
Life begins at 40: the biological and cultural roots of the midlife crisis | The Royal Society
What this covers
This Royal Society lecture by the historian Mark Jackson treats the midlife crisis as a historical object. It uses David Nobbs's novel and BBC series about Reginald Perrin, an everyman who fakes his death on a Dorset beach and returns under a new name, as a running case. Perrin's despair, his sense of lost virility, and his destructive behaviour are read as products of the 1950s and 60s, in line with the idea of being aged by history as well as by mind and body. The term itself dates to Elliot Jaques, a Tavistock-based psychoanalyst trained under Melanie Klein, whose 1965 account describes a depressive crisis at the peak of life, masked by manic denial behaviors.
The lecture then sets out the demographic background. Life expectancy in Britain rose sharply, and marriage moved earlier: 24% of women were married by 24 in 1911, against 52% in the early 1950s. Men's lives ran on occupational timetables, and Bernice Neugarten's point that the life course is socially prescribed holds the argument together. Jackson also describes a first "sandwich generation" that cared for adolescent children and ageing parents at once, and he follows rising British divorce, including the Divorce Reform Act of 1969.
The lecture also covers several intellectual and cultural currents: - Walter Pitkin's self-help book Life Begins at 40, which promoted leisure and consumption and carried an economic message as well as a personal one. - James Truslow Adams's collective vision of the American Dream, and its later reduction to material plenty. - Edmund Bergler's claim that disappointed middle-aged men turned to happiness in a hurry. - Margaret Mead's proposal of serial marriage. - Psychoanalytic ideas feeding into marriage guidance and couples therapy. - The gendered side of the story: the "empty nest," the "biological clock," and the way women's midlife was tied to reproduction.
The claims about Bergler and about Perrin as a product of historical conditions are the most contestable.
The midlife crisis is not primarily a biological or individual psychological phenomenon, but rather a social and cultural product of 20th-century demographic changes—standardized life courses, economic pressures, and the collapse of collective aspirations into narcissistic materialism—that created specific stresses on middle-aged populations.
- Standardized life course (early marriage, clustered childbearing, fixed retirement) created age anxiety and clear failure-against-milestones expectations
- Collapse of American Dream's collective vision left only materialism, creating 'happiness in a hurry' and narcissistic self-fulfillment that destabilized marriages
- Midlife crisis emerged historically as a cultural phenomenon tied to specific post-war conditions, not as inevitable biological aging
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Bernice Neugarten, a prominent American psychologist, identified that the timetable and milestones of life—when to marry, have children, work, retire—are socially prescribed rather than merely biological, meaning transitions between life stages and expectations can change as social conditions change.
“Bernice no Garson was a very prominent psychologist in America who wrote extensively on middle-aged and midlife and the transitions between very life stages and various life stages and she pointed out of course that the timetable the milestones of life were not merely biological they were also also socially prescribed so there was a socially prescribed timetable she said for the ordering of major life events a time in the life span when men and women are expected to marry a time to raise children a time to retire”
In Nobbs' novel, Reggie Perrin fakes his death by leaving his clothes on a Dorset beach, then resurfaces with a new name (Martin Wellborn) and identity, suggesting that midlife crisis involved fantasies of death and rebirth—complete escape from and reinvention of the old self.
“he drives a van down to a Dorset Beach takes off his clothes leaves them on the beach and walks out into the sea naked he doesn't drown himself he walks back up puts another set of clothes on so that he leaves his old clothes on the beach so people think that he's drowned himself puts on a new set of clothes puts on a week and takes on a new identity and he becomes eventually Martin well born”
Psychoanalytical models of aging and life stages were incorporated into practical therapeutic work, becoming foundational to marriage guidance counseling and couples therapy at institutions like the Tavistock clinic, based on understanding individual development across the life course and identifying crisis points.
“this wasn't just a theory of how we developed eating it was also incorporated into practice and psychoanalytical models of Aging became absolutely key to the work of marriage guidance counselors for example working for the national marriage guidance council or couples therapist working at the Tavistock clinic for example most of that was built on an understanding of individual development across the life course through the stages through middle age and through the various crisis points that they could produce”
Women's midlife crises in the early-to-mid 20th century literature were often tied to reproductive life and menopause, with the 'biological clock' concept (term used by journalist Richard Cohen in 1978) suggesting women's crises and transitions were governed by or reducible to their biology, distinct from men's crises.
“particularly in women in relation to reproductive life and here the argument was and most of the literature certainly in this period was on men but there was some literature on women in these cases women were understood to go through a crisis act through during after menopause as their reproductive functions supposedly disappeared or in some ways through the emptiness process so the a woman's midlife crisis which had tied very very clearly to her reproductive capacity the term biological clock or the talkee the clock is ticking in fact was used by an American journalist Richard Cohen in 1978”
The 'empty nest' concept, first introduced around 1913, was initially applied derogatorily to women, suggesting their only social function was childbearing and that they had no value once children left. However, it describes a genuine structural feature: women in the 1950s could live 52+ additional years after their last child's birth, raising questions about life meaning beyond motherhood.
“the empty nest is is as it was first introduced the empty nest in in about 1913 it was applied largely to women in a rather derogatory way that their only function in society was to have children and once those children had left they were of no value but in some ways it describes a very key feature of the extended life course that by the 1950s given the fact that women and men are marrying earlier having their children earlier a woman could live for a further 52 years after the birth of their last child”
Walter Pitkin's 1920s-1930s self-help book 'Life Begins at 40' (later adapted as a 1935 film starring Will Rogers) popularized the idea that middle-aged people should realize 30-40 years remain until age 70-80, and should pursue self-fulfillment through material improvement, leisure, and 'the art of living'—less work, more leisure and play.
“the most common way or the most popular book was Walter Pickens book entitled life begins at 40 Pitkin was an American journalist working at Columbia University in the taken miss notion that life begins at 40 to write a self-help book and you can see from the cover of the book through this book's inspiring and helpful advice thousands of men and women fearful of middle age have lost their anxieties and found new ways to make life richer happier and more worth living this was the the the blurb on the book to try and sell it and the notion both Pickens book and that phrase life begins at 40 were used in other areas life begins at 40 was a film in 1935 starring Will Rogers that was based on the book”
Elliot Jacks' theory of the midlife crisis (published 1965) posited that middle-aged men experience an identity crisis when they reach the peak of the binomial curve of life and realize death lies beyond, triggering anxiety and depressive crisis that they attempt to cover with manic behaviors designed to convince themselves they are still young.
“the paradox is that of entering the prime of life the stage of fulfillment but at the same time the prime and fulfillment are dated death lies beyond so the picture that Jack's created was off this this man usually at the peak of a binomial curve of life and when you get to that peak all you can see is the downward curve to death and that's the moment when anxiety a depressive crisis was triggered”
Divorce rates in Britain rose from fewer than 7,000 couples before WWII, had a boost after WWII (explained by hasty wartime marriages and soldiers' reintegration difficulties), plateaued briefly, then rose sharply through the late 1960s-1980s, with the Divorce Reform Act of 1969 removing the marital offense requirement and replacing it with 'irretrievable breakdown,' making divorce easier.
“before the Second World War fewer than 7,000 couples were divorced there was a big boost after the Second World War during the late forties to 50 linked largely to well explained in terms of hasty marriages during the war the difficulties that soldiers had readjusting to civilian life the fact that during separation both husbands and wives for example had had affairs those challenges led to a high level of breakdown after the Second World War there was a little bit of a plateau and then arise through the late 60s 70s and 80s now I don't to say that the midlife crisis the challenges that people faced in middle age were the only reasons for that one of the reasons for the big rise after 1970 there's a change in the divorce law the divorce reform act of her was introduced in 1969 removed the marital offence and replaced it with the notion of irretrievable breakdown making it much easier for some people to get a divorce”
The 1930s were paradoxically both a period of morbid gloom due to economic recession and fear of global war, and a period of optimism with the conception of the American Dream by James Truslow Adams (1931), who argued that life both individually and collectively did not have to decline toward death and destruction but could go upward.
“and in some ways a pick in writing in the 30s the 1930s were a strangely paradoxical period a period of morbid gloom in some kind of ways because of the recession and because of the fear of another global war but it was also a period of incredible optimism it was the period when the American Dream was conceived and the American Dream first appeared in the work of James Truslow Adams in 1931 the year before Pitkin published life begins at 40 and it's in the epilogue to this fantastic overview the epic of America and in that epilogue he tries to sketch out the future to move away from some of the doom and gloom of the interwar period to say life globally as well as individually doesn't have to go down towards death and destruction it can go the other way”
The term 'midlife crisis' was introduced approximately one decade before the 1960s (around 1955) by Canadian social scientist and psychoanalyst Elliot Jakes, who was based at the Tavistock Institute for Human Relations and had been analyzed by Melanie Klein.
“the midlife crisis now the term had been first introduced about a decade earlier by a Canadian social scientists and psychoanalyst Elliot Jax Jax had come over from Toronto in the second world war had stayed he was one of the founding members of the Tavistock Institute for human relations he was social scientists but also psychoanalyst he'd been analyzed himself by Melanie Klein”
Edmund Bergler, an American psychoanalyst practicing in the 1940s-50s, argued in 'The Revolt of the Middle-Aged Man' that depressed middle-aged people experiencing the collapse of the American Dream translated their aspirations into materialism and narcissistic self-fulfillment, seeking happiness through consumption and sexual conquest rather than genuine human connection.
“Edmund burglar the revolt of the middle-aged man published in in 1958 that Edmund burglar was an American psychoanalyst who had a very extensive clinic and he drew on his clinical experience to write about a whole variety of challenges relating to marriage middle age and midlife...what he says is that during the 40s and 50s the collapse of the American Dream in many ways...left people struggling and they translated those struggles or those aspirations into a dream of material Plenty into consumption seduced by the pleasure of consuming material goods”
We are 'aged' not just by our minds and bodies but also by history—the cultural values, attitudes, beliefs, norms, and practices inherited from the past, such that individuals like Reggie Perrin in the 1970s were shaped by historical conditions and demographic changes of the 1950s-60s.
“we are aged Reggie us we are aged not just by our minds and bodies but we are also aged by history by the cultural values the attitudes that beliefs the norms the practices that we have inherited from the past some ways Reggie Perry in the late seventies went off the rails because of what had happened in the 1950s and 60s both in terms of the life course end in terms of the seduction of materialism”
Life expectancy in Britain increased from approximately 50-60 years (if born in late 19th/early 20th century) to well into the 70s-80s by the 1950s-1960s, dramatically extending the period of adulthood and middle age that people experienced.
“couples were living longer if you were born at the end of 19th century early 20th century in this country we might expect to live until we were 14 50 60 by the 1950s 40s 50s we might expect to live until well into our 70s or perhaps eighties so life expectancy had increased giving us that longer life cycle”
Marriage age dropped significantly in the early-to-mid 20th century: in 1911 only 24% of women were married by age 24, but by the early 1950s this had risen to 52%, with most women surveyed reporting the ideal marriage age as 20-24.
“we were marrying earlier by 19 in 1911 only about 24% of women were married by the age of 24 by the early 50s that had risen to 52% and in fact if you look at some of the surveys of men and women's attitudes about marriage during this period most women would say that the ideal age to marry is between 20 and 24”
Reggie Perrin (protagonist of David Nobbs' novel/BBC series, late 1970s) is an everyman figure whose psychological despair (identity crisis), biological decline (aging, lost virility), and destructive behavior can be understood as the product of post-war demographic standardization, extended life course stresses, and collapse of collective aspirations into materialistic narcissism.
“Reggie Peron in some ways spoke for a generation he was an everyman if you like and his wife and children every day victims of the kinds of pressures that people and families were under in the 50s 60s and 70s we can certainly understand his behavior that random impulsive destructive behavior as the product of psychological despair I've hit my peak I've reached my prime but it no longer means anything because all I look forward to is the downward curve of life and death as that sense of an identity crisis that is captured very very neatly by David knobs but also you can see it in other literary and cinematic forms as well in the fifties sixties and seventies all we can read it in biological terms we can say that pairing is aging he's losing his virility he's losing his hair he's losing muscle mass and energy and that leads him into a crisis of despair as well linked to death but not entirely the same we can see this in individual terms this is a man behaving strangely what I want to suggest though is that we cannot understand Reggie unless we cast our lens wider than that unless we zoom out to see the social and the cultural conditions in which Reggie Peron was living”
Anthropologist Margaret Mead (1949) argued that in a world where people may reorient their entire lives at 40-50, lifelong marriage becomes much more difficult, and proposed multiple serial marriages as a solution—suggesting different partners for different life stages (youthful passion, parenthood, companionship) because the demands of life change across the extended life course.
“Margaret Mead I've quoted here as an anthropologist in a very interesting book male and female in 1949 published in 1949 pointed out that in a world in which people may reorient their whole lives at 40 or 50 that's a world in which marriage for life becomes much more difficult Margaret Mead solution and the solution of some science fiction writers was that we should introduce the possibility of multiple serial marriages she suggested - but many writers at the time suggested possibly three one for youthful passion one for Parenthood and one for companionship in later life”
The standardized, homogenized life course with clustered major life events created clearer age-based stages (e.g., middle-age between 30-50 or 40-60) and enabled identification of critical transitions between life phases, which had not existed in earlier periods when life events were more dispersed.
“the teasing out of the life course the the clustering of major life events in very similar ways across populations meant that people began to experience much more clearly defined stages and transitions in the life course so you could begin to identify a period of middle age between 30 and 50 40 and 60 and we could begin to identify those critical stages of transition between those life phases”
The original gendered phrase 'the best part of a woman's life begins at 40' was lost in translation/circulation, becoming simply 'life begins at 40' without the female-specific framing.
“that notion it's really interesting that as the notion life begins at 40 became popular the the the first part of that sentence the best part of a woman's life begins at 40 got lost in some kind of translation it became simply life begins at 40”
Pitkin's work functioned as both individual psychology (personal renewal strategy) and political messaging: if middle-aged and elderly people worked less and had more leisure, younger people would find more jobs, boosting the economy; if older people spent money on consumption and pleasure, they would further stimulate economic growth.
“if we reinvigorated ourselves there was hope for optimism and pickins argument was that if people as they got older the middle-aged and the elderly work less and had more leisure there would be more job opportunities for younger people which would boost the economy equally if people in middle age and older age spent their money buying things enjoying themselves purchasing leisure for example and pleasure that would also boost the economy so part of the appeal of pickins work was that it struck a chord in individuals like Reggie Peron who were struggling with their own problems but it also meant something to a Western world struggling with the effects of economic recession”
The midlife crisis is not a biological or natural inevitable phenomenon of aging, but rather immediately a social and cultural phenomenon—a set of experiences generated by historical change, shaped by cultural contexts and socioeconomic conditions, and determined also by political contingencies.
“in that context when we are saying that we're aged by history and culture within that context the midlife crisis is no longer the biological the natural phenomenon the inevitable phenomenon of aging it is immediately a social and a cultural phenomenon the midlife crisis that Reggie suffered from that we perhaps continue to suffer from is a set of experiences that is generated by historical change shaped by cultural contexts and social economic conditions and determined also by political contingencies”
The hopes and dreams of Pitkin and Adams were dashed by WWII and the Cold War; what remained of the American Dream was stripped of its collective values and reduced to a dream of material plenty (motorcars and high wages), and people could no longer achieve the 'grandiose aspirations' of democratic opportunity and collective self-fulfillment.
“what happened was the opposite those hopes and those dreams were dashed they were dashed by the second World War they were dashed by the catastrophe of global conflict and they were dashed in many ways by what happened afterwards in terms of the Cold War that sense of optimism that could create security or the sense of security that could create optimism they were dashed during the Second World War and afterwards what was left of pickins mantra and Adams dream was simply a dream of material Plenty the values the scale the basis of values that dream of social order that was democratic and egalitarian Equal Opportunities occupationally and educationally that was shattered by experiences in the second world what was left was the dream of motorcars and high wages people were left feeling that they could not achieve those other grandiose aspirations that Pitkin and Adams had set out instead what they tended to do was search for happiness in a hurry”
The 1950s-1970s generation (Reggie Perrin's cohort) could be described as the first 'Sandwich Generation' because the timing of marriage, childbearing, and parental aging aligned such that when middle-aged people (age 40-50) had adolescent children in crisis, their own parents were aging and needing care, creating simultaneous upward and downward caregiving demands.
“this is the generation in the fifties and sixties 70s Reggie parents generation that could perhaps describe themselves as the first Sandwich Generation if we think about the patterns of marriage and child rearing and aging if you imagine that we have that couple ideally marrying at twenty have their children by twenty five by the time they're 40 45 Reggie parents age their children will be going through the troubled years of adolescence their parents would be aging through retirement needing more care and you find in this period the middle aged between the age of 30 and 50 40 and 60 becoming sandwiched between the troubles of their adolescent children and the troubles of their parents”
Men's life rhythms in the mid-20th century were governed by occupational patterns rather than family patterns: they worked for a fixed number of years, often in the same job until retirement, creating a socially prescribed male life course from work-start to retirement set by government, state, or private industry.
“men's rhythm the rhythm of men's life was slightly different dictated not so much by the rhythms of the family but by the rhythms of occupational patterns by the 1950s and 60s men tended to work for a fixed number of years often in the same job until retirement so you can see the male life course in some ways also socially prescribed from the moment of starting work to the moment of retirement set by the government by the state or by private industries”
Inheritance patterns shifted dramatically: in 1891, middle-class Westerners could expect to inherit at age 37, but by the 1940s this shifted to age 56, meaning inheritance came after childbearing and often after children had left home—too late to help finance child-rearing and creating financial pressure on middle-aged couples.
“middle age was also challenged for many people by financial pressures at this time and again this was a feature of the changing life cycle in 1891 we could expect to inherit at the age of about 37 now I have to say that this is a middle-class Western story this is not true of everybody although the longer history of the midlife crisis suggests that the crisis has been democratized in many ways but if you were lucky enough to inherit in the late 19th century you could expect to inherit at the age of 37 by the 1940s you would expect to inherit not until you were 56 that meant that you inherited it's always nice to get money don't get me wrong but if you inherited you inherited after you'd had children after their children have grown up and after they left home at times when you might not need it as much as you had when you were middle-aged bringing up children that created us set of financial pressures on couples trying to bring up children”
Matilda Parsons (widow of an army officer, fitness instructor) first used the phrase 'life begins at 40' in 1917, in an interview four days after America entered WWI, proposing that 'death begins at 30' (muscle cell deterioration), and that women could extend their lives through diet and exercise to enjoy 'the best part of a woman's life' beginning at 40.
“the phrase life begins at 40 was first used well as far as we know in 1917 by mrs. Theodore Parsons Matilda Parsons who was the widow of an army officer but had already had her career as well teaching particularly young women and girls and young women and older women how to keep fit scientific bodybuilding is what she referred to it as and partly it was keeping physically fit in order to keep the mind fit and this phrase I loved she was interviewed in 1917 for the newspaper it was four days after America entered the First World War and in the interview she said very similar set of ideas to what Eliot Jack's introduced much later in the sixties it's a paradox of life she said that we do not begin to live until we begin to die death begins at 30 that is deterioration of the muscle cells set in most old age is premature and attention to diet and exercise would enable men and women to live a great deal longer than they do today the best part of a woman's life begins at 40 that was her phrase”
James Truslow Adams' American Dream was not merely material (motorcars, high wages) but a vision of a social order in which each person could attain the fullest stature they were innately capable of and be recognized by others regardless of birth or position—a collective, egalitarian vision based on trust, love, and working together.
“for Adams the American Dream was not a dream simply of motorcars and high wages so it's not just a material dream but a dream of a social order in which each man and woman shall be able to attain to the fullest statue of which they're innately capable and be recognized by others for what they are regardless of the fortuitous circumstances of birth or position so this was Adams dream and it was a dream in a sense that resonated very clearly with what Pitkin was saying...Adams argued we needed to develop a new scale and basis for values for Adams looking forward to the to achieving the American dream that meant collectivity trust love working together to make a better world”
Bergler describes the midlife man's thought process during crisis as: 'I want happiness, love, approval, admiration, sex, youth—all denied me in this stale marriage to an elderly, sickly, complaining, nagging wife. Let's get rid of her and start over. Sure, I'll provide for my first wife and children, but self-defense comes first. I just have to save myself.'
“I want happiness love approval admiration sex youth all this is denied me in this stale marriage to an elderly sickly complaining nagging wife let's get rid of her start Life all over again with another woman sure I'll provide for my first wife and children sure I'm sorry the first marriage didn't work out but self defense comes first I just have to save myself”
Midlife crisis debates in the mid-20th century were linked closely to concerns about marriage stability, which authorities regarded as essential for social stability, reflecting anxiety that midlife men's behavior (infidelity, abandonment) was threatening family breakdown and social cohesion.
“debates about the midlife crisis in this period and still I think link it very closely to concerns about the stability of marriage which was regarded by many as essential for social stability”
Psychologists Robert Lee and Marjorie Kassabian (authors of 'Weathering the Marriage Crisis During Middle Essence') identified that multiple stresses during middle age—not meeting standardized milestones, recognizing unachieved goals—led people to reappraise their lives, comparing achievements against goals and satisfactions against values, often resulting in recognition of failure and crisis.
“a number of the psychologists in this period pointed out that the extended life course that continued pressures of middle age through middle age meant that many people when they got to the age of 40 45 began what Robert Lee and Marjorie Kassabian referred to in the in the spouse Kappa don't if you can see weathering the marriage crisis during middle essence is the subtitle of the book what they pointed out that the multiple stresses during middle age that sense of recognizing that you were not achieving what you should have according to the standardized timetable of the life course meant that people began to reappraise their lives to reckon the achievements against the goals the satisfactions versus values the kind of evaluation of his life that Reggie Peron went through”
The concept of senescence, popularized by American psychologist Grandville Stanley Hall in the early 20th century, became a key framework for defining middle-age as the period between adolescence and senescence, sometimes referred to as 'middle essence'.
“one of the terms that Medawar used to describe the aging process was senescence and that concept of senescence had been popularized by an American psychologist Grandville Stanley Hall in the early 20th century and it came to be one of the key ways in which midlife and middle-age was defined during the early 20th century middle-age came to represent the period between adolescence and senescence”
Carl Jung wrote about his own personal crisis at age 37 in the 1930s, and Erik Erikson developed a developmental psychology framework identifying eight life stages, each with its own conflict, with middle-age characterized by a conflict between creativity and stagnation.
“Carl Jung in the 1930s had written about his own crisis at the age of 37 and particularly Eric Erickson an American developmental psychologist had talked about life particularly in terms of the ages or the stages of he described life in terms of eight stages each of which had its own particular conflict the stage that correlated with the period that Jax was talking about he thought was focused on a conflict between creativity on the one hand and stagnation on the other”
The phrase 'keeping up with the Joneses' originated in a 1913 American comic strip and became during the early-to-mid 20th century a key driver of envy, jealousy, emulation, and increased consumption as people measured their status against others.
“the notion the phrase keeping up with the Joneses started in a comic strip in America about 1913 but it became in those early decades of the 20th century through the 30s and 40s a key way of us measuring ourselves against others a driver in some ways of envy and jealousy a driver of emulation a driver to increase our consumption to keep up with the journey the Joneses”
Peter Medawar's work on aging as an unsolved biological problem focused on the evolutionary and biological dimensions of aging, with the downward curve of life understood not just as fear of death but as awareness of deteriorating biological vigor—graying, baldness, middle-age spread, and declining muscle mass.
“the downward curve of life was not necessarily only an awareness of approaching death it was something else it was an awareness that as we get older we get grayer or Balder all we develop middle-age spread or our muscle mass declines our vigor our vitality deteriorates and it was that sense of deteriorating vigor that fueled the cry in some kind of waste”