard work, making band a powerful antidote to the malaise afflicting young men and a vehicle for lifelong fulfillment regardless of innate talent.

  • Addiction shreds community and isolates, while band is a community enhancer that teaches values sustaining community
  • Agency and hard work, not innate talent, are what allow ordinary kids to achieve excellence and lifelong success
  • Band gives marginalized young men a sense of being worth something, which is the real protection against drugs

The argument · threads6 threads · 30 claims
0.79

Band's discipline and community foundation directly counter addiction's isolation and immediate gratification.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The hard work, perseverance, and quiet focus cultivated by band are the antithesis of and answer to the modern afflictions of social media, pornography, gambling, video games, junk food, and hyper-potent marijuana—all of which, like drugs, deliver easy immediate gratification, while band counters them by training kids in values that sustain community and personal lives.

    “it's also the antithesis, the answer to all that we have allowed to develop in our country, in my opinion, through social media apps, and pornography, and gambling, and video games... You get away from the easy, the kick back, the immediate gratification, which is what drugs are all about, but so is a smartphone with TikTok.”

  • Whereas drug addiction is based on the shredding of community and isolation, the tuba is a community enhancer—a good tuba player makes everyone in the band feel and perform better, uniting the ensemble in a way that contrasts directly with addiction's solitary nature.

    “drug addiction is really based on the shredding of community. It's all about your own isolation... here, I found the tuba was the community enhancer.”

  • Drugs and addiction enslave by narrowing one's world into a single object of interest, whereas the tuba liberates by freeing players to see all they are capable of—the two are opposite in their effect on the breadth of a person's life.

    “drug addiction is really based on the shredding of community. It's all about your own isolation... here, I found the tuba was the community enhancer.”

  • After writing about addiction, where people chase blasts of pleasure, Quinones came to understand fulfillment—rather than happiness, which doesn't quite reach it—as the deeper thing humans are actually seeking, and that what band and the tuba offer is precisely this fulfillment forged through hard work rather than purchased pleasure.

    “I've come to understand fulfillment as being the deeper thing that we are looking for. And 'happiness' doesn't quite get there in my opinion. So, you're looking for that fulfillment.”

0.79

Band creates lasting life outcomes through values that transcend competition and sport-like winning.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Band, unlike football, is 'about winning later'—a band director asked how his band did says 'too soon to tell, ask me in 10 years'—because the real payoff is not the immediate competitive result but the values and trajectory the experience sets up over a lifetime.

    “the band director goes, 'You know, too soon to tell. Ask me in 10 years.' Because band is about winning later”

  • Most band students do not go on to music careers but instead go on to solid middle-class lives, because band teaches the values that sustain community—it is a unique natural resource of American public education unlike any other public music education system in the world.

    “most of his kids did not go on to that. They go on to solid middle class lives because band teaches the values that sustain community. That's the raw, the beautiful, natural resource that is marching band in America.”

  • Roma, Texas has reached state finals but has never finished first, yet this does not matter because the value lies in the students' subsequent lives—those early finalists from 2003-2004 are, 20 years later, all doing well with prosperous families and good jobs.

    “Roma, Texas, to this date has never come in first. However, it has shown--I don't think it matters either--it shows the beauty of band... they're all doing wonderfully well. They all have these prosperous, happy families, good jobs.”

  • Band is genuinely inclusive in a way sports cannot be—far more kids can be in band than can play football or basketball, requiring only the desire to play better and work hard with others, and unlike sports it carries no risk of life-mangling injuries.

    “this is, again, the beauty of band because it is very inclusive... All you need really is the desire to play better, and to march better, and to work with others... you don't face any life-mangling injuries as a result of it.”

0.73

Tuba players discover self-worth and capability through sustained effort, creating protection against drugs.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Kids who stick with the tuba—often those at the lower end of the social pecking order—come to understand they are capable and worth something through the instrument, and this feeling of self-worth derived from a productive endeavor is the real protection against drugs.

    “if you find something that says you are worth something and you are capable, that is in my view--people would come up to me and go, ask me previous to the tuba, 'How do I keep my kids away from drugs?' Really, it's finding that feeling that you are worth something through another endeavor that doesn't have to do with drugs.”

  • For many players the tuba functions like a Mexican folk saint—a guardian watching over them through life—because even those who set it aside carry the lessons it taught (hard work, attention to detail, focus, perseverance through failure) with them, which is why so many keep tubas in their basements and return to play Tuba Christmas.

    “the tuba is a little bit like a folk saint... the tuba is a folk saint in that it teaches them all these really, really important lessons in life... 'The tuba is watching over me, even though I'm not playing it'”

  • Talent is overrated—while some are gifted from the start and should be nurtured, hard work, which is another way of saying agency, must itself be built and nurtured by teaching kids the benefits they will find through hard work, and this is what band uniquely cultivates in kids who receive no fame or recognition.

    “Talent is overrated... Hard work, which is just another way of saying agency according to your fellow there... To me, that is where you come to--but you have to build that, you have to nurture that.”

0.65

Strategic instruction and community context make band accessible and transformative for untalented ordinary kids.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The tuba became hugely important in Mexican Los Angeles largely because Mexican immigrants wanting to display their success hire bands with big brass tubas, which drove the instrument's popularity—and the resulting wave of tuba thefts from high schools, predominantly in Mexican areas.

    “it has a lot to do with Mexican immigrants wanting to show how well they've done. And so they hire bands with tubas, and big, brass, golden things... because of this popularity of the tuba in that area, you were getting lots of tubas stolen.”

  • Al Cortinas reformed the Roma, Texas band program by hiring ten band directors—one per instrument—who each taught the same students on that instrument from sixth through twelfth grade, on the theory that this continuity would prevent the dropout that typically occurred by eighth or ninth grade, transforming Roma from having barely a band to a state finals competitor.

    “what they need to do is hire 10 band directors. One for each instrument, and each band director will take kids who play, say, the clarinet... all the way through kids to 12th grade... In this way, he believes--years of band directing convinced him of this--that you will not lose these kids along the way.”

  • Unlike students recruited for innate talent, marching band kids simply sign up—a cross-section of those interested in learning to play something, often kids told by parents to do it because they aren't fast enough for football or basketball—and yet these untalented, non-auditioned kids reach state finals competing against wealthy suburban bands with private lessons.

    “it's just a cross-section of the people who were interested in learning how to play something... They'd never done anything musical in their life other than enjoy music.”

  • In the Rio Grande Valley, families understand the threat of unstructured time given that drug cartels are recruiting right there, so they push their children into band to channel their energy—evidenced by hundreds of teenagers (350 in 2023, 650 before COVID) playing Tuba Christmas, virtually all 18 and under because families cannot afford to keep expensive tubas for life.

    “people see and they understand the threat of not being in something that will take up so much of your time and channel your energies. Because the drug cartels are right there.”

0.57

Tuba's cultural history and technical evolution elevated it from comic relief to an instrument liberating musicians.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Bill Bell, the greatest tuba player of his time with the New York Philharmonic, recorded the first solo tuba record in 1957, and as it percolated out in the mid-1960s it liberated isolated young tuba players' sense of what their instrument could do—analogous to jazz players hearing Charlie Parker or rock guitarists hearing Jimi Hendrix.

    “his importance is that he recorded the first solo tuba record ever... they listened to Bill Bell show them a brand-new world that liberated their horn in their own minds.”

  • The 1973 Indiana University tuba symposium—'Tuba Woodstock'—convened hundreds of tuba players, most of whom had never seen more than four or five tuba players together, creating a collective tuba consciousness and launching a 'Tuba Civil Rights movement' asserting the instrument was worth more than playing oompah at the back of the band.

    “the first conclave of the tuba nation, essentially, at Indiana University in 1973, where hundreds of tuba players were convened... This created this kind of tuba consciousness and began what was also then the Tuba Civil Rights movement.”

  • Unlike older instruments, the tuba—invented only in 1835—is not done being tinkered with, having progressed from low-quality 1920s-1930s horns to majestic instruments that more easily channel players' virtuosity, with ongoing worldwide competition (notably from China) producing new and better approaches.

    “the tuba is not done being tinkered with... it went from very low-quality--like in the 1920s and so on, and 1930s--horns, to what are now quite majestic and able to channel the virtuosity of players much more easily.”

  • Jim Self, a renowned retired USC tuba teacher, built a 38-foot practice hall atop his house—long enough to contain the 36-foot sound wave of the lowest-register tuba note—because he was tired of practicing in 10-by-10 rooms built for trumpets and wanted to liberate the instrument's full sound.

    “Built an enormous practice hall on top of his house, 38-feet long. Long enough to contain the longest sound wave of the lowest registered tuba, which is a 36-foot long sound wave.”

  • Tubas come in many varieties and keys—C, Double B-Flat, E-Flat, and F—ranging from very large and wide to small, and include the euphonium (tenor tuba), the sousaphone (invented by John Philip Sousa to wrap around the marching player), and the concert tuba with its bell facing skyward.

    “in different keys. There's C, there's Double B-Flat, there's E-Flat, there's F... There's the euphonium, which is the tenor tuba. There was eventually the sousaphone, which John Phillips Sousa invents”

0.44

Quinones's journalism method found human truth by remaining present with people doing something productive they love.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Quinones's journalistic method is grounded in the faith that if you stick with people who are doing something productive and positive that they truly love, they will generate great stories—a principle he applied by interviewing tuba players for a decade without a clear point until the project crystallized.

    “with the faith that I had learned from my journalism career that if you stick with people who are doing something productive and positive with their lives, they will generate great stories.”

  • As a non-musician, Quinones could not perceive the connoisseur's sonic distinctions in tuba tone, but instead found his most profound, elevated feelings in repeated interviews with tuba players who had never been asked about their experiences—accessing the same exhilaration of agency and liberation that the players themselves felt.

    “I think where I found the most profound feelings was in interviews with tuba players... it's through understanding these new ideas that I began to sense the same exhilaration perhaps that they felt”

  • You cannot have a good band without a good tuba player or tuba section, so much so that some tuba players believe they lead the band—proven by the fact that if the tuba plays slightly out of tune, the whole band falls apart.

    “you cannot have a good band without a good tuba section, tuba player, or tuba section. It just doesn't happen.”

  • Because band delivers enormous human impact for the money—teaching the most precious life lessons to ordinary kids in the bleachers rather than just star athletes—any board of education or superintendent now constantly cutting budgets for such endeavors would be committing almost education malpractice.

    “any Board of Education, any superintendent, now I believe would be committing almost education malpractice to be cutting the budget constantly for those endeavors. You are getting such enormous bang for the buck in terms of just human impact.”

  • Quinones speculates—admittedly as a pipe dream without verification—that perhaps 20% of Americans were in band at some point, an experience so quietly important that people rarely mention it until prompted, yet which he believes is central to creating contented, fulfilled lives and to sustaining community.

    “I'd like to come up with some kind of tally of what percentage of Americans were at one point in band. I think you may be talking about 20% of the country at some point. I don't know if that's true at all, of course.”