
Credit Card Shutdowns Begin: The First Sign of Economic Collapse
What this covers
This is a single-narrator video from Eurodollar University, written in response to the September 2024 payroll report and the renewed talk of a soft or no landing. The argument starts from the August data on revolving credit: the second decline in three months and the largest monthly drop since 2021. The six-month average is set against June 2008 and the 2001 downturn, and the 5.4% year-over-year growth is matched to August 2008 and late 2001. The narrator reads falling card use less as a spending story than as workers acting on what they see in the labor market, which makes it different from a consumer confidence survey. Banks tightening supply is raised as a second channel.
The second half takes apart the headline payroll number. The narrator compares it with the March 2024 report, which showed 303,000 jobs against expectations of 214,000 and was hailed as a blockbuster before fading. He claims the Establishment Survey (CES)) has a habit of overstating strength at inflection points. Against it he sets a 34.2-hour average work week, JOLTS hiring and quits data, Conference Board assessments, and Challenger, Gray & Christmas hiring plans, which are the lowest year-to-date since 2011.
The more contested turns come near the end. One is the claim that a lack of hiring, not layoffs, triggers recessions, which he supports by pointing to academic work on unemployment flows. Another is that consumers read a shift from supply-shock upside to downside around March–April 2024, so the pessimism is perception and not a "vibe session." He also stresses that the credit-versus-unemployment rate correlation is directional, not a one-to-one forecast.
Declining revolving consumer credit and falling credit card usage are reliable recession signals that accurately reflect deteriorating labor market conditions, contradicting misleadingly strong headline payroll numbers that temporarily spike due to statistical quirks at inflection points.
- Revolving credit is highly inversely correlated with unemployment because consumers act on their perceptions of job security by reducing credit card use during uncertainty
- The September 2024 payroll report's 303,000 jobs figure mirrors the misleading March report that looked strong but proved to be a one-month anomaly contradicted by underlying data on hours, hiring, and quits
- Multiple independent data sources (JOLTS, hours worked, job openings, Challenger Gray & Christmas hiring plans, Conference Board) all confirm recession signals that the headline payroll number obscures
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Falling revolving credit use does not necessarily mean a huge direct impact on spending; instead it signals something vastly more important: consumer perceptions of the state of the economy, particularly the labor market, because unlike consumer confidence surveys, falling credit card balances represent consumers actually acting on their perceptions rather than merely expressing sentiment.
“it's not really about spending either Fallen credit card use doesn't necessarily mean a huge direct impact on spending instead it tells us something vastly more important in the same way consumer confidence doesn't really relate to spending plans revolving Consumer Credit isn't about that either both of them are instead drawn from perceptions of the state of the economy in particular the labor market unlike consumer confidence though Consumer Credit goes beyond consumers just saying their downbeat with falling credit card balances they feel strongly enough to act on those perceptions”
The seasonally adjusted aggregate balance for revolving credit declined in August 2024, marking the second decline in three months and the largest single monthly decline in revolving credit since 2021, with the six-month average of 3.07 billion per month equivalent to June 2008 or July-August 2001 recession periods.
“in the latest consumer credit report from the Federal Reserve for the month of August 2024 what we saw is a Slowdown in total Consumer Credit...the seasonally adjusted aggregate balance of revolving credit declined by 1.35 billion...that's the largest decline in revolving Credit in any single monthly balance since 2021”
When consumers perceive reduced job prospects, fewer hours available for work, or hints of layoffs, they wisely put away their credit cards or reduce usage to the absolute minimum as a prudent response to confronting job security threats, which is why revolving credit correlates very strongly with the unemployment rate.
“when they're faced with reduced job prospects fewer hours available for work or even just the hint of layoffs with no one hiring the idea of being let go becomes absolutely terrifying and confronting those possibilities consumers keep the credit card used to the absolute minimum”
When consumers perceive strength in the labor market, they take risk-taking behavior like using credit cards, but when they perceive slowdown in hours, slowdown in hiring, hiring freezes, or prospect of layoffs, they prudently put away credit cards, spend less, use less, and borrow less, making credit card behavior a direct reflection of real economy conditions rather than sentiment.
“if they see strength they're going to use their credit cards it's risk-taking behavior that actually is consistent with how everything is going along in the real economy if they're perceiving a Slowdown in hours a Slowdown in hiring let alone a hiring freeze maybe even the prospect of layoffs like I said in the introduction quite naturally they put away their credit cards and spend less use them less borrow Less”
Employers are trimming hours and choosing not to hire new employees because the economy is not just slowing down but is actively falling, and they are being pressured by the downturn into taking proactive measures to control costs, which workers perceive through weakening labor market signals that change their behavior.
“why else are they trimming hours why else are they choosing not to hire new employees because the economy isn't just slowing down it is actively falling they're being pressured by the downturn into taking proactive measures to control their costs and Americans are picking up on that control they're picking up on the weakness in the labor market and it's changing their behavior”
There is no hiring visible in labor market data, there are fewer hours being worked, and growing worry about potential layoffs is emerging in market commentary and data, which explains why even though one monthly payroll report can temporarily excite observers, the underlying fundamentals show it is likely to be a one-month aberration, as has happened every cycle.
“the data all of it apart from The Establishment survey headline it's absolutely consistent with what we're seeing in credit card use there's no hiring there are fewer hours and you know there's growing worry because there's likely talk about layoffs well everyone can get excited about one monthly payroll report and they do every time one comes up like in March the underlying fundamentals show why that is likely to be and almost certainly going to be a one-month aberration we are getting recession signals from all over the place”
The inverse correlation between credit card use and unemployment (shown on inverted scale) does not provide a one-to-one predictive relationship for specific unemployment levels, but instead indicates that when credit card use slows and potentially falls over sustained periods, actual unemployment in the labor market is likely rising and expected to continue rising, contrary to what a single strong payroll report suggests.
“the credit card statistics don't tell us what the unemployment rate should be it's not a onetoone relationship instead what what it tells us is that when credit card use slows down and potentially falls off as much as it has and over a sustained period that it's very likely it's due to the fact that actual unemployment in the labor market is rising and so we expect that the unemployment rate over time will be rising as well we don't know exactly what that means as far as what level unemployment quote unquote should be just that it is more likely to be going in the wrong direction”
The March 2024 payroll report showed 303,000 jobs added, exceeding economist expectations of 214,000, with headlines declaring a 'blockbuster jobs report' and 'strong US economic performance' while unemployment held at 3.8%, yet this proved to be a complete one-month illusion contradicted by all other economic data.
“employers hired 303,000 workers last month blowing past Economist expectations of just 214,000 jobs the unemployment rate held steady at 3.8% hovering near a 50-year low”
Banks themselves are less likely to raise credit card balances, issue new cards to lower quality borrowers, or extend credit lines when they observe deteriorating fundamental conditions in the real labor market (including metrics on incomes and jobs), creating a supply-side constraint on credit independent of consumer demand reduction.
“at the same time the banking system banks are less likely to raise credit card balances when the fundamental conditions in the real labor market because they're they're observing down close on the ground all of the key metrics with it whether it be incomes or jobs or anything else so they're less likely to raise credit lines and they're less likely to give out new cards to lower quality borrowers”
Year-over-year revolving credit growth of 5.4% sounds strong but is slowing significantly from previous growth rates, and this 5.4% growth rate is equivalent to August 2008 (Great Recession) or November 2001 (tail end of dot-com recession), making it a lagging recession signal even when headline year-over-year figures appear positive.
“on a year-over-year basis it sounds like revolving credit is doing really well it's it's up 5.4% year-over-year but you can see that's slowing way down from where Consumer Credit had been the rate Consumer Credit had been rising before and 5.4% that's still equivalent to August of 2008 or November 2001 at the tail end of the dotc recession”
Credit card statistics serve as a coincident to even lagging signal of consumer perception of job market conditions, meaning they still spend as much as they can until forced by circumstances to reduce usage, and this lag is why credit card contraction follows the onset of hiring weakness rather than preceding it.
“in some ways this is a coincident to even lagging signal that consumers are giving us about their perception of the job market when they see prospects go down when they see hiring frees as we're observing now they they still spend as much as they can and it's only out of an overabundance of caution or being forced to do they finally put away their cards”
Unlike the misleading September payroll figure, there is a wealth of corroboration for credit card statistics from multiple independent sources including consumer confidence, JOLTS data (which has much better correlation with reality than the Establishment survey during these periods), Japan's leading economic indicator, and other global data showing synchronized deterioration.
“unlike the September payroll figure there is a number there's a whole wealth of corroboration for what we're seeing from the credit card statistics from consumer confidence starting with jolts I've talked about this before and it's worth reiterating because the jolts data has a much better correlation reality than certainly The Establishment survey during these periods”
JOLTS data showed a sharp slowdown in hiring even before 2024, followed by accelerated slowdown especially over the last several months, with hiring in August 2024 nearly as bad as the shocking June 2024 low, meaning the last 3 months of JOLTS data clearly reflect what is behind the falling consumer credit and contradicts the strong September payroll headline.
“the jolts data showed a sharp slowdown in hiring even before we got to this year and then an accelerated slowdown especially over the last several months again the jolts data like Consumer Credit only goes through August but in the same three months we're seeing credit card use fall off and actually decline in two out of those three months we see hiring down at firmly recession territory hiring in the month of August was nearly as bad as it had been at that shocking June low”
JOLTS quit rates show Americans are perceiving a lack of opportunity in the labor market and employment, causing them not only to put credit cards away but also to voluntarily stay with their current jobs despite dissatisfaction, because they understand there are no other positions available to move to.
“from also from jolts the quits level which suggests very strongly that Americans are perceiving a lack of opportunity in the labor market in jobs in employment and therefore they are choosing not only to put their credit cards away but also to stay with the job that they have they're not voluntarily quitting the positions that they have understanding that there's likely no benefit to doing so there's nobody out there hiring”
The Establishment Survey (CES) data shows hours worked have been flat over the last 6 months (the same 6 months of credit card decline), with the hours index not rising, meaning American employers are adding workers but not increasing hours for existing workers, resulting in average work week falling to 34.2 hours in September—a clear recession signal.
“the hours index was flat over the last 6 months six months these same six months hours have stopped Rising which means American employers are if they're adding workers that means they're adding workers and not working the ones that they have as much as they had before per worker as a result the average work week fell in September all the way back to 34.2 hours which is another very clear recession signal”
The 34.2 hour average work week in September is a recession signal that is internally consistent with and corresponding to the lack of hiring shown in JOLTS, falling consumer confidence, and declining credit card usage, all pointing to the same labor market deterioration rather than the one payroll headline.
“it's not only a clear recession signal in its on its own right it's also a recession signal that is consistent and corresponding with everything else that we're talking about here lack of hiring consumer confidence falling off and credit cards use declining”
Challenger Gray & Christmas reported that US employers announced 43,891 hiring plans in September 2024 (with 41,850 from seasonal employers in retail and transportation/warehousing), down 32% from 59,353 hiring plans announced in September 2023, and for the year through September 2024 employers announced just 483,000 hiring plans from 726,333 announced year-to-date in 2023—the lowest year-to-date total since 2011.
“Challenger gray and Christmas they said us employers announced 43,800 91 hiring plans in September 2024 with 41850 of those coming from seasonal employers both in retail and transportation warehousing this is down 32% from the 59035 3 hiring plans announced in September of last year 2023 of the September 2023 hiring plans most of those were seasonal too for the year employers have announced plans to add just 483,000 from the 72633 3 announced hiring plans through September 2023 these are the lowest year-to date hiring plan since 2011”
According to Conference Board data from late September, consumer assessments of current business conditions turned negative while views of the current labor market situation softened further, with consumers more pessimistic about future labor market conditions and less positive about future business conditions and future income, reflecting concerns about reduced hours, slower payroll increases, and fewer job openings.
“according to the conference board consumers assessments of current business conditions turn negative while views of the current labor market situation softened further consumers were also more pessimistic about future labor market conditions and less positive about future business conditions and future income the deterioration across the con the conference board index as main components likely reflected consumers concerns about the labor market and reactions to fewer hours slower payroll increases and fewer job openings”
There are multiple reasons why revolving consumer credit is highly and inversely correlated with the unemployment rate: Americans put away credit cards when perceiving fewer job opportunities and problems at their workplace plus hints of layoffs, and this behavioral response is confirmed across all data sources except the Establishment Survey headline.
“there are a number of reasons why revolving consumer credit is highly and inversely correlated with the economy Americans put away their cards when they perceive fewer job opportunities problems at their at their workplace as well as potential and even hints of layoffs yet to come the data all of it apart from The Establishment survey headline it's absolutely consistent with what we're seeing in credit card use”
The September payroll report's figure must be understood in context of its own internal data (hours worked) which completely belied the headline number, showing internal inconsistency between the headline job count and actual hours metrics within the same report.
“especially ours so as we see hours get trimmed Americans are sticking sticking where they are anyway whether they like it or not because they know there's no other place to go and that was the most striking aspect of the payroll report well everybody fixated on the huge headline it was completely belii and betrayed by the hours data”
People fixate on layoffs as recession indicators, but academic data proves that it is not layoffs and firings that trigger recessions; rather, it is the lack of hiring in the early recession stages that triggers the downturn, which is why credit card behavior, consumer perception, and other leading indicators change before actual layoffs occur.
“it's understandable why people fixate instead on layoffs because we associate recession with job cuts and it's only because we don't realize that we're in recession during the early stages where there aren't as many or even any job Cuts but as I've shown before a lot of academic data has proven and has established it's not actually layoffs and firing that triggers a recession it is this lack of hiring that we see confirmed in all of this other data”
Americans have accurately picked up on the economy's transformation from supply shock upside to supply shock downside beginning around March-April 2024, which is why consumer confidence, consumer credit, leading economic indicators, and global indicators all shifted consistently at that time, not because of a 'vibe session' but because workers genuinely perceived deteriorating labor market conditions.
“Americans have picked up on the economy's transformation from the supply shock downside to the full Supply shock downside and it happened consistently in all the data around March and April”
The September 2024 payroll report showing 303,000 jobs added vastly differs from the actual underlying composition of the report, which has far more in common with recession indicators like falling credit card usage and employment weakness, mirroring the misleading March 2024 payroll number that looked strong but proved to be a one-month anomaly.
“while everyone is still in the Afterglow the Euphoria from the September payroll number the actual September payroll report the vast majority of it had far more in common what we're seeing in consumer credit and a whole bunch of other data than the headline number that comes out and gets everybody excited to begin with we've been here before not that long ago remember March or actually early April the March payroll number came out and it was huge it was a blowout”
The payroll report has a 'tortured history' of overstating the labor market during inflection periods, and has a regular pattern of appearing weak for a couple months (confirming other data), then surging seemingly out of nowhere, causing observers to declare 'all clear,' only for it to fall off again confirming what underlying data had been saying all along.
“you just choose to ignore them in favor of one number that has a very tortured history first of all during inflection periods that we already know is overstating the jobs market and also has The Habit to do this every few months it'll look weak for a couple months confirming what all the other data says and then it will surge seemingly out of nowhere and everybody will say all clear everything's just fine only for it to fall off yet again confirming what all the underlying data has been telling us all along”
The payroll report is 'highly misleading at inflection points' where it consistently overstates the labor market, making the Establishment Survey unreliable during economic transitions, which is why JOLTS, hours data, hiring plans, and credit card statistics are better indicators of actual labor market conditions.
“actual demand for labor and forget the payroll number it is highly misleading at inflection points it's overstated we know that already qcw and more than that it has this tendency to show up with a huge number seemingly out of nowhere because it is out of nowhere it is completely out of place it's out of the place with its own data in its own series as the hours num and others uh from the payroll report actually showed”
Economists and media outlets regularly declare strong labor market performance based on single monthly payroll blowouts (like March showing 303,000 and September showing 303,000) that are 'completely out of place' with the broader series trend and their own hours data, creating a predictable pattern of false optimism every few months.
“it is completely out of place it's out of the place with its own data in its own series as the hours num and others uh from the payroll report actually showed so there are a number of reasons why revolving consumer credit”
The fact that recession signals are not appearing in headline payrolls is not unusual and happens every cycle, meaning the absence of layoff announcements in payroll data does not contradict credit card contraction, consumer pessimism, hiring weakness, and hours reduction as recession indicators.
“the fact that it isn't in headline payrolls isn't actually unusual this happens every cycle too”
Credit card usage is a consistent and validated recession warning signal that has been confirmed in past cycles, and this validation extends internationally to Japan's leading economic indicator and other global data showing synchronized timing and direction with credit contraction observed in the US.
“credit card usage following credit card usage is another consistent validated recession warning I talked about yesterday Japan and its leading economic indicator a whole bunch of other data from Japan that is globally synchronized with the fallof and especially the timing”
Americans were 'downbeat' about the economy in March 2024 according to consumer sentiment measures while economists and media were celebrating strong payroll numbers, which proved that Americans' caution was warranted because the payroll surge was an illusion while the underlying weakness persisted, validating consumer perception over headline statistics.
“Americans were downbeat back in March and don't those idiots know that the payroll number was really strong that that the labor market is exceptional there's lots of hiring going on it it conflicted with all of the other evidence that we got in the form of consumer confidence and a whole bunch of others from the market say saying the payroll number was an illusion which is exactly what it proved to be”
Revolving credit statistics and credit card usage patterns are drawn directly from Federal Reserve data releases, making them officially published economic measures with consistent methodology across time periods, unlike payroll which has known biases and seasonal adjustment issues.
“in the latest consumer credit report from the Federal Reserve for the month of August 2024”
When credit card figures are revised after initial release (as happened in previous months discussed), the magnitude and direction of changes can alter the interpretation of trends, which is why careful attention to revision patterns is necessary for accurate assessment of credit trends.
“remember these these figures are revised and I went over this a couple months ago and the figures have been revised since then what that means is that that's the largest decline in revolving Credit in any single monthly balance since 2021”
Media coverage of strong payroll reports uses language like 'blockbuster jobs report' and 'defying lukewarm feelings' to create false confidence despite consumer-level observations of job weakness, creating a cognitive disconnect where official data contradicts lived experience of workers and job seekers.
“a blockbuster jobs report on Friday delivered the latest sign of strong US economic performance defying the lukewarm feelings held by many Americans”