
What this covers
This is a long interview with Zen abbot Shohaku Okumura, recorded with the Sanshin Zen Community in Bloomington, Indiana. He works through the tradition of Dogen, and especially the Genjo Koan, to ask what it means to practice before one knows what life is for. His images carry much of the argument: a fish in the ocean or a bird in the sky does not survey its element before living in it, and meaning is found by practicing, not before. He also takes up Dogen's firewood and ash, where each moment stands whole, cut off from before and after. One claim marked as contested is that the present has no duration yet contains all past and future.
The middle section is doctrinal. Okumura sets out the middle way as a path between self-indulgence and self-mortification, and between eternalism and nihilism. He explains the five aggregates as the only components of experience, with no owner behind them, and traces how the illusion of an owner produces a life of competition. He also covers the Three Bodies of Buddha, and the shift in Mahayana Buddhism from escaping suffering toward finding nirvana together with all beings. Dropping Off Body and Mind is read as the whole body functioning as one, not as a mystical event.
The talk turns practical in its treatment of zazen. He covers open eyes as a way of keeping all six sense gates receptive, the monastic day that begins the evening before, the cook's work as practice, and Dogen's three minds for community life. A Chinese Zen exchange about waving a fan, where the master's answer is simply to keep waving, anchors the point that form and ritual matter even when truth is all-pervasive.
Two turns stand out. One is the reversal of Indian and Chinese symbolism, in which darkness is wisdom beyond thought and light is the discriminating mind. The other is the claim, also marked contested, that intellectual understanding of emptiness does not change a life. He argues that change comes through bodily practice, which he compares to farming.
A Zen master teaching that authentic spiritual practice requires simultaneously engaging fully with immediate reality while transcending ego-centered attachments—neither escaping the world nor being trapped by it—and that this integration transforms suffering into wisdom through sustained, embodied practice.
- Dogen's 'genjo koan' teaching shows we must find our place and path in reality through practice, not through prior knowledge or meaning-seeking
- The middle way means living with our actual human body and limitations while remaining free from clinging to fixed identity or self-concept
- Spiritual practice is not transcendence of daily life but the actualization of Buddha-nature within ordinary activities like walking, cooking, and aging
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Dogen uses the analogy of firewood becoming ash to explain time and change: firewood has its own dharma position as firewood with before and after, but before and after are cut off; there is only the present moment of firewood being 100% firewood.
“firewood becomes ash ash cannot become firewood again however we should not view ash as after or firewood as before we should know that firewood dwells in the dharma position of firewood and has its own before and after although before and after exist past and future are cut off”
The goal of Zen practice is not to experience something different from one's day-to-day life, but rather to see deeply into the reality of each being and understand that reality is always asking 'what is this life, who are we, what am I doing', and we must answer with our practice.
“the goal of our practice is not to experience something different from our day to day lives it is to see deep into the reality of each being including this one why does anyone have to practice dogen's answer to this question was just practice we keep our eyes open naturally”
In the Zen dialogue between Master Baocher and a monk, the master's answer to 'why wave a fan if wind's nature is ever present and permeates everywhere' is simply to continue waving the fan—showing that even though ultimate truth is constant and all-pervasive, practice and manifestation are necessary; form and ritual cause the wind to manifest.
“then master baocher of mount magu was waving a fan a monk approached him and asked the nature of wind is ever present and permeates everywhere why are you waving a fan the master said you know only that the wind's nature is ever present you don't know that it permeates everywhere the monk said how does wind permeates everywhere the master just continued waving the fan the monk bowed deeply”
When a person attains realization, it is like the moon's reflection in water—the moon never becomes wet and the water is never disturbed, meaning awakening does not alter external reality but changes one's relationship to it.
“when a person attained realization it's like the moon's reflection in water the moon never becomes wet the water is never disturbed”
When a fish swims in the ocean or a bird flies in the sky, they do not need to investigate the entire ocean or sky before they can exist in it; similarly, we cannot find fixed meaning in life before we start living, but must begin practice first and discover meaning through the actualization of reality (genjo koan).
“when fish seems no matter how far it swims it doesn't reach the end of the water when a bird flies no matter how high it flies it cannot reach the end of the sky if there are fish that would swim or birds that would fly only after investigating the entire ocean or sky they would find neither path nor a place when we make this very place our own our practice becomes the actualization of reality genjokwan”
In Indian Buddhism, darkness represents ignorance (absence of light/wisdom), but in Chinese Zen, darkness represents true reality beyond thinking and beyond discrimination, while brightness or light represents the thinking mind and our conceptual creation of distinctions and values—wisdom in Zen is found in darkness beyond thought.
“light and darkness in indian buddhism and chinese and are opposite in indian buddhism darkness is ignorance ignorance means is without without light that means wisdom but in chinese then true reality beyond thinking is darkness and brightness or light is our discrimination because we when we see things we can see the difference and we make distinction between this and that brightness or light means the way we think and understand and we create a kind of a picture of the world and system of value that is how we live in a conventional way darkness is beyond thinking or beyond discrimination that is in chinese then called nothingness or emptiness”
'Dropping off body and mind' (shinjin datsuraku) in Dogen's teaching means dropping off the five aggregates in complete darkness without discrimination—the body and mind work together as one, with no independent function of individual organs but rather the whole body becoming an eye in darkness, a tongue when eating, with all actions involving the entire integrated functioning.
“dropping of poriano mind and dropping of body and mind means dropping off five aggregates in complete darkness there is no discrimination our body and mind work together as one the heart sutra says there are no eyes no ears no nose no tongue no anything because they are not independent they work together as one and there is no distinction between eye or nose or tongue the whole body becomes an eye in the darkness the whole body becomes a tongue when we eat we don't eat and taste with our mouths and tongues alone”
In Buddhist teaching, we must become free even of Buddha's teaching and even of enlightenment itself—one must not grasp any fixed idea, including the highest ideals.
“then we see that we are deluded this is enlightenment we have to become free even of the buddha's teaching even of enlightenment that is the buddha's teaching”
In the present moment, there is no length of time (no duration), so it has 'no rings'—if there were even a little length, it could be cut into before and after, but the actual present moment has zero time duration yet contains all past and future within it.
“this present moment has no ranks that be because if there are even a little bit length then we can cut movement into two and one is already gone and another side has not yet come so actually this present moment has no rings that means zero time disappeared but from this present moment that is zero you know entire past and the entire future are deflected”
Buddhism has been transmitted from India to many different countries in Asia and today in the West, and in each place a unique expression of Buddhism was created without changing the essence; similarly, each teacher has unique characteristics, and while the dharma does not change, Buddhism can change in its cultural expression.
“the dharma teaching might be some difference from much hemorrhoids or sarcoidosis buddhism has been transmitted from india to many different countries in asia and today in the west but in each place the unique nature or of buddhism was created without changing the essence indian buddhism chinese buddhism japanese buddhism and buddhism in the terrible tradition and tibetan tradition are all unique and i think each teacher has also unique in a sense buddhism can change even though dharma doesn't change”
Through sitting practice we discover that our thinking is not the owner of ourselves; we become free from ego-centered ideas and self-centered thinking, which allows us to focus on the present moment and let go of everything in the zendo, but outside the zendo in daily life we must focus on relevant stimuli (like traffic lights) while maintaining this freedom from attachment.
“by sitting practice where we're sitting we find that our thinking is not the owner of ourselves so we don't need to follow everything we want we think we become free from our ego self-centered idea or thinking and try to focus here and now and when we sit in the zendo we can really let go of everything but in our daily lives outside doesn't know we need to do something for example when we walk on the street it's important to remember the meaning of the color of the you know traffic light”
The middle way (as taught by Buddha in his first sermon) is the path between two extremes: practical extremes of self-indulgence (satisfaction of desires) and self-mortification (denial of the body); and philosophical extremes of eternalism (everything fixed) and nihilism (nothing exists).
“middleweight has two meanings one is a practical and another is a philosophical meaning what he said in the first teaching at the back to those five months is the middle way between self-indulgence and self-modification you know the first one is the way he lived at his father's palace until he left he had luxurious life his father provide everything the boy could enjoy but somehow he found that was not a meaningful life and he full of suffering in that way of life so he left his palace and started to practice”
In Mahayana Buddhism, there are three bodies of Buddha: Dharma-kaya (truth body—the ultimate universal Buddha nature, boundless and unchanging), Sambhoga-kaya (reward body—buddhas who attained enlightenment as a result of long practice), and Nirmana-kaya (manifestation body—the historical Buddha Shakyamuni who lived at a specific time and place), and these three are actually one thing.
“sri bodhi o buddha's dharma bodhi manifestation bodhi or niru manakaya and samboga kaya our manifestation body is historically shaking buddha as a person he was born at certain place at certain time and lived for certain periods of time and thought and passed away so actual person that is a foundation of this teaching that is a starting point when shakyamuni passed away buddha's student but as a disciple couldn't find a second buddha because he was so great so special person buddha was one of the three treasures in buddhism without buddha there's no buddhism so they start to think what is buddha and first he said that is dharma”
The five aggregates think they are the owner (atman, the self) and try to satisfy this perceived owner, making themselves and the owner into the most important entity, like treating the aggregates as servants of a king; this creates a life of competition because one tries to maintain the centrality of this self against others' selves.
“five already attached this kind of a production of thinking this is a concept but five five aggregate things this is more important than themselves this is like a like a king or emperor and further i agree i just think they are the employees and try to satisfy this the king or emperor or owner then our life becomes suffering for seals or four dharma cells”
Being natural is the most difficult thing for human beings; Buddha found freedom from the clinging and screening of the five aggregates to themselves, transforming them from being possessed by mara (ego-delusion) to functioning as Buddha's body and mind.
“to be natural is the most difficult thing for us human beings what buddha found was being free from the screening clinging of five aggregate to themselves buddha taught about before and after his awakening the difference is before pheno5 aggregate suffering they are called aggregate of attachment but after his awakening he found he is free from the screening or attachment so five aggregate becomes five of eight simply five aggregate”
When we give all our attention and energy to the task or practice before us, we can truly penetrate it; we study it, experiment with it, care for it repeatedly, one thing at a time—and this is how we study the characteristics of all things.
“when we give all our attention and energy to the task or practice before us we can truly penetrate it we work on the practice study it experiment with it and care for it we do this over and over again with whatever we encounter one thing at a time each time this is how we study the characteristics of all things”
Original Buddhist teaching saw samsara and nirvana as separate—practice was about escaping suffering and reaching nirvana; in Mahayana Buddhism, people found that reaching nirvana alone was not meaningful because we are interconnected with all beings—instead, the vow is to find nirvana together with all other beings.
“originally buddhist teaching is considered as we are within samsara and suffering and nirvana is a cessation of suffering so buddhist practice is a process of living from suffering or samsara and reaching nirvana but in mahinda buddhist buddhism people find to reach nirvana by oneself personally is not so meaningful because we are connected with all beings voice out of a vow that is fact the meaning of living by vowel is we are because we are living together with all beings interconnectedly only one person dating nirvana is not enough but we need to go to nirvana together with all other beings”
Within ourselves, light and darkness are together; they don't negate each other but interpenetrate—even though we are thinking, we live before thinking; even though we live beyond thinking, we are still thinking—so how these two sides work together in the healthiest way is important.
“within ourselves and light and darkestness are together they don't negate each other they are interpenetrating even though i'm thinking but i'm living life before thinking even though we are living beyond thinking still we are thinking so important point how these two sides can work together in the most healthy way”
The five aggregates (form, sensation, perception, formation, and consciousness) are the only components of experience; there is nothing that owns, uses, or drives these five aggregates—only the aggregates exist together.
“five aggregates are forms sensation perception formation and consciousness the first one is material that in our case this body and the other for mental function of our mind and what buddha taught is those five aggregates are only thing they are there are there's nothing which own and use or drive these five use those five aggregate but only five aggregate are there”
Dogen taught three minds necessary for practice in sangha or community: magnanimous mind (seeing community as interconnected without separation), parental/nurturing mind (offering to be harmonious with others because we are supported), and joyful mind (mature persons finding happiness in helping others like parents care for children).
“there are some wisdom in the in the history of buddhist or human spirituality we can learn and try to study and make change those three minds taught by dog and sanji when he wrote about practice of tenzo in the kitchen and he said not only denzo or cook but everyone in the sangha including the abbot and navis everyone in the sangha needs to have those three minds first thing is magnanimous mind that is the mind see the community as one without differentiation or separation that is interconnection and the second is a parental mind or nurturing mind that means we see we can offer something to be harmonious with other people because other people offer me or support me i also try to support others that is a nurturing mind or parental mind which i'm also often said childish mind always want to be taken care of and people take care of me we are satisfied we are happy but people don't take care of me i scream and complain but real matured person who has a parental mind can have joy within helping others because same as a parent find happiness by taking care of children that is a joyful mind”
Understanding that we are connected with everything and are empty through intellectual knowledge doesn't change life; to transform our life including body, mind and spirit we need to learn how to use our body through farming—that is, through practicing forms and rituals.
“i understand the teaching that we are connected with everything and we are empty it doesn't work that doesn't change my life in order to transform our life as a whole including body and mind and spirit we need to learn how to use our body and farming is the way we can cause the wind because wind nature is always there when we practice we can cause the wind but without this practice or form or rituals wind is simply unconcept or idea”
Finding one's place—the question on which one is sitting or the specific task before oneself—reveals the direction and path; without finding a place, life becomes meaningless.
“to me the place was the question on which i'm sitting and then we i found the place for me then i found the past the direction i have to work”
In zazen practice, keeping the eyes open naturally (not wide open, as if seeing about three feet in front) is important because closing the eyes easily leads to sleep or daydreaming, and keeping eyes open means not negating or rejecting stimuli from outside—all six sense gates remain open and receptive.
“we keep our eyes open naturally not wide open up naturally as if we see around three feet in front of ourselves so it's a kind of natural way of just keeping the eye open in our practice it keeps our eyes open is important because when i close our eyes it's easy to fall into sleep or easily we have day dreaming and also keep our eyes open is also not negate or reject the stimulus from outside our gates are open eyes”
In monastic practice, the day begins in the evening rather than the morning; monks wake around three or four in the morning for zazen and morning service, and sleeping is not a break from practice but part of the 24-hour practice itself—one must sleep in the healthiest way for body and mind.
“in the description of daily activities in the monasteries the beginning of the day is in the evening it's not in the morning when we wake up that means our day starts evening doesn't and we sleep i don't know depending up upon the teacher how long we can sleep but we usually wake up you know like three or four in the morning and we have autism practice and morning service”
In Dogen's tradition, cooking in the kitchen is an important practice (kenzo kyokum—instruction for the cook); like zazen, the cook must focus clearly on what they are doing and remember their place in the work process (washing leaves, cutting vegetables, cooking), letting go of miscellaneous thoughts while maintaining concentration on the present task.
“in dogen's tradition cooking is important practice so dogen wrote writing about kitchen practice named kenzo kyokum that is instruction for the cook and in that writing he used that same expression with the description he used for rajen”
Bodhichitta is the aspiration or awakening mind in Mahayana Buddhism—not a desire but an energy that recognizes one's way of life is not healthy and seeks to find a better, more genuine way of life; this energy exists in humans and in any spiritual tradition as the impulse toward health and wholeness.
“bodhichitta is a expression used in mahayana buddhism the people who aroused bodhichitta is called bodhisattvas the people who are seeking the body or awakening awakening means it's already there but our eyes are closed therefore we don't see awakening mind or bodhichitta or awakening mind or aspiration is that somehow deep in our body and mind there's some life force when we live in not healthy way somehow our life feel is not right away so we need to find alternative more genuine or healthy way that's not a desire but somehow some energy feel you know this is not healthy so we have to make change”
The four manifestations (abhaya kenga marga—related to the idea of self) are symptoms of the sickness caused by the idea of self; the problem with modern society is based on these four manifestations, and people suffer and create problems.
“the four gatsby kenga manga is a symptom of the sickness caused by the idea of the self according to buddhist teaching the problem with modern society is based on those four things and we suffer we create the problems and we suffer and it's really difficult to transform”
In Mahayana Buddhism, the four bodhisattva vows (to save all living beings, to eliminate all delusions, to study all dharma teachings, to attain Buddhahood) are understood as endless without a goal to be completed; rather, awakening means recognizing these vows as bottomless, and one walks step by step depending on the scenery of life, doing what one can and what is needed to help people around you.
“in buddhism in mahayana buddhism to become a buddhist we are taught in a form of four boy sort of about you know being the numbers we about to give them and all those four vowels and when we start study what's the meaning of these vowels and we find those vowels are endless that means there's no goal we can say now i save all living beings because living beings are numbers so we start to see the endless bottomless from in the beginning we just read those four bars we simply think that's good that's a good idea but when we start to practice we see that is really difficult to complete those four vowels and finally we see that is the through feeling that valve is not the goal but to awaken to that endless vow without bottom or without goal and yet we walk one step each time depending upon the scenery of life what i can do and what i need to do to be helpful to the people around us”
When a teenager, the speaker tried to find an alternative way of life and Buddhism was the answer; he thinks Shakyamuni and Dogen had the same problem—disliking something in their society and seeking alternatives; religious and spiritual people often begin by recognizing life with suffering as the base problem.
“when i was a teenager i tried to find a alternative way of life and buddhism was the answer to me you know i think shakyamuni had the same problem and dogen also almost all those religious or spiritual people didn't like something in the way you know they live in the society and try to find some alternative way of life i think it's very important to find the problem and in the case of buddhism life with suffering is a base problem so how can we free from suffering for ceremony that is the basic problem we want to find the answer”
After Buddha abandoned ascetic practice, he bathed in a river, restored his strength with food, and then sat under the Bodhi tree where he attained awakening—showing that the middle way includes proper care of the body.
“so he quit the ascetic practice and he received some food offering and so he restored some strength and he bathed in the liver or pond his body become clean and he had some energy and he started to sit under the body tree”
Dogen's poem 'though poor never poor, though sick never sick, though aging never aging, though dying never dying' expresses the non-dual reality where suffering and nirvana, living and dying are not two separate things, but interpenetrate each other—this was written at age 70 when Dogen had tuberculosis but possessed strong mental clarity despite physical weakness.
“though poor never poor though sick never sick though aging never aging though dying never dying reality prior to division hearing lies unlimited depth when we think in a conceptual logical way first half and second half are opposite and contradicted but what whichever thing is poor and not poor dying and not dying aging and yet not aging interpenetrated each other that means he was actually dying when he wrote that poem she was about 70 years old and he had a tb so physically he was not a healthy person but mentally he was very strong and healthy person”
The four seals (everything is suffering, impermanent, without self, and nirvana) are the reality Buddha awakened to, but people are blind to these realities and instead grasp the person as 'me', believing this is the center of the world and the meaning of life is to satisfy personal desire; this blindness to the four seals keeps life as samsara.
“for seals or four dharma cells the four most essential points of buddha's teaching everything is suffering impermanent and no self and nirvana those are the reality buddha awakened too but we almost always don't see that reality and we grasp this person as me and this is most important this is the center of the world to satisfy my personal desire is the meaning of life”
Dogen traveled to China to find a genuine teacher because he could not find one in Japan; this shows it is very important to find a good teacher, and the effort to seek one is justified by the clarity that results.
“gogen tried to find a genuine teacher and he couldn't find in japan so he had to go to china and he found only one good teacher it's really important to find a good teacher”
All religions and spiritual traditions have sitting meditation practice as important; Buddhist especially uses zazen as a central practice, but day-to-day activities are also practice, and many rituals, forms, and ceremonies within monastic traditions are part of practice because humans have bodies and must learn how to use body, mind, and tools to express spiritual understanding.
“all the religions of spiritual tradition have sat in where your style of practice and buddhist or them buddhist particularly of certain style that is in sort of sitting meditation zazen is most important forms of practice but our day-to-day activity is also a practice and there are so many rituals and forms and ceremonies within the monastic traditions that is also a part of our practice i think we need forms or rituals because we have body and our life is how to use this body”
In Dogen's teaching, there are three ways of viewing time: the conventional way (time flows from past through present to future), time as only the present moment with no duration, and time that does not flow (where from the big bang until now is simply one moment).
“in organs teaching there are three kind of time or three way of viewing time one is our usual way of thinking usually of understanding of time time flows from past to the present and present to the future that is one way and second is time only here and now and which has no rings and third is time which doesn't flow when he i studied logan he said how other than here and now it's one with everything in the past and in the future i think that means from the big one until now this is one moment we make a segment by thinking”
When a seed functions as a seed according to its own life force, it negates itself by becoming something else (a plant); when a baby expresses its life force, it negates babyhood and becomes a person; life is always new and fresh because things are always becoming otherwise.
“when a seed freeze functions as a seed according to its own life force it negates itself by becoming something else the nature of a seed is that it is not bound to being a human life is the same as this when a baby free express its life force it negates babyhood and becomes a person when we see this reality we see that our lives are always new and fresh”
Aging is a valuable practice because it reveals the limitation of the body and the reality that one gradually loses capacities; this period of losing abilities is not meaningless but a very important part of life, comparable to the growth period after birth when new capacities are gained.
“when i start to compare who i am and who i used to be and i think that was better then i feel just sorry and i i have to say i'm not good at anymore but this is a very important period of our life i think the same as several years after i was born each year i think i can do something i couldn't do last year but this is the opposite period this year i cannot do what i used i could do last year but this is not meaningful part of our life but this is very important part so aging is a very good practice”
In the formula 'one equal zero equal to infinity', one refers to individual identity (Shoho Kumura as one unique person), zero refers to the emptiness and non-independent nature of that person (as a collection of elements), and infinity refers to interconnectedness with all beings through the network of interdependent origination.
“in my case shohako kumra is only one person in this world and yet shohakura is simply the collection of five scandals and that's imp so this is zero and because this is zero i think i'm interconnected with everything in this network of interdependent origination again there are three aspects one is one other person that is a collection of many elements and because that is only a connection that is there's no such thing called schwark as an independent entity therefore we are connected with all beings”
Uchiyama Roshi's teacher expressed the reality that all humans have both 'thief nature' (wanting to get what belongs to others because one wants it) and 'Buddha nature' (the nature of interconnection and mutual support), and depending on one's activity and actions in each moment, one manifests either thief nature or Buddha nature.
“that is sarcoidosis are saying sarcoidosis my teacher's teacher he had a very good sense of humor so buddha nature and thief nature is the way he expressed this reality safe nature means i want this therefore i have to get that that thing i want even that is not my position if if that is other person's position i want to get it that is a safe nature and he said all of us have seven nature to satisfy our personal desire but we are also have a buddha nature that is a nature we are connected with all beings and support each other and depending upon our activity our actions here and now we may express either buddha nature or a thief nature so our practice is try to express or manifest buddha nature instead of stiff nature but we cannot live without this nature”
Connection through words and internet creates more isolation because one cannot really trust others' words or know if what is expressed is genuine; even one cannot trust oneself about whether what one is feeling and thinking matches what one is saying, so there is endemic mutual suspicion and difficulty finding peace of mind.
“even the connectedness is a kind of symptom of you know isolation that that's why we want to have connection but connection through using words and internet makes us feel more isolated because we don't really trust in other people's words is really a genuine expression of other people's feelings or heart so we have to be always suspicious about other people and even we don't believe ourselves if what i'm really feeding and thinking and what i'm saying is same thing or not you know sarah so there are so many false news fake news even what i'm saying might be something not different not really as what i feel and think”
In modern society, the entire world is one society with different people living together, making it very difficult for all to balance keeping cultural identity with being free from it—this is the most difficult and important coin (challenge) for everyone today.
“now this entire world is a one society so there are so many different people living together as a member of one society so it's very difficult time for us all of us so i think the most difficult and important coin is how can we keep identity and at the same time become free from identity racial spiritual and cultural identity we need to keep the identity and yet if we become free from identity then we have to fight against other people so this is really difficult quran for all of us”
If one is completely free with no forms or rituals and must invent everything by oneself, it is very difficult to find genuine forms of practice; therefore one needs to study the rituals and forms transmitted in traditions, even though these can change and be adapted.
“if we are completely free and we can do anything and we have to invent anything by myself then it is very difficult to find genuine forms of practice we need to at least in the beginning study what kind of rituals or forms or style of practice have been transmitted in its traditions and of course we can change”
When spiritual practice and teaching are not transmitted to the next generation, one's effort does not continue; but when practice and teaching are transmitted, spiritual figures like Shakyamuni Buddha remain alive through continuing practice 2500 years after their death, suggesting that transmission of tradition to younger people is essential for the continuation of effort.
“if you know this way of life is not transmitted to the next generation you know my effort doesn't continue in a sense you know sheikh muni buddha is still alive after 2500 years because we practice we study and practice his teaching so if our practice and teaching is continued or transmitted to younger people our effort our tradition has ended that is too bad so i really hope younger people are interested in some alternative way of life”
In sitting practice facing the wall, people take off all the clothing of definitions, evaluations, and identity (occupational status, personal qualities like clever/stupid, social class)—becoming nothing in order to just be who one is without definition.
“sitting rather than when we sit in the end of facing the wall we can take off all those clothings that means we are nothing we are free from all those definitions or evaluation about who i am but just be who i am i think that is what take off all the clothes or naked self means”
Interconnectedness as taught in Buddhist traditions came from certain lineages, and people who do not think of themselves as Buddhist can see this reality directly when they truly look at how they live within the universe supported by all things and people.
“this idea of you know inter connectedness with teaching of interconnectedness came from certain traditions certain lineage even people who don't think they are buddhist they can see that reality without belief in the doctrine when our eyes are open and see deeply how we live within this universe being supported by all things and people we can find it's important to find that reality and to live in harmonious way with all other people and things”
When the speaker was young, he thought he could do anything being healthy and strong and could change everything; now he finds his life is limited and he cannot make change by himself—if this way of life is not transmitted to the next generation, his effort ends.
“when i was young i thought i can i could do anything i i was healthy and strong and i felt i can change everything but now i found my life is limited and sooner or later i disappear i cannot make change by myself if you know this way of life is not transmitted to the next generation you know my effort doesn't continue”
Kilos (Saichiro Kilos Kumura's teacher) and the speaker's teacher Uchamuro were very different people—Kilos from a poor family with strong body, Uchamuro from a rich family, intellectual, physically weak with TB—yet what they thought were the same dharma.
“kilos very different people physically or coming in a comic way sakura she was was from very poor family and he had very strong body so he was really tough person and uchamros was from rich family and he was very intellectual he studied philosophy and yet physically he was very weak person he had tb since he was early 20s and sadler she graduated only from elementary school but ucham rush finished master course they are very different but what they thought are the same same dharma”
All humans are influenced by karma (experiences and cultural influences from our past and lineage); one cannot escape this influence or stop being one's cultural/national identity, but one must learn to be free from that identity at the same time, holding identity without being trapped by it.
“all of us have karma karma means influenced by our experience including in my case what all people in japan had been experienced that became a japanese culture and that influenced me so i cannot become free from that influence that means i am a japanese and i cannot stop being japanese and i don't think i need to but important point is i cannot lose identity as a japanese person and yet to live together with people from other tradition i have to be free from my identity as japanese so i think both can be there we need to keep identity and yet we need to be free from that identity at the same time that is a very diff difficult practice”
Finding emptiness and interconnectedness with all beings and achieving peace of mind through practice is important for people living in today's world, where many use language as a weapon to compete with others or to influence others in the way they want.
“i use even the language as a kind of a weapon to compete with others or to influence others in the way i want so in that way of life you know it's very difficult to find a peace of mind to me you know this practice to find emptiness and interconnectedness with all beings and find peace of mind is really important for us living in this world today”
When finding a teacher, one's practice is half completed because a teacher represents a model of life direction—the teacher shows which kind of life one wants to live, providing both direction and motivation to walk the path.
“in the organization there's a thing that when we find a teacher our practice is half completed teacher means which kind of life i want to live and the teacher is a learning model so i want to live like that person that is the direction and when we find that direction we want we want to walk that is almost half of the board sort of a path”
The speaker describes practice as like an anchor for a boat—without an anchor, the ship goes anywhere depending on the winds; with practice and doing things mindfully, he knows to be here and now, and when he goes somewhere else mentally, he knows how to return to what he is doing.
“to me the practice is like a anchor of the boat if there's no anchor the ship may go anywhere depending up upon the winds but doing things as practice i know i need to be here and now and when i feel i go somewhere else i know how to return what i'm doing so i think it's really helpful for me”
It is very difficult to find genuine teachers, and many fake teachers exist; unless one knows what constitutes a genuine teacher, one cannot distinguish them from false teachers; young people interested in Buddhism should study dharma teachings extensively and meet different teachers to learn to judge who are genuine teachers.
“it's very difficult there are so many teachers or fake teachers it's really difficult unless we know what is a genuine teacher we don't know what is fake teachers it's very difficult so i felt i was really lucky unfortunate as a buddhist in this country in united states you know the history of buddhism is so short yet so it's kind of difficult to find to see to judge who is who are good teachers not genuine teacher important thing is to for young people who are interested in buddhism to study the dharma as much as possible and to meet different teachers and try to find who is the genuine teachers”
Around age 30, the speaker felt he had escaped enough and could open himself to offer something to people living in the world he had rejected, transforming his motivation from escape and isolation to engagement and contribution—this transformation of aspiration is important.
“but i think around i became 30 years old i feel now i'm enough i escaped enough my escape is completed so i could open myself and try to offer something to the people who are living in that world i was practicing studying and practicing buddha's teaching the basic motivation i had when i started to study buddhism is still you know functioning and it disturbed me to be free from you know myself so i don't like the way people live in the society my practice was kind of escaping and isolating but by seeing the interconnectedness i think i could open myself and try to offer anything i can offer so it is important that is a transformation”
During intensive zazen session (sesshin) with 14 periods of 15-minute sitting separated by 10-minute walking meditation from 4am to 9pm, the speaker discovered that he did not dream properly because he had enough dreams during sitting meditation, allowing him to sleep very deeply and well.
“when i was young i found one interesting thing that is when i sit during session we sit 14 period a day one period of 15 minutes and we have a 10 minute walking meditation and we repeat that 14 times and we have a three meals and a short last each during which meet so those are three hours so from four in the morning until nine in the evening we just sit 14 period that day except three meals and we try to you know let go of thinking and i found during session i don't dream proper because i have i had enough dreams during sitting so i could sleep very well deeply”
The speaker has lived in a way that requires practicing in 'voluntary poverty'—not extreme poverty but a middle way of keeping life simple and wholesome without chasing luxurious living, eating mainly vegetables and rice, which he believes helps maintain physical health and is the best way to keep the body in good condition.
“we need to practice in poverty we can't be a super rich that means we cannot spend a luxurious life i have been eating simple wholesome food and i couldn't drink so much luxurious life is not so healthy life in the not extreme poverty but the volunteer poverty that is middleweight you know not chasing after you know luxurious life but keep the life simple and wholesome is i think the best way to keep our physical body also in a good condition”
The speaker was born after WWII when Japanese society changed completely through war, is 36 years younger than his teacher Uchiyama Roshi, was educated in the American way, and therefore cannot fully agree with or imitate his teacher, but tried not to change the dharma and practice while adapting to the very different culture of the United States.
“i am also different from both of them one difference is i was born after world war ii you know japanese society was changed almost completely by the war and ucha murash was 36 years older than me and so i was educated in the american way so it's very different as a comic person there are some things i cannot agree or i cannot follow or imitate him but i tried to not change his dharma and his practice but still after he retired when i was 26 i came to this country and it's very different you know from between japan and united states it's really different culture”
As an aging person at 73, the speaker can no longer sit as much as before due to pain in knees, buttocks, and hips; he now focuses on writing and preparing lectures, but because of the practice foundation he knows how to focus on what is necessary to do here and now, and day-to-day activities serve as practice mindfully while letting go of irrelevant thoughts.
“now i'm 73 and so i couldn't i cannot sit anymore i have you know pains you know on my knees and buttocks and hips so i cannot see you know now hoku is reading our session and literally i focus on writing and preparation for lectures i feel i know how to focus on what i need to do here and now because of the practice”
As a high school student, the speaker disliked people in Japanese society working hard to make money (Japanese people called 'economic animals'), and his initial motivation to become a Buddhist practitioner was escaping from that way of life; for almost 10 years he was closed off, not wanting to live like people in society.
“when i was a high school student i didn't like people who were living in japanese society people are working hard to make money so japanese people are called economic animals and i didn't like that so fast motivation to become a buddhist practitioner is escaping from that way of life at least first several or almost 10 years in my practice i i was closed i don't want to live in the way people lived”
The speaker is currently working on a book about Buddhist precepts; precepts are important guidelines for daily life based on practice, and through receiving precepts and understanding their meaning, people become Buddhist—a precept retreat is held where the speaker gives lectures on precepts and at the end conducts a precept ceremony.
“the book project i'm working now is a book about the precept you know to become a buddhist with a sheep in social interaction we achieve voice out of a precept by receiving the policy we become buddhist as a teacher i when i give precept to people i need to explain the meaning of the precept no one are forced to become a buddhist to become a buddhist they need their aspiration to become a buddhist”