Read Like a Champion (with Doug Lemov)
What this covers
Doug Lemov and Russ Roberts discuss why millions of American students have failed to become proficient readers, and argue that the solution lies not in intuitive teaching methods but in applying cognitive science. Lemov, an educator and author, contends that reading is biologically secondary—unlike speech, which evolved over 250,000 years, reading emerged only 5,000 years ago and rewires brain regions designed for other purposes. This distinction means reading cannot be acquired naturally but must be taught through deliberate, science-based instruction. The conversation centers on a mistaken American assumption: that students learn to think by practicing thinking. Instead, Lemov argues, they need more to think with—that is, background knowledge. This reframes what should be taught and how.
The discussion ranges across the mechanisms of reading failure and recovery. Lemov and Roberts examine how whole language ideology, which encouraged students to guess at words, displaced systematic synthetic phonics in American schools, leaving generations unable to decode. They explore why context clues are an unreliable way to learn vocabulary, and why retrieval practice and encoding into long-term memory matter more than deep understanding while reading. The conversation also addresses attention itself—showing how constant digital stimulation rewires the brain—and proposes concrete solutions: pairing historical background with difficult texts, keeping reading journals, and making reading social. Along the way, they discuss how terminology itself shapes perception, drawing an example from basketball, and defend the case for reading older literature as a form of intellectual diversity.
Lemov argues that reading is a biologically secondary skill that must be taught through science rather than intuition, and that comprehension depends primarily on background knowledge and deep vocabulary rather than on practicing generic 'thinking skills.'
- Reading is biologically secondary (unlike speech) so it requires deliberate, science-based instruction
- Comprehension and inference are domain-specific, driven by background knowledge, not transferable skills
- Vocabulary is a critical form of background knowledge, not a guessing skill, and learning requires retrieval practice that encodes in long-term memory
Reading literature demands sustained engagement because transformative power emerges from struggling with an author's sustained intellectual journey and simulating character change.
- We read fiction and nonfiction not for the facts but for the experience and the intellectual journey of a thoughtful author; a summary, a Classic Comic, or an AI summary cannot transmit what makes a book powerful, because the transformative effect comes from the sustained struggle and simulation of inhabiting characters as they change.
“Summaries are not--we don't read fiction--we don't even read nonfiction--for the facts.”
- Difficult-to-read authors like Faulkner can seem 'overrated' and impenetrable at first (e.g., The Sound and the Fury at age 16) but reward persistence; reading a more accessible entry point like As I Lay Dying twice can unlock a lifelong appreciation, and a single annotated line can capture a profound truth such as the alienation of human experience.
“having tried to read The Sound and the Fury at 16 and not getting very far and thinking, 'Well, it's just a bad book.'”
Students need knowledge and terminology as tools for thinking, not generic practice, because thinking requires content to work with and shared language to communicate.
- Giving things a name—terminology—enables conversations and shared understanding that would otherwise be impossible, which makes it a powerful and undervalued tool for creating culture within an organization or school.
“giving things a name allows you to have a conversation about it that you might not otherwise be able to have... It's such a small thing, and I think it's so undervalued as a way to create a culture in an organization”
- The American mistake is assuming that if we want students to think, the curriculum should give them lots of practice thinking; in fact what students need is more to think with—that is, knowledge—because thinking is not a content-free skill that improves through generic practice.
“The big mistake we have made in the United States is to assume that if we want students to be able to think, then our curriculum should give our students lots of practice thinking. This is a mistake because what our students need is more to think with.”