
Investing in Gold: What's Up With The Price of Gold?
What this covers
This is a single-presenter PensionCraft video, run in four parts: why gold has risen, what the rally says about the US, whether a crash is coming, and how to buy gold. It begins with the standard drivers of the gold price: the dollar, real interest rates and inflation. It then sets the 2024 move against earlier spikes in 1980, 2011 and 2020. Each of those followed a macroeconomic shock, and in inflation-adjusted terms each peaked above today's price. This surge has no comparable catalyst, apart from geopolitical instability and a US election, and the presenter treats that as the puzzle.
The most concrete explanation offered is central bank buying. China added about 160,000 troy ounces in March alone, and Turkey, India and Kazakhstan are named as heavy buyers too. The video links this to worries about the weaponization of the dollar, citing the freezing of Russian assets. It draws on Brad Setser's work showing China's holdings of US financial assets back near their level from two decades ago. The presenter flags the weaponization reading as contested.
The middle section turns to US fiscal arithmetic. Using Congressional Budget Office (CBO)) projections, it argues that debt near 100% of GDP, higher servicing costs and a budget dominated by mandatory spending leave little room to cut. The eventual result, it suggests, is a Fed forced to cut rates, which would favor gold. The rally is read as a hedge against either runaway debt or stretched equity valuations, not as a sign of economic distress.
The video declines to forecast a crash, since timing is unpredictable. It also gives long-run returns since 1871: stocks 9.1%, Treasuries 4.6%, gold 3.2%. It closes on practical routes to ownership: physical coins, which are exempt from UK capital gains tax but costly to store and less liquid, ETFs), and mining stocks, which pay dividends but behave like equities in a sell-off.
Gold prices have surged in 2024 not due to macroeconomic shocks but primarily through central bank buying and unexplained demand factors, signaling concerns about US debt sustainability and equity market valuations rather than strong economic fundamentals.
- Gold fair value model shows 18% overvaluation, with divergence driven by factors beyond interest rates and dollar strength
- Central banks (China, Turkey, India, Kazakhstan) have been substantial buyers, potentially driven by concerns about dollar weaponization
- US debt trajectory is unsustainable, forcing eventual Fed rate cuts that would support gold prices despite near-term market strength
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Central banks have been the most likely source of unexplained gold demand, with specific examples including China adding 160,000 troy ounces (approximately 5,000 kg, equivalent to a 60 cm cube) of gold to reserves in March alone, and Turkey, India, Kazakhstan, and Eastern European central banks also buying gold heavily.
“one possible source of demand for gold could be central banks now we do know that some central banks have been buying heavily for example the Chinese Central Bank added 160,000 tro ounces of gold to its reserves and that was in March alone if you're wondering how much that is in kilograms it's just under 5,000 kg and if you were to create that as a cube of gold it would roughly measure 60 cm on each side of the cube so it's quite a large amount of gold and according to this reuter story you can see beside me turkey India Kazakhstan and some Eastern European countries have also had their central banks buying gold”
China's holdings of US financial assets have declined to roughly the level they were two decades ago when China joined the WTO, according to economist and China-watcher Brad Setser, when measured as a percentage of Chinese GDP.
“there's a nice graph here from Brad seter who's a China Watcher and an economist and what is showing is that China's Holdings of US Financial assets are roughly where they were a very long time ago in fact where they were two decades ago when China joined the World Trade Organization and this is expressed as a percentage of Chinese GDP”
Physical gold bullion (including Britannia coins, sovereigns, and Queen's Beasts coins) purchased in the UK is classified as legal British currency and qualifies for capital gains tax exemption under UK law, providing tax-efficient gold exposure.
“one of the things that the Royal Mint website tells us about buying physical gold which is also classed as legal British currency is that you don't pay capital gains tax on it so they say if you buy gold and silver Britannia coins sovereigns and the popular Queens beasts range they have a capital gains tax exemption”
The price of gold has three major spikes since 1970 (in 1980, 2011, and 2020), and when adjusted to 2024 dollars, all three peaks exceeded current price levels, establishing a pattern where gold remains dormant before surging due to macroeconomic shocks.
“if we look at the price of gold since 1970 and this is expressed in real terms so that the price is given in 2024 us you can see that there have been three spikes in the price of gold over this period the first in 1980 and in fact gold is still in a draw down since that Peak the second one in 2011 and the third one more recently in 2020 in fact for all those three Peaks if we express it in 20 $4 all those prices were higher than they are today”
Central bank gold buying is likely a response to concern about weaponization of the dollar, and this pattern has been ongoing since at least 2022-2023, suggesting it is not a new phenomenon but rather accelerated response to geopolitical tensions.
“according to data from the world gold Council if you look at the Central Bank buying in 2022 and 2023 it's been very brisk indeed so this isn't something new this is something that's been going on for some time perhaps in response to weaponization of the dollar as we'll discuss later”
If US debt becomes unsustainable and debt servicing costs become unpalatable and unmanageable, the Federal Reserve will eventually be forced to cut rates and keep them low, eliminating the high-interest-rate environment that is toxic for gold and simultaneously triggering risk-off behavior that drives gold demand.
“what does this mean for the price of gold well if US debt is unsustainable then it's unlikely that the Federal Reserve would be able to keep rates High when the debt servicing cost becomes unpalatable and also unmanageable that means that the FED would have to cut and keep rates low that in turn means that the toxic environment for gold which is high interest rates would go away plus worries about us debt would probably push people towards gold as well and that's via the risk channel”
The current rally in the price of gold signals concern that either US debt will spiral out of control or equity market valuations are unsustainable and a correction is coming, suggesting investors are using gold as a defensive hedge rather than responding to genuine macroeconomic distress.
“I think the rally in the price of gold is not telling us anything good about the US economy or about the equity Market it may be that people are worried that the US market is overstretched valuations are too high and they're taking refuge in gold which typically provides a reasonable hedge when stock markets tank”
Geopolitical risk is a significant factor supporting continued high gold prices, as escalation in Middle East conflicts and Ukraine tensions drive risk-off behavior and gold purchases as a safe haven asset.
“geopolitical risk is a big one when people are scared they buy gold and a lot of the news headlines we're hearing right now about escalation of wars in the Middle East but also in Ukraine are very scary so if those do escalate and things get worse then I think gold could be potentially quite a good hedge against that pullback in Risk appetite”
The primary drivers of gold prices are: (1) the value of the US dollar (inverse relationship—strong dollar means weak gold), (2) real interest rates (high real rates create toxic environment for gold as a non-yielding asset), and (3) inflation (gold tracks inflation over the long term but is not expected to beat it).
“what are the primary drivers of the price of gold I'd say probably the most important one is the value of the dollar and that's because the value of gold is expressed in dollars so a high gold price is effectively saying that it's strong relative to the value of the dollar strong gold is weak dollar another important factor is real interest rates because if you can earn a high rate of return in something which is very low risk like us treasuries that's a toxic environment for gold given that gold is a wasting asset and it doesn't generate an income so high interest rates generally mean a low price of gold and then finally inflation is another factor which drives the price of gold as it does with any commodity because if a commodity is still useful then it will track inflation long term what we wouldn't necessarily expect is that it would beat inflation”
Part of China's reduction in US financial asset holdings was caused by money being moved from US assets back onto the balance sheets of Chinese banks, removing approximately $2 trillion worth of Chinese assets from the US system, representing a deliberate portfolio reallocation rather than valuation-driven decline.
“he explains that part of that reason for the fall is that the money was moved out of us assets and back onto the balance sheets of Chinese banks that removed about $2 trillion worth of Chinese assets”
US debt relative to GDP is projected to rise very rapidly according to the Congressional Budget Office, a politically neutral watchdog, with current levels at 100% (high by historical standards) and acceleration likely due to higher debt servicing costs from elevated interest rates despite strong post-pandemic growth.
“there has been a report from the Congressional budget office which is a politically neutral Watchdog that looks at US debt sustainability if you look at the projection of US debt relative to GDP it's projected to rise very rapidly currently it's at 100% which is high by historic standards but of course a lot of that came after the pandemic the US spent about 10% of its GDP stimulating its economy which has been very successful us growth has been very good relative to the rest of G7 but of course it comes at a price which is more debt outstanding”
Gold mining stocks provide dividend income and access to the equity risk premium as an alternative to pure gold exposure, but are not effective hedges against stock market declines because mining stocks are themselves equities correlated with broader market movements.
“Another way to get exposure is via gold miners the beauty of getting exposure that way is that they'd pay a dividend so instead of a storage cost you get the equity risk premium and you also get an income minus t to pay high dividends however it's not such a good hedge against stocks falling because you're buying stocks”
Historical analysis shows that US stocks have averaged 9.1% annualized total return since 1871 (assuming dividend reinvestment), US Treasury bonds averaged 4.6%, and gold has averaged only 3.2%, indicating that gold significantly underperforms equities over the long term.
“if we compare the price of US stocks and this is total return so I'm assuming that for stocks you reinvest the dividend and for bonds you reinvest the coupon for US Stocks you'd have averaged about 99.1% return since 1871 for us treasuries much less 4.6% and for gold you'd have made about 3.2% on average over that period”
For much of the historical period since 1871, the US dollar was pegged to gold, meaning gold's returns were by definition zero during that period, and even after the gold peg was abandoned, gold has not substantially outperformed inflation over the long term.
“the value of the dollar was pegged to Gold for a large part of that period so the return was by definition zero but what you can also see is that over the long term it's not much above inflation even after the relationship between the dollar and gold was broken”
Despite gold's poor long-term returns, diversification into gold can boost overall portfolio returns by reducing losses during sharp equity market drawdowns, and many investors find psychological comfort in diversifying across asset types beyond bonds and stocks.
“by diversifying by reducing your losses during the sharp draw down periods in equity gold does boost your long-term return plus psychologically many people find com in the fact that they've Diversified across another asset type Beyond bonds and Beyond Equity”
Physical gold storage requires safe storage solutions that come with significant costs, and physical bullion is less liquid than ETF investments, making it a trade-off between tax efficiency and convenience.
“but there you will have to think about storage safe storage and that comes with its own costs and this is a less liquid investment than something like an ETF”
The standard approach to reducing high debt-to-GDP ratios (growing faster than debt growth) faces a critical constraint: debt servicing costs are now much higher because interest rates are higher, creating a larger hurdle that cannot be easily overcome through spending cuts due to mandatory spending constraints.
“normally the way to get out of a high debt to GDP ratio is to grow faster than your debt however the debt servicing cost in the US is now much higher because interest rates are simply higher than they were so you might think the us could simply cut its expenditure and that way also reduce the growth rate of its debt to GDP ratio that way there's less of a h hurdle to grow out of the problem however if you break down US Government expenditure according to whether it's mandatory or whether it's discretionary a lot of it is now mandatory mandatory spending is not much less than 15% of GDP whereas discretionary spending which can be cut much more easily is just over 6% of GDP in falling”
Forecasting a near-term crash in gold prices is impossible because the timing of reversals is fundamentally unpredictable, though historical patterns show that rapid surges in gold are typically followed by sharp declines, but the duration of the rally cannot be predicted.
“now forecasting a crash is impossible we'll never know whether gold is going to fall over the near term certainly if we look back in time to when gold surged very rapidly it wasn't long until it started to fall very sharply as well what we can't predict is how long it's going to carry on surging before it turns around”
Discretionary spending in the US budget is just over 6% of GDP and falling, while mandatory spending (entitlements and interest on debt) is nearly 15% of GDP, leaving US government with minimal fiscal flexibility to reduce expenditure without politically contentious cuts to defense or social programs.
“mandatory spending is not much less than 15% of GDP whereas discretionary spending which can be cut much more easily is just over 6% of GDP in falling”
China may be deliberately reducing US asset holdings to avoid risk of asset confiscation by the US government in case of trade disputes, as demonstrated by the precedent of US-frozen Russian assets following Ukraine invasion, making this a form of financial hedge against geopolitical confrontation.
“perhaps another reason for that fall is that China doesn't want the US to own much of its assets because it could be that if it falls out with the us over trade maybe after a change of presidency then if that happens it can't have its assets confiscated by the us because with Russia for example after it invaded Ukraine a lot of its assets in foreign countries were frozen”
Cutting discretionary spending (defense) is politically unfeasible at present given current world geopolitical situation, and cutting entitlements would face substantial political resistance, making any meaningful reduction in US government expenditure growth unlikely despite high debt levels.
“a lot of the discretionary categories are things which will come with a lot of political push back for example cutting back military spending right now would be seen as a mistake at the moment given what's going on on the world stage”
Unlike previous gold spikes tied to macroeconomic shocks (1980, 2011, 2020), the 2024 surge lacks a major macroeconomic shock catalyst, with only geopolitical instability and a US election as potential drivers, making this movement distinct and harder to explain.
“what's different in 2024 is it hasn't really been a big macroeconomic shock there is geopolitical instability that's for certain there is an election coming up in the US but it's hard to say that there's real duress in markets in in fact stock prices as I make this video are still doing quite well”
A US election creates uncertainty that typically supports gold prices, and regardless of electoral outcome, continuation of trade disputes with China is likely, which would weaken the dollar and keep interest rates low—both factors favorable for gold.
“we've also got a US election coming up and that's usually a source of uncertainty whoever wins it's likely that we're going to carry on these trade disputes with China which could potentially escalate and which will probably act to weaken the dollar and keep interest rates low both of which are good for gold”
If US disinflation continues and the Federal Reserve begins rate cuts toward the end of 2024, this would be a favorable scenario for gold prices, eliminating the high-rate headwind that currently suppresses gold valuations.
“if we do see us disinflation carry on then of course the FED will start to cut rates eventually towards the end of this year and that would be also a good story for gold”
The World Gold Council's fair price model identifies 'unexplained' factors as the largest current driver pushing gold prices upward, beyond traditional factors like economic expansion, uncertainty, currency movements, interest rates, and momentum.
“the world gold Council also has its own fair price Model which tries to explain gold price movements that includes factors like economic expansion risk and uncertainty which tend to push up the price of gold opportunity cost from currency movements but also from interest rates momentum if the price is going up it tends to carry on going up up and finally a factor which they call unexplained and you can probably guess which is the biggest Factor at the moment pushing the price of gold up yes it's the Unexplained Factor”
Gold ETF ownership is currently much lower than during the 2011 peak, suggesting that there is more room for further retail investor inflows and upward momentum in gold prices before hitting saturation, supporting the argument for continued gold appreciation.
“if you look at the gold share of assets that would include things like equity for example and also Bonds in 2011 it was Rising very sharply and that's kind of what you'd expect lots of retail investors buying gold and pushing up the price this time around what we're seeing is a fall in ownership via ETFs so the argument by the world gold council is that there's more room for a rally as more people pile into the momentum that we're seeing in gold right now”
Gold ETF inflows have not been driving the 2024 price surge; in fact, gold ETFs have experienced steady outflows for nearly a year despite gold prices rising steadily, contradicting a simple investor-buying explanation for the price movement.
“you might think that there's a huge amount of inflows into gold ETFs there's lots of investor buying and that's pushing up the price well if you look at the amount of money flowing into gold ETFs which is a very common way of buying gold in fact we've seen steady outflows for almost a year now so while the price of gold has been steadily increasing Money's been steadily coming out of those ETFs”
Gold is a reasonable consideration as part of a diversified portfolio for investors who are concerned about geopolitical escalation or US equity market overvaluation, providing a hedge even if not held as a core position.
“if you are worried about those things and I think gold is certainly something to consider at least as part of your portfolio”
A gold fair value model (available via premium membership) using dollar strength, real 10-year US interest rates, and CPI levels suggests that as of the video's recording, gold is trading approximately 18% above fair value.
“if you have our premium website membership you'll have access to these trackers one of which is a gold fair value model now this gives you a crude idea of what gold should be worth based on those three factors which we discussed and as we make this video the model's forecasting that the price of gold is about 18% above its fair value given the strength of the US dollar right now given the real 10-year us interest rate and given the level of CPI”
The divergence between fair value and actual gold price accelerated starting in March 2024, driven primarily by a 4% decline in fair value from increased real interest rates in the US and a 3% decline from dollar strengthening, indicating that approximately 7% of the 18% overvaluation can be accounted for by these two factors alone.
“the Divergence really kicked off in March of 2024 the models fair price at that point started to go down and the price of gold started to shoot up why did the model's forecast fall well for two primary reasons the first one was that real interest rates in the United States increased and that pushes down the fair value of gold that dragged the fair price down by about 4% and then the strengthened at the same time and that wiped another 3% off the model's value for gold so clearly there's some other Factor at play here other than those three factors which we discussed”
The speaker personally does not hold gold and would likely maintain only a small holding if purchased in the future, indicating skepticism about current valuations or geopolitical/equity market concerns despite acknowledging gold's theoretical case.
“now personally I don't hold gold I might do in future who knows but it would probably be a fairly small holding and I'm certainly not drisking at the moment because of my worries about what's going on geopolitically or with the US Equity Market being overvalued”
When selecting gold ETFs, investors must verify that the fund is denominated in their home currency and trades on the relevant domestic exchange to avoid high currency conversion fees, which can significantly reduce returns.
“one thing to watch out for is that if it's not denominated in pounds then you may have to pay a high conversion fee on your broker's platform the way to check that is to drill into the fund click on the stock exchange section and then just check whether it trades on the London Stock Exchange in sterling”
Gold ETFs with low expense ratios (as low as 0.11% annually) are available to investors, particularly the XT Trackers product with 0.11% expense ratio, making direct gold exposure through ETFs cost-effective.
“the XT trackers one is only 0.11% per year”